July 18, 200818 yr Okay from what I heard there are rumors they might trade Jake for a reliever but in my opinion they should trade Hermida. Jake has almost the same average more HR and RBI and you know Jake will hit you 30+ HR each year if healthy.
July 18, 200818 yr If you trade Hermida what would the outfield be next year? Gonzo? May retire Ross? Good chance he becomes everyday player Maybin? Is he ready? I just don't know
July 18, 200818 yr LF: Willingham CF: Maybin/Carroll/Amezaga RF: Ross Okay, but that centerfield tandem is a real gamble. We know Amexaga can play out there but having him start really depletes the bench. Carroll has yet to prove he is a major leaguer at the plate (but I do love his defense). Maybin strikes out about 1/3 of his plate appeaances in AA.
July 18, 200818 yr Author Okay my point is that Jake is a better player than Hermida and is a fan favorite. Stats Minor Leagues: Maybin: .265, 12 HR, 38 RBI, 17 SB, 99 K (2007)Carroll: 22 HR 82 RBI, .572 SLG Hermida: .255, 10HR, 42RBI, 3SB, 83 K
July 18, 200818 yr Keep Hermida and lose Jacobs. As for outfielders next year, Maybin is still a question and may need another year of work in the minors. DeAza will be back. Look out for John Raynor. Playing well in Carolina. Could get a look in the spring.
July 18, 200818 yr Remember Hermida hit over .360 in the second half last year, let's see how he plays over the next couple weeks.
July 18, 200818 yr forget mcpherson for now.anyway it would be better trading hermida hes played 3 seasons hes constantly been hurt and when hes not hurt hes playing bad defense and dosent hit for a high average or rbis.gonzo will proboblay retire but u can always move amezaga to right field. then u could callup mcpherson. :whistle :shifty :whistle :thumbup :shifty :cool :notworthy :blink: :mis2
July 18, 200818 yr Okay my point is that Jake is a better player than Hermida and is a fan favorite. 1. Jake is not a better player than Hermida 2. Jake is in no way a fan favorite.
July 18, 200818 yr how is jake not a better player than hermida and not a fan favorite??????? Jake is a feast or famine hitter that famines more often than not and he's a terrible first baseman. Hermida can hit for a decent average and still has potential to get better.
July 18, 200818 yr Both Hermida and Jacobs are below average fielders and strike out way tooooo much, Hermida has shown he can hit for a higher average, but Jacobs has more power. Hermida's biggest strike IMO is his ability to stay healthy, especially during ST when everyone else who has to earn a spot on the team is busting their a$$e$, he's nursing a boo boo. I wouldn't trade either of them at this time, but of the two it would hurt the team less to move Jacobs.
July 18, 200818 yr Okay from what I heard there are rumors they might trade Jake for a reliever but in my opinion they should trade Hermida. Your opinion is wrong. Edit: and you shouldn't be allowed to have one.
July 18, 200818 yr Okay my point is that Jake is a better player than Hermida and is a fan favorite. :lol Funny way to start my day
July 18, 200818 yr i should not be able to have a opinion? At least you got one thing correct in this thread. Keep up the good work. :thumbup
July 18, 200818 yr Hermida has more potential. And we already have a replacement for Jacobs. That, alone, makes me like Hermida more.
July 18, 200818 yr how is jake not a better player than hermida and not a fan favorite??????? I'll tell you what, if we trade Jacobs, you can be in front when we rush the stadium with torches. :thumbup
July 18, 200818 yr Keep in mind Jake's OBP is .280! Hanley and Uggla's batting averages are higher than that! Herm's OBP is much better at .326. He always looks bored and probably lacks heart, but Hermida has the ability to work the count and get on base via the walk. Jake swings for the fences in every at-bat, and when he does walk, it's usually intentional. And I think Jeremy's defense has improved drastically over the last few years (and has a pretty good arm). Jake...not so much.
July 18, 200818 yr Author something I like about Jake is that he alwys tries hes best no matter the situation, you guys need to remember he was a catcher before and eventually he will be an above average first baseman with a decent arm , while Hermida never runs full speed in the outfield, Ks to much, and the only good thing is his arm cause he does not give you 20 Hr, will not drive you in 100 RBI, and cant hit .300 and does not steal bases.
July 18, 200818 yr something I like about Jake is that he alwys tries hes best no matter the situation, you guys need to remember he was a catcher before and eventually he will be an above average first baseman with a decent arm , while Hermida never runs full speed in the outfield, Ks to much, and the only good thing is his arm cause he does not give you 20 Hr, will not drive you in 100 RBI, and cant hit .300 and does not steal bases. This is cute... really, very much so... I'm too tired still to get this, Rabb, Benched, Puma... where are you guys for this, he put it on a tee for ya
July 18, 200818 yr something I like about Jake is that he alwys tries hes best no matter the situation, you guys need to remember he was a catcher before and eventually he will be an above average first baseman with a decent arm , while Hermida never runs full speed in the outfield, Ks to much, and the only good thing is his arm cause he does not give you 20 Hr, will not drive you in 100 RBI, and cant hit .300 and does not steal bases. Hermida could outrun Jake walking, Jake has 73 K's in 50 less at-bats than Hermida's 83 K's (a whopping 10-K difference), Hermida hit 18hr last year while missing significant playing time, Jake has never driven in 100 rbi either and the closest he's been is 77, Jake has never hit .300 except for 100ab audition for the Mets, and really? Jake steals bases? Hermida's 3 steals triple Jake's production. And I try real hard to sing well, but that doesn't mean I can sing. God bless Jake for trying, but trying without results means you just aren't that good. And please don't tell me Jake hits HRs, that's something I looked at when I traded baseball cards at 10 years old.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.