Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins interested in Michael Barrett

Featured Replies

I don't think that most people here realize that easy solutions for CF or C don't exist. If they did, more teams would have them.

And you're ignoring that every other team in baseball has a situation better than ours.It's one thing to say that it's a pipe-dream to hope for a Joe Mauer, it's another to acknowledge that any of the other 29 starters at either position represent an upgrade.Do they? There are a lot of CFers and catchers that are more valued than guys like Amezaga but really aren't producing. Guys like Nook Logan, Corey Patterson, Chris Duffy, these guys really aren't doing more for their teams than we are getting out of Amezaga, who is more than effective from the leadoff spot, although anywhere else he becomes a drain on the lineup. His defense has improved, he has always had abiltiy to make diving/jumping catches but he is now getting a better read on the ball and better jumps, increasing his range. As for the catcher world, that's filled with guys like Chris Ianetta, Dionner Navarro, etc. Only a few teams have a true surplus of catchers like the Braves and possibly the Mariners, and it'll take D-Train to pry Salty away. I'm not saying we shouldn't be looking at improving either position and getting a longterm solution, but we don't have a lot of tradeable commodities and I really don't care to send anything of value for a guy like Michael Barrett or Corey Patterson.Honestly, I stopped giving any credibility to this debate there. Because Amezaga's "fast" you feel he belongs at the top of the lineup and there's nothing wrong with him there.I've tried to speak to more than one brick wall here, and that's it.I'm glad you're happy with the centerfield and catching situation, and that's it.The biggest difference is De Aza can be a league average CF'er. At catcher we're further away from a solution, I mean they can give Baker a shot, but who knows.

may I ask why this is believed? Kid was hot before and all which is great. But, where is the proof of it?He's a rookie, why do we need anymore 'proof'. You have no proof he'll be below average. Every player starts out as a rookie at some point.With catcher we know what we're going to get. Nothing can be more stupid than trading away any prospects for a CF'er during this season. Unless we're competing in late july and that CF'er is a guy who will soon hit his 600th HRUmm....that's the dumbest logic I've ever heard.Reggie was a rookie last year, is he or was he league average?Yeah...Ummm.noo. De Aza's sample size is too small to make any assesment on his ability to play, and until we cna see for sure theres absolutely no reason to waste prospects on a CF'er. Reggie played practically the whole season. It seems in your attempt to sound overly intelligent you have forgotten that playing in 100+ games is a much better sample size to analyze than playing in 5 games.Do you have any idea what you're saying?You said that because De Aza's a rookie, there's absolutely nothing that suggests he'll be below average.Ignore the career .266 minor league batting average, or the career that never really got above A ball except a brief stint. Ignore that he basically repeated A ball three times. Ignore that he never hit .300 in any full season in the minors.Ignore all that. Just pretend that his 5 games in the bigs are all that matter, and that the future is impossible to predict. And that because he's a rookie, he can't possibly be any worse than league average.

I don't think that most people here realize that easy solutions for CF or C don't exist. If they did, more teams would have them.

And you're ignoring that every other team in baseball has a situation better than ours.It's one thing to say that it's a pipe-dream to hope for a Joe Mauer, it's another to acknowledge that any of the other 29 starters at either position represent an upgrade.Do they? There are a lot of CFers and catchers that are more valued than guys like Amezaga but really aren't producing. Guys like Nook Logan, Corey Patterson, Chris Duffy, these guys really aren't doing more for their teams than we are getting out of Amezaga, who is more than effective from the leadoff spot, although anywhere else he becomes a drain on the lineup. His defense has improved, he has always had abiltiy to make diving/jumping catches but he is now getting a better read on the ball and better jumps, increasing his range. As for the catcher world, that's filled with guys like Chris Ianetta, Dionner Navarro, etc. Only a few teams have a true surplus of catchers like the Braves and possibly the Mariners, and it'll take D-Train to pry Salty away. I'm not saying we shouldn't be looking at improving either position and getting a longterm solution, but we don't have a lot of tradeable commodities and I really don't care to send anything of value for a guy like Michael Barrett or Corey Patterson.Honestly, I stopped giving any credibility to this debate there. Because Amezaga's "fast" you feel he belongs at the top of the lineup and there's nothing wrong with him there.I've tried to speak to more than one brick wall here, and that's it.I'm glad you're happy with the centerfield and catching situation, and that's it.

I actually agree with Spud. Amezaga has been pretty respectable in the leadoff spot. Anyone know what his avg/obp/slg are when he leads off? Those could definitely make me change my tune if my eyes are deceiving me.

 

I think Amezaga is absolutely worthless anywhere else in the lineup, but at leadoff he sees much better pitches. I could care less that he is fast.

I don't think that most people here realize that easy solutions for CF or C don't exist. If they did, more teams would have them.

And you're ignoring that every other team in baseball has a situation better than ours.It's one thing to say that it's a pipe-dream to hope for a Joe Mauer, it's another to acknowledge that any of the other 29 starters at either position represent an upgrade.Do they? There are a lot of CFers and catchers that are more valued than guys like Amezaga but really aren't producing. Guys like Nook Logan, Corey Patterson, Chris Duffy, these guys really aren't doing more for their teams than we are getting out of Amezaga, who is more than effective from the leadoff spot, although anywhere else he becomes a drain on the lineup. His defense has improved, he has always had abiltiy to make diving/jumping catches but he is now getting a better read on the ball and better jumps, increasing his range. As for the catcher world, that's filled with guys like Chris Ianetta, Dionner Navarro, etc. Only a few teams have a true surplus of catchers like the Braves and possibly the Mariners, and it'll take D-Train to pry Salty away. I'm not saying we shouldn't be looking at improving either position and getting a longterm solution, but we don't have a lot of tradeable commodities and I really don't care to send anything of value for a guy like Michael Barrett or Corey Patterson.Honestly, I stopped giving any credibility to this debate there. Because Amezaga's "fast" you feel he belongs at the top of the lineup and there's nothing wrong with him there.I've tried to speak to more than one brick wall here, and that's it.I'm glad you're happy with the centerfield and catching situation, and that's it.

I actually agree with Spud. Amezaga has been pretty respectable in the leadoff spot. Anyone know what his avg/obp/slg are when he leads off? Those could definitely make me change my tune if my eyes are deceiving me.

Still sucks defensively. Never will have a center field arm and doesn't have the range (even though a lot of people think he does) to field his natural position.

I don't think that most people here realize that easy solutions for CF or C don't exist. If they did, more teams would have them.

And you're ignoring that every other team in baseball has a situation better than ours.It's one thing to say that it's a pipe-dream to hope for a Joe Mauer, it's another to acknowledge that any of the other 29 starters at either position represent an upgrade.Do they? There are a lot of CFers and catchers that are more valued than guys like Amezaga but really aren't producing. Guys like Nook Logan, Corey Patterson, Chris Duffy, these guys really aren't doing more for their teams than we are getting out of Amezaga, who is more than effective from the leadoff spot, although anywhere else he becomes a drain on the lineup. His defense has improved, he has always had abiltiy to make diving/jumping catches but he is now getting a better read on the ball and better jumps, increasing his range. As for the catcher world, that's filled with guys like Chris Ianetta, Dionner Navarro, etc. Only a few teams have a true surplus of catchers like the Braves and possibly the Mariners, and it'll take D-Train to pry Salty away. I'm not saying we shouldn't be looking at improving either position and getting a longterm solution, but we don't have a lot of tradeable commodities and I really don't care to send anything of value for a guy like Michael Barrett or Corey Patterson.Honestly, I stopped giving any credibility to this debate there. Because Amezaga's "fast" you feel he belongs at the top of the lineup and there's nothing wrong with him there.I've tried to speak to more than one brick wall here, and that's it.I'm glad you're happy with the centerfield and catching situation, and that's it.

I actually agree with Spud. Amezaga has been pretty respectable in the leadoff spot. Anyone know what his avg/obp/slg are when he leads off? Those could definitely make me change my tune if my eyes are deceiving me.

Still sucks defensively. Never will have a center field arm and doesn't have the range (even though a lot of people think he does) to field his natural position.

Your hatred is deceiving you. His defense is much much improved out there. When he gets enough time to get his body lined up, he actually has a solid/accurate arm. And this is coming from someone who doesn't like him.

 

Obviously I would love to see Brett Carroll grab this job by the reigns though.

I actually agree with Spud. Amezaga has been pretty respectable in the leadoff spot. Anyone know what his avg/obp/slg are when he leads off? Those could definitely make me change my tune if my eyes are deceiving me.

 

I think Amezaga is absolutely worthless anywhere else in the lineup, but at leadoff he sees much better pitches. I could care less that he is fast.

 

.292/.346/.367

I don't think that most people here realize that easy solutions for CF or C don't exist. If they did, more teams would have them.

And you're ignoring that every other team in baseball has a situation better than ours.It's one thing to say that it's a pipe-dream to hope for a Joe Mauer, it's another to acknowledge that any of the other 29 starters at either position represent an upgrade.Do they? There are a lot of CFers and catchers that are more valued than guys like Amezaga but really aren't producing. Guys like Nook Logan, Corey Patterson, Chris Duffy, these guys really aren't doing more for their teams than we are getting out of Amezaga, who is more than effective from the leadoff spot, although anywhere else he becomes a drain on the lineup. His defense has improved, he has always had abiltiy to make diving/jumping catches but he is now getting a better read on the ball and better jumps, increasing his range. As for the catcher world, that's filled with guys like Chris Ianetta, Dionner Navarro, etc. Only a few teams have a true surplus of catchers like the Braves and possibly the Mariners, and it'll take D-Train to pry Salty away. I'm not saying we shouldn't be looking at improving either position and getting a longterm solution, but we don't have a lot of tradeable commodities and I really don't care to send anything of value for a guy like Michael Barrett or Corey Patterson.Honestly, I stopped giving any credibility to this debate there. Because Amezaga's "fast" you feel he belongs at the top of the lineup and there's nothing wrong with him there.I've tried to speak to more than one brick wall here, and that's it.I'm glad you're happy with the centerfield and catching situation, and that's it.The biggest difference is De Aza can be a league average CF'er. At catcher we're further away from a solution, I mean they can give Baker a shot, but who knows.

may I ask why this is believed? Kid was hot before and all which is great. But, where is the proof of it?He's a rookie, why do we need anymore 'proof'. You have no proof he'll be below average. Every player starts out as a rookie at some point.With catcher we know what we're going to get. Nothing can be more stupid than trading away any prospects for a CF'er during this season. Unless we're competing in late july and that CF'er is a guy who will soon hit his 600th HRUmm....that's the dumbest logic I've ever heard.Reggie was a rookie last year, is he or was he league average?Yeah...Ummm.noo. De Aza's sample size is too small to make any assesment on his ability to play, and until we cna see for sure theres absolutely no reason to waste prospects on a CF'er. Reggie played practically the whole season. It seems in your attempt to sound overly intelligent you have forgotten that playing in 100+ games is a much better sample size to analyze than playing in 5 games.Do you have any idea what you're saying?You said that because De Aza's a rookie, there's absolutely nothing that suggests he'll be below average.Ignore the career .266 minor league batting average, or the career that never really got above A ball except a brief stint. Ignore that he basically repeated A ball three times. Ignore that he never hit .300 in any full season in the minors.Ignore all that. Just pretend that his 5 games in the bigs are all that matter, and that the future is impossible to predict. And that because he's a rookie, he can't possibly be any worse than league average.

 

 

Your completely misunderstanding my argument. My argument is not rookie=league average. My argument is let him play before we make a stupid move and trade away prospects for a different center fielder.

Do you have any idea what you're saying?You said that because De Aza's a rookie, there's absolutely nothing that suggests he'll be below average.Ignore the career .266 minor league batting average, or the career that never really got above A ball except a brief stint. Ignore that he basically repeated A ball three times. Ignore that he never hit .300 in any full season in the minors.Ignore all that. Just pretend that his 5 games in the bigs are all that matter, and that the future is impossible to predict. And that because he's a rookie, he can't possibly be any worse than league average.

 

 

First to preface, I am not saying that De Aza is going to be some amazing player.

 

But 1) He didn't repeat the same level of A ball. He repeated Rookie ball three times, all years as a teenager so I wouldn't view that as that big of a deal. After moving up to A ball at 20, he's moved up a level every year (A+ at 21, AA at 22). I also wouldn't call his AA stint "brief", he essientially played the entire year there.

 

2) You of all people point to his .baa as to why he's going to be bad? Common man.

 

Rather then looking at the combined stats from his R-ball years, why not look at what matters more - his past two years at A+ and AA?

 

At Jupiter, he hit .286/.370/.394. At Carolina, he hit .278/.346/.374, and if you look at his righty splits (Which matters more, expecially if we run Ross out there against LHP), he hit .299/.367/.412.

 

Again, I'm not saying he's going to be some amazing player. He's not our knight in shining arm that will sweep us off our feet when he gets back. And I have no problem at all if people don't have faith in him. But he could easily be league average, and I'd much rather see what he can do at this level before writing him off.

Pretty good points there Ensam.

 

I wish he hadn't gotten hurt... we wouldn't have to speculate about this.

 

Regardless no one's suggesting he's anything special but I'd like to see more of him when he's healthy.

 

 

For the time being let's root for Brett Carroll. :thumbup

Do you have any idea what you're saying?You said that because De Aza's a rookie, there's absolutely nothing that suggests he'll be below average.Ignore the career .266 minor league batting average, or the career that never really got above A ball except a brief stint. Ignore that he basically repeated A ball three times. Ignore that he never hit .300 in any full season in the minors.Ignore all that. Just pretend that his 5 games in the bigs are all that matter, and that the future is impossible to predict. And that because he's a rookie, he can't possibly be any worse than league average.

 

 

First to preface, I am not saying that De Aza is going to be some amazing player.

 

But 1) He didn't repeat the same level of A ball. He repeated Rookie ball three times, all years as a teenager so I wouldn't view that as that big of a deal. After moving up to A ball at 20, he's moved up a level every year (A+ at 21, AA at 22). I also wouldn't call his AA stint "brief", he essientially played the entire year there.

 

2) You of all people point to his .baa as to why he's going to be bad? Common man.

 

Rather then looking at the combined stats from his R-ball years, why not look at what matters more - his past two years at A+ and AA?

 

At Jupiter, he hit .286/.370/.394. At Carolina, he hit .278/.346/.374, and if you look at his righty splits (Which matters more, expecially if we run Ross out there against LHP), he hit .299/.367/.412.

 

Again, I'm not saying he's going to be some amazing player. He's not our knight in shining arm that will sweep us off our feet when he gets back. And I have no problem at all if people don't have faith in him. But he could easily be league average, and I'd much rather see what he can do at this level before writing him off.

 

I think De Aza's Jupiter numbers have to be taken with a grain of salt. He wasn't necessarily old for the level, but he wasn't exactly hot-shotting it either.

 

He repeated rookie ball, he didn't set the SAL on fire, and to me, didn't make a tremendous name for himself in the FSL. To look at his Jupiter numbers as a definitive end all isn't fair or accurate. He did walk, that's not debateable, but the FSL is also notorious for raw developing pitchers. Still, walking's great. However, that Jupiter walk total screams aberration...why? It was more than 150% of any other single season walk total...and a 5 year minor league career is a decent sample size.

 

Here's another problem I have with your analysis, his minor league career OBP (since let's be honest, this is his main selling point) would need to remain fairly static for him to have value in the majors. He's not an efficient base-stealer, nor an efficient slugger, so to have any value as a starter, he'd still need to hang an OBP around .330 to have any redeeming qualities warranting 500 AB's a season. Considering that total would represent a mere .020 shaving off his minor league average, it's tough to look at him as a projectible major league starter.

 

You want to tell me his defense is so good that he needs to bat 8th? OK, I guess...aside from Carroll, not like there's another stand out defensive player who wouldn't be completely overwhelmed by major league pitching.

 

You want to tell me his power stroke is just waiting, or that he'll learn to steal baes above his minor league average 70%? Great

 

Problem is, there's nothing to suggest that, and just like most players who struggled at low levels and needed to repeat, he's a near guarantee to take a step back at the major league level.

 

That's it, I'm simply saying that he's so underwhelming, it's hardly worth even making a fuss over.

He repeated rookie ball, he didn't set the SAL on fire, and to me, didn't make a tremendous name for himself in the FSL. To look at his Jupiter numbers as a definitive end all isn't fair or accurate. He did walk, that's not debateable, but the FSL is also notorious for raw developing pitchers. Still, walking's great. However, that Jupiter walk total screams aberration...why? It was more than 150% of any other single season walk total...and a 5 year minor league career is a decent sample size.

 

His R through A numbers aren't debateable; they're bad, plain and simple. But I don't view them as that much of an example of what he can do now. Age 17-20, kids are still learning the game at that age. Some progress fast, some progress slow. But he did show progression in his last two minor league years, and that's what matters. And while you do bring up a good poin about his JUP numbers, you also don't say anything about his CAR numbers. Yes, he didn't have as many ABs, but 230 ABs is still a good enough sample size.

 

His walk total did increase in JUP, but he's AB/BB ratio (8.14) was online with what he did the rest of his minor league career (R 1st year-6.97, 2nd-5.82, 3rd-9.04, A-8.97, AA-10.95, average of all years minus his JUP numbers-8.28). The most depressing thing looking at that is the decrease in the ratio in AA, but his AB/K numbers are only a little worse from AA then they were in JUP (Car-5, JUP-5.42).

 

Here's another problem I have with your analysis, his minor league career OBP (since let's be honest, this is his main selling point) would need to remain fairly static for him to have value in the majors. He's not an efficient base-stealer, nor an efficient slugger, so to have any value as a starter, he'd still need to hang an OBP around .330 to have any redeeming qualities warranting 500 AB's a season. Considering that total would represent a mere .020 shaving off his minor league average, it's tough to look at him as a projectible major league starter.

 

Now I do agree with you on this, that he needs a good OBP to be a league average starter, due to faults in his other game (Nobody can honestly expect him to be amazing out there in OF this year, he had make a couple of rookie mistakes in his short time up already. And it's not even that it's a rookie, it's that he's 23. His SB% deffinatly leaves a lot to be desired, and I do think that that would increase with experience...but wouldn't be for another couple of years. And ofcoarse no power, but excluding Carroll (He's same boat as De Aza in my eyes, waiting until he gets experience before calling his name or calling for his head), our real only option with power now is Reggie, and I doubt I even need to go there, and Ross, who has struggled against RHP).

 

But it's actually about .03 shave off, not .02. The Baseball Cube (Which I assume you're using) is missing his first Rookie ball year, I'm using Minor Leage Splits.

 

And I know that he deffinatly isn't a Pierre, but if you look at Pierre's OBP and SLG (.377 and .392), they aren't much ahead of De Aza's (.363 and .379). You can't really compare Pierre and De Aza yearly, because Pierre went to college. Obviously a big difference in .BAA, but also a big difference in BB. Pierre's drop off-.027 OBP, .022 SLG.

 

Now I'm just using Pierre because a lot of people have said that he's essentially a weaker version of Pierre.

 

I do think he could maintain around a .330-.340 OBP this year against RHP. Including LHP, I really don't know if he could...but again, with the assumption that Ross would be out there against LHP (I know Fredi said he wasn't going to platoon De Aza at the start of the year, but I'm sure a platoon would happen if De Aza struggled against LHP).

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.