December 10, 200619 yr I hope this puts to rest beliefs that our CF will come from TB. They would rather hang onto Upton and have him on their bench all season, and I think that about sums it up. They still expect to get a Kazmir-like deal in every trade.
December 10, 200619 yr I hope this puts to rest beliefs that our CF will come from TB. They would rather hang onto Upton and have him on their bench all season, and I think that about sums it up. They still expect to get a Kazmir-like deal in every trade. Benifest knows better
December 10, 200619 yr Benifest knows better If you mean to imply I am wrong and that a deal will be made - call me when Tampa is reasonable. Only there is Upton (or anyone for that matter) on the bench more valuable than Nolasco in the rotation.
December 11, 200619 yr I still think Anibal Sanchez might be our best young pitcher. Guess I'm the only one..... I have said time and time again that Sanchez is likely our number 1 starter going into the season Not likely. His peripherals were not that impressive last year, and I expect him to be the biggest drop off. He'll still likely post a sub 4 era, but unless his k/9 goes up, he's going to get hurt.
December 11, 200619 yr I still think Anibal Sanchez might be our best young pitcher. Guess I'm the only one..... I have said time and time again that Sanchez is likely our number 1 starter going into the season Not likely. His peripherals were not that impressive last year, and I expect him to be the biggest drop off. He'll still likely post a sub 4 era, but unless his k/9 goes up, he's going to get hurt. lol... Anibal is a flat out stud
December 11, 200619 yr I still think Anibal Sanchez might be our best young pitcher. Guess I'm the only one..... I have said time and time again that Sanchez is likely our number 1 starter going into the season Not likely. His peripherals were not that impressive last year, and I expect him to be the biggest drop off. He'll still likely post a sub 4 era, but unless his k/9 goes up, he's going to get hurt. lol... Anibal is a flat out stud I think he is a stud too and will get stronger more he gets away from that surgery but I agree his peripherals say he shouldnt of had as good of a year as he did this year. I think Olsen will end up with a better year for a power pitcher sense
December 11, 200619 yr I still think Anibal Sanchez might be our best young pitcher. Guess I'm the only one..... I have said time and time again that Sanchez is likely our number 1 starter going into the season D-Train will be the opening day starter, and it not it will be Johnson. Sanchez did well but he has hardly half a year of major league time.
December 11, 200619 yr Peripherals??? Anibal does one thing incredibly well, that is get hitters out! That dude just pitches as well as the best of them I have to say the red Sox are gonna seriously regret letting go of him. Just wanna add is that Upton has some great tools but we don't even know if he can play CF...He should but then again many others should have as well and have failed. Nolasco for Upton is a good valued trade on both parts but Tampa Bay again overestimating trade value of their players. if Upton doesn't get traded he will be a utility player. For the good of the kid and the good of the team They should trade the kid. Nolasco would be a great addition to their rotation and like I said they can have also Mitre if they want, but I am sure they want either Olsen or Sanchez. They will trade BJ Upton when his value is much less...Joey Gathright again!
December 11, 200619 yr Peripherals??? Anibal does one thing incredibly well, that is get hitters out! That dude just pitches as well as the best of them I have to say the red Sox are gonna seriously regret letting go of him. Just wanna add is that Upton has some great tools but we don't even know if he can play CF...He should but then again many others should have as well and have failed. Nolasco for Upton is a good valued trade on both parts but Tampa Bay again overestimating trade value of their players. if Upton doesn't get traded he will be a utility player. For the good of the kid and the good of the team They should trade the kid. Nolasco would be a great addition to their rotation and like I said they can have also Mitre if they want, but I am sure they want either Olsen or Sanchez. They will trade BJ Upton when his value is much less...Joey Gathright again! For once I don't think the Devil Rays are being completely unreasonable. Just because they don't have a starting job lined up for Upton doesn't mean that they should treat his trade value as a utility player. He was once one of the top prospects in baseball and is still highly touted, so it isn't unreasonable to expect one or two very good young players in return. The ceiling for Nolasco just isn't as high as most prospects despite his decent showing last year. And I don't think we will trade both him and Mitre, unless the FO is sold on Petit or Pinto being the number 5.
December 11, 200619 yr Between the last offseason and the D'Rays demanding Scott Olsen in return for Joey Gathright and this offseason where the D'Rays apparently want two starters for Baldelli and Nolasco for Upton is rejected out of hand (and leaked to the press), I wonder how much relations have soured between Beinfest and the D'Rays. Taking into account this and the previous reports of the Marlins completely shutting down talks for Baldelli I have serious doubts about the Marlins ever really reaching a deal with this organization (at least as long as Friedman remains in control of the D'Rays FO).
December 11, 200619 yr Nolasco for Denorfia. As much as I like Nolasco, I actually like this idea. Still too much to give up. As much as I'd hate to lose him, go ahead and trade Pinto for Denorfia straight up. At this point the Marlins might need to do this.
December 11, 200619 yr Nolasco for Denorfia. As much as I like Nolasco, I actually like this idea. Still too much to give up. As much as I'd hate to lose him, go ahead and trade Pinto for Denorfia straight up. At this point the Marlins might need to do this. Well I like your idea even better but I dont think Petit for Denorfia gets it done.
December 11, 200619 yr Nolasco for Denorfia. As much as I like Nolasco, I actually like this idea. Still too much to give up. As much as I'd hate to lose him, go ahead and trade Pinto for Denorfia straight up. At this point the Marlins might need to do this. Well I like your idea even better but I dont think Petit for Denorfia gets it done. Pinto, not Petit. I would be more in favor (slightly) of a Petit for Denorfia deal. But like you, I'm not sure it gets it done. Pinto could probably bring Denorfia here tomorrow.
December 11, 200619 yr For once I don't think the Devil Rays are being completely unreasonable. Just because they don't have a starting job lined up for Upton doesn't mean that they should treat his trade value as a utility player. He was once one of the top prospects in baseball and is still highly touted, so it isn't unreasonable to expect one or two very good young players in return. The ceiling for Nolasco just isn't as high as most prospects despite his decent showing last year. And I don't think we will trade both him and Mitre, unless the FO is sold on Petit or Pinto being the number 5. It would be one thing if Upton was completely blocked at every position. But that's not the case. If the DRays thought so highly of him they would've put him at 3B for 07 rather than bid to bring in Iwamura. Seriously, there isn't a logical thought process behind this. Even if they play up the idea that we are desperate for a CF, we're not desperate to give away young pitching with a good solid year of experience to then have to convert an infielder to a CF, whom BTW has yet to show much at all at the big league level. They want us to give up a pitcher with 15-20 win potential for a guy they won't even give a starting job, and it's insane. If it happened, I would be very dissapointed.
December 11, 200619 yr They could always DH him Either way, do you think we should be trading away good pitching to fill a defensive hole in CF with an IF who would at best be relegated to DH duty? I mean you can't be so desperate to see a move that this sounds good to you.
December 11, 200619 yr Dray fans are insane btw Rocco Baldelli+BJ Upton for Miguel Cabrera+Ricky Nolasco? http://www.raysbaseball.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=6295 I find their board pretty funny. Wish that guy wouldnt use my call name on here though whomever it was that posted on there as a marlins fan.
December 11, 200619 yr Dray fans are insane btw Rocco Baldelli+BJ Upton for Miguel Cabrera+Ricky Nolasco? http://www.raysbaseball.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=6295 I find their board pretty funny. Wish that guy wouldnt use my call name on here though whomever it was that posted on there as a marlins fan. The thing about the thread is there is enough of a belief among "some" there that either a) Delmon Young will be as good as Miggy or b) Miggy/Nolasco isn't enough to land Baldelli/Upton to make you realize how scary some of those people are. I read the whole thread. I'm not sure that was a good use of my time. :banghead
December 11, 200619 yr Dray fans are insane btw Rocco Baldelli+BJ Upton for Miguel Cabrera+Ricky Nolasco? http://www.raysbaseball.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=6295 I find their board pretty funny. Wish that guy wouldnt use my call name on here though whomever it was that posted on there as a marlins fan. The thing about the thread is there is enough of a belief among "some" there that either a) Delmon Young will be as good as Miggy or b) Miggy/Nolasco isn't enough to land Baldelli/Upton to make you realize how scary some of those people are. I read the whole thread. I'm not sure that was a good use of my time. :banghead I don't think that the Delmon Young/Miguel Cabrera comparison is that far off. In some ways they are very similar in that both of them are/were extremely polished at an extremely young age. If anything Delmon Young has more tools. He may not make quite as immediate a major impact as Miguel did but I don't doubt that he will be an amazing player if all goes well.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.