August 21, 200620 yr Just in the hypothetical, one has to wonder, assuming Ramp is correct about Girardi's tenure, he very well may have seized an opportunity to instigate an argument to get himself fired, and thusly place himself (and with him the entire coaching staff) squarely at the front of the line for Dusty's job. Perhaps the real reason cooler heads prevailed was to protect the Marlins negotiating position. Since the Marlins hold all the cards (they are paying him relatively little and can keep him from working for the next couple of years if is their pleasure). If history is any indicator, and Chicago is indeed interested, there's a price to be paid, and not an insignificant one. Were it me, I'd be looking at Murton and at least one prospect as compensation for the manager, and one more every coach who departs along with him. Stripping the Cubs of every piece of low-cost/high value prospect talent would be the name of the game. Otherwise Joe can sulk around the dugout for another two years, or if is his preference, at home on the couch without a paycheck or a job. But, be clear, he won't be even talking to Chicago unless the Marlins are guaranteed their compensation first. The last time this happened the pricetag was Randy Winn, at the time an all-star for TB, and that was just for the manager. No reason not to ask for the sun and moon. After all, you have to assume you are handing over an entire coaching staff as well. There is almost no amount of compensation to offset the loss, but not doubt Admin Beinfest will pick the Cubbies clean. When he gets done it will take the Cubs years to recover. Which in itself is fine with me. After the firesale the last offseason, if we were to trade Girardi for some Cubs prospects the Marlins won't live down the image of being a farm system for big market teams for another 10 to 15 years. As it stands, it will be at least 7 to 10 years until we live down that image. If there are irreconciable differences between Girardi and Loria I'd rather see the Marlins fire him. I don't feel like hearing jokes about Marlins plans on trading Billy the Marlin for a pitching machine for another 15 years. We will live down that image as soon as we win our third World Series title in 2008. :thumbup No, we won't live it down until after we win another WS and we hold onto a majority of the players that got us the WS trophy past their arby years (2009-2012). Who cares what our reputation is if we are winning ? Just win baby. Any franchise in sports would be ecstatic over 3 championships in 15 years.
August 21, 200620 yr Just in the hypothetical, one has to wonder, assuming Ramp is correct about Girardi's tenure, he very well may have seized an opportunity to instigate an argument to get himself fired, and thusly place himself (and with him the entire coaching staff) squarely at the front of the line for Dusty's job. Perhaps the real reason cooler heads prevailed was to protect the Marlins negotiating position. Since the Marlins hold all the cards (they are paying him relatively little and can keep him from working for the next couple of years if is their pleasure). If history is any indicator, and Chicago is indeed interested, there's a price to be paid, and not an insignificant one. Were it me, I'd be looking at Murton and at least one prospect as compensation for the manager, and one more every coach who departs along with him. Stripping the Cubs of every piece of low-cost/high value prospect talent would be the name of the game. Otherwise Joe can sulk around the dugout for another two years, or if is his preference, at home on the couch without a paycheck or a job. But, be clear, he won't be even talking to Chicago unless the Marlins are guaranteed their compensation first. The last time this happened the pricetag was Randy Winn, at the time an all-star for TB, and that was just for the manager. No reason not to ask for the sun and moon. After all, you have to assume you are handing over an entire coaching staff as well. There is almost no amount of compensation to offset the loss, but not doubt Admin Beinfest will pick the Cubbies clean. When he gets done it will take the Cubs years to recover. Which in itself is fine with me. After the firesale the last offseason, if we were to trade Girardi for some Cubs prospects the Marlins won't live down the image of being a farm system for big market teams for another 10 to 15 years. As it stands, it will be at least 7 to 10 years until we live down that image. If there are irreconciable differences between Girardi and Loria I'd rather see the Marlins fire him. I don't feel like hearing jokes about Marlins plans on trading Billy the Marlin for a pitching machine for another 15 years. We will live down that image as soon as we win our third World Series title in 2008. :thumbup No, we won't live it down until after we win another WS and we hold onto a majority of the players that got us the WS trophy past their arby years (2009-2012). Who cares what our reputation is if we are winning ? Just win baby. Any franchise in sports would be ecstatic over 3 championships in 15 years. The Marlins have had the most pronounced highs and lows of any baseball team in recent memory. But I was just speaking to outside perceptions of this team. Personally, I hope at some point that the Marlins start plunking down some cash to retain key players. My hope is that point will come once the Marlins get their own stadium and are able to draw all of the revenues from that stadium.
August 21, 200620 yr Let's suppose things take a turn for the worse, and the Marlins do poorly next year after having lost Girardi, what sort of pressure will be on Loria? Does our media have enough clout do run him out of town? And if they do run him out of town, will he take the Marlins with him or do they stay?
August 21, 200620 yr Let's suppose things take a turn for the worse, and the Marlins do poorly next year after having lost Girardi, what sort of pressure will be on Loria? Does our media have enough clout do run him out of town? And if they do run him out of town, will he take the Marlins with him or do they stay? I doubt whatever backlash Loria and the Marlins could possibly get from poor performance next season would be worse than the backlash of the trades last offseason (at the time). Not that I think the Marlins are going to have a worse season in 2007. There will be no period of the team learning how to play together or feeling they have to prove they deserve to be in the bigs. They'll know they all deserve to be in the bigs (besides Abercrombie if he somehow manages to get back on the 25 man roster) and that they can compete with any team out there.
August 21, 200620 yr I was trying to provoke discussion more than anything else, but it seems like the media is turning on Loria now more than they have anytime in the past. Numerous news sources were giving Loria a pass with the firesale, some even saying that it was called for. Why is Loria taking as much heat as he is for this incident and will it escalate? It's very strange.
August 21, 200620 yr The only ones who will believe the image that the Marlins are a farm club for others fall into two groups: 1) The Yankees, Red Sox and Mets fans who think of even the Cubs, Dodgers and Orioles as their farm clubs; or 2) weak Marlins fans who view the world as us vs. them and every little win a triumph in face of overcoming odds. I choose to ignore 1 because they ignore me. I choose to ignore 2 because their opinions are so infected by their martyrdom to be rational.
August 21, 200620 yr The only ones who will believe the image that the Marlins are a farm club for others fall into two groups: 1) The Yankees, Red Sox and Mets fans who think of even the Cubs, Dodgers and Orioles as their farm clubs; or 2) weak Marlins fans who view the world as us vs. them and every little win a triumph in face of overcoming odds. I choose to ignore 1 because they ignore me. I choose to ignore 2 because their opinions are so infected by their martyrdom to be rational. oh please...everyone knows the Marlins are a farm system to others teams...but who cares because we win more championships than other teams as well. Don't try to ignore that we aren't though....Dontrelle Willis and Girardi are next! And we will become a better team by trading them as well.
August 21, 200620 yr We aren't a farm system for other clubs. Anyone who says so is focusing too much on who is gone rather than the how and why. The favorite player syndrome. Beinfest has built his teams on youth and signed short-term mercenaries. He'll trade, let go or release them young and old if they're holding the team back from winning by either stinking up the field or hampering payroll or promise greater value in trade. The decision to constantly rotate players to keep the club consistently competitive. Not necessarily because we lack the resources to keep players. That's the disconnect between the Marlins front office and certain fans. The Marlins are always forward thinking. Fans are always backward thinking (i.e., 'OMG! Let's get this former Marlins so I can remember all the great fun I had back in year XXXX').
August 21, 200620 yr We aren't a farm system for other clubs. Anyone who says so is focusing too much on who is gone rather than the how and why. The favorite player syndrome. Beinfest has built his teams on youth and signed short-term mercenaries. He'll trade, let go or release them young and old if they're holding the team back from winning by either stinking up the field or hampering payroll or promise greater value in trade. The decision to constantly rotate players to keep the club consistently competitive. Not necessarily because we lack the resources to keep players. That's the disconnect between the Marlins front office and certain fans. The Marlins are always forward thinking. Fans are always backward thinking (i.e., 'OMG! Let's get this former Marlins so I can remember all the great fun I had back in year XXXX'). Hit the nail on the head :thumbup
August 21, 200620 yr First of all let me make it clear that I do not consider the Florida Marlins to be a farm system for other big market teams. I just wanted to make that clear to anyone reading this if it wasn't already clear from what I previously wrote. I was speaking about what the fans of other big market teams consider the Marlins due to periodic fire sales. And apparently some Marlins fans. If I viewed the team as merely being a farm team for big market teams I would not still be a fan of this team. Now let's go on to rferry's posts. We aren't a farm system for other clubs. Anyone who says so is focusing too much on who is gone rather than the how and why. The favorite player syndrome. Beinfest has built his teams on youth and signed short-term mercenaries. He'll trade, let go or release them young and old if they're holding the team back from winning by either stinking up the field or hampering payroll or promise greater value in trade. The decision to constantly rotate players to keep the club consistently competitive. Not necessarily because we lack the resources to keep players. The statement that the Marlins constantly "rotate" players to keep the club "consistently competitive" is false. It is clear that the Marlins built a team that will be competitive in future seasons. Maybe even 2007 with the quick maturation of some players and suprise gems like Dan Uggla on the squad. To write that we held last seasons firesale "not necessarily" because we lack the resources to keep players is dishonest. That was the reason repeatedly given by the Marlins FO. There is no doubt that the tenor of the firesale was different this time around (we held out for better quality prospects ready for MLB action), but that does not negate the fact this was the reason the firesale happened. The only ones who will believe the image that the Marlins are a farm club for others fall into two groups: 1) The Yankees, Red Sox and Mets fans who think of even the Cubs, Dodgers and Orioles as their farm clubs; or 2) weak Marlins fans who view the world as us vs. them and every little win a triumph in face of overcoming odds. I choose to ignore 1 because they ignore me. I choose to ignore 2 because their opinions are so infected by their martyrdom to be rational. That's the disconnect between the Marlins front office and certain fans. The Marlins are always forward thinking. Fans are always backward thinking (i.e., 'OMG! Let's get this former Marlins so I can remember all the great fun I had back in year XXXX'). Rferry, it is clear you are more of a fan of the business side of the game rather than actual players. They are just set pieces to you whose glory is just a reflection of the glory and talent of the General Manager and Front Office. That is your prerogative. I came to terms with this offseason's firesale a long time ago and have praised Beinfest for the job he did under the circumstances assembling a fine squad. Like I said, they might be able to make a playoff run next season. If they can acquire a quality centerfielder in the offseason, resign Olivo and add one or two quality relievers I think we might be in business. I realize that these moves were needed after the red ink Loria and the Marlins were swimming in. I hope the fact that almost every player on the team will be making the MLB minimum for the next two years will be the key to getting any stadium financing shortfalls covered and signing players to extensions past their arby years once a stadium deal is finalized. One thing that is clear is that this is not the way to run a baseball team longterm if you have any interest in generating a fan base and building upon that fan base year after year. The attendance figures bear that out. We have heard many testimonials on here from season ticket holders who plan on cancelling their season tickets after this season because of what the Marlins FO did this offseason. Why is this? It is because the fans don't come out to root for Admin Beinfest, David Samson or Jeffrey Loria. They come out to root for Dontrelle Willis and Miguel Cabrera. They come to root for the team. I think the squad the Marlins currently have is one that could eventually draw out more fans than teams in years past. It will take time for many fans to come back, but eventually they will. And let me just reiterate, to keep this marginally on topic, if the Marlins were to trade Girardi for prospects we would be the laughingstock of the baseball community after the recent firesale.
August 21, 200620 yr Excellent points by both RFerry AND PBC Marlin. Just a couple of comments though.... RFerry, "favorite player syndrome" as you elequently put it, is not a bad thing. Fans, especially kids, like to have idols that are around for more than 7 months. Stop being such a robot. PBC Marlin.....fantastic post but I dont agree that we would be the laughing stock of baseball if Girardi was canned. It would be a stupid move but it wouldnt be nearly as bad as our 2 firesales
August 21, 200620 yr I follow the players more than the men behind the action. I just realize all we're really cheering for is the colors of the club (mock the teal and you'll be punched). Players come and go. I'll still follow Conine and Luiy's careers. It's true that there are some factors that cause the club to do some things that others wouldn't. Just as there's some cranky fans in Chicago and New York that affect what the Mets, Cubs and Yankees do. Or what the Orioles and Nationals, or Angels and Dodgers do. Things don't operate in a vacuum. However you shouldn't ignore that the rebuilding progress was done to produce rewards sooner than in 1998. That wasn't just luck. That wasn't some guess. That was a calculated attempt to contend while Cabrera and Willis, our best two players, were with the club. Those, the same people who invested small sums in Pudge and Delgado, traded cheap solid players like Choi and Penny for veteran marginal talent, routinely piece together competitive team after competitive team, knew that and set out he job they assigned themselves. You may say that's a sign of a good front office, and that it may be. However, it's been said that any baseball team with a plan wins more often than one without. The plan may be good. The men behind it may be good. But recognize that they have it. And that plan, not the extraneous factors, are what is guiding their decisions. Whether or not they're a farm club doesn't even enter their consciousness. It only does with those fans who haven't learned or come to accept that their favorite player(s) will eventually being playing in other colors.
August 21, 200620 yr It just sounds like you had too much love for that 2005 squad (which I think was no better than the 2006 team and I knew that coming into opening day). There are offensive upgrades at nearly every position in the lineup and I would take almost every pitcher in the rotation this year over last year's. Beckett and Burnett can stay out. Loria and Samson could never have said that the moves made in the offseason were baseball moves because the media and the local fans aren't smart enough. The media spins the firesale by making it sound like losing Beckett, Burnett, Lowell, Pierre, Mota were devastating losses when in reality that was addition by subtraction. Actually, you couldn't be more wrong. I didn't have much love for the 2005 squad at all. Too many teams it looked like that team was just going through the motions. Many games they seemed to just turn it in once they found themselves behind and it was hard to watch. Our current squad is much more exciting to watch and the potential of the team if the young rookies continue to improve is scary. Bearing in mind the Marlins financial situation/stadium situation I understood the neccesity of the firesale. And I am pleased with the players we got back for the most part. They only trade in which we really got reamed was the Luis Castillo trade. It also hurt to see Beckett get traded in order to unload Lowell's contract, but it looks like Anibal might be the real deal and I definitely have been suprised by Hanley this season despite all of his shortcomings. All of that said, don't try to tell me this wasn't mainly about all salary possible while still fielding a team that had a chance at playing respectable baseball and possibly contending soon. Of course the Marlins looked to maximize the young talent they got in return (and it has paid off in spades), but first and foremost was cost cutting. If it wasn't you would see, at the least, Beckett, Castillo and Lo Duca still in Marlins uniforms.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.