Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

It's Burnett or Hudson

Featured Replies

ok, i understand that Hudson is a better pitcher than Burnett....but can someone explain to me how it makes sense to trade one pitcher who will leave the team after this year to be a free agent in exchange for another pitcher who will leave this team and become a free agent, AND throw some prospects in to boot?

636371[/snapback]

 

 

YES, the FO feels they have a better shot at signing Hudson, then a guy(AJ) who has openly stated he doesn't enjoy pitching in front of an empty stadium. And the minute he become a free agent he's out here.

 

Hudson is a southern boy, who would like nothing more than to pitch in the south ( Atlanta, Florida) Believe he'll try to get something done with the Marlins , if traded here

636383[/snapback]

 

 

If this is all based on the off-chance that we might be able to re-sign Hudson, then it is a big mistake IMO. I mean, just look at Pavano. Pavano is not even close to the pitcher that Hudson is, and every team in the majors made an offer to him. Unless we are prepared to pay TOP dollar for Hudson (i'm talking 5 years, $60 mill), this is a pipe dream and we're better off paying less for AJ this year, keeping our prospects, and foreggting about Hudson.

The marlins have a better chance of resigning AJ. Hudson wants about $14 million for 4 years. :o

 

Where does he expect to get that kind of money?

ok, i understand that Hudson is a better pitcher than Burnett....but can someone explain to me how it makes sense to trade one pitcher who will leave the team after this year to be a free agent in exchange for another pitcher who will leave this team and become a free agent, AND throw some prospects in to boot?

636371[/snapback]

 

 

YES, the FO feels they have a better shot at signing Hudson, then a guy(AJ) who has openly stated he doesn't enjoy pitching in front of an empty stadium. And the minute he become a free agent he's out here.

 

Hudson is a southern boy, who would like nothing more than to pitch in the south ( Atlanta, Florida) Believe he'll try to get something done with the Marlins , if traded here

636383[/snapback]

 

 

If this is all based on the off-chance that we might be able to re-sign Hudson, then it is a big mistake IMO. I mean, just look at Pavano. Pavano is not even close to the pitcher that Hudson is, and every team in the majors made an offer to him. Unless we are prepared to pay TOP dollar for Hudson (i'm talking 5 years, $60 mill), this is a pipe dream and we're better off paying less for AJ this year, keeping our prospects, and foreggting about Hudson.

636398[/snapback]

 

 

What do have to say or do to get through some you guys "THAT BURNETT WILL NOT RESIGN WITH THE MARLINS NO MATTER WHAT"This kid has his mind made up, and there nothing you, I, or the Marlins can do about it. Why is there a perception that this organization will not pay top dollar for a top player. There not the rich group, but they find a way to get it done when needed. Remember they were going to take a big chuck of Hampton contract form the Rockies, until he said he didn't want to come here.

 

Pavano had a "nice" season, is he worth that kind of money to the Marlins? NO Pavano will realize very soon next season that Pro Player helped him get that big fat contract. I don't want to come on here and trash Pavano because he did what he had to do, also did alot for our team, but don't blame the Marlins for that paying top dollar for a guy who can be replace.

 

Pudge do I even have to go there....

 

The bottomline is the Marlins will pay deferal payments, backloaded contract, bonuses, whatever to get a deal done with Hudson... a proven pitcher with NO prior history of arm troubles. period

Are you crazy? We couldn't even resign Pavano, a career .500 pitcher. Now you think we can resign one of the winningest pitchers in the past 10 years?

 

 

The difference is, Hudson is proven to be worth the money. Pavano hasn't shown that he's capable of consistently performing like he did last year.

 

 

I like one year rentals as much as the next guy but let's face facts, a trade for Vasquez is a smarter option considering he's locked up for the next few years. A trade for Hudson will result in the same thing at the end of 2005; an empty spot in the rotation.

 

If they're going to trade for Vazquez, I don't see why they just don't sign A.J. instead.

What do have to say or do to get through some you guys "THAT BURNETT WILL NOT RESIGN WITH THE MARLINS NO MATTER WHAT"This kid has his mind made up, and there nothing you, I, or the Marlins can do about it.

 

What makes you say that? Do you know him personally?

 

Why is there a perception that this organization will not pay top dollar for a top player.

 

The fact that they wouldn't pony up $10 million/year to keep a possible HOF catcher who lives down here might have something to do with it. He had a hell of a year with Detroit last year. The Marlins might have made the playoffs again with his bat still in the lineup.

 

 

The bottomline is the Marlins will pay deferal payments, backloaded contract, bonuses, whatever to get a deal done with Hudson... a proven pitcher with NO prior history of arm troubles. period

 

All those gyrations are more trouble than they are worth. I mean, isn't the excuse this year that our payroll is kind of hamstrung by the backloaded deals we're still paying? Arizona will still be paying for the 2001 team in 2010.

What do have to say or do to get through some you guys "THAT BURNETT WILL NOT RESIGN WITH THE MARLINS NO MATTER WHAT"This kid has his mind made up, and there nothing you, I, or the Marlins can do about it.

 

What makes you say that? Do you know him personally?

 

Why is there a perception that this organization will not pay top dollar for a top player.

 

The fact that they wouldn't pony up $10 million/year to keep a possible HOF catcher who lives down here might have something to do with it. He had a hell of a year with Detroit last year. The Marlins might have made the playoffs again with his bat still in the lineup.

 

 

The bottomline is the Marlins will pay deferal payments, backloaded contract, bonuses, whatever to get a deal done with Hudson... a proven pitcher with NO prior history of arm troubles. period

 

All those gyrations are more trouble than they are worth. I mean, isn't the excuse this year that our payroll is kind of hamstrung by the backloaded deals we're still paying? Arizona will still be paying for the 2001 team in 2010.

636415[/snapback]

 

What makes you say that? Do you know him personally?

He's told more than few people on the team, so its not a big secret

 

The fact that they wouldn't pony up $10 million/year to keep a possible HOF catcher who lives down here might have something to do with it. He had a hell of a year with Detroit last year. The Marlins might have made the playoffs again with his bat still in the lineup.

 

NO they paid 40 million for two, possibly three at best season for an aging catcher.

 

All those gyrations are more trouble than they are worth. I mean, isn't the excuse this year that our payroll is kind of hamstrung by the backloaded deals we're still paying? Arizona will still be paying for the 2001 team in 2010.

 

In sports its a win now mentality, your concern is the here and now. Baltimore in football did it by loading up and won the superbowl, the fish paid pudge for a one year run at the playoff.

 

 

Arizona will still be paying for the 2001 team in 2010

 

Didn't 'zona just sign Glaus and Ortiz for big money

What do have to say or do to get through some you guys "THAT BURNETT WILL NOT RESIGN WITH THE MARLINS NO MATTER WHAT"This kid has his mind made up, and there nothing you, I, or the Marlins can do about it.

 

What makes you say that? Do you know him personally?

 

Why is there a perception that this organization will not pay top dollar for a top player.

 

The fact that they wouldn't pony up $10 million/year to keep a possible HOF catcher who lives down here might have something to do with it. He had a hell of a year with Detroit last year. The Marlins might have made the playoffs again with his bat still in the lineup.

636415[/snapback]

AJ wont resign here, he hates management and would rather be in a big city

 

and we all agreed that Pudge would be worth $10mil for last year and this year, but the final 2 years on that contract will prove that it may have been a mistake

What do have to say or do to get through some you guys "THAT BURNETT WILL NOT RESIGN WITH THE MARLINS NO MATTER WHAT"This kid has his mind made up, and there nothing you, I, or the Marlins can do about it. Why is there a perception that this organization will not pay top dollar for a top player. There not the rich group, but they find a way to get it done when needed. Remember they were going to take a big chuck of Hampton contract form the Rockies, until he said he didn't want to come here.

 

 

 

Fine, AJ won't sign here. I agree with you. News flash - Hudson won't either, not unless we're willing to outbid the Yankees and Red Sox. You might think people unfair critize their lack of spending, but if you think those teams were ready to overpay for Pavano, wait until you see what they do for one of the top 10 pitcher in the majors. What have you seen that makes you think this team is ready to get into a bidding war?

 

My point is this - if we could get Hudson for AJ straight up, i'm all for it. But if we're throwing in prospects to go from a pitcher who 100% won't sign here to a pitcher who only 99% won't sign here, that is just plain stupid. But i'm not that concerned, b/c nothing Beinfest has ever done has indicated to me that he is that stupid.

AJ wont resign here, he hates management and would rather be in a big city

 

 

I'd bet a 4-year $36 million deal would make him like management a lot more. Also, how much bigger of a city does A.J. need to live in. There are 5 million people in the tri-county area. Where else is he going to go besides LA, NYC, Boston, Chicago, San Fran, or Houston? Even if he moves to one of those place, short of moving to LA, he'll be in for a hell of a shock in the decline in the quality of women.

 

 

and we all agreed that Pudge would be worth $10mil for last year and this year, but the final 2 years on that contract will prove that it may have been a mistake

 

 

Yet, a lot of people on here are clamoring to sign LoDuca long-term, and LoDuca is just as old as I-Rod and nowhere near as good offensively and defensively. If I-Rod declines from his current 3-year average performance, he'll still be a damn sight better than LoDuca. If you're going to overpay, you overpay for HOFers, not career mediocre players.

b/c nothing Beinfest has ever done has indicated to me that he is that stupid.

 

Well he did let Ivan go, and chose to give $5 million/year to Luis, instead. I figure any GM worth his salt could figure that .750 OPS 2nd basemen are a lot easier to replace than HOF catchers.

Even if he moves to one of those place, short of moving to LA, he'll be in for a hell of a shock in the decline in the quality of women.

 

 

Dude... Burnett is married with a kid.

Dude... Burnett is married with a kid.

 

 

Whoops! My bad. You can tell where my mind is. :p

Yet, a lot of people on here are clamoring to sign LoDuca long-term, and LoDuca is just as old as I-Rod and nowhere near as good offensively and defensively. If I-Rod declines from his current 3-year average performance, he'll still be a damn sight better than LoDuca. If you're going to overpay, you overpay for HOFers, not career mediocre players.

636437[/snapback]

I dont want Paulie back :mischief

I think getting a number 5 pitcher is just as important here wether we trade for hudson or not. I think Lima Time or Valdez wouldnt be that bad. If we spent a little more we could get Perez or Millwood and have an awesome rotation regardless of Burnett/Hudson at the top.

My point is this - if we could get Hudson for AJ straight up, i'm all for it. But if we're throwing in prospects to go from a pitcher who 100% won't sign here to a pitcher who only 99% won't sign here, that is just plain stupid.

636436[/snapback]

:thumbup

 

If that would be the case, you're right.

 

Now... Burnett for a Yankees pitcher of arguably equal talent with 4 years left on his contract is a smart deal.

I tend to side with Fishin2004....

 

The bottom line here is that we want to trade AJ and prospects for Hudson, a guy that we will have to pay FAR more to re-sign, just because he might like it here better than AJ??

 

Any reason to believe Hudson will want to stay down here when he's quite aware that the usual suspects (NY, Balt, LA, Boston, etc) will all be willing to pay top dollar for his services when he becomes a free agent next year?

 

If we KNEW we could get him signed, by all means do it. But if we're just swapping AJ & prospects for Hudson for one year with little chance of signing either one....

 

I dunno, this just doesn't make a lot of sense to me yet.

 

As much as I love watching AJ pitch, Hudson's an elite pitcher and I have trouble believing we could wrap him up. Shock me Mr. Loria!

I tend to side with Fishin2004....

 

The bottom line here is that we want to trade AJ and prospects for Hudson, a guy that we will have to pay FAR more to re-sign, just because he might like it here better than AJ??

 

Any reason to believe Hudson will want to stay down here when he's quite aware that the usual suspects (NY, Balt, LA, Boston, etc) will all be willing to pay top dollar for his services when he becomes a free agent next year?

 

If we KNEW we could get him signed, by all means do it. But if we're just swapping AJ & prospects for Hudson for one year with little chance of signing either one....

 

I dunno, this just doesn't make a lot of sense to me yet.

 

As much as I love watching AJ pitch, Hudson's an elite pitcher and I have trouble believing we could wrap him up. Shock me Mr. Loria!

636700[/snapback]

too late

 

he was traded to the braves for a pile of dung

That javier vasquez deal sounds tempting,lets do it.Doesn't javy have 3-4 years on his contract plus if the yanks put in 10 million...i'll be happy,we better do this trade before its too late,because we don't want the same thing that happened with hudson to happen with javy,let's get this dude!

That javier vasquez deal sounds tempting,lets do it.Doesn't javy have 3-4 years on his contract plus if the yanks put in 10 million...i'll be happy,we better do this trade before its too late,because we don't want the same thing that happened with hudson to happen with javy,let's get this dude!

636706[/snapback]

 

I would agree but it looks like the Fish will hold on to AJ until the trading deadline (when we must trade him). I would hate to see Vazquez have a Cy Young type season.

That javier vasquez deal sounds tempting,lets do it.Doesn't javy have 3-4 years on his contract plus if the yanks put in 10 million...i'll be happy,we better do this trade before its too late,because we don't want the same thing that happened with hudson to happen with javy,let's get this dude!

636706[/snapback]

 

I would agree but it looks like the Fish will hold on to AJ until the trading deadline (when we must trade him). I would hate to see Vazquez have a Cy Young type season.

636707[/snapback]

Every year it's the same s*** with the marlins they need to step up and stop being so damn scared,aj's talked so much crap about the f.o that i don't know how in the world he still has a marlins uni on,i say we trade his ass..

How come the Marlins could not make a trade for something better than what the Bravos offered

:blink:

 

They traded one of the best pitchers for some bench players when we could have given them some of those guys that MCkeon calls up during the year and flunk in the big show

 

:( :thumbdown

It was a odd move on the A's end as they tend to focus on getting back only immediate help. But it was a good deal. hey got a good pitcher who can start or relief, a decent 4th outfielder and a top pitching prospect.

How come the Marlins could not make a trade for something better than what the Bravos offered

:blink:

 

They traded one of the best pitchers for some bench players when we could have given them some of those guys that MCkeon calls up during the year and flunk in the big show

 

:( :thumbdown

636753[/snapback]

 

You really are underestimating the talent Beane got. What we didn't have was the phenom, can't miss pitcher with years of no arbitration ahead of him.

How come the Marlins could not make a trade for something better than what the Bravos offered

:blink:

 

They traded one of the best pitchers for some bench players when we could have given them some of those guys that MCkeon calls up during the year and flunk in the big show

 

:( :thumbdown

636753[/snapback]

 

You really are underestimating the talent Beane got. What we didn't have was the phenom, can't miss pitcher with years of no arbitration ahead of him.

636767[/snapback]

or is it that we wouldn't move that pitcher?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.