July 24, 200719 yr I highly doubt a 1 for 1 swap of Yunel Escobar for Teix was ever proposed and even if it was that is still more value than Hansen + Pena and even + Jed Lowrie. The Rangers want pitching anyways.
July 24, 200719 yr Put me in the group that thinks Ellsbury is slightly overrated at this point. He will be 24 in a little over a month and his numbers in Triple A are just average at best right now. To think he can step in at CF for a team like Boston next year and put up a .750 - .800 OPS is ridiculous. Right now Coco has a better OPS in the majors than Ellsbury has in Triple A and as good as a defender as they say Ellsbury is, I have a hard time penciling him in to be better than Coco. Still would do an Olsen for Ellsbury swap in a second though. Would love him on the Marlins. :whistle
July 25, 200719 yr I think Ellsbury is quite overrated and I'm not a big fan, what do you have against Ellsbury? Nothing at all, I think he'll be Dustin Pedroia with a lot more stolen bases in terms of a major league player, and that's pretty darn good. But a lot of people seem to think he's some great thing, but he has no power, and unlike a MIF like Pedroia, he's an outfielder. That's a pretty good player, but not nearly a top prospect/futures game savior type or anything, and if the Red Sox have to package him to get something really good at the deadline, they should do it, especially if they can do it and keep Buchholz. In review, I shouldn't say I'm not a big fan because if he's like I think he'll be at the MLB level, I will enjoy watching him play. But I do think he is pretty darn overrated, soon to be 24 year old OF's with very little power aren't any sort of great thing, even if they can steal a lot of bases and get on base a ton. Good yes, a bit above average as a MLB player likely, but not like top 25 prospect in baseball good.
July 25, 200719 yr I actually wouldn't be oppossed to trading Ellsbury for the right deal - this not being it. I think alot of Sox fans are too quick for the new shiny model when we have a proven one who is improving by the day offensively and playing the best CF in the AL this year already in Coco. If Coco gets his OPS above .800 he is absurdly valuable to us with his defense. Not a knock on Ellsbury, he's going to be real good but I like the proven thing especially when that thing is only 27. Ideally I'm sure they'd love the idea of Crisp and Ellsbury in the same OF, but between the J.D. Drew deal and Ellsbury's weakness being power, that obviously doesn't work. It seems clear either Crisp or Ellsbury has to go (I have no idea of Crisp's contract status though, I'd guess that's a big factor here). EDIT: Crisp is signed through 2009 with a 2010 option? Wow, Boston has a tough decision to make in that case. Also, through the great season Boston is having, I had no idea the drop in power J.D. is having this year, career low right now in slugging and OPS. Hmmm.
July 25, 200719 yr I don't know why people talk about Pedroia like he's some average player that Boston is just able to have in the lineup because they have good players elsewhere on the team. He's been a top 3 2B in the AL this year (even after the horrid star) and he's just a rookie. Ellsbury is going to be very good, I don't know what would have been seen in his game and production and how he handled himself in his cup of coffee debut earlier this year that he isn't warranted in being on top prospect lists. The guy scored from 2nd on a passed ball this year. He's Carl Crawford fast right now and more of a leadoff hitter then Coco. No one has mentioned his plate discipline either.
July 25, 200719 yr Ellsbury is going to be very good, I don't know what would have been seen in his game and production and how he handled himself in his cup of coffee debut earlier this year that he isn't warranted in being on top prospect lists. The guy scored from 2nd on a passed ball this year. He's Carl Crawford fast right now and more of a leadoff hitter then Coco. No one has mentioned his plate discipline either. no power :|
July 25, 200719 yr Ellsbury is going to be very good, I don't know what would have been seen in his game and production and how he handled himself in his cup of coffee debut earlier this year that he isn't warranted in being on top prospect lists. The guy scored from 2nd on a passed ball this year. He's Carl Crawford fast right now and more of a leadoff hitter then Coco. No one has mentioned his plate discipline either. meh. His rating has dropped. He used to be the next Johnny Damon now he is just the next middle of the road CF IMO. Coco Crisp would actually be a good comparasion. I see nothing in his game that suggests he will be anything more than a solid contributer to a good team. His OBP numbers aren't high enough to make up for his lack of power. A .380 OBP career average in the minors when you are always a year or two older than everyone else is good, but what will that translate to in a full season in the bigs? Speed as your #1 tool is overrated too.
July 25, 200719 yr I'm assuming that Teixeira means Lowell's walking at the end of the year, but where would he bat now (after the Ortiz health is all sorted out)? You just sit Youkilis? And I think it'd be a tough pill for Steinbrenner to swallow if Chamberlain and Sanchez is enough to get him to the Bronx. That's a deal that gets done. Years ago, you'd be right. Fortunately the Tampa faction doesn't run the Yankees baseball operations anymore. Chamberlain isn't going anywhere. The Yankees are set up to have one of the best rotations in baseball for a long time if they just hold pat. Unless the Yankees are getting an incredible deal, Joba will stay. 1. Hughes 2. Free Agent Signing (Zambrano/Santana, etc) 2. Chamberlain 4. Wang 5. Horne/Kennedy I think Ellsbury is quite overrated and I'm not a big fan, what do you have against Ellsbury? Nothing at all, I think he'll be Dustin Pedroia with a lot more stolen bases in terms of a major league player, and that's pretty darn good. But a lot of people seem to think he's some great thing, but he has no power, and unlike a MIF like Pedroia, he's an outfielder. That's a pretty good player, but not nearly a top prospect/futures game savior type or anything, and if the Red Sox have to package him to get something really good at the deadline, they should do it, especially if they can do it and keep Buchholz. In review, I shouldn't say I'm not a big fan because if he's like I think he'll be at the MLB level, I will enjoy watching him play. But I do think he is pretty darn overrated, soon to be 24 year old OF's with very little power aren't any sort of great thing, even if they can steal a lot of bases and get on base a ton. Good yes, a bit above average as a MLB player likely, but not like top 25 prospect in baseball good. Jacoby Ellsbury is old for his league (prospect-wise) and his OPS is below .700. He is the most overrated prospect in baseball outside of Brandon Wood. It's not to say he can't be a decent slap hitter at the major league level, but his relative value as a prospect is extremely low. Every organization has their Jacoby Ellsbury-types, but for some reason his hype level is getting blown up without merit. If I'm the Red Sox, I'm not trading Buchholz in a package unless I'm getting an elite starter in return. While he doesn't have an incredibly high upside (most likely a #2 in the majors), his floor is also much higher than usual. He is as near a can't miss prospect as there can be. Regardless, I don't see Teixeira getting dealt before the deadline, and rightfully so. I don't think the Rangers can get fair value for him (he's being grossly underrated in this thread, he IS a star at his position). I imagine the deadline as a whole will be relatively quiet.
July 25, 200719 yr Ellsbury is going to be very good, I don't know what would have been seen in his game and production and how he handled himself in his cup of coffee debut earlier this year that he isn't warranted in being on top prospect lists. The guy scored from 2nd on a passed ball this year. He's Carl Crawford fast right now and more of a leadoff hitter then Coco. No one has mentioned his plate discipline either. meh. His rating has dropped. He used to be the next Johnny Damon now he is just the next middle of the road CF IMO. Coco Crisp would actually be a good comparasion. I see nothing in his game that suggests he will be anything more than a solid contributer to a good team. His OBP numbers aren't high enough to make up for his lack of power. A .380 OBP career average in the minors when you are always a year or two older than everyone else is good, but what will that translate to in a full season in the bigs? Speed as your #1 tool is overrated too. You have every right to your opinion but I do remember your analysis of Pedroia as a utility player so I'll take this with a grain of salt. Lowering the rating of a prospect just because he doesn't have a lot of pop is silly. Not every team needs pop and not every successful major league player needs pop. Ellsbury will make a damn good leadoff man.
July 25, 200719 yr Ellsbury is going to be very good, I don't know what would have been seen in his game and production and how he handled himself in his cup of coffee debut earlier this year that he isn't warranted in being on top prospect lists. The guy scored from 2nd on a passed ball this year. He's Carl Crawford fast right now and more of a leadoff hitter then Coco. No one has mentioned his plate discipline either. meh. His rating has dropped. He used to be the next Johnny Damon now he is just the next middle of the road CF IMO. Coco Crisp would actually be a good comparasion. I see nothing in his game that suggests he will be anything more than a solid contributer to a good team. His OBP numbers aren't high enough to make up for his lack of power. A .380 OBP career average in the minors when you are always a year or two older than everyone else is good, but what will that translate to in a full season in the bigs? Speed as your #1 tool is overrated too. You have every right to your opinion but I do remember your analysis of Pedroia as a utility player so I'll take this with a grain of salt. You're good because I don't even remember saying that. I am sure I did though, I just don't remember saying that on this board. Still not that high on Pedroia anyways, think his numbers will fall to about league average for a second basemen.
July 25, 200719 yr Brewers acquired righthanded pitcher Scott Linebrink from the San Diego Padres in exchange for minor league pitchers Joe Thatcher, Will Inman and Steve Garrison. http://rotoworld.com/content/playerpages/p...865&id=3006
July 25, 200719 yr Wow, good deal for the Padres giving up a rental for a prospect like Wil Inman. It's still early but he has a lot of potential. http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/I/Will-Inman.shtml
July 25, 200719 yr Brewers acquired righthanded pitcher Scott Linebrink from the San Diego Padres in exchange for minor league pitchers Joe Thatcher, Will Inman and Steve Garrison. http://rotoworld.com/content/playerpages/p...865&id=3006 Yea good deal for the Padres. Kevin Towers is an awesome GM. Linebrink's numbers weren't not that great this year. His ERA easily could be a full run higher. 9 HR in 45IP while playing in Petco is scary.
July 26, 200719 yr Anyone think there will be a market for Carlos Pena? I think he is in the process of carving out a market for himself. He would probably end up being the consolation prize in the "Who will win Mark Teixeira" contest despit a higher SLG snd OPS. You've also got to love the fact that he is a natural lefty. I wonder what the DRays could get in return...?
July 26, 200719 yr Anyone think there will be a market for Carlos Pena? I wonder what the DRays could get in return...? Probably 2 more uber prospects to put in the OF. Damn the amount of talent the Drays are stockpiling is just not fair. Especially considering they will probably get the #1 overall pick once again this year coming year and take Pedro Alvarez an absolute stud/super star in the making at 3B. Are Yankee fans at all worried about the Rays in the coming years?
July 26, 200719 yr Are Yankee fans at all worried about the Rays in the coming years? Honestly? It seems so far away. They already have a great hitting team on paper and really have good speed at the top of the lineup. Yet, as good as they hit, their feilding is mediocre and their pitching is way under par. I think we'd be way more worried if they started trading some of their talent away for stud pitching or drafted some crazy good arms. As it stands, Boston remains the obvious concern with Toronto continually threatening to bust out at any time. Baltimore and TB are really more of a grind during the season. On a side note, I hear they are shopping Wigginton [possibly to the Yanks - of all teams] and you know Pena is going to draw interest. Since the Yanks aren't about to give up a pitcher for Wiggy, Pena is their only chance to bring an arm or two. It will be interesting.
July 26, 200719 yr Are Yankee fans at all worried about the Rays in the coming years? Honestly? It seems so far away. They already have a great hitting team on paper and really have good speed at the top of the lineup. Yet, as good as they hit, their feilding is mediocre and their pitching is way under par. I think we'd be way more worried if they started trading some of their talent away for stud pitching or drafted some crazy good arms. As it stands, Boston remains the obvious concern with Toronto continually threatening to bust out at any time. Baltimore and TB are really more of a grind during the season. On a side note, I hear they are shopping Wigginton [possibly to the Yanks - of all teams] and you know Pena is going to draw interest. Since the Yanks aren't about to give up a pitcher for Wiggy, Pena is their only chance to bring an arm or two. It will be interesting. I'm not a Yankees fan, but why should they be worried?? They have an unlimited payroll and basically can sign any free agent all-star they want. Same goes for the Red Sox. Now sure the Rays have a ton of talent, but when it comes down to it, I'm taking the team with the unlimited payroll with all-stars rather than the young prospects.
July 26, 200719 yr I'm not a Yankees fan, but why should they be worried?? They have an unlimited payroll and basically can sign any free agent all-star they want. Same goes for the Red Sox. Now sure the Rays have a ton of talent, but when it comes down to it, I'm taking the team with the unlimited payroll with all-stars rather than the young prospects. Since we are on the subject, the last game the Yanks played the DRays [a 21-4 beat down on July 22] here was the starting lineup for the Yanks: Cabrera [Yankees Farm] Jeter [Yankees Farm] Abreu [trade] ARod [$$$] Matsui [Yankees only MLB team] Posada [Yankees Farm] Cano [Yankees Farm] Phillips [Yankees Farm] Duncan [Yankees Farm] Pitching? Andy Pettitte [Yankees Farm Product] and Sean Henn even pitched 2 innings of releif [Yankees Farm] In other words, 7/9 guys in the field [including 2/3 pitchers] and 7/9 in the lineup were developed by the Yanks or have only played for the Yanks. Granted, Matsui dillutes the situation somewhat, but the point remains - the Yankees have a reputation for getting all these hired guns but it's easy to overlook the talent they keep in their organization. Phil Hughes will be a big part of that future and they just called up Sean Henn. They are starting to try to stockpile arms in the minors to see who shakes out, so it's interesting to see the Yankees in a rebuilding/restocking mode trying to plan for the future while simultaniously trying to make smart moves that will help them win right now. I know I for one wont/wouldn't be sad to see Damon or Giambi or Abreu go in exchange for a couple of quality players.
July 26, 200719 yr The way I see it, Tampa MUST deal him. Is he just under contract this year for TB?
July 26, 200719 yr D-rays have a lot of stud SP in their system that are going to be ready real soon. Also Pena still has 2 years of service time after this year. So they have him for awhile.
July 26, 200719 yr I believe he is signed through 2007, so yeah. Well then.. youre right, they'd be stupid not to. He has been awesome this year.. you just gotta wonder if GMs would be apprehensive that he may fall back in to old ways. Thats why Tex is getting so much more attention than him.. Tex can glove it too.. how is Penas defense?
July 26, 200719 yr In what only can be described as a strange twist, the Tigers have an interest in taking Kyle Farnsworth off the Yankees' hands. According to multiple sources, the Tigers are looking to make a deal that would bring Farnsworth back to the team he pitched 46 games for in 2005. Ideally, the Tigers would like to add Texas closer Eric Gagne but he likely will balk at a deal that sends him to a team where he can't close. Tigers scout Dick Egan was at last night's Yankees' 7-1 win over the Royals in which Farnsworth didn't pitch in. What the Yankees would get back depends on how much money the Tigers want to pay on Farnsworth's salary. Farnsworth, who is making $5.25 million this year and $5.5 million next season, is 1-1 with a 4.24 ERA. http://www.nypost.com/seven/07262007/sport...george_king.htm
July 27, 200719 yr The Indians have reportedly acquired Kenny Lofton from the Rangers for Max Ramirez. Ramirez, who was picked up from the Braves for Bob Wickman last year, has a very good bat but probably isn't going to last at catcher. Especially if the Rangers also get Jarrod Saltalamacchia, they'll probably be trying Ramirez at first base in the minors pretty soon. He could be ready to hit in the majors by 2009. http://rangers.beloblog.com/archives/2007/...ton_traded.html
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.