February 14, 200620 yr Mike Lowell didn't force anyone to trade a corner-stone. You can put the blame on th Front Office. :thumbup Or drug testing. Uh no. Drug testing didn't force Loria and Co. to go into this "market correction". Oh but it resulted in Lowell's disappearance and thus the departure of Beckett. Have any actual evidence to support this claim. Or are you just going to invoke the Spike Clause (just pull stuff out of your ass and present it as fact)?
February 14, 200620 yr This isn't really based on anything, just who I liked watching the best. C-Mike Redmond 1B-Derrek Lee 2B-Luis Castillo SS-Alex Gonzalez 3B-Mike Lowell pre-2004 LF-Cliff Floyd CF-Chuck Carr RF-Mark Kotsay SP-Ryan Dempster SP-Alex Fernandez SP-Al Leiter SP-Livan Hernandez SP-Kevin Brown
February 14, 200620 yr Mike Lowell didn't force anyone to trade a corner-stone. You can put the blame on th Front Office. :thumbup Or drug testing. Uh no. Drug testing didn't force Loria and Co. to go into this "market correction". Oh but it resulted in Lowell's disappearance and thus the departure of Beckett. Have any actual evidence to support this claim. Or are you just going to invoke the Spike Clause (just pull stuff out of your ass and present it as fact)? Well, if Barry Bonds and Sammy Sosa are guilty until proven innocent, and Mike Lowell had a much greater dropoff at the same period (when drug testing was announced in '04), a reasonable man could assume that a "debut late" and surprising power surge at the age of 30 player is just as guilty, it's just that Lowell is beloved by the local media and most national media outlets could care less about the Marlins unless they're the butt of an overdone joke.
February 14, 200620 yr Lets look at a few stats... Season-Age-2B-HR 2000-26-38-22 2001-27-37-18 2002-28-44-24 2003-29-27-32 2004-30-44-27 2005-31-36-8 Coincidentally Mike Lowell's doubles numbers dropped the same season his HR power increased. During 2004 (the season drug testing began) Mike Lowell had a very good season. Until someone provides facts I'm going to have to see the 2003-2004 as his career years. I'll wait until after this season where he'll work with a new hitting coach to determine if 2005 was a fluke or an indication of something else.
February 14, 200620 yr During 2004 (the season drug testing began) Mike Lowell had a very good season. Drug testing began in 2005, it was announced during the 2004 season. Lowell's second half of 2004 was atrocious...coincidence, no?
February 14, 200620 yr During 2004 (the season drug testing began) Mike Lowell had a very good season. Drug testing began in 2005, it was announced during the 2004 season. Lowell's second half of 2004 was atrocious...coincidence, no? Testing began in 2003... 2002 ? Before 2002, Major League Baseball had no official policy on steroid use among players. As part of a collective bargaining agreement, players and owners agree to hold survey testing in 2003. If more than 5% of results from the anonymous tests are positive, formal testing and penalties will be put into place the next year. 2003 ? Baseball announces after the season that 5% to 7% of test results were positive, triggering the new policy in 2004. 2004 ? Each player is tested once a year in season. A first positive test results in treatment, followed by a 15-day suspension for a second positive and up to a year suspension for a fifth positive. The result is no player is suspended for steroid use. 2005 ? Baseball agrees to a new policy. Banned substances include steroids, steroid precursors, designer steroids, masking agents and diuretics. There will be one unannounced mandatory test of each player during the season. In addition, there will be testing of randomly selected players, with no maximum number. And there will be random testing during the offseason. The penalties for a positive result are, first positive, 10 days; second, 30 days; third, 60 days; fourth, one year, and all without pay.
February 14, 200620 yr The policy, as it is now with actual reprecussions began in 2005. Anonymous testing with no penalties began in response to the Caminiti article in SI.
February 14, 200620 yr The policy, as it is now with actual reprecussions began in 2005. Anonymous testing with no penalties began in response to the Caminiti article in SI. Yeah ok and? During the 2004 season they still had a steroid policy regardless of how bad it was.
February 14, 200620 yr The policy, as it is now with actual reprecussions began in 2005. Anonymous testing with no penalties began in response to the Caminiti article in SI. Yeah ok and? During the 2004 season they still had a steroid policy regardless of how bad it was. A policy without teeth gets no results. If people don't have to worry about being outed after the first positive, they're not going to stop what they're doing. They were cheating in the first place, a slap on the wrist isn't going to stop them. Hence the new policy with teeth and the shocking decline in power numbers coinciding with the announcement/enactment of policy.
February 14, 200620 yr But it isn't fair to call Mike Lowell a roider because his numbers dropped the season MLB implemented "testing with teeth". If Mike Lowell has a 2003-2004 similar to the previous few years of his career I would still choose him over Cabrera at third. I'll let you have the last word because this thread has gotten way off-topic. Singling out guys because their numbers dropped following testing isn't fair. At this point you gotta look at everyone's numbers and give them the benefit of the doubt. Lets remember not only was the player in question using roids but also the competition in Mikey's case the pitcher.
February 14, 200620 yr Uhh Back to the topic please.... I love when these all-time teams pop up in discussion. Here goes C- CJ 1b-DLee 2b-Luis ss-Edgar 3b-Bonilla LF-Niner CF-Floyd (I can't remember if actually played there, but I want him on my team) RF-Sheff 5 starters-Dempster, Brown, Livan, D-Train and Hough closer-Nen
February 14, 200620 yr Lets remember not only was the player in question using roids but also the competition in Mikey's case the pitcher. So two wrongs make a right?
February 14, 200620 yr See this is where its tough. C- Charles Johnson (easy) 2b- Luis Castillo SS- Edgar Renteria 3B- Mike Lowell CF- Juan Pierre Those I think are the easy ones. Then it gets hairy.... you have Jeff Conine, Miguel Cabrera and Gary Sheffield. They all probably deserve to be on that team. So I'll just get creative. LF- Miguel Cabrera RF- Gary Sheffiled 1b- Jeff Conine SP- Josh Beckett SP - Dontrelle Willis SP- Kevin Brown SP- Ryan Dempster SP- Livan Hernandez RP- Robb Nen RP- Bryan Harvey I think the other 4 spots are wide open. I'll complete the rest of hte 25 man roster later on. We'll see how interesting it can get
February 14, 200620 yr To each his own, but if you say that the only reason Cabrera played third was that Lowell was hurt, well then I respond that the reason Lowell was on the trading block for the better part of '03 was because of Cabrera. I'll be honest though, I no longer care for Lowell. I dislike the fact that many of his accomplishments are likely steroid tainted, that he undermined most of the past two seasons through whining to the media and that he forced us to deal one of the franchise corner-stones we had to get out from under the dead-weight that was his contract. I agree you can't overlook that Lowell is the leader of most career offensive categories, but that's simply because of tenure. Cabrera likely will have the career lead in most of Lowell's categories in 2 years anyway, and he already leads Lowell in most single season categories. I think Cabrera at third is a fine choice, considering Conine and Sheffield both deserves spots in the starting lineup. swifty i would love to see your proof that Mikey Lowell was on steroids.....do you have documentation to this......you can believe what you want but don't make it sound like a fact.....mikey lowell has never been busted for steroids or anything else. mike did nothing but bust his ass to fight back from testicular cancer to become one of the best if not the best defensive third baseman in the national league and led him to have superb years prior to the last 1 1/2 years..... everyone is allowed to struggle and I think that some people might think what you think but until there is proof and a he is suspended for that matter.....don't accuse him of something that drastic....
February 14, 200620 yr Anyone who doesn't have Mike Lowell starting at 3B on an All-Time Marlins team doesn't understand the concept. Franchise leader in HR and RBI. Cabrera is a defensive liability on the OF. And Miggy has to be play :lol :lol :lol What a lame excuse. Since when are all-time teams based on defense? Breaking news: Cabrera has only played 60-something games at 3rd. That shouldn't make him eligible to be the greatest third basemen in Marlins history when there is someone that's been there longer and leads (or near the top) the franchise in many offensive categories. Talk to me in 2-3 years and my position will most likely have changed. :thumbup Mike Lowell is a solid player (I still think he is), but he is not or will ever be at the level of Miguel Cabrera. You can build your team on sentimental reasons, I made my selections based on the best overall player for each position.
February 14, 200620 yr Anyone who doesn't have Mike Lowell starting at 3B on an All-Time Marlins team doesn't understand the concept. Franchise leader in HR and RBI. Cabrera is a defensive liability on the OF. And Miggy has to be play :lol :lol :lol What a lame excuse. Since when are all-time teams based on defense? Breaking news: Cabrera has only played 60-something games at 3rd. That shouldn't make him eligible to be the greatest third basemen in Marlins history when there is someone that's been there longer and leads (or near the top) the franchise in many offensive categories. Talk to me in 2-3 years and my position will most likely have changed. :thumbup Mike Lowell is a solid player (I still think he is), but he is not or will ever be at the level of Miguel Cabrera. You can build your team on sentimental reasons, I made my selections based on the best overall player for each position. Fine. I agree, Lowell can't touch Cabrera. But the fact remains Mike Lowell has better numbers at the third base position up until now all-time as a Marlins. Like I said before 2-3 years from now this may not be the case. Cabrera as of now deserves a slot in the outfield and not in the infield.
February 14, 200620 yr LF: Jeff Conine CF: Juan Pierre RF: Cliff Floyd 1B: Derek Lee 2B: Luis Castillo SS: Edgar Renteria 3B: Miguel Cabrera C: Ivan Rodriguez 1S: Dontrelle Willis 2S: Kevin Brown 3S: Brad Penny 4S: Carl Pavano 5S: AJ Burnett SU: Ugueth Urbina CL: Armando Benitez Pinch hitter: Gary Sheffield Can you squeeze a few more teams into your signature?? Pick a damn squad Poptart.
February 14, 200620 yr Can you squeeze a few more teams into your signature?? Pick a damn squad Poptart. i was thinking the same....
February 14, 200620 yr swifty i would love to see your proof that Mikey Lowell was on steroids..... .236, 8/58 in the first year of drug-testing. If a former power-hitter who hit .221, 14/55 is guilty as sin of being a 'roider (without testing positive either, mind you), you're being naive if you think that Lowell is unquestionably innocent.
February 14, 200620 yr swifty i would love to see your proof that Mikey Lowell was on steroids..... .236, 8/58 in the first year of drug-testing. If a former power-hitter who hit .221, 14/55 is guilty as sin of being a 'roider (without testing positive either, mind you), you're being naive if you think that Lowell is unquestionably innocent. that.... and did anyone else watch him hit this year?... every time I thought he "got it", the ball still landed well short of the warning track in 2004, that ball was waaaaaaaay outta here
February 14, 200620 yr swifty i would love to see your proof that Mikey Lowell was on steroids..... .236, 8/58 in the first year of drug-testing. If a former power-hitter who hit .221, 14/55 is guilty as sin of being a 'roider (without testing positive either, mind you), you're being naive if you think that Lowell is unquestionably innocent. that.... and did anyone else watch him hit this year?... every time I thought he "got it", the ball still landed well short of the warning track in 2004, that ball was waaaaaaaay outta here so what? he is still the franchise leader in home run and rbi. to not put him on there is silly.
February 14, 200620 yr swifty i would love to see your proof that Mikey Lowell was on steroids..... .236, 8/58 in the first year of drug-testing. If a former power-hitter who hit .221, 14/55 is guilty as sin of being a 'roider (without testing positive either, mind you), you're being naive if you think that Lowell is unquestionably innocent. that.... and did anyone else watch him hit this year?... every time I thought he "got it", the ball still landed well short of the warning track in 2004, that ball was waaaaaaaay outta here so what? he is still the franchise leader in home run and rbi. to not put him on there is silly. I wasnt arguing about that.... why dont you take a look at what we are talking about, mmkay?
February 14, 200620 yr Author Can you squeeze a few more teams into your signature?? Pick a damn squad Poptart. yes, and no.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.