Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Grade Admin Beinfest's Offseason Perfomance

Featured Replies

If we get a stadium deal announced by opening day (or before trade deadline) do we still think about trading Willis or does a stadium deal not change anything?

C+, can't win them all Admin! I praise his move to bring in Gregg, this RP is going to be the key component this year out of our bullpen.

  • Author

Beinfest gets an incomplete. He has his hands tied by the lack of money. Ownership gets an F.

 

Lack of money does not prevent Beinfest from getting creative in trading some of the Marlins prospects. I'm not saying he should sell the farm, but we have enough high rated pitching prospects to put together in a package with some of the more marginal players on our 25-man roster to get what we need (and still have a sizeable squad of strong arms in our system).

We have holes to fill and we have valuable chips to trade to fill those holes but just because the trades haven't been made doesn't mean Beinfest has done a bad job. We don't know what the trade proposals were. If ownership was willing to spend $35 in payroll (a payroll amount that would leave them with a big fat operating profit at year-end) then I believe Beinfest could have fileld the holes. That's the reason I give Beinfest an Incomplete and the owner an F.

 

We don't know what the trade proposals were, but we do know the holes remain — the biggest being in the bullpen and of course centerfield. Maybe every GM is playing hardball asking for one of the big four starting pitchers in return for a good CF and those would be bad deals for the Marlins in the end. But it seems to me that Beinfest should at least be able to get more of a solution in CF. IOW, a stopgap for 2007 who would still figure to be a good bench player in coming seasons once we get a "permanent" solution.

a stopgap for 2007 who would still figure to be a good bench player in coming seasons once we get a "permanent" solution.

Alex Sanchez. If he's ready & healthy, he can easily be hitting over 300 and contributing offensively, even if not a defensive dream. Still, it would be a step up with veteran who has played the position in the majors more than anyone else on our roster. It will improve things a bit for the time being and give us another year or two to solve the CF riddle.

it has not been a good off season for the fish our bullpen is much weaker , losing helms will hurt , and our centerfield position has not been improved at all. it is a shame because we really arent that many pieces away from being a legit playoff threat , no doubt someone will chime in and say we almost made the playoffs last year i would retort everything went right last year with all of our rookies and we have not improved our team via free agent acquisition or via promotion of a top flight prospect from the farm,essentially we are still at best a 78-80 win team

Alex Sanchez is not the answer in CF, not for next year, not ever...

"Answer" or not, he is the best CF in the organization. Much closer to being "the answer" than the Reggie Abercrombies and Eric Reeds of the world, or even Amezagas & Codys. And he cost the team next to nothing.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.