December 18, 200619 yr If the person that wrote the article thinks the Mets have a match Heilman, why doesn't he think that the Marlins would be able to pull it off with Nolasco? Am I wrong in thinking that Nolasco has more value than the overhyped Heilman? Or was that just another NY favoring article? What's next? Is Alex Rios going to be traded straight up for the legendary Lastings Millege?
December 18, 200619 yr I'm constantly amazed that people put forward Heilman for trades. The guy is so bad a SP that the SP-starved Mets, who send out guys ERAs over 5 and 6 refuse to let him start for them. No one WANTS Heilman. They might take him as trade filler, but nobody is actively trying to get him on their squad.
December 18, 200619 yr If the person that wrote the article thinks the Mets have a match Heilman, why doesn't he think that the Marlins would be able to pull it off with Nolasco? Am I wrong in thinking that Nolasco has more value than the overhyped Heilman? Or was that just another NY favoring article? What's next? Is Alex Rios going to be traded straight up for the legendary Lastings Millege? I was thinking the same thing. Between Heilman and Nolasco, Nolasco is the better pitcher. The Blue Jays are looking for a starter and Heilman hasnt looked good in the chances hes been given to start. If the Mets offer Heilman and Milledge who could the Marlins throw in with Nolasco? I think Andino and another pitcher might get it done because the Jays dont really need OF help their main needs are starting pitching and SS.
December 18, 200619 yr Heilman hasnt put it together yet but that guy has the ability and the talent to do it and be succesful for a LONG time. some just need to stop being so biased about the marlins players
December 18, 200619 yr For anyone hating on Heilman, he looked pretty damn good against the 2005 Marlins and Josh Beckett, or did you all forget that one hitter that should have been a no hitter? As for not starting Heilman, Willy Randolph said that in season it was not an option because he didn't want to disrupt the Mets incredibly strong bullpen. Not that the point doesn't have some merit, but the Mets looked at it as robbing Peter to pay Paul (Heilman once every fifth day or Heilman in the 8th). Personally, I think Nolasco and Heilman are similar pitchers and Heilman is just being used correctly (my feeling is that Nolasco would be a +++ reliever).
December 18, 200619 yr I guess I'm focusing too much on the lackluster years Burnett (okay, not great) and Beckett had upon moving to the American League, but I wonder if National League pitchers (who *it is contemplated may* switch leagues *in a trade*) may have less trade value these days compared to their American league counterparts? That's a question, only slightly rhetoric, I have no idea the answer. My assumption is, all things being equal,and AL GM would pick the AL pitcher first, but I have zero to base that on other than a gut feeling.
December 18, 200619 yr Author Heilman hasnt put it together yet but that guy has the ability and the talent to do it and be succesful for a LONG time. some just need to stop being so biased about the marlins players he is a 2 pitches pitcher that even the pitching starved mets wont start I guess I'm focusing too much on the lackluster years Burnett (okay, not great) and Beckett had upon moving to the American League, but I wonder if National League pitchers (who switch leagues) may have less trade value these days compared to their American league counterparts? That's a question, only slightly rhetoric, I have no idea the answer. My assumption is, all things being equal,and AL GM would pick the AL pitcher first, but I have zero to base that on other than a gut feeling. I think it is based on the pitcher. But the NL East did score more runs last year then AL East. And the AL East uses a DH and we dont.
December 18, 200619 yr I'm constantly amazed that people put forward Heilman for trades. The guy is so bad a SP that the SP-starved Mets, who send out guys ERAs over 5 and 6 refuse to let him start for them. No one WANTS Heilman. They might take him as trade filler, but nobody is actively trying to get him on their squad. Or it could be the Mets just didnt want to remove him from that 8th inning role Heilman is finally coming into his own, and he is probably worth more than Nolasco right now I cant believe I just defended a Met
December 18, 200619 yr I'm still confused about some of this concept. Can someone explain to me about when did a setup/middle reliever who has only 1 day of glory as a starter become more valuable as far as worth than a starting pitcher who won 10 games in his rookie year. If he was a closer I could see it, but Heilman is a setup/middle reliever. Has the game disintergrated all of the sudden to this. Back to the story at hand: Alex Rios with the Marlins would be great. Picture this: Hanley Alex Rios Uggla Miggy Willy Jacobs Hermida Olivo/or whoever we pick up :thumbup
December 18, 200619 yr I'm still confused about some of this concept. Can someone explain to me about when did a setup/middle reliever who has only 1 day of glory as a starter become more valuable as far as worth than a starting pitcher who won 10 games in his rookie year. If he was a closer I could see it, but Heilman is a setup/middle reliever. Has the game disintergrated all of the sudden to this. Back to the story at hand: Alex Rios with the Marlins would be great. Picture this: Hanley Alex Rios Uggla Miggy Willy Jacobs Hermida Olivo/or whoever we pick up :thumbup Because As a Middle Relief you can pitch in alot more games than as a starter. Oh and Nolasco did put up a 4.8 era this season so its not like he was dominant either.
December 18, 200619 yr well, with all this comparison, hopefully I can end it here. Is there anyone that is a Marlins fan (not a Mets fan) that would trade Nolasco straight up for Heilman? Or, since the notion is that Heilman is worth more, would anyone trade Nolasco and another player or 2 for Heilman? I definitely wouldn't. :blink:
December 18, 200619 yr well, with all this comparison, hopefully I can end it here. Is there anyone that is a Marlins fan (not a Mets fan) that would trade Nolasco straight up for Heilman? Or, since the notion is that Heilman is worth more, would anyone trade Nolasco and another player or 2 for Heilman? I definitely wouldn't. :blink: I wouldn't either. In fact I am certain that Minaya would love to be offered that chance
December 18, 200619 yr I don't think everyone is grasping the fact that Alex Rios is an absolute badass. Hard to believe a top notch defensive RF with speed couldn't play CF. Throw in the fact that he has 3-4 cheap years makes him a home run. In other words he is the offensive equivalent of JJ,Olsen, or Anibel. And if you want to get a player of his caliber you have to trade a similarly valued pitcher. So I believe your either in one of two camps. #1- Either you believe pitching is too important to ever trade and you'd rather the Marlins try to get a CF on the cheap, if such a thing even exists anymore or #2 You believe that a great young offensive player is as valuable as a great young SP and you make the trade. Give me three top SP's and a balanced offense. I would hate to see JJ go. But I don't mind trading ANYONE if it makes our team better. And adding Alex Rios at the expense of one of our big 3 makes us better.
December 18, 200619 yr I"m in camp #3... where I know Alexis Rios is a complete stud, would make our offense/defense look amazing and I probably wouldnt complain if we traded JJ for him.. but I also really think we've assembled something special in our rotation 1 through 5 and I don't know if I'd feel comfortable losing one of Olsen, JJ, Anibal. I'm really on the fence of this whole CF thing. This probably isn't the right thread but I would like to give Nolasco some props, as he seems like the one who gets casted aside. While I agree he doesnt have the ceiling of the other 3, I think this kid still can be a helluva pitcher. While his stats werent as good as the other guys, lets not forget how impressive he looked at times when he was locating that fastball.
December 18, 200619 yr There's lots of other options besides the three mentioned and that's why Admin Beinfest is GM. I would say though, at least for me, I'm not willing to make the assumption that because Rios can play RF in the Sky Dome he can play center in Dolphin Stadium. He very well may be able to but there's no evidence, at least presented that indicates he can. BTW he is zero years years away from arbitration. If you think he has three or four years of cheap time ahead of him, look again. He goes to arbitration this winter, and if he's as good as some here say, he can expect many a handsome payday starting with the 2007 season. One has to wonder what he's worth in light of some of the signings this off-season including the deal his teammate Vernon Wells just received. Even if he gets half of Miguel Cabrera you're looking at $2-3 million next season and more and more and more in subsequent years. So he isn't going to be cheap. [source: Blue Jays | Team will have seven players eligible for salary arbitration Mon, 30 Oct 2006 Allan Ryan, of the Toronto Star, reports Toronto Blue Jays outfielders Reed Johnson and Alex Rios, pitchers Jason Frasor and Scott Downs, infielders Lyle Overbay and John McDonald and catcher Jason Phillips will all be eligible for salary arbitration this offseason. ] The other issue is how you value your own talent. Good centerfielders are hard to find to be sure but rookie starting pitchers with winning seasons and more than ten wins are the absolute gold standard for player value. If Olsen, Johnson, Sanchez and Nolasco pitched for another team I'd say the same thing, this isn't about being a homer. I would argue (it's a figure of speech, I'm not really arguing, I'm giving my opinion) there is no comparison value-wise between our three best rookie pitchers and Alex Rios. His price point is too high while theirs are low, low, low. The baseball world knows what these three pitchers can do but we don't know if Rios can play theposition or if last season was the beginning of a hall of fame-type career or the best we'll ever see from him. I am 100% NOT in the camp that says you never trade pitching because next season I'm looking forward to one of the big three bringing spectacular talent when one of them is traded. This is just not the time. One more season and with a bit of luck we'll have at least two and maybe three more (currently minor league) starters who have earned a spot in the rotation, or at least an honest chance to fight for one. It would be like selling immature sauvignon grapes to Welch's to make juicepaks for kiddies when next fall you can sell them to Cristal for champagne. I'd also join Iowa in saying jettisoning Nolasco at this point, without an heir-apparent chomping at the bit to take his place is short-sighted. If he never does more than be a 3, 4 or even fifth starter but has winning seasons every years, that's not a guy I would trade away that quickly. Besides, I don't think he fits the Blue Jays mold. So, I guess I'll pass on Rios as too expensive (right now without a stadium deal) and at the cost of one of our starters. I suggested before and I'll say again, if we can package two or three quality prospects to a team which can give Toronto what they need and we wind up with Rios, that might be another story, but I suspect when he get's through arbitration this winter he'll be a multi-million dollar man and at least temporarily, too rich for our blood.
December 18, 200619 yr Author May I simply suggest the Pettit or Garcia could most likely easily fill the role of Ricky Nolasco.
December 18, 200619 yr May I simply suggest the Pettit or Garcia could most likely easily fill the role of Ricky Nolasco. There's zero evidence Petit can do it in fact most of the evidence would say he's a year away at best and Garcia, who I love and was impressed like crazy by, even when he was getting knocked around in September, has only won * 14 games and six wins* at the AA level and, at least for me, may need three months or so on the minors (at the minimum) to be ready to start every fifth day in the show, but if he came in and won the job in spring training, I'd be happy for him that he did. * edit
December 18, 200619 yr There's lots of other options besides the three mentioned and that's why Admin Beinfest is GM. I would say though, at least for me, I'm not willing to make the assumption that because Rios can play RF in the Sky Dome he can play center in Dolphin Stadium. He very well may be able to but there's no evidence, at least presented that indicates he can. BTW he is zero years years away from arbitration. If you think he has three or four years of cheap time ahead of him, look again. He goes to arbitration this winter, and if he's as good as some here say, he can expect many a handsome payday starting with the 2007 season. One has to wonder what he's worth in light of some of the signings this off-season including the deal his teammate Vernon Wells just received. Even if he gets half of Miguel Cabrera you're looking at $2-3 million next season and more and more and more in subsequent years. So he isn't going to be cheap. [source: Blue Jays | Team will have seven players eligible for salary arbitration Mon, 30 Oct 2006 Allan Ryan, of the Toronto Star, reports Toronto Blue Jays outfielders Reed Johnson and Alex Rios, pitchers Jason Frasor and Scott Downs, infielders Lyle Overbay and John McDonald and catcher Jason Phillips will all be eligible for salary arbitration this offseason. ] The other issue is how you value your own talent. Good centerfielders are hard to find to be sure but rookie starting pitchers with winning seasons and more than ten wins are the absolute gold standard for player value. If Olsen, Johnson, Sanchez and Nolasco pitched for another team I'd say the same thing, this isn't about being a homer. I would argue (it's a figure of speech, I'm not really arguing, I'm giving my opinion) there is no comparison value-wise between our three best rookie pitchers and Alex Rios. His price point is too high while theirs are low, low, low. The baseball world knows what these three pitchers can do but we don't know if Rios can play theposition or if last season was the beginning of a hall of fame-type career or the best we'll ever see from him. I am 100% NOT in the camp that says you never trade pitching because next season I'm looking forward to one of the big three bringing spectacular talent when one of them is traded. This is just not the time. One more season and with a bit of luck we'll have at least two and maybe three more (currently minor league) starters who have earned a spot in the rotation, or at least an honest chance to fight for one. It would be like selling immature sauvignon grapes to Welch's to make juicepaks for kiddies when next fall you can sell them to Cristal for champagne. I'd also join Iowa in saying jettisoning Nolasco at this point, without an heir-apparent chomping at the bit to take his place is short-sighted. If he never does more than be a 3, 4 or even fifth starter but has winning seasons every years, that's not a guy I would trade away that quickly. Besides, I don't think he fits the Blue Jays mold. So, I guess I'll pass on Rios as too expensive (right now without a stadium deal) and at the cost of one of our starters. I suggested before and I'll say again, if we can package two or three quality prospects to a team which can give Toronto what they need and we wind up with Rios, that might be another story, but I suspect when he get's through arbitration this winter he'll be a multi-million dollar man and at least temporarily, too rich for our blood. Rios has half a good season on his resume and won't be incredibly expensive in arbitration for a few seasons. If he keeps up a low/mid .800 OPS performance, I'd expect pay raises in the veins of 2-4-7-10 over the next 4 years of his arbitration. Give or take $2-3 over the life of those years if he really starts hammering baseballs or inflation takes another ridiculous jump. Short term, he would easily fit into the 2007 $25 payroll given how they are skimping on a bullpen. Rocco's contract is 3/$11, or 5/$26 with the options AND performance escalators which could raise the value, and we like him. Rios is 15-20% more expensive then that through arbitration, and we wouldn't be guaranteed the 5th year (ignoring if the Marlins would actually buyout a player's arbitration and save some money). Basically, not a big deal. He's still undervalued. We can afford him if Beinfest thinks he is a building block player. And he certainly compliments Cabrera, Hanley, and Hermida quite well to me. The issue is, do you think he is worth X pitcher or pitchers. This guy isn't like say, Eric Byrnes, where we couldn't afford his arbitration case and/or impending FA.
December 18, 200619 yr Author May I simply suggest the Pettit or Garcia could most likely easily fill the role of Ricky Nolasco. There's zero evidence Petit can do it in fact most of the evidence would say he's a year away at best and Garcia, who I love and was impressed like crazy by, even when he was getting knocked around in September, has only won six games at the AA level and, at least for me, may need three months or so on the minors (at the minimum) to be ready to start every fifth day in the show, but if he came in and won the job in spring training, I'd be happy for him that he did. To play devils advocate was there evidence that Johnson, Sanchez, Nolasco could pitch really? Johnson had 1 start and that was it for all of them. But worst to worst they would have mitre for a number 5
December 18, 200619 yr Author Qwhy don't the marlins show interest in trade a for alex rios the blue jays need young pitching and alex is a perfect fit for centerfield john, miami, fl 12/18/06 AWell, apparently the Marlins aren't sure he is a perfect fit. Centerfield at Dolphin Stadium is so huge the team really needs a speedster , which is why it's looking at people like Alex Sanchez and still considering Eric Reed and Reggie Abercrombie. Kevin Baxter 12/18/06 http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/sport...st&pageNo=1 according to baxter seems we dont want him. Weird
December 19, 200619 yr But worst to worst they would have mitre for a number 5 Which is the most absolute worst scenario possible.
December 19, 200619 yr So Spike, I'm really curious, what are your thoughts on Mitre? Because I just don't think that you've expressed it enough, in the 285758375 threads you've mentioned him in...
December 19, 200619 yr Until one of our better prospects was ready to take the step up... yep. He's better in the rotation than in the pen, that's for sure.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.