Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Great article on our CF process

Featured Replies

And because someone will bring up who plays LF now, and I seem to be the central advocate to platoonvilles outfield slots on this board, our LF situation COULD be

 

Joe Borchard vs RHP .258/.353/.449

Cody Ross vs LHP .245/.300/.588

 

 

How about if this was in our LF:

 

.454OBP /.554 SLG with 26 homeruns? :mischief2

I'm afraid the last number is the one that matters.

 

.245/.325/.475 for $800,000

.270/.450/.525 for $10,000,000

"...but do you really want him (Willits) to start on a team on the cusp of being a serious contender? Is that what you're going for here? Is keeping Nolasco and Jacobs and trying this guy out in CF really a better idea then getting a guy like Rocco, deploying the Ross/Borchard LF platoon (which I can argue very effectively will be productive), and entrusting the 5th SP slot to J. Garcia/Petit/Mitre? I'm going to say it's a resounding no.

 

You'll be thrilled to know this will be my last Willits post this afternoon, gotta go pick up the kid at school.

 

Anyways, were it me, to answer your questions, I would go get Willits NOW, and by Willits I mean Willits or an equivalent yet unnamed, so that no matter what happened going forward I have $350k guy who's first and best position is CF and has at least a modicum of experience playing there in the bigs and as we both agree, appears to have the tools to get on base.

 

Now I can negotiate from a position of strength for Baldelli or fillintheblank. Now I don't have to empty the bank to get Rocco or someone else I covet. And even if I give up Nolasco and Jacobs in the end, I'm in a much better place to manage my roster than I was before.

 

I'm not saying you go get a Willits and that's the end of the search. I'm saying you go get him because the alternative (and sorry we've been so buddy/buddy so far today) of platooning Borchard and Ross just doesn't work for me, we all appreciate how hard Amezaga worked to fill the need in the outfield when called upon, and as much as I respect anyone who gets to the major league level, I don't think Abercrombie or Reed will ever flourish here (just being polite), and because there is nothing to lose by getting him. The absolute worst case is you can't make any other trades, Dukes winds up in prison, the Rays want the world for Rocco, Duffy or Taveras or whoever just can't be gotten for a fair price, and you're stuck with a rookie centerfielder who led all of MiLB in OBP last year.

 

As the saying goes, better that than a poke in the eye with a sharp stick.

 

BTW, for the record, I believe I was first or one of the first to bring up Rocco Baldelli as the logical choice much earlier this year when the first round (trading deadline time) of Carl Crawford talk started. As I looked at Crawford's $$ I became aware of the flaw in Baldelli's contract (he wasn'tgoing to reach his minimum AB number in 2006) and realized he was a steal for at least two-three years.

Anyways, were it me, to answer your questions, I would go get Willits NOW, and by Willits I mean Willits or an equivalent yet unnamed, so that no matter what happened going forward I have $350k guy who's first and best position is CF and has at least a modicum of experience playing there in the bigs and as we both agree, appears to have the tools to get on base.

 

Now I can negotiate from a position of strength for Baldelli or fillintheblank. Now I don't have to empty the bank to get Rocco or someone else I covet. And even if I give up Nolasco and Jacobs in the end, I'm in a much better place to manage my roster than I was before.

 

I'm not saying you go get a Willits and that's the end of the search. I'm saying you go get him because the alternative (and sorry we've been so buddy/buddy so far today) of platooning Borchard and Ross just doesn't work for me, we all appreciate how hard Amezaga worked to fill the need in the outfield when called upon, and as much as I respect anyone who gets to the major league level, I don't think Abercrombie or Reed will ever flourish here (just being polite), and because there is nothing to lose by getting him. The absolute worst case is you can't make any other trades, Dukes winds up in prison, the Rays want the world for Rocco, Duffy or Taveras or whoever just can't be gotten for a fair price, and you're stuck with a rookie centerfielder who led all of MiLB in OBP last year.

 

As the saying goes, better that than a poke in the eye with a sharp stick.

 

BTW, for the record, I believe I was first or one of the first to bring up Rocco Baldelli as the logical choice much earlier this year when the first round (trading deadline time) of Carl Crawford talk started. As I looked at Crawford's $$ I became aware of the flaw in Baldelli's contract (he wasn'tgoing to reach his minimum AB number in 2006) and realized he was a steal for at least two-three years.

haha

 

But regardless, I have no problems doing that if it's for a piece we don't need or is easily replaceable. And for the record, I'd prefer him drastically over Duffy or Taveras because I don't see a big difference in expected performance/ceilings but I see a very real difference in trade compensation. In the end, he's just not in the same league as a guy like Rocco. I also think you're kidding yourself if hypothetically they got Willits or a similar minor league player and how that would effect bargaining negotiations in the Marlins favor for a CF. We'd need a proven commodity or a top prospect to perhaps sway a deal.

 

If you want to battle today, just letting you know I'm ready to go about the two headed Borosschard monster in LF. You'd get around an 800+ OPS for 800k, which is incredibly cost effective. We probably could not obtain a LF that tops those numbers for that price without giving up more pitching. Further, assuming Rocco or a legit CF comes in, I'd much rather have that platoon (and you can add in whoever the 5th OF turns out to be too) swarming in the outfield then spending money on LF versus the bullpen. We can completely live with Borosschard hitting .245/.325/.475, 25-30 HR, and hitting 7th out in LF if we get Rocco and some relievers.

do nolasco, vargas, jacobs for baldelli and than do Anderson for Andino, put him in LF and Willy at first. Or sign a cheap OF and send Andino for a pen arm. I prefer the first. Go out and get at least one dependable arm via FA.

do nolasco, vargas, jacobs for baldelli and than do Anderson for Andino, put him in LF and Willy at first. Or sign a cheap OF and send Andino for a pen arm. I prefer the first. Go out and get at least one dependable arm via FA.

why would the White Sox trade Anderson for Andino?

do nolasco, vargas, jacobs for baldelli and than do Anderson for Andino, put him in LF and Willy at first. Or sign a cheap OF and send Andino for a pen arm. I prefer the first. Go out and get at least one dependable arm via FA.

why would the White Sox trade Anderson for Andino?

I have no idea...but it was mentioned as a possibility in one of the articles.

It's because Juan Uribe likes shooting people with guns and Ken Williams is in general an idiot and would probably do something like that.

When I read Purpa's comments on Willy Taveras and why he's such "a valuable commodity", I can't help but laugh out loud. The kid is doing something right or he wouldn't be there, but P.T. Barnum has nothing on Tim Purpa if he continues to pedal that line.

 

I'm trying to figure out who he's saying this to because his peers have to know what Taveras is worth and I can't believe he's really trying to speak them through the media because they were all just in the same building together for three days, the only conclusion is he's speaking Astros fans on why he failed to unload the guy in the first place.

 

Don't get me wrong, Taveras is a major league ballplayer and a decent one at that. But when Purpa says he's, "...a young center fielder with speed who can lead off..." I look at that .333 OBP and .278 BA, and my eyes roll back in my head.

 

Maybe he should consider Taveras leading off is why (or at least one of the whys) the 'Stros can't score any runs.

Too many people fall into the trap of thinking that speed is the only quality you need in a leadoff hitter.

Agreed. But he has intangibles too!

When I read Purpa's comments on Willy Taveras and why he's such "a valuable commodity", I can't help but laugh out loud. The kid is doing something right or he wouldn't be there, but P.T. Barnum has nothing on Tim Purpa if he continues to pedal that line.

 

I'm trying to figure out who he's saying this to because his peers have to know what Taveras is worth and I can't believe he's really trying to speak them through the media because they were all just in the same building together for three days, the only conclusion is he's speaking Astros fans on why he failed to unload the guy in the first place.

 

Don't get me wrong, Taveras is a major league ballplayer and a decent one at that. But when Purpa says he's, "...a young center fielder with speed who can lead off..." I look at that .333 OBP and .278 BA, and my eyes roll back in my head.

 

Maybe he should consider Taveras leading off is why (or at least one of the whys) the 'Stros can't score any runs.

M03...I dont even know you anymore. Earlier you quoted MLE in reference to some player and now you're on the OBP bandwagon. :thumbup

M03...I dont even know you anymore. Earlier you quoted MLE in reference to some player and now you're on the OBP bandwagon. :thumbup

 

lolololololololololololol Shamster I'm not a luddite. I've never said there is no place for stats, my contention is that stats are so incompletely collected that the more technical the formula the less relevant they become. I always look at a player's basic stats in forming an opinion about his valuable.

 

But thanks for the backhanded compliment and a good laugh :thumbup

I still don't know why there isn't more interest in Chris Denorifa.

 

Hopefully we don't trade hi, because he should be our everyday CFer next year.

M03...I dont even know you anymore. Earlier you quoted MLE in reference to some player and now you're on the OBP bandwagon. :thumbup

 

lolololololololololololol Shamster I'm not a luddite. I've never said there is no place for stats, my contention is that stats are so incompletely colected that the more technical the formula the less relevant they become. I always look at a player's basic stats in forming an opinion about his valuable.

 

But thanks for the backhanded compliment and a good laugh :thumbup

yep, I pretty much agree. I used to be all stats, but have adjusted to a good mix of traditional scouting.

Honestly, Kemp would be on the very top of my list as far as CF options go. (Excluding the possible Crawford option, if there still is any...I don't know)

 

I know many will disagree with me here.

 

 

And I would assume it would take more than just Garcia to land Kemp.

Reggie Willits

 

Not only did he have the kind of numbers I think a MarlinsLou would look for - as he went from one level in the minor leagues to another his numbers got better and better and better to the point where he led minor league baseball in OBP last season. Basically a speedy singles hitter, called the best bunter in the Angels organization, he came up three times last season (to covered injured players) and acquitted himself well in the bigs. Last year's game notes and local newspaper stories (while in AAA) are littered with quotes from his manager and opposing managers about the quality of his play. Additionally he was selected for the AAA 2006 all-star team.

Getting Rocco is drastically preferred to trying to get lucky with 'uggla and willingham types,' or as the saber community calls them Shane Victorino All-Stars, but I do like Willits and wouldn't mind taking a chance on him. That dude just flat out gets on base.

 

I see him profiling in a best case scenario as a Ryan Freel type OF whose value is directly related to his OBP potential, speed/sb production, and defense. That's still a big if though. I in general do not like outfielders who don't slug, but if he's really going to post .360+ OBP and we could get him for something nominal, why not?

 

I also wonder why the Angels would trade him when the rumor is they will dish Chone out for a 3B (crede?). They'd have CF open, and unless they go bonkers for Soriano, Willits could be a decent in house option that fits Stoneman's philosophy of speed on top of the lineup. Or, he's just a really nice obp/speed/def bench OF. Not sure if he is a realistic target, even if he fits the Marlins profile of guys we like. This would be my main concern with Willits, not if he would be good or not for us. Because clearly, even as a bench OF, he would.

Maybe The Name Terry Evans has alot to do with the availability of Willits

Reggie Willits

 

Not only did he have the kind of numbers I think a MarlinsLou would look for - as he went from one level in the minor leagues to another his numbers got better and better and better to the point where he led minor league baseball in OBP last season. Basically a speedy singles hitter, called the best bunter in the Angels organization, he came up three times last season (to covered injured players) and acquitted himself well in the bigs. Last year's game notes and local newspaper stories (while in AAA) are littered with quotes from his manager and opposing managers about the quality of his play. Additionally he was selected for the AAA 2006 all-star team.

Getting Rocco is drastically preferred to trying to get lucky with 'uggla and willingham types,' or as the saber community calls them Shane Victorino All-Stars, but I do like Willits and wouldn't mind taking a chance on him. That dude just flat out gets on base.

 

I see him profiling in a best case scenario as a Ryan Freel type OF whose value is directly related to his OBP potential, speed/sb production, and defense. That's still a big if though. I in general do not like outfielders who don't slug, but if he's really going to post .360+ OBP and we could get him for something nominal, why not?

 

I also wonder why the Angels would trade him when the rumor is they will dish Chone out for a 3B (crede?). They'd have CF open, and unless they go bonkers for Soriano, Willits could be a decent in house option that fits Stoneman's philosophy of speed on top of the lineup. Or, he's just a really nice obp/speed/def bench OF. Not sure if he is a realistic target, even if he fits the Marlins profile of guys we like. This would be my main concern with Willits, not if he would be good or not for us. Because clearly, even as a bench OF, he would.

Maybe The Name Terry Evans has alot to do with the availability of Willits

 

I know it's absolutely silly to do so because no has mentioned Willits and the Fish in the same sentence except a roto-freelancer and one Marlins blogster who probably read the same thing but since Willits came across my radar I've been reading everything I can find on the Angels' plans for CF next season.

 

Three words. "BIG-NAME-PLAYER". The LaTimes, OC Register, etc., all seem to have the same perspective and the shopping list - Soriano, Matthews, Drew, you get the picture. Willits will get packaged in some deal to fill another hole somewhere.

 

Kansas City fans seem to be interested in him as well. He also has something of a cult following with certain Angels messageboards and blogs. For the price, I think his numbers are compelling.

Reggie Willits

 

Not only did he have the kind of numbers I think a MarlinsLou would look for - as he went from one level in the minor leagues to another his numbers got better and better and better to the point where he led minor league baseball in OBP last season. Basically a speedy singles hitter, called the best bunter in the Angels organization, he came up three times last season (to covered injured players) and acquitted himself well in the bigs. Last year's game notes and local newspaper stories (while in AAA) are littered with quotes from his manager and opposing managers about the quality of his play. Additionally he was selected for the AAA 2006 all-star team.

Getting Rocco is drastically preferred to trying to get lucky with 'uggla and willingham types,' or as the saber community calls them Shane Victorino All-Stars, but I do like Willits and wouldn't mind taking a chance on him. That dude just flat out gets on base.

 

I see him profiling in a best case scenario as a Ryan Freel type OF whose value is directly related to his OBP potential, speed/sb production, and defense. That's still a big if though. I in general do not like outfielders who don't slug, but if he's really going to post .360+ OBP and we could get him for something nominal, why not?

 

I also wonder why the Angels would trade him when the rumor is they will dish Chone out for a 3B (crede?). They'd have CF open, and unless they go bonkers for Soriano, Willits could be a decent in house option that fits Stoneman's philosophy of speed on top of the lineup. Or, he's just a really nice obp/speed/def bench OF. Not sure if he is a realistic target, even if he fits the Marlins profile of guys we like. This would be my main concern with Willits, not if he would be good or not for us. Because clearly, even as a bench OF, he would.

Maybe The Name Terry Evans has alot to do with the availability of Willits

 

I know it's absolutely silly to do so because no has mentioned Willits and the Fish in the same sentence except a roto-freelancer and one Marlins blogster who probably read the same thing but since Willits came across my radar I've been reading everything I can find on the Angels' plans for CF next season.

 

Three words. "BIG-NAME-PLAYER". The LaTimes, OC Register, etc., all seem to have the same perspective and the shopping list - Soriano, Matthews, Drew, you get the picture. Willits will get packaged in some deal to fill another hole somewhere.

 

Kansas City fans seem to be interested in him as well. He also has something of a cult following with certain Angels messageboards and blogs. For the price, I think his numbers are compelling.

With the ongoing progress of Mitch Maier in the AFL and last year with AAA Omaha and the few games he made an appearance in with the big league club, and with the pretty solid play from DeJesus last year, CF really isn't number one for the Royals right now. While it would be nice to replace Joey Gathright, the Royals really need to rebuild their bullpen. That is their number one offseason concern.

 

Royals fans are expecting some big things from Mitch Maier this season.

Reggie Willits

 

Not only did he have the kind of numbers I think a MarlinsLou would look for - as he went from one level in the minor leagues to another his numbers got better and better and better to the point where he led minor league baseball in OBP last season. Basically a speedy singles hitter, called the best bunter in the Angels organization, he came up three times last season (to covered injured players) and acquitted himself well in the bigs. Last year's game notes and local newspaper stories (while in AAA) are littered with quotes from his manager and opposing managers about the quality of his play. Additionally he was selected for the AAA 2006 all-star team.

Getting Rocco is drastically preferred to trying to get lucky with 'uggla and willingham types,' or as the saber community calls them Shane Victorino All-Stars, but I do like Willits and wouldn't mind taking a chance on him. That dude just flat out gets on base.

 

I see him profiling in a best case scenario as a Ryan Freel type OF whose value is directly related to his OBP potential, speed/sb production, and defense. That's still a big if though. I in general do not like outfielders who don't slug, but if he's really going to post .360+ OBP and we could get him for something nominal, why not?

 

I also wonder why the Angels would trade him when the rumor is they will dish Chone out for a 3B (crede?). They'd have CF open, and unless they go bonkers for Soriano, Willits could be a decent in house option that fits Stoneman's philosophy of speed on top of the lineup. Or, he's just a really nice obp/speed/def bench OF. Not sure if he is a realistic target, even if he fits the Marlins profile of guys we like. This would be my main concern with Willits, not if he would be good or not for us. Because clearly, even as a bench OF, he would.

Maybe The Name Terry Evans has alot to do with the availability of Willits

 

I know it's absolutely silly to do so because no has mentioned Willits and the Fish in the same sentence except a roto-freelancer and one Marlins blogster who probably read the same thing but since Willits came across my radar I've been reading everything I can find on the Angels' plans for CF next season.

 

Three words. "BIG-NAME-PLAYER". The LaTimes, OC Register, etc., all seem to have the same perspective and the shopping list - Soriano, Matthews, Drew, you get the picture. Willits will get packaged in some deal to fill another hole somewhere.

 

Kansas City fans seem to be interested in him as well. He also has something of a cult following with certain Angels messageboards and blogs. For the price, I think his numbers are compelling.

With the ongoing progress of Mitch Maier in the AFL and last year with AAA Omaha and the pretty solid play from DeJesus last year, CF really isn't number one for the Royals right now. While it would be nice to replace Joey Gathright, the Royals really need to rebuild their bullpen. That is their number one offseason concern.

 

Royals fans are expecting some big things from Mitch Maier this season.

So Gathright is plummeting down the Depth Chart ? I love it! Joey Gathright will be forever a symbol of how big of a contrast there is between the D-Rays Organization and the Marlins

Kansas City fans seem to be interested in him as well. He also has something of a cult following with certain Angels messageboards and blogs. For the price' date=' I think his numbers are compelling.[/quote']

With the ongoing progress of Mitch Maier in the AFL and last year with AAA Omaha and the few games he made an appearance in with the big league club, and with the pretty solid play from DeJesus last year, CF really isn't number one for the Royals right now. While it would be nice to replace Joey Gathright, the Royals really need to rebuild their bullpen. That is their number one offseason concern.

 

Royals fans are expecting some big things from Mitch Maier this season.

 

I wasn't saying that the franchise was interested in him or even that it made sense.

Kansas City fans seem to be interested in him as well. He also has something of a cult following with certain Angels messageboards and blogs. For the price' date=' I think his numbers are compelling.[/quote']

With the ongoing progress of Mitch Maier in the AFL and last year with AAA Omaha and the few games he made an appearance in with the big league club, and with the pretty solid play from DeJesus last year, CF really isn't number one for the Royals right now. While it would be nice to replace Joey Gathright, the Royals really need to rebuild their bullpen. That is their number one offseason concern.

 

Royals fans are expecting some big things from Mitch Maier this season.

 

I wasn't saying that the franchise was interested in him or even that it made sense.

No need for the defense. I never said you did. I was just letting you know what the agenda is for the Royals.

No problem, I was merely commenting really about how far under the radar the guy is.

Definatly. Don't get me wrong, he'd be a hell of an addition for the Royals. I'd love to see his name on the roster instead of Joey Gathright's. But, like I said, bullpen help needs to come first.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.