June 18, 200719 yr Anything's better than Olivo in my mind. Yes sir. No Sir! Why? Because he had a good series in Kansas City? Please. 8 PB, 9/36 against base stealers, sub .230 average before the KC series. He sucks. So we throw out last seasons effort because of less than a half season? He is a streaky hitter, and his numbers will get better. I'm not saying he is the greatest catcher in the league. All I am saying is that he is the best we can afford until we develope someone better. Signing or trading for someone better will cost us too much. I'd rather save that money for CF. Olivo is not great, but he is also not as bad as some make him out to be. By the way, he also threw out 38% of base stealers last season. If you want to put up stats to back up how bad you think he is that is not one. This year merely confirms our suspicions about him last year. That he can't make consistent contact with the ball using his mitt or his glove and his only skill is throwing fast (which is only about 1% of skills used by catchers on defensive).
June 18, 200719 yr Yuck, Cubs want to move him because he sucks why would we want him? That happens with many players. Look at the trade for Kim. The Rockies thought he was garbage. Sometimes people just need a change of scenery. I am not saying Kim is the answer, just saying that is doing better over here.
June 18, 200719 yr Yuck, Cubs want to move him because he sucks why would we want him? That happens with many players. Look at the trade for Kim. The Rockies thought he was garbage. Sometimes people just need a change of scenery. I am not saying Kim is the answer, just saying that is doing better over here. Well, the issue is is that he overexemplifies what's wrong with Olivo - bad deffense. Barrett is far and away the worst deffensive starting catcher in the league. Considering that our biggest problem this season has been our pitching, not our offense, I think downgrading our catcher deffensively would be counterproductive even though it would be an upgrade offensively.
June 18, 200719 yr Anything's better than Olivo in my mind. Yes sir. No Sir! Why? Because he had a good series in Kansas City? Please. 8 PB, 9/36 against base stealers, sub .230 average before the KC series. He sucks. So we throw out last seasons effort because of less than a half season? He is a streaky hitter, and his numbers will get better. I'm not saying he is the greatest catcher in the league. All I am saying is that he is the best we can afford until we develope someone better. Signing or trading for someone better will cost us too much. I'd rather save that money for CF. Olivo is not great, but he is also not as bad as some make him out to be. By the way, he also threw out 38% of base stealers last season. If you want to put up stats to back up how bad you think he is that is not one. This year merely confirms our suspicions about him last year. That he can't make consistent contact with the ball using his mitt or his glove and his only skill is throwing fast (which is only about 1% of skills used by catchers on defensive). What's wrong with giving him tell the end of the season before ripping him? Maybe he turns it around again this season. Even then, he is still the best we can afford until we develope someone ourselves, so why drive ourselves crazy picking at him?
June 18, 200719 yr I think Barrett is a better hitter than Olivo but not much better ,so why put up with the headache?
June 18, 200719 yr Anything's better than Olivo in my mind. Yes sir. You got that right. I second that. Olivo is a BIG problem offensively in the lineup. No matter how bad Barrett may be behind the plate, his bat will give the Marlins a net gain in the slot. GO FOR IT!!!
June 18, 200719 yr Barrett isnt exactly tearing the cover off the ball.. and him hitting .210 on the road this season isnt very encouraging.
June 18, 200719 yr Anything's better than Olivo in my mind. Yes sir. No Sir! Why? Because he had a good series in Kansas City? Please. 8 PB, 9/36 against base stealers, sub .230 average before the KC series. He sucks. So we throw out last seasons effort because of less than a half season? He is a streaky hitter, and his numbers will get better. I'm not saying he is the greatest catcher in the league. All I am saying is that he is the best we can afford until we develope someone better. Signing or trading for someone better will cost us too much. I'd rather save that money for CF. Olivo is not great, but he is also not as bad as some make him out to be. By the way, he also threw out 38% of base stealers last season. If you want to put up stats to back up how bad you think he is that is not one. This year merely confirms our suspicions about him last year. That he can't make consistent contact with the ball using his mitt or his glove and his only skill is throwing fast (which is only about 1% of skills used by catchers on defensive). What's wrong with giving him tell the end of the season before ripping him? Maybe he turns it around again this season. Even then, he is still the best we can afford until we develope someone ourselves, so why drive ourselves crazy picking at him? Same reason that Abercrombie is now in the minors. It's one thing to show promise. It's another thing to perform. Olivo hasn't performed. Worse - he has not shown to have corrected flaws in his game that were apparent last year. So, what, are to give him the rest of the year for? For him to hit a few homers or throw out some runners so we ignore his flaws? Or for him to correct the flaws that have been with him for much of his career?
June 18, 200719 yr I don't think that most people here realize that easy solutions for CF or C don't exist. If they did, more teams would have them. And you're ignoring that every other team in baseball has a situation better than ours. It's one thing to say that it's a pipe-dream to hope for a Joe Mauer, it's another to acknowledge that any of the other 29 starters at either position represent an upgrade.
June 18, 200719 yr Olivo is not that bad compared to the CF situation ... I dont know knwo who said that but thats just plain nuts
June 18, 200719 yr I wouldn't say one is easier to fix than the other, but for those who believe we are one-half of a bat (and a few returning players) away from the playoffs, a new CF, able to play nearly every game, would have the greatest impact.
June 18, 200719 yr Anything's better than Olivo in my mind. Yes sir. No Sir! Why? Because he had a good series in Kansas City? Please. 8 PB, 9/36 against base stealers, sub .230 average before the KC series. He sucks. So we throw out last seasons effort because of less than a half season? He is a streaky hitter, and his numbers will get better. I'm not saying he is the greatest catcher in the league. All I am saying is that he is the best we can afford until we develope someone better. Signing or trading for someone better will cost us too much. I'd rather save that money for CF. Olivo is not great, but he is also not as bad as some make him out to be. By the way, he also threw out 38% of base stealers last season. If you want to put up stats to back up how bad you think he is that is not one. This year merely confirms our suspicions about him last year. That he can't make consistent contact with the ball using his mitt or his glove and his only skill is throwing fast (which is only about 1% of skills used by catchers on defensive). What's wrong with giving him tell the end of the season before ripping him? Maybe he turns it around again this season. Even then, he is still the best we can afford until we develope someone ourselves, so why drive ourselves crazy picking at him? Same reason that Abercrombie is now in the minors. It's one thing to show promise. It's another thing to perform. Olivo hasn't performed. Worse - he has not shown to have corrected flaws in his game that were apparent last year. So, what, are to give him the rest of the year for? For him to hit a few homers or throw out some runners so we ignore his flaws? Or for him to correct the flaws that have been with him for much of his career? Look, I have said all along that Olivo is not a great catcher. However, we don't have anyone better and it would cost us too much to trade for an upgrade, or sign a free agent upgrade. For the money, and our circumstances, I think he is ok. Would I want Olivo as a starter on my team if I had a decent payroll? No. My point is that we have to be patient until we develope a young player such as Hayes, or maybe even Baker, although I'm not so sure about Baker. We just have to live with his flaws, and take comfort in his strengths, like hitting the occasional HR, and throwing out a few runners. Olivo is not the biggest problem this team has. Starting pitching has not lived up to the hype. Jake can't stay healthy, Hermida hasn't developed as fast as we would have hoped, and CF is still a mystery. Those are the main reasons we are still under .500.
June 18, 200719 yr Anything's better than Olivo in my mind. Yes sir. No Sir! Why? Because he had a good series in Kansas City? Please. 8 PB, 9/36 against base stealers, sub .230 average before the KC series. He sucks. So we throw out last seasons effort because of less than a half season? He is a streaky hitter, and his numbers will get better. I'm not saying he is the greatest catcher in the league. All I am saying is that he is the best we can afford until we develope someone better. Signing or trading for someone better will cost us too much. I'd rather save that money for CF. Olivo is not great, but he is also not as bad as some make him out to be. By the way, he also threw out 38% of base stealers last season. If you want to put up stats to back up how bad you think he is that is not one. This year merely confirms our suspicions about him last year. That he can't make consistent contact with the ball using his mitt or his glove and his only skill is throwing fast (which is only about 1% of skills used by catchers on defensive). What's wrong with giving him tell the end of the season before ripping him? Maybe he turns it around again this season. Even then, he is still the best we can afford until we develope someone ourselves, so why drive ourselves crazy picking at him? Same reason that Abercrombie is now in the minors. It's one thing to show promise. It's another thing to perform. Olivo hasn't performed. Worse - he has not shown to have corrected flaws in his game that were apparent last year. So, what, are to give him the rest of the year for? For him to hit a few homers or throw out some runners so we ignore his flaws? Or for him to correct the flaws that have been with him for much of his career? Look, I have said all along that Olivo is not a great catcher. However, we don't have anyone better and it would cost us too much to trade for an upgrade, or sign a free agent upgrade. For the money, and our circumstances, I think he is ok. Would I want Olivo as a starter on my team if I had a decent payroll? No. My point is that we have to be patient until we develope a young player such as Hayes, or maybe even Baker, although I'm not so sure about Baker. We just have to live with his flaws, and take comfort in his strengths, like hitting the occasional HR, and throwing out a few runners. Olivo is not the biggest problem this team has. Starting pitching has not lived up to the hype. Jake can't stay healthy, Hermida hasn't developed as fast as we would have hoped, and CF is still a mystery. Those are the main reasons we are still under .500. well said...our pitching has been awful this year...before we try shoring up some position players...lets get out pitching straightened out becauuse that ultimately will decide ouur future this year and beyond
June 18, 200719 yr I wouldn't say one is easier to fix than the other, but for those who believe we are one-half of a bat (and a few returning players) away from the playoffs, a new CF, able to play nearly every game, would have the greatest impact. In essence, I agree with you. A league average centerfielder is generally an offensively better player than a league average catcher. But I disagree that a new adequate centerfielder with Jacobs getting healthy means we're a wild-card type team (if that's what you're implying).
June 18, 200719 yr Look, I have said all along that Olivo is not a great catcher. However, we don't have anyone better and it would cost us too much to trade for an upgrade, or sign a free agent upgrade. For the money, and our circumstances, I think he is ok. Would I want Olivo as a starter on my team if I had a decent payroll? No. My point is that we have to be patient until we develope a young player such as Hayes, or maybe even Baker, although I'm not so sure about Baker. We just have to live with his flaws, and take comfort in his strengths, like hitting the occasional HR, and throwing out a few runners. Olivo is not the biggest problem this team has. Starting pitching has not lived up to the hype. Jake can't stay healthy, Hermida hasn't developed as fast as we would have hoped, and CF is still a mystery. Those are the main reasons we are still under .500. I didn't say what was the biggest problem with the team was. But I will not accept that the catcher situation is acceptable or beyond fixable. Whether you consider Olivo a fill-in, a project or a supporting player, his performance this year has been unacceptable and his collected performance has not suggested we've found an answer for the long-term or short-term. Essentially, he has failed to secure a role as a supporting player, to fulfill the promise of a project, to give the production of a fill-in. I think you're limiting yourself to the options available. We need not need wait for Hayes or Baker to develop. That's not to say we need to rotate every Tom, Dick and Harry into the role as we have in centerfield. It doesn't mean we have to trade for Clement or Piazza. It means Olivo has lost his grip on the job, and should a better option become available for the right price at the right time, Olivo should be pushed aside. He is not acceptable. He is not okay. He may not be the biggest problem or the one thing that's holding us back, but he has no hold to his job any more and will not until he can show to make consistent contact with the ball with his bat and glove. As this team moves forward, they'll have to leave Olivo behind whether that means with Treanor, Baker or another player now, next month or next year. The same with Abercrombie, Amezaga and Borchard. I wouldn't say one is easier to fix than the other, but for those who believe we are one-half of a bat (and a few returning players) away from the playoffs, a new CF, able to play nearly every game, would have the greatest impact. In essence, I agree with you. A league average centerfielder is generally an offensively better player than a league average catcher. But I disagree that a new adequate centerfielder with Jacobs getting healthy means we're a wild-card type team (if that's what you're implying). It shouldn't be a question of which should happen first. Or what needs to happen first. We aren't making the playoffs with the performance we're getting from either position let alone both. However, for those (not me) who envision us able to contend with only one position addressed, CF should be the focus of their games.
June 19, 200719 yr Look, I have said all along that Olivo is not a great catcher. However, we don't have anyone better and it would cost us too much to trade for an upgrade, or sign a free agent upgrade. For the money, and our circumstances, I think he is ok. Would I want Olivo as a starter on my team if I had a decent payroll? No. My point is that we have to be patient until we develope a young player such as Hayes, or maybe even Baker, although I'm not so sure about Baker. We just have to live with his flaws, and take comfort in his strengths, like hitting the occasional HR, and throwing out a few runners. Olivo is not the biggest problem this team has. Starting pitching has not lived up to the hype. Jake can't stay healthy, Hermida hasn't developed as fast as we would have hoped, and CF is still a mystery. Those are the main reasons we are still under .500. I didn't say what was the biggest problem with the team was. But I will not accept that the catcher situation is acceptable or beyond fixable. Whether you consider Olivo a fill-in, a project or a supporting player, his performance this year has been unacceptable and his collected performance has not suggested we've found an answer for the long-term or short-term. Essentially, he has failed to secure a role as a supporting player, to fulfill the promise of a project, to give the production of a fill-in. I think you're limiting yourself to the options available. We need not need wait for Hayes or Baker to develop. That's not to say we need to rotate every Tom, Dick and Harry into the role as we have in centerfield. It doesn't mean we have to trade for Clement or Piazza. It means Olivo has lost his grip on the job, and should a better option become available for the right price at the right time, Olivo should be pushed aside. He is not acceptable. He is not okay. He may not be the biggest problem or the one thing that's holding us back, but he has no hold to his job any more and will not until he can show to make consistent contact with the ball with his bat and glove. As this team moves forward, they'll have to leave Olivo behind whether that means with Treanor, Baker or another player now, next month or next year. The same with Abercrombie, Amezaga and Borchard. I wouldn't say one is easier to fix than the other, but for those who believe we are one-half of a bat (and a few returning players) away from the playoffs, a new CF, able to play nearly every game, would have the greatest impact. In essence, I agree with you. A league average centerfielder is generally an offensively better player than a league average catcher. But I disagree that a new adequate centerfielder with Jacobs getting healthy means we're a wild-card type team (if that's what you're implying). It shouldn't be a question of which should happen first. Or what needs to happen first. We aren't making the playoffs with the performance we're getting from either position let alone both. However, for those (not me) who envision us able to contend with only one position addressed, CF should be the focus of their games. With more solid pitching and a legitimate first basemen returning from the DL, we can still easily make the playoffs with Amezaga starting the majority of the time in CF.
June 19, 200719 yr The biggest difference is De Aza can be a league average CF'er. At catcher we're further away from a solution, I mean they can give Baker a shot, but who knows.
June 19, 200719 yr The biggest difference is De Aza can be a league average CF'er. At catcher we're further away from a solution, I mean they can give Baker a shot, but who knows. may I ask why this is believed? Kid was hot before and all which is great. But, where is the proof of it?
June 19, 200719 yr The biggest difference is De Aza can be a league average CF'er. At catcher we're further away from a solution, I mean they can give Baker a shot, but who knows. may I ask why this is believed? Kid was hot before and all which is great. But, where is the proof of it? He's a rookie, why do we need anymore 'proof'. You have no proof he'll be below average. Every player starts out as a rookie at some point. With catcher we know what we're going to get. Nothing can be more stupid than trading away any prospects for a CF'er during this season. Unless we're competing in late july and that CF'er is a guy who will soon hit his 600th HR
June 19, 200719 yr The biggest difference is De Aza can be a league average CF'er. At catcher we're further away from a solution, I mean they can give Baker a shot, but who knows. may I ask why this is believed? Kid was hot before and all which is great. But, where is the proof of it? He's a rookie, why do we need anymore 'proof'. You have no proof he'll be below average. Every player starts out as a rookie at some point. With catcher we know what we're going to get. Nothing can be more stupid than trading away any prospects for a CF'er during this season. Unless we're competing in late july and that CF'er is a guy who will soon hit his 600th HR Umm....that's the dumbest logic I've ever heard. Reggie was a rookie last year, is he or was he league average? Yeah...
June 19, 200719 yr The biggest difference is De Aza can be a league average CF'er. At catcher we're further away from a solution, I mean they can give Baker a shot, but who knows. may I ask why this is believed? Kid was hot before and all which is great. But, where is the proof of it? He's a rookie, why do we need anymore 'proof'. You have no proof he'll be below average. Every player starts out as a rookie at some point. With catcher we know what we're going to get. Nothing can be more stupid than trading away any prospects for a CF'er during this season. Unless we're competing in late july and that CF'er is a guy who will soon hit his 600th HR Umm....that's the dumbest logic I've ever heard. Reggie was a rookie last year, is he or was he league average? Yeah... Ummm.noo. De Aza's sample size is too small to make any assesment on his ability to play, and until we cna see for sure theres absolutely no reason to waste prospects on a CF'er. Reggie played practically the whole season. It seems in your attempt to sound overly intelligent you have forgotten that playing in 100+ games is a much better sample size to analyze than playing in 5 games.
June 19, 200719 yr I don't think that most people here realize that easy solutions for CF or C don't exist. If they did, more teams would have them. And you're ignoring that every other team in baseball has a situation better than ours. It's one thing to say that it's a pipe-dream to hope for a Joe Mauer, it's another to acknowledge that any of the other 29 starters at either position represent an upgrade. Do they? There are a lot of CFers and catchers that are more valued than guys like Amezaga but really aren't producing. Guys like Nook Logan, Corey Patterson, Chris Duffy, these guys really aren't doing more for their teams than we are getting out of Amezaga, who is more than effective from the leadoff spot, although anywhere else he becomes a drain on the lineup. His defense has improved, he has always had abiltiy to make diving/jumping catches but he is now getting a better read on the ball and better jumps, increasing his range. As for the catcher world, that's filled with guys like Chris Ianetta, Dionner Navarro, etc. Only a few teams have a true surplus of catchers like the Braves and possibly the Mariners, and it'll take D-Train to pry Salty away. I'm not saying we shouldn't be looking at improving either position and getting a longterm solution, but we don't have a lot of tradeable commodities and I really don't care to send anything of value for a guy like Michael Barrett or Corey Patterson.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.