December 19, 200619 yr Hes better off not pitching at all. Id rather have a four man rotation than a rotation that features Mitre, as I dont like my team to lose, which is exactly what the turd is best at...even if he was on the hill on his best day with his best stuff he is still as untalented as any player that has ever lived. Pinto, Garcia, and even Petit are MUCH MUCH MUCH better options than Mitre. I still dont get why people think the guy is good, or even average, or even want him pitching for us at all.
December 19, 200619 yr From what I saw of Mitre last year, he wasnt terrible... It's pretty hard to take an opinion on a guy who got injured early in the year. He kept us in the game in the majority of his starts, with a few really nice ones sprinkled in between. I mean, his ERA was pretty weighted down by two terrible bullpen appearances. (7 ER in 0 IP) Take those out and his ERA is a respectable 4.18. I think he could be pretty decent out of the pen and as a spot starter.
December 19, 200619 yr mitre has never shown anything out of the pen but when hes starting he can put together decent outings and give a team with an average offense a chance to win
December 19, 200619 yr mitre has never shown anything out of the pen but when hes starting he can put together decent outings and give a team with an average offense a chance to win :|
December 19, 200619 yr The Blue Jays would like to replace starter Ted Lilly, who signed a four-year deal with the Cubs earlier this month. In order to obtain a starter, Toronto possibly could make outfielders Alex Rios, Reed Johnson or Adam Lind, along with some pitching prospects, available. Of those outfielders, Rios likely would net the most in return. Last season, the 25-year-old hit .302 with 17 home runs and 82 RBIs. His season was shortened to 128 games due to a staph infection in his left leg, but he flashed his power potential at the plate and is a strong defender in right field. "There's a lot of interest in Rios," Ricciardi said. "We'll see. We'd be crazy not to explore any avenues, but that doesn't mean we're trading him." http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/news/article...6&fext=.jsp
December 19, 200619 yr Qwhy don't the marlins show interest in trade a for alex rios the blue jays need young pitching and alex is a perfect fit for centerfield john, miami, fl 12/18/06 AWell, apparently the Marlins aren't sure he is a perfect fit. Centerfield at Dolphin Stadium is so huge the team really needs a speedster , which is why it's looking at people like Alex Sanchez and still considering Eric Reed and Reggie Abercrombie. Kevin Baxter 12/18/06 :|
December 19, 200619 yr Qwhy don't the marlins show interest in trade a for alex rios the blue jays need young pitching and alex is a perfect fit for centerfield john, miami, fl 12/18/06 AWell, apparently the Marlins aren't sure he is a perfect fit. Centerfield at Dolphin Stadium is so huge the team really needs a speedster , which is why it's looking at people like Alex Sanchez and still considering Eric Reed and Reggie Abercrombie. Kevin Baxter 12/18/06 :| :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: Please go no!
December 19, 200619 yr Author Qwhy don't the marlins show interest in trade a for alex rios the blue jays need young pitching and alex is a perfect fit for centerfield john, miami, fl 12/18/06 AWell, apparently the Marlins aren't sure he is a perfect fit. Centerfield at Dolphin Stadium is so huge the team really needs a speedster , which is why it's looking at people like Alex Sanchez and still considering Eric Reed and Reggie Abercrombie. Kevin Baxter 12/18/06 :| :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: :blink: Please go no! sometimes I wonder if Baxter even knows anything. He seems very very ignorant on things sometimes.
December 19, 200619 yr sometimes I wonder if Baxter even knows anything. He seems very very ignorant on things sometimes. Sometimes? :banghead
December 19, 200619 yr Author http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/...sp&c_id=fla With so many young pitchers on the roster, and a lot of pitching in the Minor Leagues, why didn't the team get rid of Sergio Mitre? He is nowhere near as talented as other pitchers in the organization. There was talk that we declined to trade him to the Reds for Chris Denorfia. -- Jeff K., Coral Springs, Fla. I'm not so sure Mitre ever was offered straight up for Denorfia. The Marlins are exploring a number of options for a young center fielder. Ideally, they'd like someone young and talented, without much service time, to grow along with their already young roster. As for dealing Mitre, the team is being careful with which pitchers it parts with. Having someone like Mitre on the roster is important, because invariably you need more than five starters due to either injuries or lack of performance. So having depth in the starting rotation is important. Besides, should Nolasco be switched to closer, Mitre would be a candidate to fill that spot in the rotation. for mitre fans Why don't the Marlins go after Bernie Williams? He's a veteran outfielder with a lot of experience and he plays center field. Signing him would answer a lot of questions. -- Michael O., Miami Beach, Fla. Going after Williams made more sense a year ago, when just about every position was unsettled and Joe Girardi was manager. Girardi was a teammate of Williams with the Yankees, and there could have been a link to lure Williams to the Marlins. It didn't happen then, and it isn't under consideration now. With new manager Fredi Gonzalez in place, and a number of positions already determined, the Marlins ideally are looking for younger options in center field. Williams is 38. He's a career Yankee, and chances are he will go back to New York. The Marlins ideally want a long-term solution in center, which is why they are interested in B.J. Upton of Tampa Bay. Alex Sanchez was signed to a Minor League contract with an invitation to big-league camp. Sanchez will get a shot, but he provides a stopgap should none of the younger players win the job outright. So we are still after Bj Upton
December 19, 200619 yr You go Jeff! Honestly, the idea of Mitre starting(or even being on this team) makes me want to puke. You all say you havent seen enough of him while he was doing his thing trying his hardest to lose last year...what makes you think he is any different than the guy that was complete garbage with the Cubs? The CUBS! He is so bad the Cubs, who never have enough pitching, damn near forced us to take him.
December 19, 200619 yr You go Jeff! Honestly, the idea of Mitre starting(or even being on this team) makes me want to puke. You all say you havent seen enough of him while he was doing his thing trying his hardest to lose last year...what makes you think he is any different than the guy that was complete garbage with the Cubs? The CUBS! He is so bad the Cubs, who never have enough pitching, damn near forced us to take him. For one, the Cubs didn't force us to take him. He makes no money, he has minor league options. The Red Sox were forced to take Mike Lowell. This is not anywhere near the same situation. Secondly, He's easily one of the 12 best MLB ready pitchers in the organization: Willis, Sanchez, Olsen, Johnson, Nolasco, Gregg, Tankeresly, Pinto, J. Garcia. That's 9 I won't argue. Who's next? Petit? Owens? Lindstrom? Nate FIELD? That's literally it. Who you putting above Mitre? Petit easily needs a full year in AAA starting. Owens and Lindstrom are so far 1 year wonders (in the minors) with a lot of pump cause of their numbers, but completely unproven. Nate Field is a minor league free agent. After them, you have single A kids like H. Garcia, Vanden Hurk, etc who will not be breaking camp and shouldn't be rushed. He's probably 10th right now. Top 12 for SURE just in case Owens or FIELD really starts throwing fire. He's not as bad as you think he is. He's still only 25/26 years old, he's been hurt on and off, and given health, should be a sub 5.00 era long reliever. Is that great? no. Is it someone you build around? No. But given the RP market and having Mitre for somewhere between 400-500k, that's a solid guy for 5-6-7 RP in the pen to just eat random non-pressure innings at not a huge liability. I agree with you, if a current SP is traded, the next options for the 5 should be J. Garcia or Petit until they prove they can't do it, but Mitre is not the worst pitcher ever and I won't mind if he throws 70-80 IP between relief appearances and a handful of spot starts if need be. There's no one better in free agency for 2-3 times the price. He's not making or breaking this team as a contender anyway you look at it. You know what makes me want to puke? The best 3 center fielders in the Marlins organization are currently Alex Sanchez, Eric Reed, and Reggie Abercrombie. This is why the Marlins should float some names to the Blue Jays and see what they are looking for, for Alex Rios. Maybe the price is wrong, but maybe it's not. (Trying to link it back to the thread here). Mitre is nowhere near the problem.
December 19, 200619 yr I have nothing to add to this thread. I will say though that I do have a man-marlin-non-gay-message board-crush on marlinslou. The man is just gold. Anything he says I agree with. If Beinfest was fired, I'd have zero problem with Marlinslou as GM. Carry on now.............
December 19, 200619 yr This thread is getting kinda crazy! My response is that Mitre really has no value to anyone. The team got better when he wasn't pitching. He doesn't want to relieve. He is a 5th starter on some other teams and a marginal one at best. The comment is that he was a throw-in and he cost us nothing...Let's get rid of nothing then, whatever we can get for him is fine with me. On this team if we need a start from somebody we have Pinto and Gregg, even if you have concerns about Petit who is the first available option. You can make an assumption that Mitre is as good as gone. He will be the throw-in in another deal of some kind or sold to Japan. Upton is a likely target for the Marlins and fits the profile of what is considered as the perfect fit, bit the D-Rays are playing hard to get, although he has no role on that team except as maybe a utility player. That is a waste of a bright prospect like Upton! Rios is a real option but is the price right?
December 19, 200619 yr Author I'm a B.J. Upton fan. With Evan Longoria rising through the farm system, Zobrist at shortstop and the outfield filled, what are the Rays' plans for Upton -- hold on to him and find him a starting spot, or possibly trade him for some pitching? -- Colby, Keene, N.H. Right now, Upton has Rays management pulling out its hair trying to decide what to do with this incredible athlete whose physical gifts are envied by all. Unfortunately, he lacks the consistency to make routine plays defensively. He also seems to have taken a step back at the plate. Players can get by on potential only so long, and the sands inside the hourglass are quickly passing for Upton. He is available if the right trade comes along, but those clubs would be faced with the same question of where to put him. The coming season is a big one for Upton. http://tampabay.devilrays.mlb.com/NASApp/m...jsp&c_id=tb Apparently the Rays' intent in pursuing Giles was to further increase their depth of position players; they've got Jorge Cantu at second and also could use Akinori Iwamura at that position. Rocco Baldelli continues to be the subject of trade talk. (Jim McIsaac / Getty Images) The Rays remain engaged in various trade discussions regarding their young outfielders and infielder B.J. Upton. Recent talks with the Dodgers about outfielder Rocco Baldelli failed to advance. The Marlins' pursuit of Upton also went nowhere; the Rays rejected the Marlins' offer of right-hander Ricky Nolasco, prompting the Marlins to kick around the idea of building a three-way deal around those players. The Mets would have been the third club, giving up young pitching to go to the Rays along with Nolasco in exchange for Cantu. http://msn.foxsports.com/mlb/story/6287132
December 19, 200619 yr Why would the Mets and Marlins would want two defensive liabilities, Cantu at second base or Upton in centerfield is beyond me and for the price of a successful rookie starting major league pitcher PLUS pitching prospects is beyond me. Cantu and Upton both share "the most likely to be squeezed out of a job" spotlight this upcoming season in Tampa, which might be a good thing for the Rays. Possibly Cantu can find a job at first base where his defensive shortcomings can be held to a minimum, but Upton who failed as a shortstop (as referenced above) to make even routine plays holds little promise in the outfield other than blazing speed, and with a slumping bat at both the minor league and major league levels. He's a faster version of Chris Aguila with less defense. You look at Chris Aguila in the minors and you go OMG this guy is going to tear up the major leagues but he just never is quite able to prove himself. Ditto Upton. Cantu was hurt last season, maybe he'll come back offensively but in the NL I don't think he can excel defensively at 2B which is what the Mets would want. Thankfully neither Minaya nor Beinfest drank the kool-aid.
December 19, 200619 yr You gotta love how an Alex Rios thread turns into another Spike crapping on Mitre thread.
December 19, 200619 yr Author Why would the Mets and Marlins would want two defensive liabilities, Cantu at second base or Upton in centerfield is beyond me and for the price of a successful rookie starting major league pitcher PLUS pitching prospects is beyond me. Cantu and Upton both share "the most likely to be squeezed out of a job" spotlight this upcoming season in Tampa, which might be a good thing for the Rays. Possibly Cantu can find a job at first base where his defensive shortcomings can be held to a minimum, but Upton who failed as a shortstop (as referenced above) to make even routine plays holds little promise in the outfield other than blazing speed, and with a slumping bat at both the minor league and major league levels. He's a faster version of Chris Aguila with less defense. You look at Chris Aguila in the minors and you go OMG this guy is going to tear up the major leagues but he just never is quite able to prove himself. Ditto Upton. Cantu was hurt last season, maybe he'll come back offensively but in the NL I don't think he can excel defensively at 2B which is what the Mets would want. Thankfully neither Minaya nor Beinfest drank the kool-aid. Please tell me you didnt just compare Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? Please tell me that.
December 19, 200619 yr Why would the Mets and Marlins would want two defensive liabilities, Cantu at second base or Upton in centerfield is beyond me and for the price of a successful rookie starting major league pitcher PLUS pitching prospects is beyond me. Cantu and Upton both share "the most likely to be squeezed out of a job" spotlight this upcoming season in Tampa, which might be a good thing for the Rays. Possibly Cantu can find a job at first base where his defensive shortcomings can be held to a minimum, but Upton who failed as a shortstop (as referenced above) to make even routine plays holds little promise in the outfield other than blazing speed, and with a slumping bat at both the minor league and major league levels. He's a faster version of Chris Aguila with less defense. You look at Chris Aguila in the minors and you go OMG this guy is going to tear up the major leagues but he just never is quite able to prove himself. Ditto Upton. Cantu was hurt last season, maybe he'll come back offensively but in the NL I don't think he can excel defensively at 2B which is what the Mets would want. Thankfully neither Minaya nor Beinfest drank the kool-aid. Cantu would go to the Mets and Upton would come to S Florida The D-Rays would get maybe 2 or 3 pitchers. That's not too bad but i still believe is's absurd that the D-Rays rejected Nolasco. At least they are still talking. We may need to move these postings. They are well beyond the tangent this thread
December 19, 200619 yr Author welcome to start a new thead with it Eddie, no problem splitting it up. I figured all another BJ Upton thread would do is start another debate over denorfia, wilts, upton, baldelli, etc. Just like it has often lately. Didnt mean to start up the debate here though.
December 19, 200619 yr Please tell me you didnt just compare Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? Please tell me that. Yes I did. Got a problem with that? Both showed tremendous promise in the minor leagues and both were unable to translate that success to the major league level. I realize you have some kind of fan crush on Upton but putting the Marlins aside for a minute, do you see a whole flock or even one other team beating a path to the Rays' door to acquire him? Simply, the answer is no. There's a reason. And Eddie, I agree, it's absurd (Nolasco not being enough to get Upton) but I'm not sure the teams are still talking. With the closer thing still up in the air and Ricky being a logical candidate to take up at least part of the role, trading him right now (at least forme) makes little sense.
December 19, 200619 yr Why would the Mets and Marlins would want two defensive liabilities, Cantu at second base or Upton in centerfield is beyond me and for the price of a successful rookie starting major league pitcher PLUS pitching prospects is beyond me. Cantu and Upton both share "the most likely to be squeezed out of a job" spotlight this upcoming season in Tampa, which might be a good thing for the Rays. Possibly Cantu can find a job at first base where his defensive shortcomings can be held to a minimum, but Upton who failed as a shortstop (as referenced above) to make even routine plays holds little promise in the outfield other than blazing speed, and with a slumping bat at both the minor league and major league levels. He's a faster version of Chris Aguila with less defense. You look at Chris Aguila in the minors and you go OMG this guy is going to tear up the major leagues but he just never is quite able to prove himself. Ditto Upton. Cantu was hurt last season, maybe he'll come back offensively but in the NL I don't think he can excel defensively at 2B which is what the Mets would want. Thankfully neither Minaya nor Beinfest drank the kool-aid. Are you honestly comparing Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? I love how you instantly sour on a player, Milledge being a second example, after an initial stint in the majors at 21/22 years old is relatively unsuccessful. Sure, no problem with Cantu having to move away from 2B eventually, but you are out of your mind if you think BJ Upton isn't a player. He needs a scenery change as badly as any player in baseball. There are so many examples I can use here, as in Gary Sheffield holding little promise as an OF after being chased from SS and then 3B, and Hanley slumping in the minors and then magically turning into the ROY, but whatever. BJ is going to be really good and would fill a glaring hole for the Marlins in the short and long term. If we can acquire him for Nolasco, and any pitcher in our farm system, ANY, that's a win for us. ... Chris Aguila. Honestly?
December 19, 200619 yr I'm a B.J. Upton fan. With Evan Longoria rising through the farm system, Zobrist at shortstop and the outfield filled, what are the Rays' plans for Upton -- hold on to him and find him a starting spot, or possibly trade him for some pitching? -- Colby, Keene, N.H. Right now, Upton has Rays management pulling out its hair trying to decide what to do with this incredible athlete whose physical gifts are envied by all. Unfortunately, he lacks the consistency to make routine plays defensively. He also seems to have taken a step back at the plate. Players can get by on potential only so long, and the sands inside the hourglass are quickly passing for Upton. He is available if the right trade comes along, but those clubs would be faced with the same question of where to put him. The coming season is a big one for Upton. http://tampabay.devilrays.mlb.com/NASApp/m...jsp&c_id=tb Apparently the Rays' intent in pursuing Giles was to further increase their depth of position players; they've got Jorge Cantu at second and also could use Akinori Iwamura at that position. Rocco Baldelli continues to be the subject of trade talk. (Jim McIsaac / Getty Images) The Rays remain engaged in various trade discussions regarding their young outfielders and infielder B.J. Upton. Recent talks with the Dodgers about outfielder Rocco Baldelli failed to advance. The Marlins' pursuit of Upton also went nowhere; the Rays rejected the Marlins' offer of right-hander Ricky Nolasco, prompting the Marlins to kick around the idea of building a three-way deal around those players. The Mets would have been the third club, giving up young pitching to go to the Rays along with Nolasco in exchange for Cantu. http://msn.foxsports.com/mlb/story/6287132 They also have Reid Brignac who is a huge prospect at SS coming up the line fast so Zobrist or Brignac may need to move to 2nd base anyway...Damn I wish the Marlins had this problem
December 19, 200619 yr They also have Reid Brignac who is a huge prospect at SS coming up the line fast so Zobrist may need to move to 2nd base anyway...Damn I wish the Marlins had this problem We do have this problem, but with starting pitching. I'll take that problem over their's anyday.
December 19, 200619 yr Author Please tell me you didnt just compare Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? Please tell me that. Yes I did. Got a problem with that? Both showed tremendous promise in the minor leagues and both were unable to translate that success to the major league level. I realize you have some kind of fan crush on Upton but putting the Marlins aside for a minute, do you see a whole flock or even one other team beating a path to the Rays' door to acquire him? Simply, the answer is no. There's a reason. And Eddie, I agree, it's absurd (Nolasco not being enough to get Upton) but I'm not sure the teams are still talking. With the closer thing still up in the air and Ricky being a logical candidate to take up at least part of the role, trading him right now (at least forme) makes little sense. That is like me comparing Reggie Abercrombie to Albert Pujols. It is completely and utterly ignorant in every since of the ideal. You cant be serious in believing that the talent of Chris Aguila comes within 1/10 of that of BJ Upton? BJ Upton is one of the most talented young players seem in recent generations. Where Chris was never much more then a 2nd rate prospect that was renown for marlins fans because in high school he hit a large number of HRs. You cant be serious and believe Aguila is 1/10th the talent of BJ Upton. There is no position prospect in our entire minors right now (and I am high on Coughlin) that comes close to the potential of Upton. They also have Reid Brignac who is a huge prospect at SS coming up the line fast so Zobrist may need to move to 2nd base anyway...Damn I wish the Marlins had this problem And Dukes and Guzman have good potential too. Gomes could be back after not being hurt now. They are so stacked with position prospects. Brignac is going to be a monster in the majors, huge power hitting SS.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.