Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Girardi Rumors

Featured Replies

you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back

 

thats the general consensus

 

Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he is will take a tremendous PR hit.

 

Who knows where this team would be without Joe.

 

 

I honestly believe that we would have the same exact record, maybe 2-3 games better. I also think the difference between a great and average manager is only about 2-3 games either way in the W/L column though.

 

Giradi is not a great manager.

Regardless of whether the manager actually had an impact on the team's performance (positive or negative), Loria better hope they have a better record next year. If the team doesn't, his critics will become more vocal and greater in number.

 

Even if it is undeserved, a lot of people have attributed the team's success to Girardi. If the team falters, and Loria is perceived to be the reason why Girardi left, he takes big time PR hit. And as you can already see, Loria's opponents in the media are becoming more numerous.

you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back

 

thats the general consensus

 

Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he is will take a tremendous PR hit.

 

Who knows where this team would be without Joe.

 

 

I honestly believe that we would have the same exact record, maybe 2-3 games better. I also think the difference between a great and average manager is only about 2-3 games either way in the W/L column though.

 

Giradi is not a great manager.

Regardless of whether the manager actually had an impact on the team's performance (positive or negative), Loria better hope they have a better record next year. If the team doesn't, his critics will become more vocal and greater in number.

 

Even if it is undeserved, a lot of people have attributed the team's success to Girardi. If the team falters, and Loria is perceived to be the reason why Girardi left, he takes big time PR hit. And as you can already see, Loria's opponents in the media are becoming more numerous.

 

 

No doubt about that, I agree 100%. I'm pretty confident though that we will improve. Why wouldn't we ?

you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back

 

thats the general consensus

 

Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he is will take a tremendous PR hit.

 

Who knows where this team would be without Joe.

 

 

I honestly believe that we would have the same exact record, maybe 2-3 games better. I also think the difference between a great and average manager is only about 2-3 games either way in the W/L column though.

 

Giradi is not a great manager.

Regardless of whether the manager actually had an impact on the team's performance (positive or negative), Loria better hope they have a better record next year. If the team doesn't, his critics will become more vocal and greater in number.

 

Even if it is undeserved, a lot of people have attributed the team's success to Girardi. If the team falters, and Loria is perceived to be the reason why Girardi left, he takes big time PR hit. And as you can already see, Loria's opponents in the media are becoming more numerous.

 

 

No doubt about that, I agree 100%. I'm pretty confident though that we will improve. Why wouldn't we ?

 

You just never know. Sometimes players perform beyond their capabilities, and if that's the case, then maybe we'll see a falloff next year. Sometimes pressure from raised expectations gets to the players, and they don't do as well. Who knows? Look at the Indians. Who expected them to be this much worse than they were last year?

you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back

 

thats the general consensus

 

Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he will take a tremendous PR hit.

It definitely will do better next year with or without him.

I tend to agree but you never know.

I agree with you. I think they will be better, but it's not a sure thing. Nothing is a sure thing. What I'm saying is, if they don't improve, Loria will be wishing the media was as nice to him as they are now.

you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back

 

thats the general consensus

 

Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he will take a tremendous PR hit.

It definitely will do better next year with or without him.

I tend to agree but you never know.

The Marlins will likely have a real centerfielder, Hermida will start to live up to his potential, and the Marlins can expect great improvement from Jacobs and Ramirez.

 

You also have to think the bullpen will be improved (how could it not be?).

 

Ultimately the Marlins will contend next year and Girardi will just be a blur in our memories. No PR nightmare.

 

 

 

 

 

Quite possibly your most ridiculous post penguino in reference to the whole Girardi situation.

 

 

Its all based on maybe's and predictions (yours):

 

"Hermida will live up to his potential."

 

"Great improvement from Jacobs and Ramirez"

 

"The Marlins will contend next year".

 

"The bullpen will be improved".

 

 

 

 

What would your thoughts on Girardi be if this team had UNDERACHEIVED? I can only imagine.

 

 

I enjoy your posts and respect your baseball knowledge but you have got to be kidding me..........

you get the feeling around the stadium these last few days and there is about 5% chance that Girardi is coming back

 

thats the general consensus

 

Loria better pray that next year's team outperforms this year's. Otherwise, he will take a tremendous PR hit.

It definitely will do better next year with or without him.

I tend to agree but you never know.

The Marlins will likely have a real centerfielder, Hermida will start to live up to his potential, and the Marlins can expect great improvement from Jacobs and Ramirez.

 

You also have to think the bullpen will be improved (how could it not be?).

 

Ultimately the Marlins will contend next year and Girardi will just be a blur in our memories. No PR nightmare.

 

 

I agree with all that expect I wouldn't count on much improvement from Jacobs. I'm not sold on his long term ability as our future first baseman.

Im not a fan of Girardi, but when Loria lets him go it will be an extraordinary PR nightmare

Im not a fan of Girardi, but when Loria lets him go it will be an extraordinary PR nightmare

 

 

 

 

Right.

 

 

Which will only get worse if the team doesnt improve upon this years record.

 

Less rookie's/decent record in 2006 = Bigger expectations for 2007

Just in the hypothetical, one has to wonder, assuming Ramp is correct about Girardi's tenure, he very well may have seized an opportunity to instigate an argument to get himself fired, and thusly place himself (and with him the entire coaching staff) squarely at the front of the line for Dusty's job.

 

Perhaps the real reason cooler heads prevailed was to protect the Marlins negotiating position.

 

Since the Marlins hold all the cards (they are paying him relatively little and can keep him from working for the next couple of years if is their pleasure). If history is any indicator, and Chicago is indeed interested, there's a price to be paid, and not an insignificant one.

 

Were it me, I'd be looking at Murton and at least one prospect as compensation for the manager, and one more every coach who departs along with him. Stripping the Cubs of every piece of low-cost/high value prospect talent would be the name of the game. Otherwise Joe can sulk around the dugout for another two years, or if is his preference, at home on the couch without a paycheck or a job.

 

But, be clear, he won't be even talking to Chicago unless the Marlins are guaranteed their compensation first.

 

The last time this happened the pricetag was Randy Winn, at the time an all-star for TB, and that was just for the manager. No reason not to ask for the sun and moon. After all, you have to assume you are handing over an entire coaching staff as well. There is almost no amount of compensation to offset the loss, but not doubt Admin Beinfest will pick the Cubbies clean. When he gets done it will take the Cubs years to recover.

 

Which in itself is fine with me.

I am counting down until we see the "who will replace Giradi as manager in 2007" thread...

 

I would assume, if the Marlins are going to sever their relationship with Joe, they already know.

I am counting down until we see the "who will replace Giradi as manager in 2007" thread...

 

I would assume, if the Marlins are going to sever their relationship with Joe, they already know.

 

 

Here's hoping for Fredi Gonzalez.

I am counting down until we see the "who will replace Giradi as manager in 2007" thread...

 

I would assume, if the Marlins are going to sever their relationship with Joe, they already know.

 

 

Here's hoping for Fredi Gonzalez.

Considering how many times he's been (pardon my phrasing) the bridesmaid and never the bride, one has to suspect there is some fatal flaw there that has led at least four teams I can think of from hiring him.

I am counting down until we see the "who will replace Giradi as manager in 2007" thread...

 

I would assume, if the Marlins are going to sever their relationship with Joe, they already know.

 

 

Here's hoping for Fredi Gonzalez.

Considering how many times he's been (pardon my phrasing) the bridesmaid and never the bride, one has to suspect there is some flaw there that has led at least four teams I can think of from hiring him.

 

 

I would agree with that statement if he wasn't so young. Only 42. He is also a perfect fit for the Marlins. Unlike Giradi, this job I would imagine be his dreamjob. It'd be nice to have some stability in the dugout.

Just in the hypothetical, one has to wonder, assuming Ramp is correct about Girardi's tenure, he very well may have seized an opportunity to instigate an argument to get himself fired, and thusly place himself (and with him the entire coaching staff) squarely at the front of the line for Dusty's job.

 

Perhaps the real reason cooler heads prevailed was to protect the Marlins negotiating position.

 

I know you said hypothetical but I really can't see him putting himself in such an excruciatingly uncomfortable and embarrassing situation in such a calculated manner.

 

Now the second part...yeah, I can see that as a strong possibility.

 

I still think this seriously damages an already quite shaky public image. Even if the team does great next year, can this FO afford to have even a temporary PR nightmare given its history? Like I said before, I don't think it's about Girardi's effectiveness or importance to the team but about the public and media perception.

How about we just let this thread die? :banghead

 

Whether the thread dies or not, the issue is a reality. IMO it's pretty natural that it would be discussed on a Marlins board.

How about we just let this thread die? :banghead

 

Well, if he wanted to quell the rumors, Loria could hold a press conference tomorrow announcing that Girardi just signed a two-year extension....or just announce publicly that things are blown out of proportion and that Girardi will remain the manager next year.

 

But, since he hasn't done this, his silence leads me to believe that this story has teeth. If this was going on in NY, it would be front page news of the Post until Loria actually said something.

If a team has success (or failure) the lion's share of the credit always goes to the players especially in baseball. It's no different with the 2006 Marlins.

 

 

And even if credit DOES go to the coach, I would give more of it to the assistant coaches. I mean for me, Perry Hill is a much bigger factor than Girardi on Dan Uggla being a major league 2B when people were predicting his defense would make him a bench player at best. Gary Tuck is a bigger factor than Girardi on the catchers (though it was Girardi who brought him in). Same can be said for Willingham's fielding. And for the pitchers, Girardi has had to do some babysitting (Olsen) and some pep talks for sure, but for me Kranitz would get most of the credit.

 

But these articles talking about how Loria should apologize, I don't get it. Do I think he should've demanded an apology in front of the team from Girardi? Of course not, that's juvenile and stupid. But you don't mouth off to your boss in front of all his customers.

 

The PR nightmare scenario is right though. People already are just waiting for another reason to dump on Loria down here.

Just in the hypothetical, one has to wonder, assuming Ramp is correct about Girardi's tenure, he very well may have seized an opportunity to instigate an argument to get himself fired, and thusly place himself (and with him the entire coaching staff) squarely at the front of the line for Dusty's job.

 

Perhaps the real reason cooler heads prevailed was to protect the Marlins negotiating position.

 

Since the Marlins hold all the cards (they are paying him relatively little and can keep him from working for the next couple of years if is their pleasure). If history is any indicator, and Chicago is indeed interested, there's a price to be paid, and not an insignificant one.

 

Were it me, I'd be looking at Murton and at least one prospect as compensation for the manager, and one more every coach who departs along with him. Stripping the Cubs of every piece of low-cost/high value prospect talent would be the name of the game. Otherwise Joe can sulk around the dugout for another two years, or if is his preference, at home on the couch without a paycheck or a job.

 

But, be clear, he won't be even talking to Chicago unless the Marlins are guaranteed their compensation first.

 

The last time this happened the pricetag was Randy Winn, at the time an all-star for TB, and that was just for the manager. No reason not to ask for the sun and moon. After all, you have to assume you are handing over an entire coaching staff as well. There is almost no amount of compensation to offset the loss, but not doubt Admin Beinfest will pick the Cubbies clean. When he gets done it will take the Cubs years to recover.

 

Which in itself is fine with me.

 

 

 

I wouldnt mind a murton and pie

what i was say that on 790 the ticket this afteroon round 4pm their talking that Girardi is most likely will be gone because Loria is not saying if Girardi is stay or going and their donot like each other and their not talking

Just in the hypothetical, one has to wonder, assuming Ramp is correct about Girardi's tenure, he very well may have seized an opportunity to instigate an argument to get himself fired, and thusly place himself (and with him the entire coaching staff) squarely at the front of the line for Dusty's job.

 

Perhaps the real reason cooler heads prevailed was to protect the Marlins negotiating position.

 

Since the Marlins hold all the cards (they are paying him relatively little and can keep him from working for the next couple of years if is their pleasure). If history is any indicator, and Chicago is indeed interested, there's a price to be paid, and not an insignificant one.

 

Were it me, I'd be looking at Murton and at least one prospect as compensation for the manager, and one more every coach who departs along with him. Stripping the Cubs of every piece of low-cost/high value prospect talent would be the name of the game. Otherwise Joe can sulk around the dugout for another two years, or if is his preference, at home on the couch without a paycheck or a job.

 

But, be clear, he won't be even talking to Chicago unless the Marlins are guaranteed their compensation first.

 

The last time this happened the pricetag was Randy Winn, at the time an all-star for TB, and that was just for the manager. No reason not to ask for the sun and moon. After all, you have to assume you are handing over an entire coaching staff as well. There is almost no amount of compensation to offset the loss, but not doubt Admin Beinfest will pick the Cubbies clean. When he gets done it will take the Cubs years to recover.

 

Which in itself is fine with me.

 

 

After the firesale the last offseason, if we were to trade Girardi for some Cubs prospects the Marlins won't live down the image of being a farm system for big market teams for another 10 to 15 years. As it stands, it will be at least 7 to 10 years until we live down that image. If there are irreconciable differences between Girardi and Loria I'd rather see the Marlins fire him. I don't feel like hearing jokes about Marlins plans on trading Billy the Marlin for a pitching machine for another 15 years.

If a team has success (or failure) the lion's share of the credit always goes to the players especially in baseball. It's no different with the 2006 Marlins.

 

 

And even if credit DOES go to the coach, I would give more of it to the assistant coaches. I mean for me, Perry Hill is a much bigger factor than Girardi on Dan Uggla being a major league 2B when people were predicting his defense would make him a bench player at best

 

 

That is a great point about Perry meaning lots more to this team and absolutely true.

 

 

Just in the hypothetical, one has to wonder, assuming Ramp is correct about Girardi's tenure, he very well may have seized an opportunity to instigate an argument to get himself fired, and thusly place himself (and with him the entire coaching staff) squarely at the front of the line for Dusty's job.

 

Perhaps the real reason cooler heads prevailed was to protect the Marlins negotiating position.

 

Since the Marlins hold all the cards (they are paying him relatively little and can keep him from working for the next couple of years if is their pleasure). If history is any indicator, and Chicago is indeed interested, there's a price to be paid, and not an insignificant one.

 

Were it me, I'd be looking at Murton and at least one prospect as compensation for the manager, and one more every coach who departs along with him. Stripping the Cubs of every piece of low-cost/high value prospect talent would be the name of the game. Otherwise Joe can sulk around the dugout for another two years, or if is his preference, at home on the couch without a paycheck or a job.

 

But, be clear, he won't be even talking to Chicago unless the Marlins are guaranteed their compensation first.

 

The last time this happened the pricetag was Randy Winn, at the time an all-star for TB, and that was just for the manager. No reason not to ask for the sun and moon. After all, you have to assume you are handing over an entire coaching staff as well. There is almost no amount of compensation to offset the loss, but not doubt Admin Beinfest will pick the Cubbies clean. When he gets done it will take the Cubs years to recover.

 

Which in itself is fine with me.

 

 

After the firesale the last offseason, if we were to trade Girardi for some Cubs prospects the Marlins won't live down the image of being a farm system for big market teams for another 10 to 15 years. As it stands, it will be at least 7 to 10 years until we live down that image. If there are irreconciable differences between Girardi and Loria I'd rather see the Marlins fire him. I don't feel like hearing jokes about Marlins plans on trading Billy the Marlin for a pitching machine for another 15 years.

 

 

We will live down that image as soon as we win our third World Series title in 2008. :thumbup

Just in the hypothetical, one has to wonder, assuming Ramp is correct about Girardi's tenure, he very well may have seized an opportunity to instigate an argument to get himself fired, and thusly place himself (and with him the entire coaching staff) squarely at the front of the line for Dusty's job.

 

Perhaps the real reason cooler heads prevailed was to protect the Marlins negotiating position.

 

Since the Marlins hold all the cards (they are paying him relatively little and can keep him from working for the next couple of years if is their pleasure). If history is any indicator, and Chicago is indeed interested, there's a price to be paid, and not an insignificant one.

 

Were it me, I'd be looking at Murton and at least one prospect as compensation for the manager, and one more every coach who departs along with him. Stripping the Cubs of every piece of low-cost/high value prospect talent would be the name of the game. Otherwise Joe can sulk around the dugout for another two years, or if is his preference, at home on the couch without a paycheck or a job.

 

But, be clear, he won't be even talking to Chicago unless the Marlins are guaranteed their compensation first.

 

The last time this happened the pricetag was Randy Winn, at the time an all-star for TB, and that was just for the manager. No reason not to ask for the sun and moon. After all, you have to assume you are handing over an entire coaching staff as well. There is almost no amount of compensation to offset the loss, but not doubt Admin Beinfest will pick the Cubbies clean. When he gets done it will take the Cubs years to recover.

 

Which in itself is fine with me.

 

 

After the firesale the last offseason, if we were to trade Girardi for some Cubs prospects the Marlins won't live down the image of being a farm system for big market teams for another 10 to 15 years. As it stands, it will be at least 7 to 10 years until we live down that image. If there are irreconciable differences between Girardi and Loria I'd rather see the Marlins fire him. I don't feel like hearing jokes about Marlins plans on trading Billy the Marlin for a pitching machine for another 15 years.

 

 

We will live down that image as soon as we win our third World Series title in 2008. :thumbup

 

No, we won't live it down until after we win another WS and we hold onto a majority of the players that got us the WS trophy past their arby years (2009-2012).

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.