Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Jeremy Hermida

Featured Replies

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

 

Cody Ross is having a better year than any of the guys you mentioned. It's not crazy to say it. It's certainly debatable.

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

 

Cody Ross is having a better year than any of the guys you mentioned. It's not crazy to say it. It's certainly debatable.

He's having a better year (I would argue that Cantu is having a better year), but I don't believe he is a better player.

 

That said, maybe you are right, it's not that crazy.

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

 

Cody Ross is having a better year than any of the guys you mentioned. It's not crazy to say it. It's certainly debatable.

He's having a better year (I would argue that Cantu is having a better year), but I don't believe he is a better player.

 

That said, maybe you are right, it's not that crazy.

 

Not if you take defense into account. Cody is having a good year with the glove.

Can you explain?

 

I ask because last year after the break he had a walk every 10.7 ABs and this year he has a walk every 10.4 ABs so he's walking a bit more than he did during the one extended period of time that he had success in the majors.

 

You're right, I haven't really looked at the numbers in awhile. My mistake.

 

As far as Hermida's second half goes, I'm actually one that doesn't put that much stock in it. It was mostly BABIP and BAA driven, so saying that he can repeat that is essentially say he's as good of a BAA hitter as Miguel Cabrera, which he isn't. IMO at this point in his career, he's probably been what he's been since the start of June but with a bit higher AVG (.270-.280) and maybe a little more power, putting him at the low .800 OPS range (.250/.346/.421/.767 has been his line). But I guess we'll see what he becomes.

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

 

Cody Ross is having a better year than any of the guys you mentioned. It's not crazy to say it. It's certainly debatable.

He's having a better year (I would argue that Cantu is having a better year), but I don't believe he is a better player.

 

That said, maybe you are right, it's not that crazy.

 

Not if you take defense into account. Cody is having a good year with the glove.

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

 

I guess you may be surprised but Cody ranks 4th out of 22 CFs in RZR and he ranks 7th best out of the 22 in Innings / OOZ. He's having a solid year both with the bat and the glove.

 

--- minimum 505 innings

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

 

I guess you may be surprised but Cody ranks 4th out of 22 CFs in RZR and he ranks 7th best out of the 22 in Innings / OOZ. He's having a solid year both with the bat and the glove.

 

--- minimum 505 innings

Wow, I stand corrected. You go Cody!

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

 

I guess you may be surprised but Cody ranks 4th out of 22 CFs in RZR and he ranks 7th best out of the 22 in Innings / OOZ. He's having a solid year both with the bat and the glove.

 

--- minimum 505 innings

Wow, I stand corrected. You go Cody!

 

Cody plays the outfield well, i think he is one of the few bright spots on Defense we have this year, Hermida has pontential in every way but he hasn't proved it in anything. He seems to have power but hasn't hit 30+ home runs, he has a great arm in the outfield but is below average with the glove, he can't bunt, he can't steal, he will be trade bait sometime next year.

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

 

I guess you may be surprised but Cody ranks 4th out of 22 CFs in RZR and he ranks 7th best out of the 22 in Innings / OOZ. He's having a solid year both with the bat and the glove.

 

--- minimum 505 innings

Wow, I stand corrected. You go Cody!

 

Cody plays the outfield well, i think he is one of the few bright spots on Defense we have this year, Hermida has pontential in every way but he hasn't proved it in anything. He seems to have power but hasn't hit 30+ home runs, he has a great arm in the outfield but is below average with the glove, he can't bunt, he can't steal, he will be trade bait sometime next year.

I'm not sure why we would want him to bunt. Then again, I don't like our 2 hitter bunting at all. (That said, Cody can't bunt or steal either.)

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

 

I guess you may be surprised but Cody ranks 4th out of 22 CFs in RZR and he ranks 7th best out of the 22 in Innings / OOZ. He's having a solid year both with the bat and the glove.

 

--- minimum 505 innings

Wow, I stand corrected. You go Cody!

 

Cody plays the outfield well, i think he is one of the few bright spots on Defense we have this year, Hermida has pontential in every way but he hasn't proved it in anything. He seems to have power but hasn't hit 30+ home runs, he has a great arm in the outfield but is below average with the glove, he can't bunt, he can't steal, he will be trade bait sometime next year.

I'm not sure why we would want him to bunt. Then again, I don't like our 2 hitter bunting at all. (That said, Cody can't bunt or steal either.)

 

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

 

I guess you may be surprised but Cody ranks 4th out of 22 CFs in RZR and he ranks 7th best out of the 22 in Innings / OOZ. He's having a solid year both with the bat and the glove.

 

--- minimum 505 innings

 

 

 

 

 

He has been OUTSTANDING this year which really surprised me because you look at his past seasons, he didn't show this kind of range.

 

The question becomes was he just under-par of what he really is the past two seasons, or is he over-playing his ability this year (or is he actually somewhere imbetween).

 

The biggest thing though is that this year he has more innings played in center than 06-07 combined.

 

08-

rzr: .943

ooz: 33, 505 inn

 

07-

rzr: .879

ooz: 5, 239 inn (10 over 505 inn)

 

06-

rzr: .895

ooz: 6, 145 inn (20 over 505 inn)

 

06 and 07-

rzr: .885

ooz: 11, 384 inn (14 over 505 inn)

 

06-08 combined-

rzr: .918 RZR

ooz: 44, 889 inn (25 over 505 inn)

Please tell me whoever started this thread has not seen a marlins game in the last two years. you have to be kidding me.

 

Last year Hermida had more Homeruns, RBI, Hits, Doubles, Triples, Walks, and Stolen bases. He also hit for a higher Average had a higher On Base Percentage a higher Slugging Percentage and higher OPS.

 

Now lets assume for the sake of argument that Hermida and Jacobs are equal defensively or even that Jacobs is a little bit better, who would you rather have?

 

a 24 year old RF that hits for a higher average, more power, and drives in more runs

 

OR

 

a 27 year old 1B that plays below average defense and doesn't produce at the level of most 1st basemen?

 

TOUGH CHOICE?!?!?!

 

I'm the first person along with my friends that constantly question Hermida's passion and think he is an absolute bumb, but are u really serious with this question? Hermida has better numbers than Jacobs and probably doesn't even try half as hard. If a manager can ever untap Hermida's potential he could be a great player, IF NOT he'll still be a whole hell of a lot better than Mike Jacobs.

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

That's the arguable part. A lot of us don't thing that a 2 hitter is supposed to be that, fast and bunting (read giving away outs and making it harder to score runs). I think a 2 hitter should be what Hermida was in the 2nd part of last year. Lots of walks and great at getting on base. Decent speed is good too, which is what Hermida has.

 

We should be trying to put a man at 1st and 2nd with no outs, not a man on 2nd with one out. Keep in mind that the run expectancy with a man on first and no outs is .953 and with a man on 2nd with 1 out is .725.

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

That's the arguable part. A lot of us don't thing that a 2 hitter is supposed to be that, fast and bunting (read giving away outs and making it harder to score runs). I think a 2 hitter should be what Hermida was in the 2nd part of last year. Lots of walks and great at getting on base. Decent speed is good too, which is what Hermida has.

 

We should be trying to put a man at 1st and 2nd with no outs, not a man on 2nd with one out. Keep in mind that the run expectancy with a man on first and no outs is .953 and with a man on 2nd with 1 out is .725.

 

 

previous marlins players who succeed at the 2 whole are Amezaga and Castillo, Mark Kotsay i believe batted 2nd, they were all speed guys who could bunt a guy over if needed or bunt for a base hit and has loathes of speed, walks are also important, Castillo was the master of 3-2 counts, while Amezaga always seemed to get on base, Hermida seems like the prototypical #7 hitter, a guy with little speed, low batting average and not bunting ability who can hit a ball in the hole wit runners on 1st and 2nd to score a run.

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

That's the arguable part. A lot of us don't thing that a 2 hitter is supposed to be that, fast and bunting (read giving away outs and making it harder to score runs). I think a 2 hitter should be what Hermida was in the 2nd part of last year. Lots of walks and great at getting on base. Decent speed is good too, which is what Hermida has.

 

We should be trying to put a man at 1st and 2nd with no outs, not a man on 2nd with one out. Keep in mind that the run expectancy with a man on first and no outs is .953 and with a man on 2nd with 1 out is .725.

 

 

previous marlins players who succeed at the 2 whole are Amezaga and Castillo, Mark Kotsay i believe batted 2nd, they were all speed guys who could bunt a guy over if needed or bunt for a base hit and has loathes of speed, walks are also important, Castillo was the master of 3-2 counts, while Amezaga always seemed to get on base, Hermida seems like the prototypical #7 hitter, a guy with little speed, low batting average and not bunting ability who can hit a ball in the hole wit runners on 1st and 2nd to score a run.

Just to start, Amezaga has only started 9 games in the 2 spot while with the Fish, so I am going to outright ignor that.

 

Also, in 2003, Luis Castillo only put down the sacrifice bunt in 13 games out of the 143 games he started. His success was based more on the fact that he walked a ton and he struck out very little. He did a great job of getting on base for his 3-4-5 hitters to bring him in.

 

That is the kind of thing that Hermida showed he could do in the 2nd half of last year. In 2007, he had a .296 BA and a .369 OBP. I wouldn't call that a "low batting average".

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

That's the arguable part. A lot of us don't thing that a 2 hitter is supposed to be that, fast and bunting (read giving away outs and making it harder to score runs). I think a 2 hitter should be what Hermida was in the 2nd part of last year. Lots of walks and great at getting on base. Decent speed is good too, which is what Hermida has.

 

We should be trying to put a man at 1st and 2nd with no outs, not a man on 2nd with one out. Keep in mind that the run expectancy with a man on first and no outs is .953 and with a man on 2nd with 1 out is .725.

 

 

previous marlins players who succeed at the 2 whole are Amezaga and Castillo, Mark Kotsay i believe batted 2nd, they were all speed guys who could bunt a guy over if needed or bunt for a base hit and has loathes of speed, walks are also important, Castillo was the master of 3-2 counts, while Amezaga always seemed to get on base, Hermida seems like the prototypical #7 hitter, a guy with little speed, low batting average and not bunting ability who can hit a ball in the hole wit runners on 1st and 2nd to score a run.

Just to start, Amezaga has only started 9 games in the 2 spot while with the Fish, so I am going to outright ignor that.

 

Also, in 2003, Luis Castillo only put down the sacrifice bunt in 13 games out of the 143 games he started. His success was based more on the fact that he walked a ton and he struck out very little. He did a great job of getting on base for his 3-4-5 hitters to bring him in.

 

That is the kind of thing that Hermida showed he could do in the 2nd half of last year. In 2007, he had a .296 BA and a .369 OBP. I wouldn't call that a "low batting average".

 

i still don't see him as a "long term solution" for the marlins, he is an average fielder and as the #2 hitter in the lineup he has sucked, last year when he batted .296 he batted farther down in the lineup, I do not blame him as much but more for Fredi putting Hermida in a spot in the lineup where he does not fit, Hermida, in my opinion, strikes out way to much, 83 already this year. I personally think De Aza could've been the long term solution if he wasn't so brittle, and I don't trust Maybin, but I will have to give him a chance since we gave up so much to get him.

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

That's the arguable part. A lot of us don't thing that a 2 hitter is supposed to be that, fast and bunting (read giving away outs and making it harder to score runs). I think a 2 hitter should be what Hermida was in the 2nd part of last year. Lots of walks and great at getting on base. Decent speed is good too, which is what Hermida has.

 

We should be trying to put a man at 1st and 2nd with no outs, not a man on 2nd with one out. Keep in mind that the run expectancy with a man on first and no outs is .953 and with a man on 2nd with 1 out is .725.

 

 

previous marlins players who succeed at the 2 whole are Amezaga and Castillo, Mark Kotsay i believe batted 2nd, they were all speed guys who could bunt a guy over if needed or bunt for a base hit and has loathes of speed, walks are also important, Castillo was the master of 3-2 counts, while Amezaga always seemed to get on base, Hermida seems like the prototypical #7 hitter, a guy with little speed, low batting average and not bunting ability who can hit a ball in the hole wit runners on 1st and 2nd to score a run.

Just to start, Amezaga has only started 9 games in the 2 spot while with the Fish, so I am going to outright ignor that.

 

Also, in 2003, Luis Castillo only put down the sacrifice bunt in 13 games out of the 143 games he started. His success was based more on the fact that he walked a ton and he struck out very little. He did a great job of getting on base for his 3-4-5 hitters to bring him in.

 

That is the kind of thing that Hermida showed he could do in the 2nd half of last year. In 2007, he had a .296 BA and a .369 OBP. I wouldn't call that a "low batting average".

 

i still don't see him as a "long term solution" for the marlins, he is an average fielder and as the #2 hitter in the lineup he has sucked, last year when he batted .296 he batted farther down in the lineup, I do not blame him as much but more for Fredi putting Hermida in a spot in the lineup where he does not fit, Hermida, in my opinion, strikes out way to much, 83 already this year. I personally think De Aza could've been the long term solution if he wasn't so brittle, and I don't trust Maybin, but I will have to give him a chance since we gave up so much to get him.

Now there is the main problem. Hermida is striking out more than he ever has, mostly because the Marlins want him to be "aggressive" as opposed to being the walk machine who would take a ton of pitches.

 

The real Hermida, who gets on base and doesn't strikeout much. He is the perfect 2 hitter. Maybe more if his power reaches what it is. But I think it is a misrepresentation to say that Hermida is a "low speed, low average, high power" guy.

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

That's the arguable part. A lot of us don't thing that a 2 hitter is supposed to be that, fast and bunting (read giving away outs and making it harder to score runs). I think a 2 hitter should be what Hermida was in the 2nd part of last year. Lots of walks and great at getting on base. Decent speed is good too, which is what Hermida has.

 

We should be trying to put a man at 1st and 2nd with no outs, not a man on 2nd with one out. Keep in mind that the run expectancy with a man on first and no outs is .953 and with a man on 2nd with 1 out is .725.

 

 

previous marlins players who succeed at the 2 whole are Amezaga and Castillo, Mark Kotsay i believe batted 2nd, they were all speed guys who could bunt a guy over if needed or bunt for a base hit and has loathes of speed, walks are also important, Castillo was the master of 3-2 counts, while Amezaga always seemed to get on base, Hermida seems like the prototypical #7 hitter, a guy with little speed, low batting average and not bunting ability who can hit a ball in the hole wit runners on 1st and 2nd to score a run.

Just to start, Amezaga has only started 9 games in the 2 spot while with the Fish, so I am going to outright ignor that.

 

Also, in 2003, Luis Castillo only put down the sacrifice bunt in 13 games out of the 143 games he started. His success was based more on the fact that he walked a ton and he struck out very little. He did a great job of getting on base for his 3-4-5 hitters to bring him in.

 

That is the kind of thing that Hermida showed he could do in the 2nd half of last year. In 2007, he had a .296 BA and a .369 OBP. I wouldn't call that a "low batting average".

 

i still don't see him as a "long term solution" for the marlins, he is an average fielder and as the #2 hitter in the lineup he has sucked, last year when he batted .296 he batted farther down in the lineup, I do not blame him as much but more for Fredi putting Hermida in a spot in the lineup where he does not fit, Hermida, in my opinion, strikes out way to much, 83 already this year. I personally think De Aza could've been the long term solution if he wasn't so brittle, and I don't trust Maybin, but I will have to give him a chance since we gave up so much to get him.

Now there is the main problem. Hermida is striking out more than he ever has, mostly because the Marlins want him to be "aggressive" as opposed to being the walk machine who would take a ton of pitches.

 

The real Hermida, who gets on base and doesn't strikeout much. He is the perfect 2 hitter. Maybe more if his power reaches what it is. But I think it is a misrepresentation to say that Hermida is a "low speed, low average, high power" guy.

 

i will believe all those things until he decides to prove me wrong

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

That's the arguable part. A lot of us don't thing that a 2 hitter is supposed to be that, fast and bunting (read giving away outs and making it harder to score runs). I think a 2 hitter should be what Hermida was in the 2nd part of last year. Lots of walks and great at getting on base. Decent speed is good too, which is what Hermida has.

 

We should be trying to put a man at 1st and 2nd with no outs, not a man on 2nd with one out. Keep in mind that the run expectancy with a man on first and no outs is .953 and with a man on 2nd with 1 out is .725.

 

 

previous marlins players who succeed at the 2 whole are Amezaga and Castillo, Mark Kotsay i believe batted 2nd, they were all speed guys who could bunt a guy over if needed or bunt for a base hit and has loathes of speed, walks are also important, Castillo was the master of 3-2 counts, while Amezaga always seemed to get on base, Hermida seems like the prototypical #7 hitter, a guy with little speed, low batting average and not bunting ability who can hit a ball in the hole wit runners on 1st and 2nd to score a run.

Just to start, Amezaga has only started 9 games in the 2 spot while with the Fish, so I am going to outright ignor that.

 

Also, in 2003, Luis Castillo only put down the sacrifice bunt in 13 games out of the 143 games he started. His success was based more on the fact that he walked a ton and he struck out very little. He did a great job of getting on base for his 3-4-5 hitters to bring him in.

 

That is the kind of thing that Hermida showed he could do in the 2nd half of last year. In 2007, he had a .296 BA and a .369 OBP. I wouldn't call that a "low batting average".

 

i still don't see him as a "long term solution" for the marlins, he is an average fielder and as the #2 hitter in the lineup he has sucked, last year when he batted .296 he batted farther down in the lineup, I do not blame him as much but more for Fredi putting Hermida in a spot in the lineup where he does not fit, Hermida, in my opinion, strikes out way to much, 83 already this year. I personally think De Aza could've been the long term solution if he wasn't so brittle, and I don't trust Maybin, but I will have to give him a chance since we gave up so much to get him.

Now there is the main problem. Hermida is striking out more than he ever has, mostly because the Marlins want him to be "aggressive" as opposed to being the walk machine who would take a ton of pitches.

 

The real Hermida, who gets on base and doesn't strikeout much. He is the perfect 2 hitter. Maybe more if his power reaches what it is. But I think it is a misrepresentation to say that Hermida is a "low speed, low average, high power" guy.

 

i will believe all those things until he decides to prove me wrong

I feel he proved it by doing it last year.

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

That's the arguable part. A lot of us don't thing that a 2 hitter is supposed to be that, fast and bunting (read giving away outs and making it harder to score runs). I think a 2 hitter should be what Hermida was in the 2nd part of last year. Lots of walks and great at getting on base. Decent speed is good too, which is what Hermida has.

 

We should be trying to put a man at 1st and 2nd with no outs, not a man on 2nd with one out. Keep in mind that the run expectancy with a man on first and no outs is .953 and with a man on 2nd with 1 out is .725.

 

i don't feel the same, he still had a .966 fielding percentage last year, one of the worst in the MLB, his fielding worrys me more than his hitting, he always seems "lazy" when going after a ball.

previous marlins players who succeed at the 2 whole are Amezaga and Castillo, Mark Kotsay i believe batted 2nd, they were all speed guys who could bunt a guy over if needed or bunt for a base hit and has loathes of speed, walks are also important, Castillo was the master of 3-2 counts, while Amezaga always seemed to get on base, Hermida seems like the prototypical #7 hitter, a guy with little speed, low batting average and not bunting ability who can hit a ball in the hole wit runners on 1st and 2nd to score a run.

Just to start, Amezaga has only started 9 games in the 2 spot while with the Fish, so I am going to outright ignor that.

 

Also, in 2003, Luis Castillo only put down the sacrifice bunt in 13 games out of the 143 games he started. His success was based more on the fact that he walked a ton and he struck out very little. He did a great job of getting on base for his 3-4-5 hitters to bring him in.

 

That is the kind of thing that Hermida showed he could do in the 2nd half of last year. In 2007, he had a .296 BA and a .369 OBP. I wouldn't call that a "low batting average".

 

i still don't see him as a "long term solution" for the marlins, he is an average fielder and as the #2 hitter in the lineup he has sucked, last year when he batted .296 he batted farther down in the lineup, I do not blame him as much but more for Fredi putting Hermida in a spot in the lineup where he does not fit, Hermida, in my opinion, strikes out way to much, 83 already this year. I personally think De Aza could've been the long term solution if he wasn't so brittle, and I don't trust Maybin, but I will have to give him a chance since we gave up so much to get him.

Now there is the main problem. Hermida is striking out more than he ever has, mostly because the Marlins want him to be "aggressive" as opposed to being the walk machine who would take a ton of pitches.

 

The real Hermida, who gets on base and doesn't strikeout much. He is the perfect 2 hitter. Maybe more if his power reaches what it is. But I think it is a misrepresentation to say that Hermida is a "low speed, low average, high power" guy.

 

i will believe all those things until he decides to prove me wrong

I feel he proved it by doing it last year.

really? A 2 hitter is supposed to be fast and be able to bunt at all times to advance the runner and be able to spot his hits, Hermida can only pull the ball.

That's the arguable part. A lot of us don't thing that a 2 hitter is supposed to be that, fast and bunting (read giving away outs and making it harder to score runs). I think a 2 hitter should be what Hermida was in the 2nd part of last year. Lots of walks and great at getting on base. Decent speed is good too, which is what Hermida has.

 

We should be trying to put a man at 1st and 2nd with no outs, not a man on 2nd with one out. Keep in mind that the run expectancy with a man on first and no outs is .953 and with a man on 2nd with 1 out is .725.

 

 

previous marlins players who succeed at the 2 whole are Amezaga and Castillo, Mark Kotsay i believe batted 2nd, they were all speed guys who could bunt a guy over if needed or bunt for a base hit and has loathes of speed, walks are also important, Castillo was the master of 3-2 counts, while Amezaga always seemed to get on base, Hermida seems like the prototypical #7 hitter, a guy with little speed, low batting average and not bunting ability who can hit a ball in the hole wit runners on 1st and 2nd to score a run.

Just to start, Amezaga has only started 9 games in the 2 spot while with the Fish, so I am going to outright ignor that.

 

Also, in 2003, Luis Castillo only put down the sacrifice bunt in 13 games out of the 143 games he started. His success was based more on the fact that he walked a ton and he struck out very little. He did a great job of getting on base for his 3-4-5 hitters to bring him in.

 

That is the kind of thing that Hermida showed he could do in the 2nd half of last year. In 2007, he had a .296 BA and a .369 OBP. I wouldn't call that a "low batting average".

 

i still don't see him as a "long term solution" for the marlins, he is an average fielder and as the #2 hitter in the lineup he has sucked, last year when he batted .296 he batted farther down in the lineup, I do not blame him as much but more for Fredi putting Hermida in a spot in the lineup where he does not fit, Hermida, in my opinion, strikes out way to much, 83 already this year. I personally think De Aza could've been the long term solution if he wasn't so brittle, and I don't trust Maybin, but I will have to give him a chance since we gave up so much to get him.

 

Why dont you trust maybin?

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

 

Cody Ross is having a better year than any of the guys you mentioned. It's not crazy to say it. It's certainly debatable.

He's having a better year (I would argue that Cantu is having a better year), but I don't believe he is a better player.

 

That said, maybe you are right, it's not that crazy.

 

Not if you take defense into account. Cody is having a good year with the glove.

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

 

Out of all our OF you pick Ross to have a problem with?

When did he not have enough speed to track down a ball, from what I have seen he has had plenty of speed. If it's anyone you should be saying that about it's Hermida, and his lackadaisical strides and his 3 second ball pick up and throw.

Ross' future has a gold glove in it. :thumbup

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

 

Cody Ross is having a better year than any of the guys you mentioned. It's not crazy to say it. It's certainly debatable.

He's having a better year (I would argue that Cantu is having a better year), but I don't believe he is a better player.

 

That said, maybe you are right, it's not that crazy.

 

Not if you take defense into account. Cody is having a good year with the glove.

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

 

Out of all our OF you pick Ross to have a problem with?

When did he not have enough speed to track down a ball, from what I have seen he has had plenty of speed. If it's anyone you should be saying that about it's Hermida, and his lackadaisical strides and his 3 second ball pick up and throw.

Ross' future has a gold glove in it. :thumbup

 

No, out of the only person we were talking about previously, I picked Cody. It would be dumb to take a conversation about Cody Ross and suddenly go "Hermida sucks!". Who would do that?...

 

And historically, Cody has had below average range out in centerfield, as Nny posted above. Though, it has been proven to me that he has really expanded his zone this year.

 

You make it seem as if I had something against Cody Ross, even though it is widely known that I love Cody, and have claimed many times to have started the first Co-Dy chant.

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

 

Cody Ross is having a better year than any of the guys you mentioned. It's not crazy to say it. It's certainly debatable.

He's having a better year (I would argue that Cantu is having a better year), but I don't believe he is a better player.

 

That said, maybe you are right, it's not that crazy.

 

Not if you take defense into account. Cody is having a good year with the glove.

My problem with Cody's defense is that he doesn't cover nearly enough room out there in center. He has great instincts out there and takes beautiful routes, but he just doesn't have the natural speed to cover all that room at the DS.

 

Out of all our OF you pick Ross to have a problem with?

When did he not have enough speed to track down a ball, from what I have seen he has had plenty of speed. If it's anyone you should be saying that about it's Hermida, and his lackadaisical strides and his 3 second ball pick up and throw.

Ross' future has a gold glove in it. :thumbup

 

No, out of the only person we were talking about previously, I picked Cody. It would be dumb to take a conversation about Cody Ross and suddenly go "Hermida sucks!". Who would do that?...

 

And historically, Cody has had below average range out in centerfield, as Nny posted above. Though, it has been proven to me that he has really expanded his zone this year.

 

You make it seem as if I had something against Cody Ross, even though it is widely known that I love Cody, and have claimed many times to have started the first Co-Dy chant.

 

Were talking about the present, not the past. I know you love stats but the stats dont always follow a certain player to his future, which is "JUST ANOTHER" reason why stats mean nothing.

 

It seems to me your more of a Hermida fan overall after reading the thread above, correct me if I am wrong. :mis2

 

I just dont understand why you would call out Cody's play and "range" in CF..."NOW" of all times, are you watching the games?

 

He is a stud in CF, but I assume to you, next year he will go back to being an average CF'er.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.