December 10, 200619 yr I think the only one getting underrated is Olsen. I'm sure Joey Gathright would agree with that.
December 10, 200619 yr slider, changeup, fastball makes 3 major league pitchers by my count. No way is Olsen's changeup major league average. I think the only one getting underrated is Olsen. I'm sure Joey Gathright would agree with that. This year last time, yes, Scott Olsen was extremely underrated. He is being overrated right now.
December 10, 200619 yr I rather trade Willis before I trade one of Olsen, Sanchez, Johnson but I would be willing to give the Devil Rays Olsen/Johnson and Aaron Thompson for Upton and Dukes. I'll pass on Olsen/Johnson/Sanchez for Upton straight up
December 10, 200619 yr Forgetting the fact that Olsen (along with Sanchez) carried the team on his back when Johnson was falling off the face of the planet towards the end of the year..... Major League Numbers: Olsen- 13-11, 4.03 ERA, 201.0 IP, 181 H, 107 R (90 ER), 28 HR, 85 BB, 187 K, 1.32 WHIP, 3.81 BB/9, 8.37 K/9 JJ- 12-7, 3.14 ERA, 169.1 IP, 147 H, 68 R (59 ER), 14 HR, 78 BB, 143 K, 1.33 WHIP, 4.15 BB/9, 7.60 K/9 Olsen has pitched over 30 more innings than JJ yet he still averages almost a strikeout more per nine innings and half a walk less (so much for Olsen being out of control walking people). The WHIPs are the same, and Olsen's had the misfortune of having serious defensive trouble behind him (17 unearned runs). Granted, those 17 runs didn't count against his ERA, but it's a very likely conclusion that some of those earned runs were the fault of the defense as well. In fact, the only thing Johnson really has on Olsen is that he keeps it in the park more. Playing in JRS 81 times a year, the HR really aren't that big of a deal over the course of an entire season. Plus, 5 of those HR were over a 20 inning span in 2005. Minor League Numbers: Olsen- 22-22, 3.06 ERA, 403.0 IP, 347 H, 165 R (137 ER), 19 HR, 159 BB, 436 K, 1.26 WHIP, 3.55 BB/9, 9.74 K/9 JJ- 23-25, 3.71 ERA, 359.1 IP, 355 H, 192 R (148 ER), 13 HR, 136 BB, 291 K, 1.37 WHIP, 3.41 BB/9, 7.29 K/9 First thing about Johnson and Olsen- Johnson never had a sub 3 ERA in the minors, while Olsen was sub 3 3/5 seasons. The WHIP is 11 points lower, he K's 2.5 more guys per nine than JJ (almost 10 per 9 innings!), and has a similar HR/9 rate. The walks are similar with a slight nod to JJ, and both pitchers were plagued by horrible defense on the farm. Add all those numbers to Olsen being a power pitching lefty while JJ is an innings eating righty.....and the nod for better pitcher clearly goes to Olsen. And I can't believe Beinfest even offered Nolasco for Upton. Hey, worth a try I suppose.
December 10, 200619 yr Forgetting the fact that Olsen (along with Sanchez) carried the team on his back when Johnson was falling off the face of the planet towards the end of the year..... Major League Numbers: Olsen- 13-11, 4.03 ERA, 201.0 IP, 181 H, 107 R (90 ER), 28 HR, 85 BB, 187 K, 1.32 WHIP, 3.81 BB/9, 8.37 K/9 JJ- 12-7, 3.14 ERA, 169.1 IP, 147 H, 68 R (59 ER), 14 HR, 78 BB, 143 K, 1.33 WHIP, 4.15 BB/9, 7.60 K/9 Olsen has pitched over 30 more innings than JJ yet he still averages almost a strikeout more per nine innings and half a walk less (so much for Olsen being out of control walking people). The WHIPs are the same, and Olsen's had the misfortune of having serious defensive trouble behind him (17 unearned runs). Granted, those 17 runs didn't count against his ERA, but it's a very likely conclusion that some of those earned runs were the fault of the defense as well. In fact, the only thing Johnson really has on Olsen is that he keeps it in the park more. Playing in JRS 81 times a year, the HR really aren't that big of a deal over the course of an entire season. Plus, 5 of those HR were over a 20 inning span in 2005. Umm, so the WHIPS are the same but JJ has an ERA almost one whole run lower than Olsen, yet Scott is clearly the better pitcher because he strikes out .77 more batters per 9 innings? The fact that he gave up TWICE as many homeruns is not insignificant at all, it is probably due to him being a 2 pitch pitcher. Because he does play in an extreme pitcher park like JRS, makes the stat even worse, IMO. He gave up 9 at home, 14 on the road. Homeruns hurt you alot more than striking out .77 more batters than the other guy helps you.. BTW- Against RHB he had a 4.48 ERA, WHIP of 1.44 and BAA of .255. What makes you think those numbers will improve? I'd imagine next year we will see managers take out all lefties in the lineup, and I'd bet that 4.48 ERA line is closer to what Scott will put up next year.
December 10, 200619 yr The Devil Rays reportedly rejected a deal to send B.J. Upton to the Marlins for Ricky Nolasco. Nolasco is a clear notch below the Marlins' other young starters, so there was no way that was going to fly. The Rays might be open to moving Upton in the right deal, but they're more likely to get equal value in return for Rocco Baldelli. Source: St. Petersburg Times I think I would trade Olsen for Upton. :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink:
December 10, 200619 yr Forgetting the fact that Olsen (along with Sanchez) carried the team on his back when Johnson was falling off the face of the planet towards the end of the year..... Johnson was the most consistent starter in the rotation last season, the stopper who could be counted on for most of the season to step up and stop the bleeding when other rookie pitchers or Dontrelle weren't delivering. And I don't see how you can say Olsen "carried the team on his back" toward the end of last year. In August, he posted a record of 2-3 with a 5.73 ERA. For September he had a few quality starts and a decent ERA at 3.29, but in the end came out with a record of 1-3 for that month. Johnson had a better August than Olsen, posting a 3-1 record with a 4.11 ERA. And before he "fell off the face of the planet" as you put it, Johnson looked like he was going to finish strong. During the September 12 game against the Mets when he was injured (after coming back to pitch after two rain delays), he had given up 3 hits and no runsover the course of 5 IP. Major League Numbers: Olsen- 13-11, 4.03 ERA, 201.0 IP, 181 H, 107 R (90 ER), 28 HR, 85 BB, 187 K, 1.32 WHIP, 3.81 BB/9, 8.37 K/9 JJ- 12-7, 3.14 ERA, 169.1 IP, 147 H, 68 R (59 ER), 14 HR, 78 BB, 143 K, 1.33 WHIP, 4.15 BB/9, 7.60 K/9 Olsen has pitched over 30 more innings than JJ yet he still averages almost a strikeout more per nine innings and half a walk less (so much for Olsen being out of control walking people). The WHIPs are the same, and Olsen's had the misfortune of having serious defensive trouble behind him (17 unearned runs). Granted, those 17 runs didn't count against his ERA, but it's a very likely conclusion that some of those earned runs were the fault of the defense as well. In fact, the only thing Johnson really has on Olsen is that he keeps it in the park more. Playing in JRS 81 times a year, the HR really aren't that big of a deal over the course of an entire season. Plus, 5 of those HR were over a 20 inning span in 2005. There are a few things Johnson had on Olsen during their rookie seasons other than giving up less homeruns. The biggest one of course is that he gave up less runs than Olsen, with Johnson having posting a sizeably more impressive ERA than him. If you want to go with another measure besides the standard 3.10 ERA Johnson had to Olsen's 4.04 ERA, Johnson had an ERA+ of 137 to Olsen's 105. As far as unearned runs go, if you do the math you'll find both Johnson and Olsen gave up roughly the same percentage of them. So it wasn't like Johnson was the beneficiary of stellar defense during all of his outings while Olsen had guys dogging it in the field whenever he took the mound. Besides this, Johnson gave up less hits than Olsen in 2006. While Olsen gave up 7.97 H/9, Johnson gave up 7.8 H/9. Johnson also had a better BAA (.236 to Olsen's .239). And when Olsen was hit, he was hit harder than Johnson with batters posting a .410 SLG against Olsen to Johnson's .368 SLG in 2006. Minor League Numbers: Olsen- 22-22, 3.06 ERA, 403.0 IP, 347 H, 165 R (137 ER), 19 HR, 159 BB, 436 K, 1.26 WHIP, 3.55 BB/9, 9.74 K/9 JJ- 23-25, 3.71 ERA, 359.1 IP, 355 H, 192 R (148 ER), 13 HR, 136 BB, 291 K, 1.37 WHIP, 3.41 BB/9, 7.29 K/9 First thing about Johnson and Olsen- Johnson never had a sub 3 ERA in the minors, while Olsen was sub 3 3/5 seasons. The WHIP is 11 points lower, he K's 2.5 more guys per nine than JJ (almost 10 per 9 innings!), and has a similar HR/9 rate. The walks are similar with a slight nod to JJ, and both pitchers were plagued by horrible defense on the farm. Add all those numbers to Olsen being a power pitching lefty while JJ is an innings eating righty.....and the nod for better pitcher clearly goes to Olsen. And I can't believe Beinfest even offered Nolasco for Upton. Hey, worth a try I suppose. Something you leave out about Olsen is his injury history, which is worrisome especially in 2007 when you consider his frame and the leap in IP he took from 2005 to 2006. One thing that you also leave out of your summation are the improvements Johnson showed during his first year in the bigs from his time in the minors and his short time on the Marlins in 2005. This includes improvements in H/9, K/9, WHIP and of course ERA. Not only that, but over the course of this last season I saw some improvement in his control, which isn't reflected in the career MLB numbers you posted above (which were skewed by the 10 walks he gave up in 12 IP in 2005). I expect further improvement in Johnson's control next season and in the end I think any who believe Johnson's ceiling to be merely that of an "innings eating righty" are in for a suprise during the coming years. While I don't necessarily think he will turn into an ace, I see his ceiling right now at being a solid #2. And keep in mind Johnson is still only 22 years old. I think he has the mental makeup and the build to improve even further over the next few years and I look forward to seeing it.
December 10, 200619 yr Umm, so the WHIPS are the same but JJ has an ERA almost one whole run lower than Olsen, yet Scott is clearly the better pitcher because he strikes out .77 more batters per 9 innings? The fact that he gave up TWICE as many homeruns is not insignificant at all, it is probably due to him being a 2 pitch pitcher. Because he does play in an extreme pitcher park like JRS, makes the stat even worse, IMO. He gave up 9 at home, 14 on the road. Homeruns hurt you alot more than striking out .77 more batters than the other guy helps you.. BTW- Against RHB he had a 4.48 ERA, WHIP of 1.44 and BAA of .255. What makes you think those numbers will improve? I'd imagine next year we will see managers take out all lefties in the lineup, and I'd bet that 4.48 ERA line is closer to what Scott will put up next year. First, RHB had 522 AB against Olsen while LHB had 148 AB. "Taking out all the lefties" already happened, so that stat bump won't happen. Also, speaking of stats, let's look at a different one - the two halves of the season. After the ASB, Johnson's ERA rose almost 2 whole points while Olsen's dropped .41. So the 'innings eater' gets gassed while the power lefty actually gets better as the season progresses. In fact, after June JJ's ERA rose every month of the year until the season's conclusion. Just what you want to see out of a rookie pitcher after teams have seen him for the second, third, and fourth times - ERA going up.
December 10, 200619 yr Major League Numbers: Olsen- 13-11, 4.03 ERA, 201.0 IP, 181 H, 107 R (90 ER), 28 HR, 85 BB, 187 K, 1.32 WHIP, 3.81 BB/9, 8.37 K/9 JJ- 12-7, 3.14 ERA, 169.1 IP, 147 H, 68 R (59 ER), 14 HR, 78 BB, 143 K, 1.33 WHIP, 4.15 BB/9, 7.60 K/9 Olsen has pitched over 30 more innings than JJ yet he still averages almost a strikeout more per nine innings and half a walk less (so much for Olsen being out of control walking people). The WHIPs are the same, and Olsen's had the misfortune of having serious defensive trouble behind him (17 unearned runs). Granted, those 17 runs didn't count against his ERA, but it's a very likely conclusion that some of those earned runs were the fault of the defense as well. In fact, the only thing Johnson really has on Olsen is that he keeps it in the park more. Playing in JRS 81 times a year, the HR really aren't that big of a deal over the course of an entire season. Plus, 5 of those HR were over a 20 inning span in 2005. I guess numbers can be interpreted selectively...Olsen pitched 31.2 innings more, gave up 31 more ERs and double the number of HRs. I don't much care that Olsen gave up more or less walks, but looking at just how many runs they give up, and how, I don't see how someone can slot Olsen above JJ. I like Olsen, and things may change, but JJ has shown more at the big league level thus far. Either way, trading any of our starters (even Nolasco IMO) for a guy who can't even earn a starting position in Tampa is a bad idea, if not insane.
December 10, 200619 yr I'm with IOWA on this one, I think Olsen is going to be a 20 game winner in the feature. Kid has all the makings of a superstar. I'd be pretty upset if they gave up Olsen for Upton because I believe Olsen is going to be our best pitcher this year. Yes, better than Dtrain and Josh Johnson.
December 10, 200619 yr Author I'm with IOWA on this one, I think Olsen is going to be a 20 game winner in the feature. Kid has all the makings of a superstar. I'd be pretty upset if they gave up Olsen for Upton because I believe Olsen is going to be our best pitcher this year. Yes, better than Dtrain and Josh Johnson. I would bet anything on that!
December 10, 200619 yr I will take him over Johnson and Sanchez this year but I think Willis is going to have a monster year following his trends
December 10, 200619 yr Umm, so the WHIPS are the same but JJ has an ERA almost one whole run lower than Olsen, yet Scott is clearly the better pitcher because he strikes out .77 more batters per 9 innings? The fact that he gave up TWICE as many homeruns is not insignificant at all, it is probably due to him being a 2 pitch pitcher. Because he does play in an extreme pitcher park like JRS, makes the stat even worse, IMO. He gave up 9 at home, 14 on the road. Homeruns hurt you alot more than striking out .77 more batters than the other guy helps you.. BTW- Against RHB he had a 4.48 ERA, WHIP of 1.44 and BAA of .255. What makes you think those numbers will improve? I'd imagine next year we will see managers take out all lefties in the lineup, and I'd bet that 4.48 ERA line is closer to what Scott will put up next year. First, RHB had 522 AB against Olsen while LHB had 148 AB. "Taking out all the lefties" already happened, so that stat bump won't happen. Also, speaking of stats, let's look at a different one - the two halves of the season. After the ASB, Johnson's ERA rose almost 2 whole points while Olsen's dropped .41. So the 'innings eater' gets gassed while the power lefty actually gets better as the season progresses. In fact, after June JJ's ERA rose every month of the year until the season's conclusion. Just what you want to see out of a rookie pitcher after teams have seen him for the second, third, and fourth times - ERA going up. Actually Johnson's ERA didn't rise anywhere close to "2 whole points" after the ASB. It did rise, yes, but it rose from 2.21 pre-ASB to 3.10 by the end of the year, a rise of .89 (and I think if he had not been injured on September 12 he would have been more in the 2.95-3.05 range). While Olsen showed a slight downtick in his ERA post-ASB, it isn't anywhere as dramatic as you try to make it sound. Pre-ASB, Olsen had a 4.24 ERA and by the end of the season he had a 4.04 ERA, a decrease of .20. Lets look at your claim teams figured Johnson out after facing him a second, third and fourth time and drove up his ERA as a result and compare it to Olsen's performance against teams he faced on three or more occasions in 2006. First lets look at JJ — Josh Johnson vs the Mets 1. May 26, 2006 @ DS - Win, 7.0 IP, 1 R, 0 ER, 2 H, 2 BB, 8 K, Win 2. July, 8, 2006 @ Shea - Win, 5.0 IP, 2 R, 0 ER, 2 H, 5 BB, 5 K, Win 3. September 12, 2006 @ DS - ND, 5.0 IP, 0 R, 0 ER, 3 H, 1 BB, 3 K, ND Final record of Johnson vs the Mets in 2006: 2-0, 17 IP, 0.00 ERA, 7 H, 9 BB, 16 K Josh Johnson vs the Braves 1. May 10, 2006 @ DS - Win, 6.0 IP, 1 R, 0 ER, 4 H, 0 BB, 4 K 2. May 15, 2006 @ TTF - ND, 5.0 IP, 2 R, 2 ER, 7 H, 3 BB, 6 K 3. June 13, 2006 @ DS - Win, 6.0 IP, 1 R, 1 ER, 7 H, 2 BB, 7 K 4. July 26, 2006 @ TTF - ND, 6.0 IP, 4 R, 3 ER, 7 H, 3 BB, 6 K Final record of Johnson vs the Braves in 2006: 2-0, 23 IP, 2.35 ERA, 25 H, 8 BB, 23 K The two teams who Johnson faced the most in 2006, and arguably our biggest division rivals, were either dominated or kept in check. So much for your claim about repeated exposure to teams driving up JJ's ERA. Now lets look at Scott Olsen — Scott Olsen vs the Braves 1. May 18 2006 @ TTF - Loss, 4.2 IP, 8 R, 8 ER, 8 H, 2 BB, 7 K 2. July 27, 2006 @ TTF - Win, 6.0 IP, 0 R, 0 ER, 2 H, 2 BB, 5 K 3. August 18, 2006 @ DS - Loss, 1.2 IP, 5 R, 5 ER, 4 H, 4 BB, 2 K Final record of Olsen vs the Braves in 2006: 1-2, 12.1 IP, 9.49 ERA, 14 H, 8 BB, 14 K Scott Olsen vs the Mets 1. July 9, 2006 @ Shea - ND, 5.0 IP, 3 R, 3 ER, 6 H, 0 BB, 5 K 2. August 1, 2006 @ DS - ND, 6.0 IP, 4 R, 4 ER, 6 H, 4 BB, 10 K 3. September 13, 2006 @ DS - ND, 8.0 IP, 3 R, 3 ER, 6 H, 2 BB, 3 K 4. September 19, 2006 @ Shea - ND, 7.0 IP, 1 R, 1 ER, 5 H, 2 BB, 6 K Final record of Olsen vs the Mets in 2006: 0-0, 26.0 IP, 3.81 ERA, 23 H, 8 BB, 24 K Scott Olsen vs the Phillies 1. April 21, 2006 @ CBP - Win, 6.2 IP, 2 R, 1 ER, 8 H, 2 BB, 1 K 2. May 2, 2006 @ DS - ND, 3.0 IP, 3 R, 3 ER, 2 H, 4 BB 2 K 3. September 8, 2006 @ DS - Loss, 7.2 IP, 3 R, 3 ER, 8 H, 2 BB, 7 K 4. September 24, 2006 @ CBP - Loss, 2.2 IP, 7 R, 3 ER, 7 H, 0 BB, 4 K 5. September 30, 2006 @ DS - Loss, 6.0 IP, 4 R, 4 ER, 5 H, 4 BB, 6 K Final record of Olsen vs the Phillies in 2006: 1-3, 26.0 IP, 4.85 ERA, 30 H, 12 BB, 20 K Looking at those stats it would seem the exact opposite is true of what you wrote and it was Olsen, not Johnson, who was hurt by repeated exposure to teams. The beatings the Phillies gave Olsen on May 2 and September 24 & September 30 after he put in decent outings against them on the previous outings on April 21 and September 8 are probably the most troubling. Definitely not the kind of performances you like to see overall against the teams that figure to be our toughest competition in the NL East for years to come.
December 10, 200619 yr Some rookies thrive against certain teams and some struggle but in the end, they're still just a rookie. Give it time, Olsen has the best stuff out of all of our starters and has shown it at times throughout the year.
December 10, 200619 yr Some rookies thrive against certain teams and some struggle but in the end, they're still just a rookie. Give it time, Olsen has the best stuff out of all of our starters and has shown it at times throughout the year. I'm not going to argue, I'm just going to add this: To be our best pitcher, or anyone else's for that matter, I think a pitcher will need to do more than show the best stuff "at times" - they've got to do it consistently. That's the key difference for us - Olsen may dominate more at times, and even more often we might say, but JJ is seemingly never bad. And when he is we could still score 5 runs and win.
December 10, 200619 yr The Devil Rays reportedly rejected a deal to send B.J. Upton to the Marlins for Ricky Nolasco. Nolasco is a clear notch below the Marlins' other young starters, so there was no way that was going to fly. The Rays might be open to moving Upton in the right deal, but they're more likely to get equal value in return for Rocco Baldelli. Source: St. Petersburg Times I think I would trade Olsen for Upton. If the D'Rays will not take Nolasco for Upton ? a prospect without a position slated to ride the pine in Tampa next season ? I think we can safely assume that they will not take Nolasco as the centerpiece in a deal for Baldelli. As for dealing Olsen for Upton straight up, that sounds like another Kazmir deal (maybe even worse since it seems very likely after his rookie that Olsen will achieve his potential) in the making and would definitely be the worst trade of the offseason. If we are going to deal Olsen, it should only be in a deal for Baldelli. Even if that would be a somewhat fair trade, I'm not sure I would pull the trigger. After rejecting Nolasco for Upton (or wanting no part of Nolasco it seems), I expect the Marlins to be looking elsewhere this offseason for their centerfielder and not deal with the D'Rays again unless they come to us with a reasonable offer. That is a very fair assesment of the situation. This summarizes the D-Rays FO trade tendencies, that is why they will never win anything. I feel Nolasco for Upton trade is a very fair proposal considering that Nolasco won 11 games as a rookie and Upton had a forgetable performance and doesn't really have a position as a player.Now if we talk based on upside well Upton has a world of potential . Potential means he hasn't accomplished anything. Think about it, Tampa has no use or no need for Upton and typical of their FO style they are posturing with him as trade bait. This is the Joey Gathright scenario all over again. I hope we get Upton but he isn't worth Olsen or JJ. If they want Mitre they can have him as well but not much else. Pinto maybe, depending on what else the D-Rays can include in the deal
December 10, 200619 yr Author I still think Anibal Sanchez might be our best young pitcher. Guess I'm the only one.....
December 10, 200619 yr I still think Anibal Sanchez might be our best young pitcher. Guess I'm the only one..... I somehow doubt that
December 10, 200619 yr Author I still think Anibal Sanchez might be our best young pitcher. Guess I'm the only one..... I somehow doubt that No one mentions him. I'm not just talking about the no hitter either. He shut down 1 good team after another and has as good of stuff as anyone. He's another bulldog also. I would take him over Johnson OR Olsen.
December 10, 200619 yr All of them, Olsen, JJ, Sanchez, Nolasco, Tankerley and Pinto, I don't think we've seen anything that approaches where they'll be with a major league season under their belts. Maybe Garcia too. The key to me was keeping Kranitz. Don't break this group up.
December 10, 200619 yr I still think Anibal Sanchez might be our best young pitcher. Guess I'm the only one..... I have said time and time again that Sanchez is likely our number 1 starter going into the season
December 10, 200619 yr I think I would trade Olsen for Upton. Thank god you're not our GM Scott Olsen is going to be a 20 game winner I doubt it. I seriously doubt it. Olsen's attitude is what will hold him back.... Like Josh Beckett? A cocky SOB at times....remember he is also a kid.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.