Since polls seem to be the hip thing to do nowadays...I thought itd be cool to do a baseball player oriented one - to make an all-time great team.

 

Im going to make these nomination threads for each postion (with closers getting a thread as well) and then when we amass a good number of candidates, We will vote on them with the winner getting immortalized in MarlinBaseball.com lore forever.

 

Any player, who has ever played, may be nominated, since this is an all-time team.

 

Please try not to nominate more than 2 or 3 on your own, as this gets everyone involved.

 

Next Up: Right Handed Pitchers

Bob Gibson

Pedro Martinez

Tom Seaver

Big Train Walter Johnson

Bob Gibson

Tom Seaver

Pedro Martinez

Jack Morris

Cy Young

Drysdale

Gibson

Ryan

Satchel Paige

Catfish Hunter

Walter Johnson

Roger Clemens

Bob Feller

Christy Mathewson

Greg Maddux - yeah, don't be biased

Jose Rijo

Christy Mathewson

Just adding new names.

 

Roger Clemens

Bob Gibson

Nolan Ryan

Gaylord Perry

Christy Mathewson

Juan Marichal

Gaylord Perry

Grover Alexander

Tom Seaver

Christy Mathewson

Juan Marichal

Gaylord Perry

673150[/snapback]

:plain!!!!!!!!!!!

 

christy

walter

rocket

 

are my 3

Randy Johnson

Warren Spahn

Sandy Koufax

 

:plain :plain :plain

:lol :lol :lol

:plain :plain :plain

Roger Clemens

Nolan Ryan

Pedro Martinez

Walter Johnson

Roger Clemens

 

Honorable Mention:

Greg Maddux

Cy Young

Pete Alexander

Christy Matthewson

Grover Cleveland Alexander

Dizzy Dean

Clemens, Johnson, Ryan, Maddux, Paige, Koufax.

Voting Starts.

I go with Bob Gibson, when I think of nasty I think of him.

 

Johnson and Cy Young would round out my top three.

i voted for the Big train

Gotta be the man whose fastball couldn't be seen

 

Big Train Walter Johnson

Nolan Ryan...... but I voted for Bob Feller.

Gibson

Did some of the people nominating pitchers minus PhishPhan who clearly did it on purpose realize this is right handed pitchers.