September 5, 200521 yr Author Would anyone disagree with my contention that the Dolphins are far superior to the Panthers at the skill positions? 929922[/snapback] :lol :lol :lol :lol
September 5, 200521 yr Would anyone disagree with my contention that the Dolphins are far superior to the Panthers at the skill positions? 929922[/snapback] :lol :lol :lol :lol 929986[/snapback] Was that disagreement? Cause I'm pretty sure they'd trade all their backs for Ronnie Brown alone. And as for WR, I'd take Chambers over Steve Smith. Booker and Gardner would be about a draw. And I'd take Boston over Colbert. I don't even know who their TE is. I'm sure he's not better than McMichael. I don't know if QB is considered a "skill position". Obviously, if it is, they've got us licked there. And if you are disagreeing, could you try something more than a series of smiley faces? Cause I'm having a hard time seeing what you're getting at with those.
September 5, 200521 yr Author Would anyone disagree with my contention that the Dolphins are far superior to the Panthers at the skill positions? 929922[/snapback] :lol :lol :lol :lol 929986[/snapback] Was that disagreement? Cause I'm pretty sure they'd trade all their backs for Ronnie Brown alone. And as for WR, I'd take Chambers over Steve Smith. Booker and Gardner would be about a draw. And I'd take Boston over Colbert. I don't even know who their TE is. I'm sure he's not better than McMichael. I don't know if QB is considered a "skill position". Obviously, if it is, they've got us licked there. And if you are disagreeing, could you try something more than a series of smiley faces? Cause I'm having a hard time seeing what you're getting at with those. 930096[/snapback] I will give you a draw on the WR position. I was taking into account the QB position as well. As for Ronnie Brown, I don't think they'd trade all their backs for a guy who's never had a carry in the NFL. We both know that an insane college performance doesn't guarantee that the player will be anything like that in the pros.
September 5, 200521 yr As for Ronnie Brown, I don't think they'd trade all their backs for a guy who's never had a carry in the NFL. We both know that an insane college performance doesn't guarantee that the player will be anything like that in the pros. 930097[/snapback] Well, I just disagree with you on that. They don't even like Foster enough to start him over Davis, and Davis must be eligible for senior discounts by now. Anyway, throw in Ricky and tell me what you think.
September 5, 200521 yr Author As for Ronnie Brown, I don't think they'd trade all their backs for a guy who's never had a carry in the NFL. We both know that an insane college performance doesn't guarantee that the player will be anything like that in the pros. 930097[/snapback] Well, I just disagree with you on that. They don't even like Foster enough to start him over Davis, and Davis must be eligible for senior discounts by now. Anyway, throw in Ricky and tell me what you think. 930108[/snapback] I'd kill to have Stephen Davis back in Washington. I am not discounting Ronnie Brown's talent, I'm just not going to hypothesize about a rookie being better than two veterans before any snaps are even taken in the 05 season. As for Ricky, he obviously has the talent, but because of his hiatus and weight loss, I have to think of him the same way I think of a rookie - just going to wait and see.
September 5, 200521 yr The WR are a draw. Their tight ends are Kris Magnum, Mike Seidman, and Gaines. I'll take Steven Davis, Deshaun Foster, and Eric Shelton, plus Brad Hoover and Nick Goings(FB) who also will cary the ball alot, over "High Times" Williams and a rookie. And WR might be a draw or slightly in Miami's favor, but the vastly superior QB makes up for that. I'd say Carolina would be better at QB even if Stefan LeFors was starting.
September 5, 200521 yr IMO, 3 wins for the Dolphins is a bit of a stretch since it puts them on par with the Bills and Niners. If the Bills are a 3 win team, the Dolphins are a 1 win team.
September 5, 200521 yr Well, if you actually think Carolina's RBs are better than Miami's, then I can kinda see why you think Carolina's so great, but I hope you'll forgive me if I don't run over to Vegas and lay a thousand dollars on Carolina. I REALLY think that your assessment of their RB situation is WAAAAAY out of line with common wisdom, though I suppose it's possible that I'm the one who's out of line. IMO, they have one of the crummiest backfields in the league. There's some potential there with Shelton and Foster, but, still, crummy.
September 5, 200521 yr Also, I don't think QB counts as a skill position. But it is more important than all the skill positions combined, so obviously Carolina has a better offense than Miami. There's no way I'm arguing that. I just think teams won't have a big problem defending Carolina.
September 5, 200521 yr Also, I don't think QB counts as a skill position.? But it is more important than all the skill positions combined, so obviously Carolina has a better offense than Miami.? There's no way I'm arguing that.? I just think teams won't have a big problem defending Carolina. 930151[/snapback] 2004 Carolina Passing Stats Yards: 3889 Passing yards(10th NFL, 5th NFC) Yards Per Game: 243.1(10th NFL, 5th NFC) Yards Per Attempt: 7.26(14th NFL, 6th NFC) TDs: 29(T-5th NFL, 4th NFC) INT: 15(13th NFL, 5th NFC) 2004 Carolina Rushing Stats Yards: 1582(28th NFL, 14th NFC) Yards Per Game: 98.9(28th NFL, 14th NFC) Yards Per Carry: 3.7(28th NFL, 13th NFC) TDs: 10(T-19th NFL, T-8th NFC) Fumbles: 17(T-23rd NFL, T-12th NFC) Lost Fumbles: 8(T-24th NFL, T-13th NFC) Attempts: 422(22nd NFL, 9th NFC) 2004 Total Offense Yards: 5225(13th NFL, 6th NFC) Yards per game: 326.6(13th NFL, 6th NFC) Points: 355(13th NFL, 5th NFC) Points per game: 22.2(13th NFL, 5th NFC) Carolina was horrible running the ball last season. But simply by Foster and Davis coming back, and the draft of Shelton, that should improve vastly. The passing game is already there and should improve as well. Dont be suprised if Davis gets traded in the middle of the season either, if Foster and Shelton can prove that they can handle a considerable load of rushing attempts. So, even if they do shut down the run, the pass should be able to make up for it(192 1st downs through the air...4th in the NFC, 8th NFL), but thats all moot as their rushing attack should in theory be greatly improved this year.
September 5, 200521 yr I personally wouldn't be surprised if their rushing stats go DOWN this year. Looking at 3 of the 4 teams below them last year--Miami, Tampa, and Oakland--all the 3 of those teams (I think) improved their rushing game more than Carolina did over the offseason. Also, Mushin Muhammad was pretty good last year. Led the league in receiving yards and TDs. He plays for the Bears now. Maybe you think Mushin was great because of Delhomme. Consider, then, that Carolina's next leading receiver was Keary Colbert with 745 yards. Delhomme sure didn't fix him up great. Colbert was probably about 50th in the league in receiving yards. I don't actually know because neither Yahoo! nor ESPN continue listing past #41. Also, consider that Delhomme's completion percentage was a paltry 58.2% last year. That was good enough for 21st overall. My guess is the passing stats will look worse this year as well. That defense had better be amazing.
September 5, 200521 yr Bengals 2005: at Cleveland - Win (Superior team) Minnesota - Loss (Superior team) at Chicago - Win (Superior team) Houston - Win (at home; probably a little better than them) at Jacksonville - Win (Jags are so overrated) at Tennessee - Win (they suck) Pittsburgh - Loss (Dammit) Green Bay - Win (Home) at Baltimore - Loss (Dammit) Indianapolis - Loss (I doubt they can stop us, but I doubt we can stop them) Baltimore - Win (We'll find a way...just like we did down 14 going into the 4th Q last year at their place) at Pittsburgh - Loss (We usually beat them once a year, but I'll be nice) Cleveland - Win (See above) at Detroit - Win (Joey Harrington..hahaha) Buffalo - Win (No Kitna this time...at home) at Kansas City - Loss (Hard to win there) I want to see how you can possibly see us going 6-10, I want that game by game breakdown. If you have us under .500 at home, you're insane. Obviously, I don't expect this to be right, but I don't even see a scenario we go 6-10, unless we just get pwned by injuries. There's no way we're worse than we were last season, we have our whole offense back and we played a harder schedule last season.
September 5, 200521 yr Minnesota won't be 13-3. 11-5 sounds better Buffalo won't be 3-13. 9-7 sounds better Green Bay won't be 9-7. 6-10 sounds better Baltimore will be MUCH better than 8-8 Tennessee will have trouble sniffing 5-11, let alone 11-5. Chicago is about right at 2-14. Detroit is better than 5-11. Kansas City and Arizona are both better than 7-9. There is NO WAY the Falcons hit 13-3. 9-7 for the overrated group from "NOT-SO-HOT-LANTA" is more like it. Finally, Colts win the Super Bowl over Carolina.
September 5, 200521 yr The Ravens are scary, but until Kyle Boller shows he can pull his weight, they're a .500 team. Why do so many people discount Pittsburgh now? Last time I checked they had excellent coaching and a solid running game. Don't say that Ben Roethlisberger will have a sophomore slump which will result in Pittsburgh missing the playoffs. Ben Roethlisberger threw around 15 passes a game anyway, obviously he's not 100% of the team's success. The same reason you discount the Ravens this season is how you prove that Pittsburgh will be good this year.... Hmmmmmmm
September 12, 200521 yr We'll see who's laughing in January. :plain 929757[/snapback] Bump! I think everyone who's seen your prediction of the Jets winning the AFC East and going to the Superbowl will be laughing. Care to revise your outlook after today's drubbing?
September 12, 200521 yr We'll see who's laughing in January. :plain 929757[/snapback] Bump! I think everyone who's seen your prediction of the Jets winning the AFC East and going to the Superbowl will be laughing. Care to revise your outlook after today's drubbing? 941654[/snapback] To Dodge's credit, the 2003 New England Patriots got absolutely shallacked 31-0 by the Bills and went on to win that funny silver trophy with some Italian guy's name on it.
September 12, 200521 yr Steve Smith looked awesome, which is good news for the Panthers. The bad news: they lost to the freaking Saints at home. The march to the Super Bowl continues.
September 12, 200521 yr We'll see who's laughing in January.? :plain 929757[/snapback] Bump! I think everyone who's seen your prediction of the Jets winning the AFC East and going to the Superbowl will be laughing. Care to revise your outlook after today's drubbing? 941654[/snapback] To Dodge's credit, the 2003 New England Patriots got absolutely shallacked 31-0 by the Bills and went on to win that funny silver trophy with some Italian guy's name on it. 941673[/snapback] And the 2001 New England Patrios lost to the Bengals in Week 1 and went on to do the same.
January 5, 200620 yr k.. I'm bumping this just for fun.. some interesting arguments in this thread. We need something to talk about until wildcard weekend. Sorry Dodge :mischief
January 5, 200620 yr This thread is hilarious. Everyone was wrong about everything. I like where I said that I'd take Chris Chambers over Steve Smith.
January 5, 200620 yr Bengals 2005: at Cleveland - Win (Superior team) Minnesota - Loss (Superior team) at Chicago - Win (Superior team) Houston - Win (at home; probably a little better than them) at Jacksonville - Win (Jags are so overrated) at Tennessee - Win (they suck) Pittsburgh - Loss (Dammit) Green Bay - Win (Home) at Baltimore - Loss (Dammit) Indianapolis - Loss (I doubt they can stop us, but I doubt we can stop them) Baltimore - Win (We'll find a way...just like we did down 14 going into the 4th Q last year at their place) at Pittsburgh - Loss (We usually beat them once a year, but I'll be nice) Cleveland - Win (See above) at Detroit - Win (Joey Harrington..hahaha) Buffalo - Win (No Kitna this time...at home) at Kansas City - Loss (Hard to win there) I want to see how you can possibly see us going 6-10, I want that game by game breakdown. If you have us under .500 at home, you're insane. Obviously, I don't expect this to be right, but I don't even see a scenario we go 6-10, unless we just get pwned by injuries. There's no way we're worse than we were last season, we have our whole offense back and we played a harder schedule last season. :lol I didn't even rememeber making this post. I had us going 10-6, 1 off, but I missed 5 of the individual games. Good times.
January 5, 200620 yr This thread is hilarious. Everyone was wrong about everything. I like where I said that I'd take Chris Chambers over Steve Smith. :lol :lol :lol :lol Yeah I saw that. Yeah everyone was wrong about something in this thread.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.