August 14, 200620 yr Who did Girardi want to play catcher instead of Olivo? Willy? Treanor? I'm guessing Treanor because for awhile they were splitting the catching duties pretty evenly. Don't you supporters think it's pretty amazing that he was wrong about many of the players having career years (Johnson, Nolasco, and now Olivo)? Please forgive Girardi for misplacing his crystal ball. DelGot2rings and the penguin, For this team to even be mentioned in the WC chase in the middle of August ALONE is evidence enough of Girardi's success. Should they have a 6 game lead in the NL East? Get real. EVERY LAS VEGAS oddsmaker had this team projected to fail miserably this year. DelGOT2rings, you must be kidding me when you say Girardi supporters never give evidence of what he has done to improve this young ballclub. I will not go over those points for the 10th time. Go back and find em. Its laughable that you went into exile when the Marlins went on their astonishing run on May 22nd because you knew your Girardi propaganda would be laughed at on this board. The 2006 Marlins have NO CF, for the first 2 months the bullpen failed miserably (all of them) and they play defense like a bunch of rookie kids (which fittingly, they are). So dont tell me that the payroll is not an issue. You dont want it to be used as a defense for Girardi because you know its his best defense. Girardi has played very well with the deck he was dealt.
August 14, 200620 yr And the only people saying that this team is in the Wild Card race are the kool aid drinkers on this board. i believe they have a chance and have never drank kool aid but i think you might be a drinker of this http://forum.atlasrr.com/forum/data/Silico...29_Haterade.gif
August 14, 200620 yr And the only people saying that this team is in the Wild Card race are the kool aid drinkers on this board. i believe they have a chance and have never drank kool aid but i think you might be a drinker of this http://forum.atlasrr.com/forum/data/Silico...29_Haterade.gif Totally freakin awesome sig! :lol :lol
August 14, 200620 yr And the only people saying that this team is in the Wild Card race are the kool aid drinkers on this board. i believe they have a chance and have never drank kool aid but i think you might be a drinker of this http://forum.atlasrr.com/forum/data/Silico...29_Haterade.gif :lol :notworthy p.s nice sig
August 14, 200620 yr I want Girardi gone after this season but I don't think I'd want McKeon back. He hasn't even had a full season in the majors managing, and you want him gone already? wont matter, he'll be in Wrigley next year anyway
August 14, 200620 yr Rumor'd by who? Name one published report that stated Mckeon was about to get rehired or even had talks with the Marlins about coming in. Just because he is interviewed in an article about the incident does not mean there is a possibility of him coming back. The only time I have heard anything about Mckeon coming back as Marlin's manager if Girardi were fired is from you. And because of that it cannot be considered a rumor. It's just speculation from a fan.
August 14, 200620 yr WildMarlinMan2003, take your ethnocentric "and he's Latin" BS and shove it. That should have nothing to do with it. Can you imagine if we were getting Leyland back and a supporter added "and he's Anglo, so he can relate better to most of our players" or a new owner and someone said "and he's Jewish." It's absurd, and a sign of low self esteem on your part. Disgusting! By the way, by last name, only 7 of 25 guys on the active roster are "Latin" and all of them have proved they can play for non-Latin managers. Nolasco was born in CA and sounds like it when he speaks. Sounds like we ned to AVOID a Latin manager because he might clash with the Gringos! Also, isn't Girardi of Italian descent? They were the original Latins. Whatever you say man....when we were looking for a new manager, even the Miami Herald added that being of Latino decent would be a plus for a manager in Miami. Orlando Magic got Carlos Arroyo and ALL of the Puerto Ricans go to the games with PR flags everywhere. From a marketing standpoint, being Latino helps in a city like Miami..... Whatever you say, but you are acting like a bigot even if you haven't realized it. By your logic, Fredy had better not apply for a job in a majority Anglo community, even though he is qualified, because "being of [Anglo] descent would be a plus for a manager in [most MLB cities]," and because "from a marketing standpoint, being [Anglo] helps in a city like [most MLB cities]." Sometimes, I think that ethnic bigots MAY realize the folly of their ways if they imagine the shoe on the other foot. Thankfully, the fans in most MLB cities aren't as bigoted as you think Miami Latinos are, otherwise all the Latino and Black managers elsewhere would have been victimized by your counterparts in other ethnic groups and never given a shot. By the way, despite all the marketing geared toward the Latino community, I don't think our attendance has been or can be impacted by the ethnicity of players or managers. Not many Latinos are going out to see Nolasco, Cabrera, Amezaga, etc., are they? I think Fredy is one of the best managerial candidates around, he would be if his last name were Smith, and I think he should have a shot in any MLB community. But you can't ask for "being Latin" to be considered a plus here in Miami unless you agree it shuold be a minus just about everywhere else, which would be wrong. Let's leave his ethnic background, and that of any other candidate, out of it.
August 14, 200620 yr Where does it say McKeon's coming back??? Stop trying to make things up. Make things up???? I never said HE's coming back! It sounds like he's sucking up and if ANY MLB team offered Jack a job I think he would take it.....especially from the Marlins! You just made up a rumor saying he is coming back. That article in no way implied McKeon was even thinking about coming back. Seeing as how he was your last manager, who else is better to ask if Loria yells at the umps? Nobody. They asked him, he gave an honest answer, and that is it. He was VERY close to becoming our manager again when we were about to fire Girardi. how do you know it was jack that was going to take over?
August 14, 200620 yr The thing I have found most disturbing about the whole Girardi controversy these days ? besides the actual incident between him and Loria ? is how the FO has acted AFTER Girardi said there was nothing to the rumors. Some FO sources leaked to the media first that Girardi held back Johnson and Nolasco against their wishes. Then a day or so later FO sources leak to the media that Girardi held back Olivo against their wishes. Not to mention leaking what the aborted press conference was about. What is the point of this after Girardi had gone out of his way to quell rumors that there was a problem? Get Girardi to fire back some tirade publically against the FO so Loria has a legitimate excuse to fire him rather than just because he told Loria to be quiet? A preemptive strike for when Girardi leaves if he decides to trash the Marlins FO? To just embarass Girardi? I'm not sure, but unless Girardi and Loria work things out before the season is through there is a good chance Jack McKeon or Fredi Gonzalez will be donning a Marlins uni next season.
August 14, 200620 yr The thing I have found most disturbing about the whole Girardi controversy these days ? besides the actual incident between him and Loria ? is how the FO has acted AFTER Girardi said there was nothing to the rumors. Some FO sources leaked to the media first that Girardi held back Johnson and Nolasco against their wishes. Then a day or so later FO sources leak to the media that Girardi held back Olivo against their wishes. Not to mention leaking what the aborted press conference was about. What is the point of this after Girardi had gone out of his way to quell rumors that there was a problem? Get Girardi to fire back some tirade publically against the FO so Loria has a legitimate excuse to fire him rather than just because he told Loria to be quiet? A preemptive strike for when Girardi leaves if he decides to trash the Marlins FO? To just embarass Girardi? I'm not sure, but unless Girardi and Loria work things out before the season is through there is a good chance Jack McKeon or Fredi Gonzalez will be donning a Marlins uni next season. I also don't like some in the FO taking shots at Girardi through the media. I think there's a 50/50 chance Girardi wont be the manager next year but I don't see McKeon coming back. If McKeon still wanted to manage the Marlins and Loria / Beinfest still wanted McKeon to manage the Marlins then McKeon wouldn't have "retired" last October.
August 14, 200620 yr I want Girardi gone after this season but I don't think I'd want McKeon back. He hasn't even had a full season in the majors managing, and you want him gone already? wont matter, he'll be in Wrigley next year anyway I doubt it, but we'll see.
August 19, 200620 yr Whether we like it or not this story is not dead and forgotten. Until Loria makes some kind of comment the press is not going to drop it. Miami Herald A Loria apology to Girardi would be right thing to do By Greg Cote gcote@MiamiHerald.com Posted on Sat, Aug. 19, 2006 Joe Girardi returned to the crime scene Friday night, back at the Marlins' ballpark for the first time since owner Jeffrey Loria decided abruptly to fire him -- only to be talked out of it by other club officials -- after the team's previous home game 12 days earlier. No yellow police tape was up, but don't doubt there was a crime, and that the victim was the young manager who sat here now, facing the glut of media and TV cameras. The owner, in a pique of ego, in a knee-jerk reaction that seemed heavy on the jerk, had nearly erased this man whose rookie-laden team has stunningly overachieved. It didn't take the firing to go through for Loria to be guilty. For him to nearly do it, was a crime against baseball, or at least against common sense. Had the huffing, puffing owner not been dissuaded by cooler heads, the national embarrassment heaped upon this franchise would have taken its rightful place alongside the fire sale of a championship team; the majors' lowest attendance average; the sports' cheapest player payroll (by far); and progress toward a new stadium that moves with the alacrity of a giant tortoise on a siesta. 'NO COMMENT' HERE Somebody asked Girardi, prior to the 6-1 loss to the Braves that commenced a 10-game Florida homestand, if he has since learned how to deal with Loria or handle him. Short pause. ''No comment,'' he said. Things have gotten chilly around here. The young Marlins continue on the edge of the NL wild-card race, in a season when most experts figured them to challenge the 1962 Mets for historic futility, but management-owner relations have taken on icicles. Girardi tries to talk baseball -- ''Each day that ticks off, we need to get even hotter'' -- but this distraction remains. He did his postgame media session outside the clubhouse rather than in his office, a rarity. You wondered, for just a second, if somebody had ordered the lock changed on his office door. His relationship with the owner might be beyond repair. You are left to wonder if Loria, who did not attend Friday's game, wouldn't almost prefer a late-season fizzle from here to make a managerial change after the season slightly less indefensible. For his part, Girardi is predictably proper and politic, but wouldn't even offer to speculate Friday on his future with the club. ''I don't know where I'm going to be tomorrow,'' he said. ``I just hope I'm alive.'' Largely overlooked in this Loria-authored distraction is its potential negative impact on the team. Then again, a 5-4 road trip followed. ''What's been surprising about having so young a club is how easy they push things aside,'' offered catcher Matt Treanor. ``It's part of the learning process. They have to worry about the business at hand.'' Most every effort to get Girardi to delve into his relationship with Loria was parried Friday. Most every attempt to invite him to explain the recent blowup was met with a shield. ''There's internal stuff that's meant to stay internal,'' he said. ''`Internal is internal.'' By way of example, Girardi then told an inquiring reporter: ``I don't want to see the organs inside your body.'' This is supposition on our part and cannot be known, but it is nearly impossible -- now -- to believe Girardi will be back next season. You have to think that if his former Yankees or certainly his hometown Cubs called about manager openings they conceivably could have, Girardi would be out of South Florida so fast he'd leave tread marks. Could you blame him? No. It isn't that a rookie manager is by any measure beyond criticism from an owner, but when the bottom line says your guy merits Manager of the Year consideration, it probably is true that what that manager deserves most from his owner is a raise, not a pink slip. Or at least a little public support in place of the meddling. It shouldn't be Loria wanting to get rid of Girardi at this point. It should be the other way around. PETTY DISAGREEMENTS Loria hasn't taken as much heat as he needed to for his blowup on Aug. 6. Petty disagreements throughout the season culminated when Loria, seated right near the dugout, yelled at Girardi during the game for not storming onto the field to argue a ball-strike call (after he'd been ejected for arguing the night before). The frustrated manager yelled back. Loria was pacified (and talked out of firing Girardi) only after the manager later agreed to apologize to the owner in front of the team. That's a humiliation that can get under your skin and into your bones. That's something you don't easily forget. Maybe things might start to get better between the manager and owner if the apology yet owed is given so that everybody knows it. That would be the apology from Loria to Girardi, for a gross overreaction that nearly blew up in the franchise's face, and might yet cost the club a bright young manager who seems just the right fit to grow this green team into something that blossoms. ''Sorry, Joe,'' would be a suggestion if Loria wanted to get right to the point. And: ``Good job.''
August 19, 200620 yr This all goes back to certain writers in this area not liking Loria/Samson. I don't know of anyone that can tell their boss (that they are on thin ice with to begin with) to shut up and not have to deal with consequences. To turn this around and say Loria needs to apologize? For what? For yelling at the ump? For being a fan? For getting upset with Joe when he he was told to shut up? I believe Joe should have come out early and said "In the heat of battle Mr. Loria was vocal, I was vocal and I stepped over the line and spoke to my boss in an inappropriate way. If my players spoke to me like that there would be an issue and I should be held to the same standard. I apologize to Mr. Loria for my actions." Loria should apologize? Ha! I wonder how often Greg Cote's employer has apologized to him? My guess is Greg never told his employee to shut up in a meeting or at a public event.
August 19, 200620 yr I think a good analogy is the Mark Cuban/Avery Johnson situation. Even when Cuban was going nuts during the finals and was screaming at the refs, Johnson had to take it...you could see it in his face. He wanted to run over to Cuban, kick the crap out of him, and tell him he was pissing off the refs and potentially ruining his team's chances of winning. But he couldn't...Cuban was the OWNER of the team and the person who gave Avery Johnson a chance when most people thought Cuban should have hired a coach with more experience. That's exactly the situation here. Girardi should be able to run his team without his boss yelling at the umps, but it was bad form for Girardi to publicly yell at his boss. Considering that Loria gave this guy a job when he had zero head coaching experience (and only one year as a bench coach on any level), it was very arrogant of Girardi to bark at Loria in front of the TV cameras. Girardi should be able to manage the Marlins without having to deal with an overzealous, micromanaging owner, but - coming from the freakin yankees - you'd think Girardi would have learned to develop a thick skin when it comes to dealing with the guy who cuts the checks.
August 19, 200620 yr Good points Del. Here is another...Joe wants to manage in Chicago or one day for the Yankees? Joe, I realize this has become a national story but in general this is the very soft S. Fla media market in an area where only the hard core fans care. Go to Chicago or NY and this is front page news for two weeks (ask Paul LoDuca) and nort backpage news for 2 days.
August 19, 200620 yr I think the bottom line here is who stands to lose more. That Loria can do whatever he wants is not even arguable, obviously he can but, regardless of the varying opinions on this board, the truth is that the general perception (both locally and nationally) is that Girardi has done a great job guiding this team. Loria, on the other hand has not fared too well in the public relations department. If Girardi leaves or gets fired he will go on to continue his career elsewhere likely unscathed whereas Loria will still be in S.Fla as owner of a team trying to get a stadium built and trying to win some measure of trust among the fanbase having now incurred even more damage to his image. Opinions about who is right and who is wrong or what Loria should feel he should or shouldn't do are kind of irrelevant. The issue is really what is in the best interest of the organization. Girardi made some attempt at quieting this when he said he expected be in S. Fla. The silence from Loria's camp doesn't seem to have helped. BTW, I realize this story would be a zillion times bigger in NY but it's been news here for a lot more than 2 days and has not escaped national attention.
August 20, 200620 yr the guy on 790 say that marlins owner going let Girardi going let go as soon as season is finish their not getting alone
August 20, 200620 yr the guy on 790 say that marlins owner going let Girardi going let go as soon as season is finish their not getting alone huh ???, could you retype that please.
August 20, 200620 yr the guy on 790 say that marlins owner going let Girardi going let go as soon as season is finish their not getting alone huh ???, could you retype that please. you honestly couldnt understand that?
August 20, 200620 yr I think the bottom line here is who stands to lose more. That Loria can do whatever he wants is not even arguable, obviously he can but, regardless of the varying opinions on this board, the truth is that the general perception (both locally and nationally) is that Girardi has done a great job guiding this team. Loria, on the other hand has not fared too well in the public relations department. If Girardi leaves or gets fired he will go on to continue his career elsewhere likely unscathed whereas Loria will still be in S.Fla as owner of a team trying to get a stadium built and trying to win some measure of trust among the fanbase having now incurred even more damage to his image. Opinions about who is right and who is wrong or what Loria should feel he should or shouldn't do are kind of irrelevant. The issue is really what is in the best interest of the organization. Girardi made some attempt at quieting this when he said he expected be in S. Fla. The silence from Loria's camp doesn't seem to have helped. BTW, I realize this story would be a zillion times bigger in NY but it's been news here for a lot more than 2 days and has not escaped national attention. I completely agree. It behooves Loria to act with just a little more decorum. Remember he is trying to get a good deal of money out of public coffers, and he doesn't help his chances by further dirtying his already tarnished image.
August 20, 200620 yr you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back thats the general consensus
August 20, 200620 yr you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back thats the general consensus Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he will take a tremendous PR hit.
August 20, 200620 yr you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back thats the general consensus Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he is will take a tremendous PR hit. Yep, Joe has done a termenous job with these young players. Who knows where this team would be without Joe.
August 20, 200620 yr you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back thats the general consensus Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he is will take a tremendous PR hit. Who knows where this team would be without Joe. I honestly believe that we would have the same exact record, maybe 2-3 games better. I also think the difference between a great and average manager is only about 2-3 games either way in the W/L column though. Giradi is not a great manager.
August 20, 200620 yr you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back thats the general consensus Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he is will take a tremendous PR hit. Yep, Joe has done a termenous job with these young players. Who knows where this team would be without Joe. Um...doesn't this apply if Girardi stays? No more "he's a first year manager" or "they're a bunch of rookies" excuses. In a weak NL, the expectations for this team will be higher. Come to think of it, if Girardi leaves, think of the expectations his new team will have. Basically, whatever happens here, expectations will be high all around.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.