Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Hunt for WMD "officially" over

Featured Replies

Here's a question that I hesitate to even ask, but I have to get it out.

 

Seeing as how the most pressing reason for going into Iraq was that Saddam refused to turn over his WMDs....

 

...Saddam kept insisting there were no WMDs....

 

...and now investigations have concluded there were no WMDs....

 

so what exactly was Saddam supposed to do there to avoid a U.S. invasion?

 

Not that I sympathize with Saddam mind you, he's a piece of garbage & needs to rot in a cell for life or be executed for other crimes. But the casualties Iraq has sustained, both military and civilian, not to mention the destruction of towns, infrastructure, etc, are not a small thing.

 

Does George Bush or the U.S. Government owe Iraq an apology?

 

I keep seeing the U.S. casualty numbers every time there's an article in the newspaper. It's up to 1570 or something. Anyone want to take a shot at the number of Iraqi military that died? Iraqi civilians?? Because our government screwed up? And yes, you risk death if you're fighting for a terrible dictator in Saddam Hussain. Nevertheless, these are people who would probably be alive had we gotten it "right". And I'm not talking about the insurgents fighting us now. They deserve whatever they're getting.

 

So exactly what is the U.S. responsible for here?

Nobody is saying tehy arent doing anything in Afghanistan. What everyone is saying is that they should have put 100% into Afghanistan. Unless its possible provide 200% in resources, you have to admit any alternative conflict means we dont go full out in the first conflict. Now do we need 100%? Not necessarily but certainly Iraq was no side mission. In fact it was a massivley larger operation. So it certainly took away from it.

 

And when Bush himself has said its a success for mere containment of BinLaden, you have to wonder how low the standards are. Cmon accord, lets say it was Clinton in office and he came out and told everyone "dont worry folks, Bin Laden is contained in his caves, we have succeeded"..how would Republicans treat him? They would fry him.

 

And I wish you guys would refrain from blaming everything on the liberal media. There is no proof that the media is liberal. Not always pro conservative and no always pro Republican? Yes. But liberal? Cmon. Not one person has been able to name me a liberal commentator with his own show on any of the major television networks. The liberal media is the biggest red herring in the history of intelligent discussion.

I keep seeing the U.S. casualty numbers every time there's an article in the newspaper. It's up to 1570 or something. Anyone want to take a shot at the number of Iraqi military that have died? Iraqi civilians?? Because our government screwed up? And yes, you risk death if you're fighting for a terrible dictator in Saddam Hussain. Nevertheless, these are people who would probably be alive had we gotten it "right".

 

 

Interesting that the liberal media never talks about this.

I'm not disagreeing with you and I completely agree that the war in Iraq is unjustified and we should not be there. While it's great we removed Saddam from power and whatnot, it wasn't worth 1,500+ American lives to do it.

And I wish you guys would refrain from blaming everything on the liberal media. There is no proof that the media is liberal. Not always pro conservative and no always pro Republican? Yes. But liberal? Cmon. Not one person has been able to name me a liberal commentator with his own show on any of the major television networks. The liberal media is the biggest red herring in the history of intelligent discussion.

756013[/snapback]

not to get on a totally different tangent here, but ask a few of your friends who aren't particularly liberal or conservative if they perceive a liberal bias coming from the major TV networks.

 

to be completely honest with you, i find the bias so blatantly easy to detect that i usually just write off people who dispute the notion of the major established liberal media as ideologues not worth arguing with. i'm not calling you that--i'm just saying that's how i perceive folks who dispute something i find to be totally obvious.

And I wish you guys would refrain from blaming everything on the liberal media. There is no proof that the media is liberal. Not always pro conservative and no always pro Republican? Yes. But liberal? Cmon.? Not one person has been able to name me a liberal commentator with his own show on any of the major television networks. The liberal media is the biggest red herring in the history of intelligent discussion.

756013[/snapback]

not to get on a totally different tangent here, but ask a few of your friends who aren't particularly liberal or conservative if they perceive a liberal bias coming from the major TV networks.

 

to be completely honest with you, i find the bias so blatantly easy to detect that i usually just write off people who dispute the notion of the major established liberal media as ideologues not worth arguing with. i'm not calling you that--i'm just saying that's how i perceive folks who dispute something i find to be totally obvious.

756048[/snapback]

 

Except the term liberal has been miscontrued ferociously by the right that a LOT of things come off to people as having a liberal slant.

 

For example, if CNN puts up a story that makes Bush look bad, would you not claim thats the liberal CNN doing its thing again? But what exactly makes that per say biased towards liberals?

 

Want a perfect example? Tom Delay does all these unethical things and what does he say? Its the liberal media against him..says it over and over and over and over again. So what happens if the media runs a story tommorow that makes him look bad. Well isnt that what he has been telling us about the media?

 

My point being, if I dont like what someone is saying about me or dont want someone to say something bad about me, cant I characterize them over and over as having an agenda? Then when they critisize me, Ive already provided the cover.

 

And Im not speaking in absolutes here and not as an idealogue. The NYtimes is pretty liberal. Thats clear and obvious. So is the New Republic. Im not denying it when its obvious. But how can something be obviously characteristic when there are numerous examples to the contrary?

I think that's where the distinction needs to be made. Just because a news organization publishes an article which critizes the President/Congress/Government's actions, doesn't mean that they have a liberal bias.

 

Plus, what other excuse would Tom DeLay use? He can't say that the President or Congress is against him because they are of a Democratic majority, since they're not. So what does he do? What pretty much any Republican would when they don't have anything else to whine about, and that's the "liberal media conspiracy" thing. Case closed.

 

Conservatives should realize that they are currently in control, and don't need to whine anymore, at least until after the midterm elections.

Oh the sheer irony that I just happend to be watching the daily show. Stewart has a clip of a CNN piece today. A women who was defending the Texas law banning homosexuals from adopting kids brought up a study that kids in homosexual households are 11x more likely to be abused. The pro gay guy said he never heard of that study. Guess what? The women made it up(obviously) and the great journalist from CNN didnt point it out. Just said good argument from both of you. (Steward ripped her). SHE LET THE CONSERVATIVE GET AWAY WITH MAKING STUFF UP! How is that liberal slant? Would you have seen that as a conservative bias? Thats the kind of stuff that falls through the cracks.

What ever happened to FDR and JFK saying America must be a beacon for democracy, a driving force for democracy? Isolationism did plenty good for this country before WWI and after WWI. Just because we didnt find WMDs in storage facilities, stacked up, doesnt mean Saddam didnt have the capabilities of producing them. We found plenty evidence that he could've made WMDs very easily. Leaving Saddam alone and letting him run his country the way he wanted to run it, wouldve put the security of this country and many other countries at risk. Not only countries but innocent people wouldve have been in grave danger. Innocent people he wouldve slaughtered and sent to his torcher chambers and put away in his mass graves, all things found. Should we apologize? Never. Do you not remember election day in Iraq, or the day Saddam's regime was overtaken, the pure joy of freedom these people enjoyed.

 

It seems like some of you want the US to fail, no matter the cost. Im here to tell you, the US isnt gonna fail, neither are the Iraqi people. 20 years from now, when we are traveling to Iraq and the middle east with ease you will realize these people can live in peace.

Its certainly a leap to invade a country for their potential to be dangerous to us rather than a clear and present threat. We didnt invade because they were a potential threat. We were told the threat was much graver than that. If the threshold to ask our troops to sacrifice themselves was a possibility that a nation could become a threat down the road, then I say its too low a threshold. FDR and JFK both dealt with much graver threats. Heck Cuba was developing facilities for the USSR and JFK didnt invade.

 

 

And of course we should be the beacon of democracy. But idealism aside, lets be honest. Spreading democracy and looking out for the best interests of people in other countries often takes a back seat. The people of Iraq only became a concern of most people when politicians chose to make them a concern.

 

 

Nobody wants the US to fail. I think the biggest problem in this day and age, especially for liberals, is to make it clear that what we want more than anything is our nation to be secure. But the security of the US is not a simple idea. Its very complex. If someone differs on how to preserve that security, they cant be seen as anti US or wimpy on national security.

 

Imagine how many Americans wouldnt have died had we not invaded Vietnam. Vietnam ended up falling to communism anyway and it didnt do anything horrible to us. But if someone before hand had said we shouldnt send our troops there because it isnt a priority, would they be weak on our national security or would they be right?

What ever happened to FDR and JFK saying America must be a beacon for democracy, a driving force for democracy? Isolationism did plenty good for this country before WWI and after WWI. Just because we didnt find WMDs in storage facilities, stacked up, doesnt mean Saddam didnt have the capabilities of producing them. We found plenty evidence that he could've made WMDs very easily. Leaving Saddam alone and letting him run his country the way he wanted to run it, wouldve put the security of this country and many other countries at risk. Not only countries but innocent people wouldve have been in grave danger. Innocent people he wouldve slaughtered and sent to his torcher chambers and put away in his mass graves, all things found. Should we apologize? Never. Do you not remember election day in Iraq, or the day Saddam's regime was overtaken, the pure joy of freedom these people enjoyed.

 

It seems like some of you want the US to fail, no matter the cost. Im here to tell you, the US isnt gonna fail, neither are the Iraqi people. 20 years from now, when we are traveling to Iraq and the middle east with ease you will realize these people can live in peace.

756088[/snapback]

 

 

 

so lets attack north korea.

Bush was wrong about WMDs being there. It doesnt mean that WMDs werent there before we decided to invade. They had a few months to get rid of WMDs. Again was Bush wrong? YES Thats the easy answer. Did Bush LIE? I dont think he blatently lied. I honestly believe that he thought that there were WMDs. Saddam was a credible threat to the security of this country, I believed that, and Bush believed that. I didnt need him to give a speech to figure that out. Saddam was sociopath, with a LARGE history of being a coniving and manipulative person. Bottom line Saddam couldnt be trusted and for anyone to trust him is beyond me.

 

F_M Vietnam was a lot more complicated than the US trying to stop communism. The US was trying to bail out the French. That particular war the US was not losing on the war front.

 

F_M JFK almost started a nuclear war to stop the Russians from brining in weapons to Cuba. He did try to invade unfortunately he botched that one up real nice.

 

F_M If you had the chance to stop Hitler in 1936 would you have done so.

 

F_M I for one dont like to see any American die in conflict. However, to ensure the security and to ensure the American way of life (where you CAN question your leaders), conflicts are necessary.

 

The great thing about this country is that we can discuss this. Believe what you want to believe, I cant tell what to think. This is how I feel. If this was Clinton who invaded Iraq I'd be behind him 100%.

so lets attack north korea.

756095[/snapback]

I have no problem with that.

 

However, this conflict in Iraq has been a great success, in terms of US casualities. Taking out Saddams regime was quick and easy. I feel that N. Korea would take a larger effort...but I am all for removing that regime from N. Korea.

I think my biggest problem with the Iraq war was how we rushed into it so quickly, without making sure that all of our intelligence was correct.

nothing like attacking a soverign nation because we dont like what they may or may not possess.

756105[/snapback]

Very true.... :p

Even with the fact that their were no WMD's ever found the war was still a success because we freed a country from a brutal dictator and gave them a chance at a free life.

756135[/snapback]

 

 

 

awseome!

 

 

i'm paying for us to be the damn freedom figthers of the world.

 

 

ho boy!

 

 

instead of focusing on domestic issues and getting America good for America we are freeing the world from the oppression of those big bad guys.

 

 

Should we make a list of all the bad men we have to throw out of office?

Its the manifest destiny. In the 1800s it was our justification to spread religion, capitalism and democracy to the mexicans and the rest of the west. Now it is our justification to spread those things through the world things dont change. As an arrogant nation we force our system on others nothing shocking really

Its the manifest destiny. In the 1800s it was our justification to spread religion, capitalism and democracy to the mexicans and the rest of the west. Now it is our justification to spread those things through the world things dont change. As an arrogant nation we force our system on others nothing shocking really

756161[/snapback]

 

 

 

may be the same philosophy but you need a different term.

 

 

manifest destiny only extended to the pacific.

Its the manifest destiny. In the 1800s it was our justification to spread religion, capitalism and democracy to the mexicans and the rest of the west. Now it is our justification to spread those things through the world things dont change. As an arrogant nation we force our system on others nothing shocking really

756161[/snapback]

 

 

 

may be the same philosophy but you need a different term.

 

 

manifest destiny only extended to the pacific.

756165[/snapback]

Good point twojuans. It certainly is true that there is an undercurrent of moral propriety to the the invade Iraq cause. You get the sense that its the same philosophy when you see people critisize Arabs for not being grateful. But Im not so sure we live in a world of moral relativism and if we dont have an obligation to consider ourselves the beacon of progress. In places like Iran, intellectual desire to make the nation what we want to make the nation. The autonomy involved here is probably greater. Though we have to be wary with some of those involved in this country ie the neocons.

I don't have a problem with freeing oppressed people, but this country will go broke if we try to help everyone.

 

I think that first, we should solve our domestic problems, before devoting so much money and resources to wars.

I don't have a problem with freeing oppressed people, but this country will go broke if we try to help everyone.

 

I think that first, we should solve our domestic problems, before devoting so much money and resources to wars.

756273[/snapback]

 

If we knew how to fix our domestic problems we wouldnt have to be at war. All the govt does is throw money at things to fix them and that isnt the way htings work.

I don't have a problem with freeing oppressed people, but this country will go broke if we try to help everyone.

 

I think that first, we should solve our domestic problems, before devoting so much money and resources to wars.

756273[/snapback]

 

If we knew how to fix our domestic problems we wouldnt have to be at war. All the govt does is throw money at things to fix them and that isnt the way htings work.

756285[/snapback]

Amen to that...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.