Everything posted by Valid
-
Fire brant brown?
Perhaps. I guess the question is whether or not we can blame Brown for guys like Garcia, Wendle, Stallings and Segura (even though he's gone now) massively underachieving. Gurriel sucked in 2022 as well, so it's not like he fell off as soon as he got here. DLC is probably a fourth OF (or at least a guy who should be hiding in a better lineup if he's going to start). Jazz just can't stay healthy and I think a lot of his struggles have to do with his own mental hurdles. I don't know. Even if Brown deserves some blame, the fact of the matter is that the FO has done a horrendous job putting this offense together. Soler is the only real power bat. Nobody walks. Too many guys strike out (regardless of what analytics try to say, strikeouts do matter). And to be fair, outside of Jazz and Berti, who here really has the speed to steal bases? The real problem is roster construction. If the FO doesn't sign a couple of legitimate bats this offseason (and I mean legitimate; not signing reclamation projects and once-great hitters like JD Martinez and hoping they regain their form from five years ago, which we know is what they'll probably do), 2024 is going to be another difficult year to watch this offense.
-
Would this team have a better record under Donnie Baseball?
The 2005 team was probably the most talented team we've ever had on paper. There is no reason why that squad shouldn't have won at least 90 games and made the playoffs. And yes absolutely. Literally no one on this forum expected this team to be 14 over at any point this season. Well, they got there, and now that they are a .500 team like most people anticipated, suddenly Don is better than Skip?
-
Fire brant brown?
Let's be real here: this isn't saying much at all. This lineup still sucks.
-
Would this team have a better record under Donnie Baseball?
With Don we would have never been 14 over. And I would venture to say that the 2005 Marlins ushered in a bigger tank job considering that team was actually legitimately talented up and down the roster. They were 78-67 and in control of a WC spot on Sept. 13. They then went 3-12 the rest of the way.
-
Would this team have a better record under Donnie Baseball?
Your threads keep getting worse and worse. This forum did nothing but make fun of Don all of last year and throughout the entire first half of this season when the team was doing well. Now because the team has fallen off, we are seriously discussing whether or not we would be better off with Don?
-
David Robertson
Lol you come on here everyday lambasting the Marlins FO for not doing anything. They actually do something and acquire a star reliever, and because it hasn't worked out like you hoped, you now say "admit the failure." If the Marlins DIDN'T acquire a reliever at the deadline, you would be on here complaining that Kim doesn't know what she's doing and that she is too concerned with holding on to prospects.
-
David Robertson
Yeah let's be honest here: no one outside of seriously diehard Marlins knew who either of those guys were and the chances of either prospect becoming impactful MLB guys are slim to none. Robertson was a lockdown reliever for his entire career. He has just so happened to suck since arriving here. The trade was great at the time and anyone pretending it was a horrible deal all along is kidding themselves.
-
Who should we claim?
Wouldn't the Marlins have to pay the remainder of his salary for the rest of the season? Entirely possible he's too "expensive" (even though he's only making $8 million this year).
-
Who should we claim?
I think DLC is either a really good fourth outfielder or an okay guy to have in a loaded lineup where you can kind of hide him. He would be fine on the Braves, for example. The problem here is that the Marlins' lineup stinks and he is one of their best hitters.
-
Who should we claim?
I don't think anyone here would really disagree that DLC shouldn't be a long-term fixture. At least not in the starting lineup. His slash line is almost identical to last year's, so he pretty much is what he is at this point (like a .730 OPS bat). He also actually hits righties better than lefties, so it's not like he's a lefty masher who can platoon, either. Not sure Renfroe is the answer, though. He has been worse than DLC this year and he's 31. His ISO went from regularly being above .230 to just .185 this season, so he could be declining. And power is pretty much the only thing he's good for considering he doesn't really get on base. If he is losing his power, he is essentially useless.
-
What do you put in your fruit salad?
We don't need to know what honeydew does to you in your private life.
-
Who should we claim?
Nah. He has a .649 OPS. He was really good in the playoffs last year but that was about it. Dude is always hurt, too. And to think the Yankees traded Jordan Montgomery for him.
-
David Robertson
I mean, yeah, but the post I quoted said that the team's vibes have been off since the trade. That isn't true.
-
Jorge Soler player option
Yeah Bell's option is for $16.5 million. Even with as well as he has hit since coming here, he is still OPSing just .747 on the year (and he wasn't great in 2022 either). There is next to no chance any team offers him that kind of money. I would be surprised if he doesn't opt in.
-
David Robertson
I actually wouldn't mind it so long as it's a one-year deal. Yeah he's been bad here so far but I don't think he just suddenly forgot how to pitch. The dude has been nails for his entire career. Unless the wheels just suddenly came off the second he put on a Marlins uniform (which I guess is actually a legitimate possibility seeing as how, well, Marlins), I am willing to bet he'll be much better next season.
-
David Robertson
The team was going south long before the Robertson trade.
-
What happened to Skip
All I had to do was read the title to know you were the one who made this thread.
-
The DelayiNg Problem
They are two games back in the loss column...
-
The DelayiNg Problem
I think the thing with this team is that these guys are resilient. That isn't a question. They have shown the ability to pick themselves off the mat after tough losses time and time again this season. So I actually do think they have the intestinal fortitude. It's just that they don't really have the overall talent. Even with the deadline additions, this offense is still trash, and the pitching hasn't been as good since the break (and that's even with Sandy starting to get back to his old self). I don't know. I think they still have what it takes to make the playoffs, because the field of competition is pretty weak overall (evidenced by the fact that they have gone 11-24 since the break and are still right in this thing). But I also think it's pretty clear that there is a dearth of talent here (which I think everyone pretty much knew all along).
-
What do you put in your fruit salad?
I wasn't sure if you were serious or not so I actually looked this up...and you weren't lying. Yeah this confirms my original statement all the more.
-
What do you put in your fruit salad?
Meh. Weird texture. Stringy things attached. Probably my least favorite fruit on its own.
-
What do you put in your fruit salad?
I actually think fruit salad enhances some fruits. For example, I don't like bananas on their own, but I think they are great in fruit salads.
-
Some thoughts so far..
At the very least, they are playing meaningful baseball in late August. It's a start. Even if this team doesn't make the playoffs, there are a lot of reasons to be hopeful for the future. Kim seems to know what she's doing (at least to an extent). It's just a matter of whether or not Bruce opens his wallet at all. I'm not even saying he has to spend like crazy; just spend money in the right places.
-
Some thoughts so far..
It's @mystikol87's fault for being vegan.
-
Some thoughts so far..
Well now I'm concerned.