December 19, 200619 yr I understand exactly what you are saying dude. I wouldnt fault you for making that deal with West/Volstad even for the potential of Upton if indeed he becomes that good. My suggestion of Johnson for Rios was more that I believe in Johnson less then alot of others on here seem to. But, I cant fault them for that belief as last year he was wonderful for the team. What about Nolasco and Thompson? He is right near to Volstad/West in potential at 19 and all. A little behind but not far and is a solid lefty potential arm. I think the situation for Upton is like this right now. (this is all assumptions, so I could easily be wrong) TB values him worth more then Nolasco, closer to the Johnson group Marlins value him at worth less then the Johnson group, little more then Nolasco. I think his value is somewhere right beween the two. Nolsaco + Pettit/Garcia/Pinto/etc etc etc I couldnt fault you at all for making the trade of Nolasco + West. I would love to see Upton hit your stat line in teal and lead off for us. Upton, Hanley, Miggy, Jacobs, Willingham, Uggla, Hermida, Olivo (perhaps upgrade then) If Upton hits that line at age 24-25 range that would be a wonderful lineup specially if we can keep together our big 4, slide in Pettit/Garcia/Pinto/etc into the final spot. So Yes, I guess when push comes to shove I would give up that (sorry for round about thinking there, ar work here) I'd much rather prefer dishing Thompson, but by all accounts, he's probably SP prospect # 5 for us at the moment behind West/Volstad, Sinkbeil, and Gaby. Some places like BA even put Tucker in front of him... But regardless, I can live without any of these guys if we're going to get a very capable and above average CF. Also, a point that I think is important, Dontrelle is going to have to be traded in the next year or so and he's going to bring in the motherload package of 3-4 prospects, 2 of which should be A+. This is going to fix any organizational holes we have, and we don't have many, so we have the liberty to 'risk' a prospect trade of SP for CF and it won't really effect our bottom line if it doesn't hit. You never want to be wrong on deals, but I'd rather fail in a trade that logically makes sense at the time than sit on our asses with insane minor league P depth and Reggie Abercrombie hanging out on the 25 man roster.
December 19, 200619 yr You know, it's funny this age absolutism you preach makes no sense when you compare two players most often mentioned as peers, Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera where Miggy is three years YOUNGER than Pujols. No says Cabrera will be Pujols in another three years, they say "they" are the two of the best in the league. Period. But I think you do hear that about Pujols and Cabs. You hear that in another year or two, Cabs could be at Pujols level. Cabs is still a big step below Pujols, but eventually I think he can get to the next echelon of greatness.
December 19, 200619 yr Upton with his five tools could have pushed Hollins to the bench three years ago to make a spot for himself if he had shown he had what it takes. He didn't and hasn't so far. Great players force themselves into lineups, good players wait their turn. So far Upton's turn hasn't come. He's not blocked by anyone, don't you think there's a reason he hasn't been handed the shortstop position outright in 2007? Yea, but you don't put 20 year olds on the bench when they can get AB in AAA. Also, Ryan Howard had to wait his turn. That's not necessarily true with what I bolded. Lou, I would make the point that the Rays have brought him up twice, 2004 and 2006. Both times he had regular playing time and accumulated 150+ ABs both times so you have to believe they were at least looking seriously at the guy. They traded away their shortstop (lugo) and handed the job to Upton but here it is (almost) 2007 and Upton isn't even being seriously considered as their shortstop of the future. That's why I called him good, not great. I'm not saying he's a bum or not fit for the major leagues or anything remotely like that. And I think that's a reasonable assessment that reasonable people can understand if not agree on. He had a chance to show he was the guy they wanted him to be and he didn't pass the test. Maybe somewhere else at another time he will, but so far he hasn't. You can only live off your potential for so long. Sooner or later you have to produce, especially when you're handed the opportunity he was given last season.
December 19, 200619 yr Author I understand exactly what you are saying dude. I wouldnt fault you for making that deal with West/Volstad even for the potential of Upton if indeed he becomes that good. My suggestion of Johnson for Rios was more that I believe in Johnson less then alot of others on here seem to. But, I cant fault them for that belief as last year he was wonderful for the team. What about Nolasco and Thompson? He is right near to Volstad/West in potential at 19 and all. A little behind but not far and is a solid lefty potential arm. I think the situation for Upton is like this right now. (this is all assumptions, so I could easily be wrong) TB values him worth more then Nolasco, closer to the Johnson group Marlins value him at worth less then the Johnson group, little more then Nolasco. I think his value is somewhere right beween the two. Nolsaco + Pettit/Garcia/Pinto/etc etc etc I couldnt fault you at all for making the trade of Nolasco + West. I would love to see Upton hit your stat line in teal and lead off for us. Upton, Hanley, Miggy, Jacobs, Willingham, Uggla, Hermida, Olivo (perhaps upgrade then) If Upton hits that line at age 24-25 range that would be a wonderful lineup specially if we can keep together our big 4, slide in Pettit/Garcia/Pinto/etc into the final spot. So Yes, I guess when push comes to shove I would give up that (sorry for round about thinking there, ar work here) I'd much rather prefer dishing Thompson, but by all accounts, he's probably SP prospect # 5 for us at the moment behind West/Volstad, Sinkbeil, and Gaby. Some places like BA even put Tucker in front of him... But regardless, I can live without any of these guys if we're going to get a very capable and above average CF. Also, a point that I think is important, Dontrelle is going to have to be traded in the next year or so and he's going to bring in the motherload package of 3-4 prospects, 2 of which should be A+. This is going to fix any organizational holes we have, and we don't have many, so we have the liberty to 'risk' a prospect trade of SP for CF and it won't really effect our bottom line if it doesn't hit. You never want to be wrong on deals, but I'd rather fail in a trade that logically makes sense at the time than sit on our asses with insane minor league P depth and Reggie Abercrombie hanging out on the 25 man roster. I completely agree with you Marlinslou. Sometimes you need to take the risk to get the reward. We risked in 2003 sending off a nice prospect in adrian gonzalez (great player now) for Urbina it worked out then. I have nightmares of Reggie dropping baseballs in Atlanta still :thumbdown Mlbtraderumors just put up their 2007 Devil Rays lineup and all. They say they need a SS (strange brignac is there and he is a monster in the future). What about offering Nolasco, Andino and Thompson/Gaby/etc. I guess in the end all we can say is in beinfest we trust (not that we have a choice otherwise :drunks ) thank you for the posts btw, always enjoy reading yours, ramps and swifts
December 19, 200619 yr You know, it's funny this age absolutism you preach makes no sense when you compare two players most often mentioned as peers, Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera where Miggy is three years YOUNGER than Pujols. No says Cabrera will be Pujols in another three years, they say "they" are the two of the best in the league. Period. But I think you do hear that about Pujols and Cabs. You hear that in another year or two, Cabs could be at Pujols level. Cabs is still a big step below Pujols, but eventually I think he can get to the next echelon of greatness. I understand your POV but the point was they are mentioned in the same sentence, and further it isn't like Cabrera is a .280 hitter looking to make it to Pujols' level, they have the same OBP and Miggy even hit for a higher average, you can slice it anyway you want, they are already peers for all intents and purposes. Maybe I'm reading/hearing different people than you are but I don't hear people saying "one day Miguel Cabrera will be as good as Albert Pujols, I hear them saying Albert and Miguel are two of the best hitters in the National League.
December 19, 200619 yr You know, it's funny this age absolutism you preach makes no sense when you compare two players most often mentioned as peers, Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera where Miggy is three years YOUNGER than Pujols. No says Cabrera will be Pujols in another three years, they say "they" are the two of the best in the league. Period. But I think you do hear that about Pujols and Cabs. You hear that in another year or two, Cabs could be at Pujols level. Cabs is still a big step below Pujols, but eventually I think he can get to the next echelon of greatness. I understand your POV but the point was they are mentioned in the same sentence, and further it isn't like Cabrera is a .280 hitter looking to make it to Pujols' level, they have the same OBP and Miggy even hit for a higher average, you can slice it anyway you want, they are already peers for all intents and purposes. Maybe I'm reading/hearing different people than you are but I don't hear people saying "one day Miguel Cabrera will be as good as Albert Pujols, I hear them saying Albert and Miguel are two of the best hitters in the National League. That's a completely different argument. When two players are of a similar skill set and close in age, it's one thing to say they are one another's equal. But to completely dismiss a player's career at the ripe old age of 22 and juxtapose him with a AAA retread who didn't get his first failed shot until 25, well, that's another story. Roger Clemens, Johan Santana. Over a decade seperates the two but they are still regarded as two of the best pitchers in baseball. Why? Because success is a much fairer measuring stick than difficulty. To call someone a success takes only numbers and a basic understanding of what is and isn't reasonable to expect a ball player to do. But to call someone a "failed...faster version of Chris Aguila" at only 22 takes something completely different.
December 19, 200619 yr You know, it's funny this age absolutism you preach makes no sense when you compare two players most often mentioned as peers, Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera where Miggy is three years YOUNGER than Pujols. No says Cabrera will be Pujols in another three years, they say "they" are the two of the best in the league. Period. But I think you do hear that about Pujols and Cabs. You hear that in another year or two, Cabs could be at Pujols level. Cabs is still a big step below Pujols, but eventually I think he can get to the next echelon of greatness. I understand your POV but the point was they are mentioned in the same sentence, and further it isn't like Cabrera is a .280 hitter looking to make it to Pujols' level, they have the same OBP and Miggy even hit for a higher average, you can slice it anyway you want, they are already peers for all intents and purposes. Maybe I'm reading/hearing different people than you are but I don't hear people saying "one day Miguel Cabrera will be as good as Albert Pujols, I hear them saying Albert and Miguel are two of the best hitters in the National League. That's a completely different argument. When two players are of a similar skill set and close in age, it's one thing to say they are one another's equal. But to completely dismiss a player's career at the ripe old age of 22 and juxtapose him with a AAA retread who didn't get his first failed shot until 25, well, that's another story. Roger Clemens, Johan Santana. Over a decade seperates the two but they are still regarded as two of the best pitchers in baseball. Why? Because success is a much fairer measuring stick than difficulty. To call someone a success takes only numbers and a basic understanding of what is and isn't reasonable to expect a ball player to do. But to call someone a "failed...faster version of Chris Aguila" at only 22 takes something completely different. Why do you continue to distort? Didn't you say pages ago you were done with this subject (and with me) but here you are back again and again and again with more out of context distortions and misrepresentations. In your world I guess there is only one POV. Too bad, you miss so much in life that way.
December 19, 200619 yr You know, it's funny this age absolutism you preach makes no sense when you compare two players most often mentioned as peers, Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera where Miggy is three years YOUNGER than Pujols. No says Cabrera will be Pujols in another three years, they say "they" are the two of the best in the league. Period. But I think you do hear that about Pujols and Cabs. You hear that in another year or two, Cabs could be at Pujols level. Cabs is still a big step below Pujols, but eventually I think he can get to the next echelon of greatness. I understand your POV but the point was they are mentioned in the same sentence, and further it isn't like Cabrera is a .280 hitter looking to make it to Pujols' level, they have the same OBP and Miggy even hit for a higher average, you can slice it anyway you want, they are already peers for all intents and purposes. Maybe I'm reading/hearing different people than you are but I don't hear people saying "one day Miguel Cabrera will be as good as Albert Pujols, I hear them saying Albert and Miguel are two of the best hitters in the National League. While you may hear them say "Cabs and Pujols are two of the best in the NL", you also hear "Pujols is far and away the best". I love Cabrera, but he really isnt on the level of Pujols right now. Pujols is the total package, while Cabs is still a work in progress.
December 19, 200619 yr Author You know, it's funny this age absolutism you preach makes no sense when you compare two players most often mentioned as peers, Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera where Miggy is three years YOUNGER than Pujols. No says Cabrera will be Pujols in another three years, they say "they" are the two of the best in the league. Period. But I think you do hear that about Pujols and Cabs. You hear that in another year or two, Cabs could be at Pujols level. Cabs is still a big step below Pujols, but eventually I think he can get to the next echelon of greatness. I understand your POV but the point was they are mentioned in the same sentence, and further it isn't like Cabrera is a .280 hitter looking to make it to Pujols' level, they have the same OBP and Miggy even hit for a higher average, you can slice it anyway you want, they are already peers for all intents and purposes. Maybe I'm reading/hearing different people than you are but I don't hear people saying "one day Miguel Cabrera will be as good as Albert Pujols, I hear them saying Albert and Miguel are two of the best hitters in the National League. While you may hear them say "Cabs and Pujols are two of the best in the NL", you also hear "Pujols is far and away the best". I love Cabrera, but he really isnt on the level of Pujols right now. Pujols is the total package, while Cabs is still a work in progress. Would it be unfair to say in the top end Miguel Cabrera will more likely turn into a Manny Ramirez then Albert Pujols Ramp?
December 19, 200619 yr Upton with his five tools could have pushed Hollins to the bench three years ago to make a spot for himself if he had shown he had what it takes. He didn't and hasn't so far. Great players force themselves into lineups, good players wait their turn. So far Upton's turn hasn't come. He's not blocked by anyone, don't you think there's a reason he hasn't been handed the shortstop position outright in 2007? Yea, but you don't put 20 year olds on the bench when they can get AB in AAA. Also, Ryan Howard had to wait his turn. That's not necessarily true with what I bolded. Lou, I would make the point that the Rays have brought him up twice, 2004 and 2006. Both times he had regular playing time and accumulated 150+ ABs both times so you have to believe they were at least looking seriously at the guy. They traded away their shortstop (lugo) and handed the job to Upton but here it is (almost) 2007 and Upton isn't even being seriously considered as their shortstop of the future. That's why I called him good, not great. I'm not saying he's a bum or not fit for the major leagues or anything remotely like that. And I think that's a reasonable assessment that reasonable people can understand if not agree on. He had a chance to show he was the guy they wanted him to be and he didn't pass the test. Maybe somewhere else at another time he will, but so far he hasn't. You can only live off your potential for so long. Sooner or later you have to produce, especially when you're handed the opportunity he was given last season. Yea and more importantly, he was 20 and 22 years old, an age very few players succeed at unless your name is Andruw Jones or Miguel Cabrera. It's great he had the opportunity to play, but it's not like "that's it! you can't play" just because he wasn't Hanley awesome right away. He's got plenty of time to develop into the player he will become. You don't sour on a guy and start relating him to Chris Aguila because of this. I don't know why you are still bringing up the SS garbage either, because Upton is not a SS. That was a failure of TB's minor league system not making him an OF earlier. They got greedy and tried to get the bat in the infield even though they knew he would never cut it. Like I said before, the DBacks picked up on this with J. Upton already and converted him to a CF. Point is, BJ is going to be a plus CF for somebody, sooner rather than later, and he fits exactly into what we're trying to do. He'll probably OPS .750-.800 for 1-3 seasons (which is still really good for CF), and then jump into the mid .800's for his prime years, plus have all that crazy speed. He also hits RHP and LHP effectively. That's a really good CF if not atrocious defensively, which I doubt he would be. He's EXACTLY what we need, and if we can get him keeping the 1-4 starters, freaking awesome.
December 19, 200619 yr I'm not going to try to go through this entire thread cause it seems to have snowballed into something else, but I will add a few things: This thread was about Alex Rios and the possibility of acquiring him. He could very well be worth one of our starting pitchers, but I'd like to have a better idea of whether or not he can consistently look as good as he did before he got hurt this year. BJ Upton isn't worth any of our starting pitchers. He may develop and be a great consistent player in the future. Right now, he's not even good enough to win a starting position on one of the worst teams in the major leagues. Every one of our SPs are at the very least Good at the major league level. Comparing him to Aguila is valid, even if not toally accurate. Sure, it took Aguila longer to be a good minor league player, but the point remains that he does post good minor league numbers, but is garbage in the majors. If you look at the numbers they are posting now, rather than trying to adjust for age, you'll get it. The fact is though that if we wanted Minor league 300 hitter in CF we could've resigned Aguila and used him. Or Eric Reed for that matter. I'm not saying he's a bust, but we aren't talking about bringing him in as a prospect and giving him time to develop for a year. We are talking about giving up more than 1 quality SP to make this guy or full-time CF. And that is a bad idea. I'd rather play Alex Sanchez than trade for Upton personally. Both will/would be defensive liabilities, both should hit better than the other CF candidates, but Sanchez is a career CF with a career ML Avg of 290, over 320 if you look at his last 2 seasons in the bigs (04 & 05). And while he may not be the CF of the future at age 30, we also already have him for cheap, and don't need to give up any arms for him. Point is, BJ is going to be a plus CF for somebody, sooner rather than later, and he fits exactly into what we're trying to do. He'll probably OPS .750-.800 for 1-3 seasons (which is still really good for CF). Unlikely, since TB seems to like him on the bench so much that they want too much for him. As far the OPS predictions, just remember Hermida and his ROY season that never was.
December 19, 200619 yr BJ Upton isn't worth any of our starting pitchers. He may develop and be a great consistent player in the future. Right now, he's not even good enough to win a starting position on one of the worst teams in the major leagues. Every one of our SPs are at the very least Good at the major league level. Comparing him to Aguila is valid, even if not toally accurate. Sure, it took Aguila longer to be a good minor league player, but the point remains that he does post good minor league numbers, but is garbage in the majors. If you look at the numbers they are posting now, rather than trying to adjust for age, you'll get it. The fact is though that if we wanted Minor league 300 hitter in CF we could've resigned Aguila and used him. Or Eric Reed for that matter. I'm not saying he's a bust, but we aren't talking about bringing him in as a prospect and giving him time to develop for a year. We are talking about giving up more than 1 quality SP to make this guy or full-time CF. And that is a bad idea. But you have to look at age. You can't just ignore that factor. That's huge! Although not extreme, I feel like Upton's situation is similar to Josh Willingham's was. Everyone knew he was going to hit, but for one reason or another, we kept moving Willingham to positions where he was blocked by very good players(Id rather not get started on how we totally blew it with Josh, as he should be on his 3rd or 4th year, not his second).(now that I think about it, maybe Willingham's situation isnt that similar, but I felt like venting anyway) With the talent level of our pitchers(as a whole), and the awesome talent that is BJ Upton, I would have no problem giving them Josh Johnson or Ricky Nolasco(+any minor league arm). He's that good of a prospect.
December 19, 200619 yr I'm not going to try to go through this entire thread cause it seems to have snowballed into something else, but I will add a few things: This thread was about Alex Rios and the possibility of acquiring him. He could very well be worth one of our starting pitchers, but I'd like to have a better idea of whether or not he can consistently look as good as he did before he got hurt this year. BJ Upton isn't worth any of our starting pitchers. He may develop and be a great consistent player in the future. Right now, he's not even good enough to win a starting position on one of the worst teams in the major leagues. Every one of our SPs are at the very least Good at the major league level. Comparing him to Aguila is valid, even if not toally accurate. Sure, it took Aguila longer to be a good minor league player, but the point remains that he does post good minor league numbers, but is garbage in the majors. If you look at the numbers they are posting now, rather than trying to adjust for age, you'll get it. The fact is though that if we wanted Minor league 300 hitter in CF we could've resigned Aguila and used him. Or Eric Reed for that matter. I'm not saying he's a bust, but we aren't talking about bringing him in as a prospect and giving him time to develop for a year. We are talking about giving up more than 1 quality SP to make this guy or full-time CF. And that is a bad idea. I'd rather play Alex Sanchez than trade for Upton personally. Both will/would be defensive liabilities, both should hit better than the other CF candidates, but Sanchez is a career CF with a career ML Avg of 290, over 320 if you look at his last 2 seasons in the bigs (04 & 05). And while he may not be the CF of the future at age 30, we also already have him for cheap, and don't need to give up any arms for him. Rios should be fine. And he's worth the risk with our pitching depth longterm. BJ Upton is 22 years old and cannot be compared to a career minor leaguer. Holy jesus. Aguila was 26/27 and flopping in the bigs, Upton was doing it at 20 and 22 years old. This is an astronomical 5 year difference in growth! Let alone, BJ Upton was a top 10 prospect in baseball for 3 years, would still be top 10-15 if he were eligible. And we're not talking about giving up more than 1 quality SP, we're talking about giving Nolasco and a prospect who may turn into a quality SP, and which we have at least 5 with # 3 SP potential in A/AA within 2 years. I'd want a MLB resume for JJ unlike Ramp, but you have to respect BJ for who he is. The guy is going to be a very good player. Also, Upton is blocked by Carl Crawford, Rocco Baldelli, and Delmon Young. Or as I like to call it, the best young outfield in baseball. This isn't a can't win a spot on the worst team issue. He's not an infielder. He can't play SS, and 3B is a toss up too. He will be their primary bench player playing all over the OF, a little 3B, maybe a little 1B, and DH some. He's not going to sit on the bench for them, he's going to be very active. Also, they are the worst team because they have Scott Kazmir and 11 people in baseball uniforms that occasionally get some outs. It's not because of the young hitters. Alex Sanchez is not a good idea, unless it's for the 5th OF spot. This team needs to make a move for a CF.
December 19, 200619 yr Also, a point that I think is important, Dontrelle is going to have to be traded in the next year or so and he's going to bring in the motherload package of 3-4 prospects, 2 of which should be A+. This is going to fix any organizational holes we have, and we don't have many, so we have the liberty to 'risk' a prospect trade of SP for CF and it won't really effect our bottom line if it doesn't hit. You never want to be wrong on deals, but I'd rather fail in a trade that logically makes sense at the time than sit on our asses with insane minor league P depth and Reggie Abercrombie hanging out on the 25 man roster. That is the key right there, MarlinsLou. At this point I am pretty sure Beinfest's plan is to hold out till after the stadium deal is inked and then trade Dontrelle for our centerfielder and/or catcher of the future, probably during the 2007 offseason. Or possibly a third baseman as there is a good chance Miguel will be on his way out as well (though I am less certain of this). If the Marlins plan is to trade Dontrelle sometime within the next year (and I believe it is) it makes all the sense in the world to hold onto Johnson, Olsen and Sanchez at this point. If we can get a deal done for the centerfielder we need for Nolasco plus prospects, fine. But otherwise we have to keep playing the waiting game until Dontrelle brings us what we need.
December 19, 200619 yr Why would the Mets and Marlins would want two defensive liabilities, Cantu at second base or Upton in centerfield is beyond me and for the price of a successful rookie starting major league pitcher PLUS pitching prospects is beyond me. Cantu and Upton both share "the most likely to be squeezed out of a job" spotlight this upcoming season in Tampa, which might be a good thing for the Rays. Possibly Cantu can find a job at first base where his defensive shortcomings can be held to a minimum, but Upton who failed as a shortstop (as referenced above) to make even routine plays holds little promise in the outfield other than blazing speed, and with a slumping bat at both the minor league and major league levels. He's a faster version of Chris Aguila with less defense. You look at Chris Aguila in the minors and you go OMG this guy is going to tear up the major leagues but he just never is quite able to prove himself. Ditto Upton. Cantu was hurt last season, maybe he'll come back offensively but in the NL I don't think he can excel defensively at 2B which is what the Mets would want. Thankfully neither Minaya nor Beinfest drank the kool-aid. Are you honestly comparing Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? I love how you instantly sour on a player, Milledge being a second example, after an initial stint in the majors at 21/22 years old is relatively unsuccessful. Sure, no problem with Cantu having to move away from 2B eventually, but you are out of your mind if you think BJ Upton isn't a player. He needs a scenery change as badly as any player in baseball. There are so many examples I can use here, as in Gary Sheffield holding little promise as an OF after being chased from SS and then 3B, and Hanley slumping in the minors and then magically turning into the ROY, but whatever. BJ is going to be really good and would fill a glaring hole for the Marlins in the short and long term. If we can acquire him for Nolasco, and any pitcher in our farm system, ANY, that's a win for us. ... Chris Aguila. Honestly? You pimped out Gathright like he was a hall of famer waiting to happen...wanting to even trade JJ or Olsen for a player that is garbage in the bigs. Everyone has their bad opinions, you yourself are not immune.
December 19, 200619 yr Please tell me you didnt just compare Chris Aguila to BJ Upton? Please tell me that. Yes I did. Got a problem with that? Both showed tremendous promise in the minor leagues and both were unable to translate that success to the major league level. I realize you have some kind of fan crush on Upton but putting the Marlins aside for a minute, do you see a whole flock or even one other team beating a path to the Rays' door to acquire him? Simply, the answer is no. There's a reason. And Eddie, I agree, it's absurd (Nolasco not being enough to get Upton) but I'm not sure the teams are still talking. With the closer thing still up in the air and Ricky being a logical candidate to take up at least part of the role, trading him right now (at least forme) makes little sense. that's crazy. aguila never had tremendous promise...not even close.
December 19, 200619 yr Also, a point that I think is important, Dontrelle is going to have to be traded in the next year or so and he's going to bring in the motherload package of 3-4 prospects, 2 of which should be A+. This is going to fix any organizational holes we have, and we don't have many, so we have the liberty to 'risk' a prospect trade of SP for CF and it won't really effect our bottom line if it doesn't hit. You never want to be wrong on deals, but I'd rather fail in a trade that logically makes sense at the time than sit on our asses with insane minor league P depth and Reggie Abercrombie hanging out on the 25 man roster. That is the key right there, MarlinsLou. At this point I am pretty sure Beinfest's plan is to hold out till after the stadium deal is inked and then trade Dontrelle for our centerfielder and/or catcher of the future, probably during the 2007 offseason. Or possibly a third baseman as there is a good chance Miguel will be on his way out as well (though I am less certain of this). If the Marlins plan is to trade Dontrelle sometime within the next year (and I believe it is) it makes all the sense in the world to hold onto Johnson, Olsen and Sanchez at this point. If we can get a deal done for the centerfielder we need for Nolasco plus prospects, fine. But otherwise we have to keep playing the waiting game until Dontrelle brings us what we need. If we get a stadium deal, then trade Dontrelle and Miggy, I'm done with this franchise.
December 19, 200619 yr I'm not going to try to go through this entire thread cause it seems to have snowballed into something else, but I will add a few things: This thread was about Alex Rios and the possibility of acquiring him. He could very well be worth one of our starting pitchers, but I'd like to have a better idea of whether or not he can consistently look as good as he did before he got hurt this year. BJ Upton isn't worth any of our starting pitchers. He may develop and be a great consistent player in the future. Right now, he's not even good enough to win a starting position on one of the worst teams in the major leagues. Every one of our SPs are at the very least Good at the major league level. Comparing him to Aguila is valid, even if not toally accurate. Sure, it took Aguila longer to be a good minor league player, but the point remains that he does post good minor league numbers, but is garbage in the majors. If you look at the numbers they are posting now, rather than trying to adjust for age, you'll get it. The fact is though that if we wanted Minor league 300 hitter in CF we could've resigned Aguila and used him. Or Eric Reed for that matter. I'm not saying he's a bust, but we aren't talking about bringing him in as a prospect and giving him time to develop for a year. We are talking about giving up more than 1 quality SP to make this guy or full-time CF. And that is a bad idea. I'd rather play Alex Sanchez than trade for Upton personally. Both will/would be defensive liabilities, both should hit better than the other CF candidates, but Sanchez is a career CF with a career ML Avg of 290, over 320 if you look at his last 2 seasons in the bigs (04 & 05). And while he may not be the CF of the future at age 30, we also already have him for cheap, and don't need to give up any arms for him. Rios should be fine. And he's worth the risk with our pitching depth longterm. BJ Upton is 22 years old and cannot be compared to a career minor leaguer. Holy jesus. Aguila was 26/27 and flopping in the bigs, Upton was doing it at 20 and 22 years old. This is an astronomical 5 year difference in growth! Let alone, BJ Upton was a top 10 prospect in baseball for 3 years, would still be top 10-15 if he were eligible. And we're not talking about giving up more than 1 quality SP, we're talking about giving Nolasco and a prospect who may turn into a quality SP, and which we have at least 5 with # 3 SP potential in A/AA within 2 years. I'd want a MLB resume for JJ unlike Ramp, but you have to respect BJ for who he is. The guy is going to be a very good player. Also, Upton is blocked by Carl Crawford, Rocco Baldelli, and Delmon Young. Or as I like to call it, the best young outfield in baseball. This isn't a can't win a spot on the worst team issue. He's not an infielder. He can't play SS, and 3B is a toss up too. He will be their primary bench player playing all over the OF, a little 3B, maybe a little 1B, and DH some. He's not going to sit on the bench for them, he's going to be very active. Also, they are the worst team because they have Scott Kazmir and 11 people in baseball uniforms that occasionally get some outs. It's not because of the young hitters. Alex Sanchez is not a good idea, unless it's for the 5th OF spot. This team needs to make a move for a CF. Don't forget Gomes is there as well
December 19, 200619 yr Also, a point that I think is important, Dontrelle is going to have to be traded in the next year or so and he's going to bring in the motherload package of 3-4 prospects, 2 of which should be A+. This is going to fix any organizational holes we have, and we don't have many, so we have the liberty to 'risk' a prospect trade of SP for CF and it won't really effect our bottom line if it doesn't hit. You never want to be wrong on deals, but I'd rather fail in a trade that logically makes sense at the time than sit on our asses with insane minor league P depth and Reggie Abercrombie hanging out on the 25 man roster. That is the key right there, MarlinsLou. At this point I am pretty sure Beinfest's plan is to hold out till after the stadium deal is inked and then trade Dontrelle for our centerfielder and/or catcher of the future, probably during the 2007 offseason. Or possibly a third baseman as there is a good chance Miguel will be on his way out as well (though I am less certain of this). If the Marlins plan is to trade Dontrelle sometime within the next year (and I believe it is) it makes all the sense in the world to hold onto Johnson, Olsen and Sanchez at this point. If we can get a deal done for the centerfielder we need for Nolasco plus prospects, fine. But otherwise we have to keep playing the waiting game until Dontrelle brings us what we need. Planning on moving Dontrelle in the future has relatively no effect on trading any of the other current rotation starters for a CF. It's all about acquiring talent. I'd rather create skepticism with J. Garcia or Petit taking the 5th rotation spot in 2007 versus giving CF to the holy trinity - Alex Sanchez, Eric Reed, and Reggie Abercrombie, or some other stopgap. By 2008 (or mid 08) someone, if not all, of the Gaby, Volstad, West, class will be ready for a rotation spot, and secondly, let's say we did a JJ/Rios, or Nolasco and West for Upton, or whatever for a CF, it's not a big deal in targeting a young C and SP instead of a young CF and C with Dontrelle if the plan is to move him. The lineup would be ferocious with Rios or Rocco or Upton, etc, and the whole lineup would all be under control until 2010 (except Cabrera who they can't really ever trade unless they are retarded, and Olivo who is whatever). We have so much pitching depth, we'll survive anyway you look at it. I don't need to completely scenario it out, but trust me when I say I could field a very competitive team in 2007 and 2008, trading JJ or Nolasco + top prospects this offseason for a CF, and Dontrelle the next offseason for whatever it is we need - my guess would be a catcher and additional pitching in any form. Oakland's been doing it for years this way. You can give up a lot of talent and still be fine if you acquire needs that you keep for awhile and keep a strong farm system, which we currently have pitching wise. I'm not saying your idea of waiting isn't the safer and/or smarter way to go and holds no merit, but I'd rather take the chance the young pitchers will respond a second year in a row then keeping everyone and hope we contend with a .650 OPSing platoon in CF. A CF who can mash a bit could be the last piece to this team, even with dishing out a good young pitcher. Just a difference in philosophy I guess. It's not that I think JJ or anyone is going to fall apart and we need to take advantage of their value right now. I just believe in the pitching depth, especially come 08/09 when are going to be overwhelmed with power arms.
December 20, 200619 yr But you have to look at age. You can't just ignore that factor. That's huge! Although not extreme, I feel like Upton's situation is similar to Josh Willingham's was. Everyone knew he was going to hit, but for one reason or another, we kept moving Willingham to positions where he was blocked by very good players(Id rather not get started on how we totally blew it with Josh, as he should be on his 3rd or 4th year, not his second).(now that I think about it, maybe Willingham's situation isnt that similar, but I felt like venting anyway) With the talent level of our pitchers(as a whole), and the awesome talent that is BJ Upton, I would have no problem giving them Josh Johnson or Ricky Nolasco(+any minor league arm). He's that good of a prospect. In terms of a single year's performance, age doesn't make a difference, and I can ignore it. In a vaccuum, I don't care if the guy batting 300 is 30 or the guy batting 200 is 20. I will play the guy hitting 300. In terms of signing to a long term contract, that may be a different story. Nolasco & JJ especially have already shown a good bit at the ML level, which BJ Upton has not. Besides that, he doesn't have a position to play in Tampa. No matter what they ask for, Upton isn't worth any of our 5 SPs, not to us or them, at least not yet.
December 20, 200619 yr Author So... has Rios to Marlins been said in any publication? Nope, the fish arent interested it seems at all.
December 20, 200619 yr Swift, that's not the bet, but why am I not surprised you are already trying to backtrack on your words? Your comparison was to Hanley Ramirez. Stand by that or stop being insulting just to be insulting. Here's a more than a fair bet. Ramirez appeared in 158 games and had 633 ABs. Toqualify for this bet because Upton may not hit first all he has to do is have 500 ABs and post equivalent or better offensive numbers than Hanley and sure, I'll up the bet to a month, no problemo here. I'll go further.If he even gets 500ABs I'll not post for a week, regardless of how well he does, I'd like to see you do the same if he doesn't. I mean surely this season has to be the season he plays somewhere regularly (at the MLB level). As for Aguila, I've made my analogy absolutely clear. Eddie A. just posted (above) and while he understands my analogy and what it was based on he disagrees in a gentlemanly way. Why can't you do that? Why is insulting and demeaning comments and lecturing someone on why their opinion is not only wrong but you're happy to name-call them in the process your modus operandi? So are you up for the bet? You game? Thats the nature of fans on this board. I find it histerical how much people argue over a team we all love. The level of class on this board really hits rock bottom at points. It's a shame, it's a shame b/c its my favorite message board. Part of the reason I avoid speaking my opinion is b/c people do not understand the concept of an opinion.
December 22, 200619 yr Author http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/hotstove06/c...&id=2704742 an espn article on the young drays players mentions us fish I would be greatful if anyone can put the insider crasnick piece on here too
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.