I'm just a little worried about the Marlins right now. The reason they were winning games last season was because of the offense and it won't be as good in 2009 as it was in 2008. I don't think the Marlins can afford to trade Uggla right now. I'm not a believer in AA stats and projecting that guys like Coghlan could step in and produce anywhere near the level of Uggla. AA pitchers are nowhere near the quality of major league pitchers and that is a fact. You can mark Uggla down for 100 runs scored, 30 homers and 90 RBIs for 2009 but what kind of numbers would Coghlan, Bonifacio or Andino put up? At some point the Marlins have to quit being cheap and Uggla is without a doubt the 2nd best position player on the Marlins right now and that's not debateable. I really just don't see the upside of trading him because I'm not so certain the Marlins would get quite the haul that a lot of you do.
You sure about that? Because I disagree completely. Baseball is a team sport.
C - .251/.323/.340 (.664), and now we have a full year of Baker and whoever replacing Treanor/Rabelo. This could go up 100 OPS points easily. That is an enormous enormous improvement.
1B - .253/.304/.506 (.811). This is completely empty with that OBP, and when Gaby and friends make this a .280/.340/.450 line, the effects of Jacobs will be understood. Not losing anything here. This might be an upgrade even with a lower expected team OPS at the position because of the huge OBP upgrade.
2B - .259/.351/.497 (.848). This is probably going down a little but, not much but I'd say 20-30 OPS points. This is a relative wash with Uggla. Agree completely this is a likely 100 OPS drop without him which is why I want to keep him around for 2009, but this isn't a big deal.
SS - .303/.396/.530 (.926). He'll do it again.
3B - .270/.324/.438 (.761). Yea this is pretty low. You can thank Helm's 128 AB with a lower than .600 OPS here. This is easily going up as a combination of Cantu, McDallas mashing only righties, and Helms mashing only lefties which he can hit, is going to happen. I pray Bonifacio does not play much here, but I'm pretty confident he won't as we have 4 corner IF options.
LF - .270/.366/.467 (.833). Now we have a problem, and I'm going to do Ross here and not Hermida for simplicity. Willingham and Gonzalez had very solid years in LF for us, and it's going to be tough for Ross to replicate this by himself, especially with no 4th OF. This is probably going down 30-50 OPS points unless Ross keeps up the offense versus right handers. I really hope we bring in a left handed LF guy to help him out here.
CF - .262/.318/.432 (.750). I'm very confident, at a minimum, Maybin can hit this.
RF - .243/.311/.407 (.718). We don't need to get into the Hermida debate, but regardless of who plays here next year, this is going to go up. The team is not going to allow this to happen in right field again.
So basically, (the number that follows are realistic OPS bumps or decreases in production)
Increases - Catcher (75), Third Base (50), Right Field (50)
Wash - First Base, Shortstop, Center Field
Decreases - Second Base (30), Left Field (50)
This is pretty damn fair, and it is really undercutting the impact Baker, Hermida, and Ross can each make because Baker could easily hit more than a mid 700 OPS, and the corner outfielders could easily both be over an .800 OPS, and not in the .775 range which I'm presenting above just for arguments sake. The team is better offensively right now than the 2008 season simply because we're going to get a lot more out of those three positions. It's going to take a significant injury to Hanley, Uggla, or an outfielder to not improve here. Our kids can play. You shouldn't be worried about McPherson, Maybin, Sanchez, and Baker. They don't have to do much to equal or better last year's performance. The real key to the whole offense is Hermida. If he shows up like 2007, the offense is going to be phenomenal and we're going to score tons of more runs. If he is the next Teahen, we'll still be as good or better. That's a nice gamble to have. (And longterm, we could be developing four .850 OPS monster players with Stanton, Morrison, Dominguez, and Skipworth, and other average MLB bats from Coghlan, Cousins, Raynor, Petersen, Smolinski, and Bonifacio. The offense isn't going anywhere anytime soon).
Also, let's hypothetically take Uggla out.
Way up - Catcher (75), Third Base (50), Right Field (50)
Wash - First Base, Shortstop, Center Field
Decreases - Second Base (100), Left Field (50)
See how the offense is still better than 2008 (granted this is a crude analysis, but you get the idea), and again, if Baker, Hermida, and Ross hit higher than the .750-.775, the team takes off. This isn't a big deal for the Marlins. We should keep Dan for 2009 to give Coghlan and Bonifacio another year to develop, but if Coghlan does it again in AAA, it's going to be time to move Dan for that A+ "Aldersen" style pitching prospect and go with the scrappy slap hitters. His gains in offense over the potential replacements is not going to be worth $7-10 million dollars. Right now at the $4.5-5 million range and Coghlan just out of AA, sure. Things probably change in 2010. Maybe even the deadline.
Let's take it further also about the Marlins, defensively, the corner IF slots are going up huge, and the new outfield arrangement is an even bigger upgrade as well. The team is going to win 3-5 more games simply on defense next year. And we have our 5 starting pitchers ready to go, where we won't be giving 38 starts to Hendrickson, Badenhop, Tucker, and Cruz next year. Huge upgrade. Even if Nolasco comes down, and Anibal/Miller throw high 4 eras, this is an upgrade. We could use a 6th SP though, but we'll keep an eye on that over the rest of the offseason just so we don't have to resort to Vanden Hurk or Badenhop again. As we've gone over in other threads, we have 20 bullpen arms all at AA or above. We don't have problems there. The only issue is going to be competition by attrition and figuring out which ones are going to make it. I'm very optimistic by the end of the year we have Lindstrom, Nunez, Tucker, Ceda, and Cruz throwing fireballs, and hopefully Pinto and Kroenke/Meyer/Tank producing a bit from the left. Really like the pen longterm.
Again, why are you worried about the Marlins? It's very legitimate to think this team is improved offensively, defensively, and pitching wise right now. And our farm is loaded. None of what I've typed is a stretch or could be considered overly homerish. This is pretty damn objective, and really not expecting much out Baker, Ross, Hermida, McPherson, Sanchez, Maybin, and the starters. Sure we should have done better with the Olsen trade, and we still need a veteran bullpen/6th starter and a left handed 4th outfielder, but those are very minor things when it comes down to it compared to where we are.
We're in great shape even if Beinfest still makes some bone-headed Nelson moves here and there.
Jesus Christ that was thorough! Well done sir.