Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Alex Rios

Featured Replies

"Out of my mind" for having an opinion?

 

I was not comparing the two other than to say both succeeded in the minors and showed great promise but were not able to translate that at the major league level. Why this seems to bother some of you is baffling to me.

 

And while I did proffer that Aguila was better defensively, I doubt you could find anyone who thinks Upton is anything but a defensively liability. That is the rap on him, he has all these tools but can't make even simple plays.

 

No one here stands by players and is for giving them a chance more than me Lou. I haven't "soured" on him, his own performance, both offensively and defensively since 2004 have soured his chances in the bigs, not anything I've said.

 

Whether you like it or not he isn't worth Ricky Nolasco after three straight years of under-performing, NEVERMIND Ricky Nolasco PLUS "any pitcher in our farm system", I suppose that includes West, Volstad, anyone?

 

And this from FishFan79:

 

"That is like me comparing Reggie Abercrombie to Albert Pujols.

 

It is completely and utterly ignorant in every since of the ideal. You cant be serious in believing that the talent of Chris Aguila comes within 1/10 of that of BJ Upton? BJ Upton is one of the most talented young players seem in recent generations. Where Chris was never much more then a 2nd rate prospect that was renown for marlins fans because in high school he hit a large number of HRs."

 

You do understand you are obsessed with Upton don't you?

Please tell me you didnt just compare Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? Please tell me that.

 

Yes I did. Got a problem with that?

 

Both showed tremendous promise in the minor leagues and both were unable to translate that success to the major league level. I realize you have some kind of fan crush on Upton but putting the Marlins aside for a minute, do you see a whole flock or even one other team beating a path to the Rays' door to acquire him? Simply, the answer is no. There's a reason.

 

That's the worst comparison imaginable. I can't believe I just read it.

 

You realize Aguila couldn't even smell a bench spot in the bigs until 25?

 

You realize that Upton is only 22 has beaten down professional pitching for the better part of two years and was not met with the promotion many felt was appropriate for his success while the major league club allowed an inferior player to "block" him. Sound familiar *cough* Hanley Ramirez *cough*.

 

Seriously...

 

"Out of my mind" for having an opinion?

 

I was not comparing the two other than to say both succeeded in the minors and showed great promise but were not able to translate that at the major league level. Why this seems to bother some of you is baffling to me.

 

And while I did proffer that Aguila was better defensively, I doubt you could find anyone who thinks Upton is anything but a defensively liability. That is the rap on him, he has all these tools but can't make even simple plays.

 

No one here stands by players and is for giving them a chance more than me Lou. I haven't "soured" on him, his own performance, both offensively and defensively since 2004 have soured his chances in the bigs, not anything I've said.

 

Whether you like it or not he isn't worth Ricky Nolasco after three straight years of under-performing, NEVERMIND Ricky Nolasco PLUS "any pitcher in our farm system", I suppose that includes West, Volstad, anyone?

 

And this from FishFan79:

 

"That is like me comparing Reggie Abercrombie to Albert Pujols.

 

It is completely and utterly ignorant in every since of the ideal. You cant be serious in believing that the talent of Chris Aguila comes within 1/10 of that of BJ Upton? BJ Upton is one of the most talented young players seem in recent generations. Where Chris was never much more then a 2nd rate prospect that was renown for marlins fans because in high school he hit a large number of HRs."

 

You do understand you are obsessed with Upton don't you?

 

BJ UPTON IS 22 f***ING YEARS OLD!!! GET THAT THROUGH YOUR BRAIN!!!!!!!

 

CHRIS AGUILA WAS LANGUISHING IN THE MINORS AT 22 YEARS OLD!!!!

 

Just for kicks, the last full season Upton spent at any level was as a 21 year old in AAA. He went .303/.392/.490/.882. Aguila's 21 year old season? HIGH A BALL .240/.292/.357/.649.

 

The next year Aguila continued to struggle failing to post an OPS above .800.

 

To compare the two is laughable and completely disregards common sense.

  • Author

"Out of my mind" for having an opinion?

 

I was not comparing the two other than to say both succeeded in the minors and showed great promise but were not able to translate that at the major league level. Why this seems to bother some of you is baffling to me.

 

And while I did proffer that Aguila was better defensively, I doubt you could find anyone who thinks Upton is anything but a defensively liability. That is the rap on him, he has all these tools but can't make even simple plays.

 

No one here stands by players and is for giving them a chance more than me Lou. I haven't "soured" on him, his own performance, both offensively and defensively since 2004 have soured his chances in the bigs, not anything I've said.

 

Whether you like it or not he isn't worth Ricky Nolasco after three straight years of under-performing, NEVERMIND Ricky Nolasco PLUS "any pitcher in our farm system", I suppose that includes West, Volstad, anyone?

 

And this from FishFan79:

 

"That is like me comparing Reggie Abercrombie to Albert Pujols.

 

It is completely and utterly ignorant in every since of the ideal. You cant be serious in believing that the talent of Chris Aguila comes within 1/10 of that of BJ Upton? BJ Upton is one of the most talented young players seem in recent generations. Where Chris was never much more then a 2nd rate prospect that was renown for marlins fans because in high school he hit a large number of HRs."

 

You do understand you are obsessed with Upton don't you?

 

 

Feel free to send an email to Baseball america and ask their opinion of BJ Upton in CF, they will give you their answer. Personally I dont care one way or the other if we get Upton or Baldelli, Wilts (suggested at mlbtraderumors), etc etc. All I care is they get someone not named Taveras or Abercrombie personally.

 

As for my "Obsession" with BJ Upton, you dont know the first thing about me please dont be foolish or childish by making Ass-umptions of myself.

 

As Swift just posted your statement was absolutely ignorant in every possible way. Many folks have compared Upton to Hanley Ramirez before Ramirez sucess and afterwards.

 

As I stated you are ignorant in this instance it seems from your blanket statement to try to prove your point. Now you calling me childishly obsessed merely shows it more because I have a different opinion. I never stated you are "Out of your mind" for your opinion. But, I did say it is ignorant.

 

Ignorant = Unaware or uninformed.

 

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/ignorant

 

Chris Aguila is the same as BJ Upton? Come on.

"Out of my mind" for having an opinion?

 

I was not comparing the two other than to say both succeeded in the minors and showed great promise but were not able to translate that at the major league level. Why this seems to bother some of you is baffling to me.

 

And while I did proffer that Aguila was better defensively, I doubt you could find anyone who thinks Upton is anything but a defensively liability. That is the rap on him, he has all these tools but can't make even simple plays.

 

No one here stands by players and is for giving them a chance more than me Lou. I haven't "soured" on him, his own performance, both offensively and defensively since 2004 have soured his chances in the bigs, not anything I've said.

 

Whether you like it or not he isn't worth Ricky Nolasco after three straight years of under-performing, NEVERMIND Ricky Nolasco PLUS "any pitcher in our farm system", I suppose that includes West, Volstad, anyone?

 

And this from FishFan79:

 

"That is like me comparing Reggie Abercrombie to Albert Pujols.

 

It is completely and utterly ignorant in every since of the ideal. You cant be serious in believing that the talent of Chris Aguila comes within 1/10 of that of BJ Upton? BJ Upton is one of the most talented young players seem in recent generations. Where Chris was never much more then a 2nd rate prospect that was renown for marlins fans because in high school he hit a large number of HRs."

 

You do understand you are obsessed with Upton don't you?

BJ Upton has underperformed for three straight years? He hit .303/.392/.490, with 44/13 SB in AAA as a 21 year old last year. Yea, that sucks. Likewise, he drew 65 BB in 398 AB this year (.374 OBP). Sure, he had severe AVG and SLUG drops, but the batting eye is there. He's not falling apart.

 

Likewise, Hanley was awful in the minors before he dropped last year. BJ is going to be exactly the same way. Tampa Bay is messing with this kid's mind moving him to a multitude of different positions when they should have realized earlier into his development he wasn't going to be a shortstop. The DBacks figured this out with the other Upton and moved him to CF before he got above low A ball, Drays have player evaluation issues as we've gone over before. Plus, they are refusing to give him a certified starting spot in the majors (not entirely their fault because how can you argue with Crawford, Delmon, and Rocco as an OF) when it is clearly visible he's done with the minors and ready to be a MLB player.

 

He's so not worth Nolasco the Rays turned that deal down. I would trade Nolasco and West/Volstad for Upton today. We'd be a lot better short and long term. He's really going to be that good.

Please tell me you didnt just compare Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? Please tell me that.

 

Yes I did. Got a problem with that?

 

Both showed tremendous promise in the minor leagues and both were unable to translate that success to the major league level. I realize you have some kind of fan crush on Upton but putting the Marlins aside for a minute, do you see a whole flock or even one other team beating a path to the Rays' door to acquire him? Simply, the answer is no. There's a reason.

 

That's the worst comparison imaginable. I can't believe I just read it.

 

You realize Aguila couldn't even smell a bench spot in the bigs until 25?

 

You realize that Upton is only 22 has beaten down professional pitching for the better part of two years and was not met with the promotion many felt was appropriate for his success while the major league club allowed an inferior player to "block" him. Sound familiar *cough* Hanley Ramirez *cough*.

 

Seriously...

 

I'm so sorry you find fault with my "opinion" Swift but if you even bothered to read what I wrote the comparison was only that neither was able to make the transition from the minor leagues to the bigs. I don't need a lecture on how to form an opinion or how I want to make an analogy, and if you don't have the faculties to understand the root of the comparison is not their tools, not their age, simply their shared inability to make that transition over the last three years, and that both held out unrealized promise that never materialized, there's not much I can say to yet another one of your insulting comments. I'm not the villain here, Upton with his five tools could have pushed Hollins to the bench three years ago to make a spot for himself if he had shown he had what it takes. He didn't and hasn't so far. Great players force themselves into lineups, good players wait their turn. So far Upton's turn hasn't come. He's not blocked by anyone, don't you think there's a reason he hasn't been handed the shortstop position outright in 2007?

 

I don't hate the guy. I just do not believe the hype and obsession shown here where people are falling over themselves to support the unsupportable. I'll say this, if Upton plays regularly in the major and equals Hanley Ramirez' 2006 numbers in 2007, I'll take a two week break from MB.com at seasons end. How about you do the same if he doesn't? Wanna take that bet?

 

Lost here is Tampa's own mouthpiece admitting Upton isn't very good defensively.

 

 

 

Lou, I was talking about his major league numbers in 2004. Ditto 2006. I thought that was clear from the context of not succeeding the MLB level.

 

Please tell me you didnt just compare Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? Please tell me that.

 

Yes I did. Got a problem with that?

 

Both showed tremendous promise in the minor leagues and both were unable to translate that success to the major league level. I realize you have some kind of fan crush on Upton but putting the Marlins aside for a minute, do you see a whole flock or even one other team beating a path to the Rays' door to acquire him? Simply, the answer is no. There's a reason.

 

That's the worst comparison imaginable. I can't believe I just read it.

 

You realize Aguila couldn't even smell a bench spot in the bigs until 25?

 

You realize that Upton is only 22 has beaten down professional pitching for the better part of two years and was not met with the promotion many felt was appropriate for his success while the major league club allowed an inferior player to "block" him. Sound familiar *cough* Hanley Ramirez *cough*.

 

Seriously...

 

"Out of my mind" for having an opinion?

 

I was not comparing the two other than to say both succeeded in the minors and showed great promise but were not able to translate that at the major league level. Why this seems to bother some of you is baffling to me.

 

And while I did proffer that Aguila was better defensively, I doubt you could find anyone who thinks Upton is anything but a defensively liability. That is the rap on him, he has all these tools but can't make even simple plays.

 

No one here stands by players and is for giving them a chance more than me Lou. I haven't "soured" on him, his own performance, both offensively and defensively since 2004 have soured his chances in the bigs, not anything I've said.

 

Whether you like it or not he isn't worth Ricky Nolasco after three straight years of under-performing, NEVERMIND Ricky Nolasco PLUS "any pitcher in our farm system", I suppose that includes West, Volstad, anyone?

 

And this from FishFan79:

 

"That is like me comparing Reggie Abercrombie to Albert Pujols.

 

It is completely and utterly ignorant in every since of the ideal. You cant be serious in believing that the talent of Chris Aguila comes within 1/10 of that of BJ Upton? BJ Upton is one of the most talented young players seem in recent generations. Where Chris was never much more then a 2nd rate prospect that was renown for marlins fans because in high school he hit a large number of HRs."

 

You do understand you are obsessed with Upton don't you?

 

BJ UPTON IS 22 f***ING YEARS OLD!!! GET THAT THROUGH YOUR BRAIN!!!!!!!

 

CHRIS AGUILA WAS LANGUISHING IN THE MINORS AT 22 YEARS OLD!!!!

 

Just for kicks, the last full season Upton spent at any level was as a 21 year old in AAA. He went .303/.392/.490/.882. Aguila's 21 year old season? HIGH A BALL .240/.292/.357/.649.

 

The next year Aguila continued to struggle failing to post an OPS above .800.

 

To compare the two is laughable and completely disregards common sense.

 

You just get more insulting as the day goes on don't you?

 

I doubt you've even read what I wrote.

Please tell me you didnt just compare Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? Please tell me that.

 

Yes I did. Got a problem with that?

 

Both showed tremendous promise in the minor leagues and both were unable to translate that success to the major league level. I realize you have some kind of fan crush on Upton but putting the Marlins aside for a minute, do you see a whole flock or even one other team beating a path to the Rays' door to acquire him? Simply, the answer is no. There's a reason.

 

That's the worst comparison imaginable. I can't believe I just read it.

 

You realize Aguila couldn't even smell a bench spot in the bigs until 25?

 

You realize that Upton is only 22 has beaten down professional pitching for the better part of two years and was not met with the promotion many felt was appropriate for his success while the major league club allowed an inferior player to "block" him. Sound familiar *cough* Hanley Ramirez *cough*.

 

Seriously...

 

I'm so sorry you find fault with my "opinion" Swift but if you even bothered to read what I wrote the comparison was only that neither was able to make the transition from the minor leagues to the bigs. I don't need a lecture on how to form an opinion or how I want to make an analogy, and if you don't have the faculties to understand the root of the comparison is not their tools, not their age, simply their shared inability to make that transition over the last three years, and that both held out unrealized promise that never materialized, there's not much I can say to yet another one of your insulting comments. I'm not the villain here, Upton with his five tools could have pushed Hollins to the bench three years ago to make a spot for himself if he had shown he had what it takes. He didn't and hasn't so far. Great players force themselves into lineups, good players wait their turn. So far Upton's turn hasn't come. He's not blocked by anyone, don't you think there's a reason he hasn't been handed the shortstop position outright in 2007?

 

I don't hate the guy. I just do not believe the hype and obsession shown here where people are falling over themselves to support the unsupportable. I'll say this, if Upton plays regularly in the major and equals Hanley Ramirez' 2006 numbers in 2007, I'll take a two week break from MB.com at seasons end. How about you do the same if he doesn't? Wanna take that bet?

 

Lost here is Tampa's own mouthpiece admitting Upton isn't very good defensively.

 

 

 

Lou, I was talking about his major league numbers in 2004. Ditto 2006. I thought that was clear from the context of not succeeding the MLB level.

 

If you don't "have the faculties" to understand that no comparison of baseball players is fair if age is completely disregarded, then this is truly pathetic.

 

BJ Upton is/has been better at every level at the same age (and been further along) than Aguila. Hence, the comparison is retarded. Hell, the fact that this is still going on has made me lose almost all faith in the intelligence of Marlins fans.

 

I'll tell you what I will bet you, and we can go for a month ban, a year ban or a lifetime ban, I'm down for anything.

 

The highest number of games Aguila spent in the majors was 65 in 2005. He posted a line of .244/.272/.282/.554

 

If Upton is given 65 games or more I will be that he surpasses all of those figures. Time to put up or shut up in your confidence of comparison. If they are so similar take my bet. I'll go for a lifetime ban with ya buddy.

Please tell me you didnt just compare Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? Please tell me that.

 

Yes I did. Got a problem with that?

 

Both showed tremendous promise in the minor leagues and both were unable to translate that success to the major league level. I realize you have some kind of fan crush on Upton but putting the Marlins aside for a minute, do you see a whole flock or even one other team beating a path to the Rays' door to acquire him? Simply, the answer is no. There's a reason.

 

And Eddie, I agree, it's absurd (Nolasco not being enough to get Upton) but I'm not sure the teams are still talking. With the closer thing still up in the air and Ricky being a logical candidate to take up at least part of the role, trading him right now (at least forme) makes little sense.

 

 

That is like me comparing Reggie Abercrombie to Albert Pujols.

 

It is completely and utterly ignorant in every since of the ideal. You cant be serious in believing that the talent of Chris Aguila comes within 1/10 of that of BJ Upton? BJ Upton is one of the most talented young players seem in recent generations. Where Chris was never much more then a 2nd rate prospect that was renown for marlins fans because in high school he hit a large number of HRs.

 

You cant be serious and believe Aguila is 1/10th the talent of BJ Upton. There is no position prospect in our entire minors right now (and I am high on Coughlin) that comes close to the potential of Upton.

 

They also have Reid Brignac who is a huge prospect at SS coming up the line fast so Zobrist may need to move to 2nd base anyway...Damn I wish the Marlins had this problem

 

 

I Do understand what you mean in comparing Aguila to Upton in reference to performance in the minors vs performance in the majors. Though talent and skill-wise they are not comparable, they both exceeded in the minors and have failed to perform in the majors. However with Upton the Kid is so young and has so much talent that you just have to believe in the right situation and with the right approach towards his development he will be able to show his abilities. In Aguila's case he is just what is called a 4A player good enough for a few cups of coffee but just not quite a major league player. there are hundreds of those...most players in AAA ball as a matter of fact. Aguila may develop a role with some major league team as a defensive replacement, pinchrunner or pinchhitter but unfortunately that is his peak. The Marlins don't have a need for a player of that type right now. We need players who are capable starters

Swift, that's not the bet, but why am I not surprised you are already trying to backtrack on your words?

 

Your comparison was to Hanley Ramirez. Stand by that or stop being insulting just to be insulting.

 

Here's a more than a fair bet. Ramirez appeared in 158 games and had 633 ABs. Toqualify for this bet because Upton may not hit first all he has to do is have 500 ABs and post equivalent or better offensive numbers than Hanley and sure, I'll up the bet to a month, no problemo here. I'll go further.If he even gets 500ABs I'll not post for a week, regardless of how well he does, I'd like to see you do the same if he doesn't. I mean surely this season has to be the season he plays somewhere regularly (at the MLB level).

 

As for Aguila, I've made my analogy absolutely clear. Eddie A. just posted (above) and while he understands my analogy and what it was based on he disagrees in a gentlemanly way. Why can't you do that? Why is insulting and demeaning comments and lecturing someone on why their opinion is not only wrong but you're happy to name-call them in the process your modus operandi?

 

So are you up for the bet?

 

You game?

That's a tough act to follow 03. Hanley had one of the best rookie seasons of all time

That's a tough act to follow 03. Hanley had one of the best rookie seasons of all time

 

I didn't make the comparison. Swift did.

That's a tough act to follow 03. Hanley had one of the best rookie seasons of all time

 

I didn't make the comparison. Swift did.

He never said he would put up those numbers in his rookie year. He said his skills and every aspect of his game(besides his accuracy from SS) have been compared to Hanley. Which they have been.

That's a tough act to follow 03. Hanley had one of the best rookie seasons of all time

 

I didn't make the comparison. Swift did.

He never said he would put up those numbers in his rookie year. He said his skills and every aspect of his game(besides his accuracy from SS) have been compared to Hanley. Which they have been.

 

*ding*

 

Swift, that's not the bet, but why am I not surprised you are already trying to backtrack on your words?

 

Your comparison was to Hanley Ramirez. Stand by that or stop being insulting just to be insulting.

 

Here's a more than a fair bet. Ramirez appeared in 158 games and had 633 ABs. Toqualify for this bet because Upton may not hit first all he has to do is have 500 ABs and post equivalent or better offensive numbers than Hanley and sure, I'll up the bet to a month, no problemo here. I'll go further.If he even gets 500ABs I'll not post for a week, regardless of how well he does, I'd like to see you do the same if he doesn't. I mean surely this season has to be the season he plays somewhere regularly (at the MLB level).

 

As for Aguila, I've made my analogy absolutely clear. Eddie A. just posted (above) and while he understands my analogy and what it was based on he disagrees in a gentlemanly way. Why can't you do that? Why is insulting and demeaning comments and lecturing someone on why their opinion is not only wrong but you're happy to name-call them in the process your modus operandi?

 

So are you up for the bet?

 

You game?

 

And you're not back tracking on your words?

 

Put up or shut up, I'm done with this and you.

  • Author

Swift, that's not the bet, but why am I not surprised you are already trying to backtrack on your words?

 

Your comparison was to Hanley Ramirez. Stand by that or stop being insulting just to be insulting.

 

Here's a more than a fair bet. Ramirez appeared in 158 games and had 633 ABs. Toqualify for this bet because Upton may not hit first all he has to do is have 500 ABs and post equivalent or better offensive numbers than Hanley and sure, I'll up the bet to a month, no problemo here. I'll go further.If he even gets 500ABs I'll not post for a week, regardless of how well he does, I'd like to see you do the same if he doesn't. I mean surely this season has to be the season he plays somewhere regularly (at the MLB level).

 

As for Aguila, I've made my analogy absolutely clear. Eddie A. just posted (above) and while he understands my analogy and what it was based on he disagrees in a gentlemanly way. Why can't you do that? Why is insulting and demeaning comments and lecturing someone on why their opinion is not only wrong but you're happy to name-call them in the process your modus operandi?

 

So are you up for the bet?

 

You game?

 

 

That is a completely dumb bet there dude. Hanley Ramirez just finished one of the top 15 best seasons for a rookie position player in the history of baseball. You cant expect Upton to put up numbers like that. Hell, Hanley most likely wont put up those numbers again this year himself! (even though I surely hope he does). Hanley and Upton have always been compared throughout their career for potentials and they should end up being close to one another in abilities if they both make the jump. Hanley did it, upton there is a good chance to do it next. But you compared him to Chris AGUILA. :banghead :banghead :banghead

 

 

Here is my opinion of what Upton's line would be in the majors starting all the time at CF.

 

270-290 BA/330-360 OBP/400-500 SLG, 10-20 HR, 20-40 SB

For a career line if he hits his projections it would be a matching numbers to around Hanley puts up. They are very similar players, Upton takes walks more then Hanley though typically from minor league numbers. Hanley is a little faster.

 

It will take him a year perhaps 2 to fully transition to CF, but he should be fine there his brother just made the transition very well himself. His arm is great, his speed is great. The route running will just take time.

 

What would I give up?

 

I would give up Ricky Nolasco and a prospect not named West or Volstad. Any other prospect in the system from Gaby Hernandez to Jose Garcia to Pettit I would pack with Ricky for him. I would consider Josh Johnson for him if we got something else back. But I would only do that if we cant find anything else comparable (I would prefer rios for johnson personally).

 

BJ Upton is pretty much the type of player Wilts is for the Angels just with more speed and more power potential and a stronger arm. He is also 5 years younger (I believe wilts was going on 27 next year, upton will start at 22 I believe).

 

But Upton needs a chance for regular playing time and away from that backwards organization that is the Devil Rays to become anything close to successful.

Alright take it down a notch guys.

 

We're all die hard Marlins fans. Sometimes we get caught up in the heat of a debate (myself included) but there's really no need to get venemous over Chris Aguila of all people.

Here is my opinion of what Upton's line would be in the majors starting all the time at CF.

 

270-290 BA/330-360 OBP/400-500 SLG, 10-20 HR, 20-40 SB

lol... youre numbers hit all over the board

Upton with his five tools could have pushed Hollins to the bench three years ago to make a spot for himself if he had shown he had what it takes. He didn't and hasn't so far. Great players force themselves into lineups, good players wait their turn. So far Upton's turn hasn't come. He's not blocked by anyone, don't you think there's a reason he hasn't been handed the shortstop position outright in 2007?

Yea, but you don't put 20 year olds on the bench when they can get AB in AAA. Also, Ryan Howard had to wait his turn. That's not necessarily true with what I bolded.

 

If the Rays made Upton a CF when he was 19, this wouldn't be an issue. There is no question whether he's going to hit or not - this goes back to the DRays simply messing up by not making him an OF earlier. Now he is COMPLETELY blocked by Crawford, Rocco, and Delmon, and we can actually go further because of Iwamura at 3B with Guzman right behind him, and Longoria behind him in coming seasons, and Iwamura/Gomes (and Dukes) can each play OF spots as well. BJ is the odd man out because he's not a superior defender to Rocco or Iwamura (while exhibiting similar offensive ability), and his offensive ceiling is not as high as Crawford or Delmon. This isn't a knock on BJ being pushed aside for other guys, these are just really good players around him. Players like BJ flat out never get traded before making a MLB impact unless it's for a superstar. If we're actually able to get him for Nolasco + any prospect in the minors, wow. What a steal. If only we could be so lucky.

 

And to be a third party arbiter to your "bet" with swift, the argument was a 'similar' jump in production to Hanley. I would say if Upton gets 500 plate appearances and hits a .270/.350/.425 or better (or just an overall .775+ OPS to not argue specific percentages if OBP is 10 lower, and slugging 20 higher, whatever) and in general displays 'passable' defense to the tune of not insulting ZR, RF, errors, etc defensive stats, Swift will have beat you out on this one. I think that's a fair baseline for both of you if you guys want to go toe to toe on this one. Using Hanley's season is just to much of a stretch. That was one hell of a rookie year.

  • Author

Here is my opinion of what Upton's line would be in the majors starting all the time at CF.

 

270-290 BA/330-360 OBP/400-500 SLG, 10-20 HR, 20-40 SB

lol... youre numbers hit all over the board

I am trying to give just a range from best to worst there. Best case would be

 

290/360/500/860 OPS 20HR, 40 SB

 

Worst would be something like

270/330/400/730 (still better then our CF last year)

 

But I guess I should of put it like that. It was sorta everywhere :)

I'll make it real simple, for Swift to win Upton must get 500 ABs at the major league level and hit .285. No homeruns, no stolen bases, no esoteric stats, just simple ABs and BA. Nothing else matters.

 

Real simple.

I'll make it real simple, for Swift to win Upton must get 500 ABs at the major league level and hit .285. No homeruns, no stolen bases, no esoteric stats, just simple ABs and BA. Nothing else matters.

 

Real simple.

Why do you want to make this bet so bad?

I'll make it real simple, for Swift to win Upton must get 500 ABs at the major league level and hit .285.

 

Real simple.

 

Yeah, because that's relevant to the discussion, just any random number that's a far cry from Chris Aguila and his career .228 average.

 

I've said it before and I'll say it again, we're making the Aguila comparison, you can pick any major league season of Aguila's and I will bet that Upton will easily surpass it.

 

So, unless you're back tracking on your comparison which I obviously lack the faculties to understand (since, I still don't think he hit .285 in the majors at any point), this is over.

 

And I mean it, I'll life time ban bet it.

I'll make it real simple, for Swift to win Upton must get 500 ABs at the major league level and hit .285.

 

Real simple.

 

Yeah, because that's relevant to the discussion, just any random number that's a far cry from Chris Aguila and his career .228 average.

 

I've said it before and I'll say it again, we're making the Aguila comparison, you can pick any professional season of Aguila's and I will bet that Upton will easily surpass it.

 

So, unless you're back tracking on your comparison which I obviously lack the faculties to understand (since, I still don't think he hit .285 in the majors at any point), this is over.

 

And I mean it, I'll life time ban bet it.

 

 

You're saying because you're trying to save face, let's be honest here.

 

You realize Upton has already had more MLB ABs than Aguila don't you or were you so busy name-calling that you didn't notice? I never made a comparison offensively of the two players, nor did I even make a wide-ranging talent comparison, all I said, repeatedly, was here's two players who showed alot in the minors and couldn't make it translate in the big leagues. You've distorted that so that you could find yet another opportunity to demean and insult me. I'm used to it Swift, you are what you are.

 

I'll make it real simple, for Swift to win Upton must get 500 ABs at the major league level and hit .285.

 

Real simple.

 

Yeah, because that's relevant to the discussion, just any random number that's a far cry from Chris Aguila and his career .228 average.

 

I've said it before and I'll say it again, we're making the Aguila comparison, you can pick any professional season of Aguila's and I will bet that Upton will easily surpass it.

 

So, unless you're back tracking on your comparison which I obviously lack the faculties to understand (since, I still don't think he hit .285 in the majors at any point), this is over.

 

And I mean it, I'll life time ban bet it.

 

 

You're saying because you're trying to save face, let's be honest here.

 

You realize Upton has already had more MLB ABs than Aguila don't you or were you so busy name-calling that you didn't notice? I never made a comparison offensively of the two players, nor did I even make a wide-ranging talent comparison, all I said, repeatedly, was here's two players who showed alot in the minors and couldn't make it translate in the big leagues. You've distorted that so that you could find yet another opportunity to demean and insult me. I'm used to it Swift, you are what you are.

Here is my opinion of what Upton's line would be in the majors starting all the time at CF.

 

270-290 BA/330-360 OBP/400-500 SLG, 10-20 HR, 20-40 SB

lol... youre numbers hit all over the board

I am trying to give just a range from best to worst there. Best case would be

 

290/360/500/860 OPS 20HR, 40 SB

 

Worst would be something like

270/330/400/730 (still better then our CF last year)

 

But I guess I should of put it like that. It was sorta everywhere :)

By 25 years old, I expect baseline .280/.360/.450, 40/15 SB, type years, with a lot of potential slugging growth. He can develop into a 20+ HR guy for sure. Totally worth Nolasco + anyone in the farm, partially due to the fact he is MLB ready right now and the best player we'd be sending TB in this scenario will be starting the year in High A Ball.

 

This question goes back to one of your posts saying West/Volstad should be off limits, so I ask what's better?

 

Rios for Johnson/Olsen/Anibal (plus maybe a nominal second player like Julianel, Nestor, etc)

or

Upton for Nolasco and West/Volstad

 

I'd do either of those trades (well just JJ for the first one) when it comes down to it, but I'd rather do the later and not worry about what West/Volstad might become versus knowing what we have with JJ. I'd honestly be surprised if TB would take it too because they'd probably want/need something closer to MLB ready. Maybe Nolasco/Gaby Hernandez makes more sense saying that, but then they lose some ceiling and might need a third pitcher, like one of the relievers... you get the idea. In general, I agree completely with the notion of keeping the big 3 in a potential deal for Upton, but it'll be hard using Nolasco + non top top prospects because our good stuff is ETA 2009 and the DRays are going to want production now.

I'll make it real simple, for Swift to win Upton must get 500 ABs at the major league level and hit .285.

 

Real simple.

 

Yeah, because that's relevant to the discussion, just any random number that's a far cry from Chris Aguila and his career .228 average.

 

I've said it before and I'll say it again, we're making the Aguila comparison, you can pick any professional season of Aguila's and I will bet that Upton will easily surpass it.

 

So, unless you're back tracking on your comparison which I obviously lack the faculties to understand (since, I still don't think he hit .285 in the majors at any point), this is over.

 

And I mean it, I'll life time ban bet it.

 

 

You're saying because you're trying to save face, let's be honest here.

 

You realize Upton has already had more MLB ABs than Aguila don't you or were you so busy name-calling that you didn't notice? I never made a comparison offensively of the two players, nor did I even make a wide-ranging talent comparison, all I said, repeatedly, was here's two players who showed alot in the minors and couldn't make it translate in the big leagues. You've distorted that so that you could find yet another opportunity to demean and insult me. I'm used to it Swift, you are what you are.

 

I'll make it real simple, for Swift to win Upton must get 500 ABs at the major league level and hit .285.

 

Real simple.

 

Yeah, because that's relevant to the discussion, just any random number that's a far cry from Chris Aguila and his career .228 average.

 

I've said it before and I'll say it again, we're making the Aguila comparison, you can pick any professional season of Aguila's and I will bet that Upton will easily surpass it.

 

So, unless you're back tracking on your comparison which I obviously lack the faculties to understand (since, I still don't think he hit .285 in the majors at any point), this is over.

 

And I mean it, I'll life time ban bet it.

 

 

You're saying because you're trying to save face, let's be honest here.

 

You realize Upton has already had more MLB ABs than Aguila don't you or were you so busy name-calling that you didn't notice? I never made a comparison offensively of the two players, nor did I even make a wide-ranging talent comparison, all I said, repeatedly, was here's two players who showed alot in the minors and couldn't make it translate in the big leagues. You've distorted that so that you could find yet another opportunity to demean and insult me. I'm used to it Swift, you are what you are.

 

I'll even say it twice. You made the Aguila/Upton comparison.

 

YOU made the Aguila/Upton comparison.

 

YOU said that Upton couldn't translate to the majors

 

YOU said that Upton couldn't translate to the majors

 

Thus, it is reasonable to conclude that "not translating" to the majors is representative of Aguila's numbers

 

Thus, it is reasonable to conclude that "not translating" to the majors is representative of Aguila's numbers

 

I am willing to prove your comparison asinine

 

I am willing to prove your comparison asinine

 

You are now backing off your initial comparison

 

You are now backing off your initial comparison

 

I am done with this, the wager is there, your inaction speaks volumes about your credibility and confidence in your beliefs

 

I am done with this, the wager is there, your inaction speaks volumes about your credibility and confidence in your beliefs

  • Author

Here is my opinion of what Upton's line would be in the majors starting all the time at CF.

 

270-290 BA/330-360 OBP/400-500 SLG, 10-20 HR, 20-40 SB

lol... youre numbers hit all over the board

I am trying to give just a range from best to worst there. Best case would be

 

290/360/500/860 OPS 20HR, 40 SB

 

Worst would be something like

270/330/400/730 (still better then our CF last year)

 

But I guess I should of put it like that. It was sorta everywhere :)

By 25 years old, I expect baseline .280/.360/.450, 40/15 SB, type years, with a lot of potential slugging growth. He can develop into a 20+ HR guy for sure. Totally worth Nolasco + anyone in the farm, partially due to the fact he is MLB ready right now and the best player we'd be sending TB in this scenario will be starting the year in High A Ball.

 

This question goes back to one of your posts saying West/Volstad should be off limits, so I ask what's better?

 

Rios for Johnson/Olsen/Anibal (plus maybe a nominal second player like Julianel, Nestor, etc)

or

Upton for Nolasco and West/Volstad

 

I'd do either of those trades (well just JJ for the first one) when it comes down to it, but I'd rather do the later and not worry about what West/Volstad might become versus knowing what we have with JJ. I'd honestly be surprised if TB would take it too because they'd probably want/need something closer to MLB ready. Maybe Nolasco/Gaby Hernandez makes more sense saying that, but then they lose some ceiling and might need a third pitcher, like one of the relievers... you get the idea. In general, I agree completely with the notion of keeping the big 3 in a potential deal for Upton, but it'll be hard using Nolasco + non top top prospects because our good stuff is ETA 2009 and the DRays are going to want production now.

 

 

I understand exactly what you are saying dude. I wouldnt fault you for making that deal with West/Volstad even for the potential of Upton if indeed he becomes that good. My suggestion of Johnson for Rios was more that I believe in Johnson less then alot of others on here seem to. But, I cant fault them for that belief as last year he was wonderful for the team.

 

What about Nolasco and Thompson? He is right near to Volstad/West in potential at 19 and all. A little behind but not far and is a solid lefty potential arm. I think the situation for Upton is like this right now.

(this is all assumptions, so I could easily be wrong)

 

TB values him worth more then Nolasco, closer to the Johnson group

Marlins value him at worth less then the Johnson group, little more then Nolasco.

 

I think his value is somewhere right beween the two.

Nolsaco + Pettit/Garcia/Pinto/etc etc etc

 

Another thing to consider is that the Drays are looking for a SS according to (http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/). What about fixing Robert Andino to the deal? He has great defensive potential for them and could be useful in a trade. He is blocked here from Hanley and Uggla.

 

 

I couldnt fault you at all for making the trade of Nolasco + West. I would love to see Upton hit your stat line in teal and lead off for us.

Upton, Hanley, Miggy, Jacobs, Willingham, Uggla, Hermida, Olivo (perhaps upgrade then)

 

If Upton hits that line at age 24-25 range that would be a wonderful lineup specially if we can keep together our big 4, slide in Pettit/Garcia/Pinto/etc into the final spot.

 

 

 

So Yes, I guess when push comes to shove I would give up that :) (sorry for round about thinking there, ar work here)

Nothing but insults, why am I not surprised? I've noticed how you depend on the word "asinine" as one of your favorite putdowns. Tell me, when you got your thesaurus were you able to get past the letter A?

 

As for the duplicate post you know Admin took the system down for a few minutes and that's what caused it but if course you have to keep being you. And of course you ignore the fact Upton already has more career MLB at bats than Aguila and you're still distorting what I said.

 

You know, it's funny this age absolutism you preach makes no sense when you compare two players most often mentioned as peers, Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera where Miggy is three years YOUNGER than Pujols. No says Cabrera will be Pujols in another three years, they say "they" are the two of the best in the league. Period.

 

Age only matters (within some reasonable criteria - you don't compare a 22 year old to a 32 year old) when there is no other way to make your argument. There are simply too many variable. When they started playing organized ball, when they started playing professional ball, did they go to college, did one of them go do a Peace Corps stint or otherwise work away from the game, was one of injured (often for example a pitcher having TJ and needing 18 months+/- to recuperate. All these factor and many more are much more important that simply looking at two players' ages and drawn a conclusion.

 

So I guess you're still not willing to bet Upton vs Ramirez or even Upton vs 500 ABs and .285 BA in 2007? Take Ramirez out of it completely.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.