Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Jeremy Hermida

Featured Replies

How come you guys werent saying anything when jeremy hermida had that 12 game hitting streak? Seriousley, you have to show some patience. The talent is there, it's just taking him a little longer to use his talents and become the great hitter we know he can. And Mungo, how the hell is he a bust? He showed that he can play at a very high level against good competition. To me that isnt a bust.

 

He has never done it on a consistant basis. Until he does that, stays healthy for a full year and hits more than 17 or 18 HR's, I'll believe he is worth what we drafted him at. Unless he does that he is a bust.

 

 

He hit 18 HRs last year and had a .297 average, so i dont know where you're going with that.

The general approach at the plate has had a negative effect on Hermida. You know that Pressley has a very aggressive approach for the hitters on the team. Hermida is often trying to hit too many home runs or doubles and its showing with his dramatic increase in strike outs. This is not the kind of player he is, or should try to be. He can hit the long ball, yes, but he's a guy who should have a high average, high on base, good at bats, makes contact, is patient at the plate, etc. We don't NEED him to be a home run hitter, we have plenty of those. He's built as more of a line drive guy.

 

If Pressley has an aggressive hitting approach then we need a new hitting coach, enough said.

Most high-value prospects would be looking at a rookie year right now. I also think that the Marlins are f***ing with his plate approach trying to make him disciplinedaggressive, and as a result they are turning walks into Ks, the Reds did the same thing to Paul O'Neill and he didn't flourish until he got away from them and was allowed to approach the game on his terms.

 

 

EDIT: Typo fixed

Career OPS in parenthesis

 

 

Tony Gwynn, 23 years old, .727 OPS (.847)

Paul O'Neill, 23 years old, 14 ABs (.833)

Mark Grace, 23 years old, minor leagues (.825)

Jim Edmonds, 23 years old, 61 ABs, .614 OPS (.904)

Kenny Lofton, 23 years old, Tuscon Toro.... traded for Eddie Taubensee (.795)

Sean Casey, 23 years old, 1/2 season, .792 OPS; less than Hermida's 75% of a season at age 23 (.818)

Hal Morris, 23 years old, 20 ABs (.794)

Sean Green, 23 years old, .790 OPS (.849)

 

Sean Green, Vernon Wells and Rondell White are the most similar current-era batters through 23 years old. I think those guys are OK.

and rightfully so. Hermida is NOT a bust and to suggest that is outright stupid. He is a cornerstone and future building block of this franchise. I consider him more valuable to our future than Uggla.

 

You have your opinion and I have mine, and we'll see what happens in the 2nd half. But from where he was picked he needs to hit .280 - .290, smack in 25+ HR's and have at least 120 RBI at this point in his career, to make him worthy of where we picked him.

 

Just to show how colossally stupid and ignorant you truly are, and how absolutely f***ing ridiculous your expectations for this kid are, I did a search on Baseball reference to find the number of seasons in which a batter between the ages of 23-25 had at least 25 homers, a .290 BA, and 120 RBI.

 

Out of, the approximately, 18,000 individual seasons that have been played while a player was 23-25 in the history of the game, there have been 51 seasons like the one you described.

 

In other words, you want Hermida to produce at a level that has been attained by .2% of all players ever?

 

God damn, I wish I could just ban you forever, you f***ing troll.

Career OPS in parenthesis

 

 

Tony Gwynn, 23 years old, .727 OPS (.847)

Paul O'Neill, 23 years old, 14 ABs (.833)

Mark Grace, 23 years old, minor leagues (.825)

Jim Edmonds, 23 years old, 61 ABs, .614 OPS (.904)

Kenny Lofton, 23 years old, Tuscon Toro.... traded for Eddie Taubensee (.795)

Sean Casey, 23 years old, 1/2 season, .792 OPS; less than Hermida's 75% of a season at age 22 (.818)

Hal Morris, 23 years old, 20 ABs (.794)

Sean Green, 23 years old, .790 OPS (.849)

 

Sean Green, Vernon Wells and Rondell White are the most similar current-era batters through 23 years old. I think those guys are OK.

 

I did a similar experiment last season, and there's nothing to appease the Hermida haters. Whatever.

How come you guys werent saying anything when jeremy hermida had that 12 game hitting streak? Seriousley, you have to show some patience. The talent is there, it's just taking him a little longer to use his talents and become the great hitter we know he can. And Mungo, how the hell is he a bust? He showed that he can play at a very high level against good competition. To me that isnt a bust.

 

He has never done it on a consistant basis. Until he does that, stays healthy for a full year and hits more than 17 or 18 HR's, I'll believe he is worth what we drafted him at. Unless he does that he is a bust.

Well, he's been healthy basically all this year and is on pace for 18 home runs.

 

And he's tied for 21st out of 25 RFs in OPS.

 

He has stunk this year.

His OPS+ at 11 out of 16 in the NL (I don't like to compare between leagues). That's in front of Jeff Francoeur, Ken Griffey Jr, Geoff Jenkins, Hunter Pence, and Austin Kearns.

 

He's within 10 points of Randy Winn, Kosuke Fukudome, Justin Upton, and Andre Eithier.

 

He hasn't been great, but his .737 OPS is only .002 under league average. I wouldn't say he has "stunk".

He has been exceptionally not good this year. I'm the biggest Hermida defender on the board, and I'll admit that much.

 

That said, just like last year, I expect it to be much higher by the end.

How come you guys werent saying anything when jeremy hermida had that 12 game hitting streak? Seriousley, you have to show some patience. The talent is there, it's just taking him a little longer to use his talents and become the great hitter we know he can. And Mungo, how the hell is he a bust? He showed that he can play at a very high level against good competition. To me that isnt a bust.

 

He has never done it on a consistant basis. Until he does that, stays healthy for a full year and hits more than 17 or 18 HR's, I'll believe he is worth what we drafted him at. Unless he does that he is a bust.

Well, he's been healthy basically all this year and is on pace for 18 home runs.

 

And he's tied for 21st out of 25 RFs in OPS.

 

He has stunk this year.

His OPS+ at 11 out of 16 in the NL (I don't like to compare between leagues). That's in front of Jeff Francoeur, Ken Griffey Jr, Geoff Jenkins, Hunter Pence, and Austin Kearns.

 

He's within 10 points of Randy Winn, Kosuke Fukudome, Justin Upton, and Andre Eithier.

 

He hasn't been great, but his .737 OPS is only .002 under league average. I wouldn't say he has "stunk".

 

There's nothing wrong in comparing hitters across the leagues. You're using guys with fewer than qualifying ABs. I don't like doing that except for catchers. I dont know what you mean by 10 points. Do you mean 10 OPS+ points? If yes, 10 OPS+ points is a lot. Ethier's OPS+ is 12 higher than Hermida's. Also, I would want my RF to hit more than the league average that inlcludes pitchers and catchers.

Okay my point is that Jake is a better player than Hermida and is a fan favorite.

 

1. Jake is not a better player than Hermida

 

2. Jake is in no way a fan favorite.

 

1. Jake is a better player. Hermida is a joke defensively(Jake aint so good either), buta pretty respectable bat and with time can really turn out in our favor. Jake is always getting injured, and since we already have Willingham with chronic back whatevers... I dont think there is enough room for two spots to be covered on the IR, and clearly a healthy Willingham is better than a healthy Jacobs so that arguement is done. If its between Hermida and Jake... Id take the more durable but less talented Hermida, especially because Jakes value is higher in a trade, IMO. Get a better return, but we dont have enough room for two starters in this future to be constantly on the IR/DL. Jacobs value is more now, proabably entering his prime, than Hermida's is, but Hermida is only 24.

 

2. Jake is not a fan favorite. Neither is Hermida. Hanley, Uggla, Amezaga, are fan favorites.

 

1) Wrong, Jake is not respectable with the bat. He sucks. The man is hitting .242 with an OBP of .280. He couldn't get on base to save his life. The only thing that saves him is that every once in a while a flyout will be a home run. Besides that, he has nothing. He has no patience at the plate and is one of the worst defensive firstbaseman in baseball.

 

Hermida, on the other hand, is hitting .255 with an OBP of .326. Not great, but nowhere near as bad as Jacobs. Hermida hasn't been terrible this year, his OPS+ is 97, which shows that he has been about average (yes, I know that Jake's is higher, but that's all slugging and no OBP.) On the other end, Hermida's defense has improved, he makes less of those bonehead moves than last year and less errors to show for it . He has good range, good speed, and a good arm.

 

2) Go to the stadium. Wait till they announce Jeremy...the ladies love cool J.

 

 

1) Read it again, I said Hermida is respectable with a bat. I claimed everything you did, you are on my side here... so I dont know what you are trying to start.

 

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

I think Hermida can definitely hit many more home runs if he swings for the fence in every at bat. Hermida has shown his power, he's just more disciplined than Jake. I would like to see Dallas up soon; he's absolutely killing it in AAA. And lets not mention how Jake gets injured every season as well. Honestly, I really like Jacobs on the team. The begin the season, he was very out spoken and let everyone know that he expected to win. Since the Town Hall meeting at fan fest he said he was here to play and play hard. But his inability to field his position is nerve wrecking at times. If he was still raking like he was to start the season then it makes it a little acceptable. But with the situation the team is in, I think it only makes sense to trade Jake................ And Rabelo, I can't stand that guy...lol

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

 

why would it be so crazy to say that... Cody hasn't had enough time in the bigs to prove he can be "better" than those players

I don't know what you guys have noticed but Jake's productivity has gone way down and Hermida is still producing. In fact, he was big for yesterday. Sounds pretty solid to me. Plus, Jake bobbled a ball the other day so I would definitely keep Hermida.

Most high-value prospects would be looking at a rookie year right now. I also think that the Marlins are f***ing with his plate approach trying to make him aggressive, and as a result they are turning walks into Ks, the Reds did the same thing to Paul O'Neill and he didn't flourish until he got away from them and was allowed to approach the game on his terms.

 

 

this is what I'm really scared of, when you compare to where he was before in discipline to where he is now....

Hermida's not going anywhere. It's not like we'd get too terribly much for him, either.

and rightfully so. Hermida is NOT a bust and to suggest that is outright stupid. He is a cornerstone and future building block of this franchise. I consider him more valuable to our future than Uggla.

 

You have your opinion and I have mine, and we'll see what happens in the 2nd half. But from where he was picked he needs to hit .280 - .290, smack in 25+ HR's and have at least 120 RBI at this point in his career, to make him worthy of where we picked him.

 

Just to show how colossally stupid and ignorant you truly are, and how absolutely f***ing ridiculous your expectations for this kid are, I did a search on Baseball reference to find the number of seasons in which a batter between the ages of 23-25 had at least 25 homers, a .290 BA, and 120 RBI.

 

Out of, the approximately, 18,000 individual seasons that have been played while a player was 23-25 in the history of the game, there have been 51 seasons like the one you described.

 

In other words, you want Hermida to produce at a level that has been attained by .2% of all players ever?

 

God damn, I wish I could just ban you forever, you f***ing troll.

 

Hey, Mungo. I'm talking to you.

2) I dont think because ladies think Hermida is cute that he is a fan favorite. A fan favorite is loved because of character and skill.

A fan favorite is a favorite player of the fans. It really has nothing to do with "character and skill."

 

It would be crazy to say that Cody Ross is better than Hermida, or even Cantu and Willingham, but there is no arguing that Cody is a fan favorite.

 

I never said he wasnt... why would you even argue that when I clearly put Amezaga, definately not one of the best players, on my small list? Cody Ross is, the fans love him, because he is able to hit a HR at the right time. Of course there is tons to do with character... and skill. You think the fans like players that suck? No. You think the fans like boring players? No. Mike Jacobs is a boring character. Alfredo Amezaga is a fun character. You wouldnt see Hermida's hermies, the flying whitey, or the crowd chanting Jeremy like they do with all the others night in and night out.

Okay my point is that Jake is a better player than Hermida and is a fan favorite.

 

Stats Minor Leagues:

Maybin: .265, 12 HR, 38 RBI, 17 SB, 99 K

(2007)Carroll: 22 HR 82 RBI, .572 SLG

 

Hermida: .255, 10HR, 42RBI, 3SB, 83 K

 

I think you will be in a very small minority with that opinion.

You said Jacobs is a more talented hitter. That's crazy.

 

Ok you reversed that, I said Hermida is less talented(at his current state, I also said with time he can be really good) but if you will, then power, not talent.

Most high-value prospects would be looking at a rookie year right now. I also think that the Marlins are f***ing with his plate approach trying to make him aggressive, and as a result they are turning walks into Ks, the Reds did the same thing to Paul O'Neill and he didn't flourish until he got away from them and was allowed to approach the game on his terms.

 

 

this is what I'm really scared of, when you compare to where he was before in discipline to where he is now....

Can you explain?

 

I ask because last year after the break he had a walk every 10.7 ABs and this year he has a walk every 10.4 ABs so he's walking a bit more than he did during the one extended period of time that he had success in the majors.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.