Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

JP Rumors with Seattle

Featured Replies

rw:

Along with Ron Villone, Juan Pierre is a target in the Mariners' trade talks with the Marlins.

 

We assume that any Pierre deal would include Jeremy Reed going the other way, as there wouldn't be any room for him in the Seattle outfield with Pierre in center. Considering that Reed is a better defender than Pierre and will probably be the better hitter of the two by 2007, the Mariners should stand pat.

 

Man would I love to see Jeremy Reed here. His defense in PPS would be out-freakin-standing to watch.

 

Didn't hit particularly well last year but drew a nice share of walks.. and has had more walks than K's in each of his seasons in the minors.

 

I would absolutely love to see him on the Marlins.

I've never seen him play or know too much about him, but I've heard he's a great young player.

Do it...quick.

 

Reed and Hermida and Willingham in the outfield for the next 4 years? :drool

Do it...quick.

 

Reed and Hermida and Willingham in the outfield for the next 4 years? :drool

 

 

I agree but we would need to find someone who is superior to Willingham to play LF. There are plenty of young options and we still have many players left to trade.

  • Author

Spike doesn't like Willingham. STOP THE PRESSES

It's not that I dont like Willingham, it's just that I dont think he is good enough to start at the MLB level and would get destroyed by MLB pitching.

 

When he was dominating in AA he was already a 24 or 25 year old college product playing against kids 3 years younger on average, and the same in AAA.

 

He is 27 now, has no defensive value, and has shown nothing that makes it seem like he should be the automatic starter in LF.

 

I am sorry that I disagree with all of you, but I don't see Willingham as anything but an average utility player, and think that him as a regular starter would hurt the team more than any move we have made.

It's not that I dont like Willingham, it's just that I dont think he is good enough to start at the MLB level and would get destroyed by MLB pitching.

 

When he was dominating in AA he was already a 24 or 25 year old college product playing against kids 3 years younger on average, and the same in AAA.

 

He is 27 now, has no defensive value, and has shown nothing that makes it seem like he should be the automatic starter in LF.

 

I am sorry that I disagree with all of you, but I don't see Willingham as anything but an average utility player, and think that him as a regular starter would hurt the team more than any move we have made.

 

seriously dude.

 

have you ever watched Josh play the field? Im being honest here because I feel like you havent. He is more than adequate in the corner outfield positions and he has a pretty good arm as well. And if you dont think his bat is ready, you got another thing coming.

I look forward to rubbing his stats in Spike's face all season.

  • Author

Dude, seriously. You say the same thing over and over and over and over again. You don't like him. WE GET IT.

 

This forum was a lot better when you were on suspension.. seriously. No offence.

Is it that hard to fathom that we can find someone better than a 27 year old career minor leaguer? It worked with Jason Bay and the Pirates, but I dont see it happening with Willingham and us.

 

in all seriousness, have you ever EVER watched him play?

Yes I have, and I have never seen anything which makes it seem like he should be the automatic option to start in LF. You all think the guy can walk on water, I think he would struggle to hit .200 at the MLB level.

 

I have no personal dislike of the guy, I'd love to see him as a bench player, but I personally dont want him anywhere near the starting lineup.

 

If he does it and does well I'll eat my crow, if he proves he is not good enough, I expect the same from everyone on here who thinks he is the messiah.

Career minor leaguer. :lol

 

The only "career minor leaguers" on our current roster are Joe Dillon (MLB debut in 8th pro season) and Chris Aguila (MLB debut in 8th pro season).

 

Willingham reached the majors in his 5th pro season. And part of the reason it took him that long is because we moved him to catcher, thus slowing his development. It's not rocket science.

It's not that I dont like Willingham, it's just that I dont think he is good enough to start at the MLB level and would get destroyed by MLB pitching.

 

When he was dominating in AA he was already a 24 or 25 year old college product playing against kids 3 years younger on average, and the same in AAA.

 

He is 27 now, has no defensive value, and has shown nothing that makes it seem like he should be the automatic starter in LF.

 

I am sorry that I disagree with all of you, but I don't see Willingham as anything but an average utility player, and think that him as a regular starter would hurt the team more than any move we have made.

 

 

Holy crap I can't believe you found it necessary to do this once again.

 

I'm thinking that from now on you could just type, "Hi, it's Spike!" on every post and that's it. We'll just assume there's a bunch of stuff underneath on how you don't think Josh Willingham is any good.

Actually I've said all I am going to say about Willingham:

 

If he wins the LF spot and sucks I'll say I told you so

If he wins the LF spot and does well I'll eat my crow

 

All I want is another option. Holliday, taking Hamilton in the rule V draft, something. That is fair is it not? Because Willingham is no gurantee to be any good at the big level.

I personally hope we try to trade for someone like Matt Holliday...the Rocks want Lo Duca right? Give them something else and get Holliday and JD Closser. I also want Gathright.

 

 

Hell, as long as we're at it, I want Barry Bonds.

I love the trade.

I think Reed has the possibility to be amazing for us. He has good speed to, so he could be a threat on the bases (not as much as pierre).

 

But he is expected to develope into a 5 tool player.

 

Here are some other JP rumors

 

Pierre Deal To Yanks Has Marlins Perkin?

December 2

New York Post (registration required): " Now, Pierre could be returning to The Bronx as the Yankees? center-fielder. The cash-dumping Marlins have asked for lefty Sean Henn and right-handed reliever Scott Proctor for Pierre, and the Yankees didn?t reject the offer."

Should White Sox add Pierre?

December 2

Chicago Tribune columnist Phil Rogers (scroll down) (registration required): "Even if Williams finds a way to add Juan Pierre as a second leadoff man, it wouldn't be as bad as standing pat would have been. Pierre could be a one-year rental, here only to help the White Sox's chances of a repeat."

Guillen not one to rest on Sox? achievements

December 2

Daily Herald (registration required): "After trading for Thome and retaining Konerko, Williams said he?s not looking to make any more major moves. Still, rumors abound that the Sox will add a speedy center fielder such as the Florida Marlins? Juan Pierre or the Tampa Bay Devil Rays? Joey Gathright."

Pierre may be Plan B

December 2

Boston Globe (scroll down): "Boston is aware the Yankees plan to wade into the Johnny Damon negotiations, which has led them, league sources said, to begin exploring the possibility of Juan Pierre as Plan B."

 

Trading for Gathright was already a rumor, as was Dook to the Rockies, but what we would get in return was not specified.

 

 

I could see us trading off willingham and a pitching prospect for Gathright. Not sure if it is really a good trade for us. But, never know.

Seattle is supposedly upset that Reed's power numbers havent been growing.

 

 

Well that certainly makes JP all the more valuable :D

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.