Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

MarlinsBaseball.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Acquire a starter over a reliever?

Featured Replies

Obtain Greg Zaun and Miguel Batista from the Jays.

 

Starrting Staff: Beckett, Burnett, Pavano, Penny & Batista

 

Bullpen becomes:

Benitez

Koch

Manzy

Willis

Perisho - ONLY to be used on a lefty bat.

Oliver

Howard/Wayne/Borland - who do ya want?

  • Author

Cape, and I want Vernon Wells in our OF :)

 

Let's first work on a trio of solid setup men. If we are to win this thing our starters go 7 innings most games. Give us Manzy, Koch and Willis as setup guys and we are looking better.

 

When that's in place we can work on the final 2 spots.

Batista is terribly overrated.

 

His best years have been out the bullpen and he's never had more than 11 wins. He's inconsistent and has been overrated since he won the WS with Arizona.

Why would the Jays trade Wells who is an up and coming player? I am aware that they have some promising players ready to take the field but I just don't see them trading a stud like Wells.

Willis in the bullpen, gives us a break. Remind me, who has two out of our three complete games and is our best hitting pitchers by a mile?

why move Willis out of the rotation?

 

I dont get some of you

I agree! By putting Willis in the Pen you are not using his talent to the Fullest.

  • Author

I was being sarcastic about Wells.

 

I don't get some of you. We sit here and moan and groan about the bullpen each and every day. If the opportunity is there to better the pen on a daily basis, you consider it.

 

Did we just say, no way...Cabrera is a 3B, no move to the OF? If it helps the club you consider all options.

I was being sarcastic about Wells.

 

I don't get some of you. We sit here and moan and groan about the bullpen each and every day. If the opportunity is there to better the pen on a daily basis, you consider it.

 

Did we just say, no way...Cabrera is a 3B, no move to the OF? If it helps the club you consider all options.

Yes but the only reason we wanted Cabs in the OF was because there was someone better at third.

 

Are you telling me Batista is a better starting pitcher than Willis?

  • Author

No, what I am saying is that I'd rather have Batista as a # 5 and Willis as a daily setup man with Manzy and Koch than Willis as a # 5 and Borland, Howard, Perisho getting the ball in the 7th inning on too often.

Starrting Staff: Beckett, Burnett, Pavano, Penny & Batista

 

Bullpen becomes:

Benitez

Koch

Manzy

Willis

Perisho - ONLY to be used on a lefty bat.

Oliver

 

 

im likeing this set up right here willis needs to go to the bull pen and get grounded,and i think in the bulllpen u throw in borland.

i like that idea though, Miguel Bautista isnt really a bad pitcher, and we need a good relief pitcher. Dontrelle can do that job but i dont want him to go to the bullpen for some reason.

people people people.. the answer is in chad fox: he just needs to come off the dl some day, and things should be fine..

 

just get rid of billy koch and his retarded neck move pitching self!

  • Author

I will repeat my original proposal.

 

Willis has 17 starts left. Let's assume the team goes 9-8 in those starts. Based on how he has been throwing that is a fair projection in my opinion. What would our record be if another starter took his place? Go out and acquire a legit MLB starter with an ERA between 4.75 and 5.25. With this guy can we go 5-12? Of course we can. Probably even better than that. Probably more like 7-10 or 8-9.

 

Now for the next 85 games we have Dontrelle Willis joining Manzy (and eventually Koch?) as our setup guys. Can many games that our pen has blown so far could Willis have saved for Benitez?

 

When I first proposed this idea I think people felt I was slighting Willis. He has been inconsistent but I see Willis as a great addition to the pen and will be used in big situations.

 

Keep this in mind. As things stand right now, come October when we enter the playoffs Willis is in the pen.

In half of Willis' starts he has pitched 5 innings or less. He might as well be considered a reliever already if that's all he's contributing.

 

But seriously the kid needs to go see a therapist or something to work himself out.

why move Willis out of the rotation?

 

I dont get some of you

Amen. Why are some of you so obsessed with getting Dontrelle out of the starting rotation? He has been pretty good this year, up and down, but solid. He is young and getting better. Heck, we won 5-4 tonight.

Willis is good in short doses...look at the world series....I think he could be the 8th inning guy....get Livan and we're still golden in the rotation.

bullpen is the most overrated aspect of baseball. you dont take a STARTER and make him a RELIEVER and say it will make the team BETTER when he would be pitching less

and you DONT TYPE like this in HOPES that people WILL GET a better GRASP of what you are trying to SAY.

 

this thread should've been dead!

and you DONT TYPE like this in HOPES that people WILL GET a better GRASP of what you are trying to SAY.

 

this thread should've been dead!

im tryin to figure out if u agree or disagree.......you make no sense with that post :thumbdown

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...
Background Picker
Customize Layout

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.