July 18, 200818 yr And then we realize that the other option was still John Kerry... :whistle But that's for a different forum. You truly believe we are better off with The Bushmeister ? :banghead :banghead :banghead But yes, for another forum.
July 18, 200818 yr I thionk i voeted for jake thinkin who would i want to trade. I want to keep hermida I won't vote on it because its just a dumb question. I would rather keep Hermida of the two, but really want both to be gone. One is just a bad MLB player, the other is a huge draft bust.
July 18, 200818 yr and rightfully so. Hermida is NOT a bust and to suggest that is outright stupid. He is a cornerstone and future building block of this franchise. I consider him more valuable to our future than Uggla. You have your opinion and I have mine, and we'll see what happens in the 2nd half. But from where he was picked he needs to hit .280 - .290, smack in 25+ HR's and have at least 120 RBI at this point in his career, to make him worthy of where we picked him. It's not like he was the #1 overall pick. He was the number 11 pick, still high, but still a High Schooler who must thought was the most polished hitter in the draft. The player taken before him was Drew Meyer (see, this is a bust, I don't think you understand what the word means) and the player after was Joe Saunders. And those stats you put up as to what he should be hitting, he nearly put up those numbers in 120 games last season (minus the RBIs) showing he is capable of doing it.
July 18, 200818 yr Hermida has so much talent that we haven't seen yet Why is he holding it back then ? Its time guys to admit he is is a bust. He should have been a 3rd or 4th round pick and no better than that. I mean he's no Josh Booty or Marc Valdes, but he is pretty bad for a 1st round, supposedly cannot-miss prospect. Even if he is a bust, i'll still take him over Jacobs. The point of this thread isn't whether or not Hermida is a bust, it's to see if you think Jacobs is better.
July 18, 200818 yr Hermida is just having an off year hes a good player nothing great. You cannot really expect the Marlins to trade him away he plays a solid right field. Jacobs has shown the same thing for a few years now Home Run numbers, poor defense belongs in the AL as a DH imo.
July 18, 200818 yr Okay my point is that Jake is a better player than Hermida and is a fan favorite. 1. Jake is not a better player than Hermida 2. Jake is in no way a fan favorite. 1. Jake is a better player. Hermida is a joke defensively(Jake aint so good either), buta pretty respectable bat and with time can really turn out in our favor. Jake is always getting injured, and since we already have Willingham with chronic back whatevers... I dont think there is enough room for two spots to be covered on the IR, and clearly a healthy Willingham is better than a healthy Jacobs so that arguement is done. If its between Hermida and Jake... Id take the more durable but less talented Hermida, especially because Jakes value is higher in a trade, IMO. Get a better return, but we dont have enough room for two starters in this future to be constantly on the IR/DL. Jacobs value is more now, proabably entering his prime, than Hermida's is, but Hermida is only 24. 2. Jake is not a fan favorite. Neither is Hermida. Hanley, Uggla, Amezaga, are fan favorites.
July 18, 200818 yr Okay my point is that Jake is a better player than Hermida and is a fan favorite. 1. Jake is not a better player than Hermida 2. Jake is in no way a fan favorite. 1. Jake is a better player. Hermida is a joke defensively(Jake aint so good either), buta pretty respectable bat and with time can really turn out in our favor. Jake is always getting injured, and since we already have Willingham with chronic back whatevers... I dont think there is enough room for two spots to be covered on the IR, and clearly a healthy Willingham is better than a healthy Jacobs so that arguement is done. If its between Hermida and Jake... Id take the more durable but less talented Hermida, especially because Jakes value is higher in a trade, IMO. Get a better return, but we dont have enough room for two starters in this future to be constantly on the IR/DL. Jacobs value is more now, proabably entering his prime, than Hermida's is, but Hermida is only 24. 2. Jake is not a fan favorite. Neither is Hermida. Hanley, Uggla, Amezaga, are fan favorites. 1) Wrong, Jake is not respectable with the bat. He sucks. The man is hitting .242 with an OBP of .280. He couldn't get on base to save his life. The only thing that saves him is that every once in a while a flyout will be a home run. Besides that, he has nothing. He has no patience at the plate and is one of the worst defensive firstbaseman in baseball. Hermida, on the other hand, is hitting .255 with an OBP of .326. Not great, but nowhere near as bad as Jacobs. Hermida hasn't been terrible this year, his OPS+ is 97, which shows that he has been about average (yes, I know that Jake's is higher, but that's all slugging and no OBP.) On the other end, Hermida's defense has improved, he makes less of those bonehead moves than last year and less errors to show for it . He has good range, good speed, and a good arm. 2) Go to the stadium. Wait till they announce Jeremy...the ladies love cool J.
July 18, 200818 yr and rightfully so. Hermida is NOT a bust and to suggest that is outright stupid. He is a cornerstone and future building block of this franchise. I consider him more valuable to our future than Uggla. You have your opinion and I have mine, and we'll see what happens in the 2nd half. But from where he was picked he needs to hit .280 - .290, smack in 25+ HR's and have at least 120 RBI at this point in his career, to make him worthy of where we picked him. :lol 120 RBI's? Even many superstars don't reach that milestone. Plus, it's more of a team stat, than it is an individual stat.
July 18, 200818 yr Not saying this is 100% fair, but compare Uggla's numbers as a 23 year old in Single A ball to Hermida as a 23 year old in the majors. I'll even post them, since I'm nice like that - Uggla: 134 games 23 HR, 46 walks, .290 BA, .355 OBP .504 SLG .859 OPS Hermida: 123 games 18 HR 47 walks .296 BA, 369 OBP .501 SLG . 870 OPS :notworthy Patience people, patience! Plus, Uggla's trade value couldn't be any higher right now, and knowing Loria, he probably won't sign him. (especially with a prospect in Chris Coghlan, waiting in the minors). I totally agree with The_Godfather. But we can't afford patience !!! :banghead Don't you people get the fact this guys have to produce for us NOW when they are here, because once he is arbitration eligible he will be gone !!! That is why its stupid to be drafting so many HS kids, as opposed to College players, and this is another drafting mistake by Beinfest. He needs to get college players that are closer to MLB ready, so he can take advantage of their prime time and then trade them because Loria won't pay them. If Hermida doesn't blossom until he is 27-28 it will be too late for us. You're right! Lets not be patient...look at the Mets, for example...they're doing really great. They're a whole 1.5 games better than us with 1 player in the farm system. AWESOME! Or...like the Yankees. Buying and buying really got them far in the 80's! You have to be patient with prospects to have long-term success. There's still time for Hermida to become a good player (he showed great flashes last year in the 2nd half).
July 18, 200818 yr and rightfully so. Hermida is NOT a bust and to suggest that is outright stupid. He is a cornerstone and future building block of this franchise. I consider him more valuable to our future than Uggla. You have your opinion and I have mine, and we'll see what happens in the 2nd half. But from where he was picked he needs to hit .280 - .290, smack in 25+ HR's and have at least 120 RBI at this point in his career, to make him worthy of where we picked him. :lol 120 RBI's? Even many superstars don't reach that milestone. Plus, it's more of a team stat, than it is an individual stat. HE DOESN'T HAVE 120 AR BE EYES YET?! f***, nevermind. Looking at last year's stats, we actually need to trade: The Roster.
July 18, 200818 yr How come you guys werent saying anything when jeremy hermida had that 12 game hitting streak? Seriousley, you have to show some patience. The talent is there, it's just taking him a little longer to use his talents and become the great hitter we know he can. And Mungo, how the hell is he a bust? He showed that he can play at a very high level against good competition. To me that isnt a bust.
July 18, 200818 yr How come you guys werent saying anything when jeremy hermida had that 12 game hitting streak? Seriousley, you have to show some patience. The talent is there, it's just taking him a little longer to use his talents and become the great hitter we know he can. And Mungo, how the hell is he a bust? He showed that he can play at a very high level against good competition. To me that isnt a bust. To have patience you must have Andrew Miller.
July 18, 200818 yr Not saying this is 100% fair, but compare Uggla's numbers as a 23 year old in Single A ball to Hermida as a 23 year old in the majors. I'll even post them, since I'm nice like that - Uggla: 134 games 23 HR, 46 walks, .290 BA, .355 OBP .504 SLG .859 OPS Hermida: 123 games 18 HR 47 walks .296 BA, 369 OBP .501 SLG . 870 OPS :notworthy Patience people, patience! Plus, Uggla's trade value couldn't be any higher right now, and knowing Loria, he probably won't sign him. (especially with a prospect in Chris Coghlan, waiting in the minors). I totally agree with The_Godfather. But we can't afford patience !!! :banghead Don't you people get the fact this guys have to produce for us NOW when they are here, because once he is arbitration eligible he will be gone !!! That is why its stupid to be drafting so many HS kids, as opposed to College players, and this is another drafting mistake by Beinfest. He needs to get college players that are closer to MLB ready, so he can take advantage of their prime time and then trade them because Loria won't pay them. If Hermida doesn't blossom until he is 27-28 it will be too late for us. You're right! Lets not be patient...look at the Mets, for example...they're doing really great. They're a whole 1.5 games better than us with 1 player in the farm system. AWESOME! Or...like the Yankees. Buying and buying really got them far in the 80's! You have to be patient with prospects to have long-term success. There's still time for Hermida to become a good player (he showed great flashes last year in the 2nd half). What part of "he won't be here when he is 27-28 and in his prime" do you not get ? If he blossoms then he will be in his 6th or 7th season, and into a multi-year deal. That is something the Marlins will not be doing for a guy that hasn't shown the potential. Hanley is an exception rather than what can be expected as the rule for the future of this franchise. How long will it take you folks to understand this ????? How many guys have to leave til you realize we are the East Coast version of the Oakland A's ????
July 18, 200818 yr How come you guys werent saying anything when jeremy hermida had that 12 game hitting streak? Seriousley, you have to show some patience. The talent is there, it's just taking him a little longer to use his talents and become the great hitter we know he can. And Mungo, how the hell is he a bust? He showed that he can play at a very high level against good competition. To me that isnt a bust. He has never done it on a consistant basis. Until he does that, stays healthy for a full year and hits more than 17 or 18 HR's, I'll believe he is worth what we drafted him at. Unless he does that he is a bust.
July 18, 200818 yr How come you guys werent saying anything when jeremy hermida had that 12 game hitting streak? Seriousley, you have to show some patience. The talent is there, it's just taking him a little longer to use his talents and become the great hitter we know he can. And Mungo, how the hell is he a bust? He showed that he can play at a very high level against good competition. To me that isnt a bust. He has never done it on a consistant basis. Until he does that, stays healthy for a full year and hits more than 17 or 18 HR's, I'll believe he is worth what we drafted him at. Unless he does that he is a bust. I have to agree with Mungo to a point... Hermida is just an average to good player... nothing great, nothing awful. (IMO)
July 18, 200818 yr 2) Go to the stadium. Wait till they announce Jeremy...the ladies love cool J. LOL--What is the deal with that? It wasn't like that the last few years. I haven't been to Miami this year, but I saw on tv some teenagers wearing "Hermida's Hotties" tank tops (Which is a total knockoff of Horford's Hotties). And they might have been the same girls I saw at the Trop last month with teal halter tops that said Hermida on the back. I guess every team needs a hearthrob. I'm more of an Amezaga girl But back to the point, Jeremy got into a groove at the plate in the second half last year. I wouldn't give up on him just yet. And I like that he's not all about power. When he runs into a homer, you can tell that he does have some serious power, but he doesn't make that his whole game -- that's a good thing. Jake will never learn plate discipline, and I'd rather see Cantu playing first and Dallas at third.
July 18, 200818 yr How come you guys werent saying anything when jeremy hermida had that 12 game hitting streak? Seriousley, you have to show some patience. The talent is there, it's just taking him a little longer to use his talents and become the great hitter we know he can. And Mungo, how the hell is he a bust? He showed that he can play at a very high level against good competition. To me that isnt a bust. He has never done it on a consistant basis. Until he does that, stays healthy for a full year and hits more than 17 or 18 HR's, I'll believe he is worth what we drafted him at. Unless he does that he is a bust. Well, he's been healthy basically all this year and is on pace for 18 home runs.
July 18, 200818 yr LOL--What is the deal with that? It wasn't like that the last few years. I haven't been to Miami this year, but I saw on tv some teenagers wearing "Hermida's Hotties" tank tops (Which is a total knockoff of Horford's Hotties). And they might have been the same girls I saw at the Trop last month with teal halter tops that said Hermida on the back. I guess every team needs a heartthob. I'm more of an Amezaga girl But back to the point, Jeremy got into a groove at the plate in the second half last year. I wouldn't give up on him just yet. And I like that he's not all about power. When he runs into a homer, you can tell that he does have some serious power, but he doesn't make that his whole game -- that's a good thing. Jake will never learn plate discipline, and I'd rather see Cantu playing first and Dallas at third. It's because he is jacked on the Marlins video screen and he has a tiny head...
July 18, 200818 yr Most high-value prospects would be looking at a rookie year right now. I also think that the Marlins are f***ing with his plate approach trying to make him aggressive, and as a result they are turning walks into Ks, the Reds did the same thing to Paul O'Neill and he didn't flourish until he got away from them and was allowed to approach the game on his terms.
July 18, 200818 yr Most high-value prospects would be looking at a rookie year right now. I also think that the Marlins are f***ing with his plate approach trying to make him disciplined, and as a result they are turning walks into Ks, the Reds did the same thing to Paul O'Neill and he didn't flourish until he got away from them and was allowed to approach the game on his terms. I thought they told him he was being too patient in the minors and wanted him to be more aggressive.
July 18, 200818 yr Most high-value prospects would be looking at a rookie year right now. I also think that the Marlins are f***ing with his plate approach trying to make him disciplined, and as a result they are turning walks into Ks, the Reds did the same thing to Paul O'Neill and he didn't flourish until he got away from them and was allowed to approach the game on his terms. I thought they told him he was being too patient in the minors and wanted him to be more aggressive. Yeah. That is stupid. That kind of thinking makes you Mike Jacobs.
July 18, 200818 yr Not saying this is 100% fair, but compare Uggla's numbers as a 23 year old in Single A ball to Hermida as a 23 year old in the majors. I'll even post them, since I'm nice like that - Uggla: 134 games 23 HR, 46 walks, .290 BA, .355 OBP .504 SLG .859 OPS Hermida: 123 games 18 HR 47 walks .296 BA, 369 OBP .501 SLG . 870 OPS :notworthy Patience people, patience! Plus, Uggla's trade value couldn't be any higher right now, and knowing Loria, he probably won't sign him. (especially with a prospect in Chris Coghlan, waiting in the minors). I totally agree with The_Godfather. But we can't afford patience !!! :banghead Don't you people get the fact this guys have to produce for us NOW when they are here, because once he is arbitration eligible he will be gone !!! That is why its stupid to be drafting so many HS kids, as opposed to College players, and this is another drafting mistake by Beinfest. He needs to get college players that are closer to MLB ready, so he can take advantage of their prime time and then trade them because Loria won't pay them. If Hermida doesn't blossom until he is 27-28 it will be too late for us. You're right! Lets not be patient...look at the Mets, for example...they're doing really great. They're a whole 1.5 games better than us with 1 player in the farm system. AWESOME! Or...like the Yankees. Buying and buying really got them far in the 80's! You have to be patient with prospects to have long-term success. There's still time for Hermida to become a good player (he showed great flashes last year in the 2nd half). What part of "he won't be here when he is 27-28 and in his prime" do you not get ? and what is your point? 27-28 is 3-4 years from now. Hermida might be a much better player then...which would increase his trade value, if need be. There's no point in trading him now.
July 18, 200818 yr How come you guys werent saying anything when jeremy hermida had that 12 game hitting streak? Seriousley, you have to show some patience. The talent is there, it's just taking him a little longer to use his talents and become the great hitter we know he can. And Mungo, how the hell is he a bust? He showed that he can play at a very high level against good competition. To me that isnt a bust. He has never done it on a consistant basis. Until he does that, stays healthy for a full year and hits more than 17 or 18 HR's, I'll believe he is worth what we drafted him at. Unless he does that he is a bust. Well, he's been healthy basically all this year and is on pace for 18 home runs. And he's tied for 21st out of 25 RFs in OPS. He has stunk this year.
July 18, 200818 yr The general approach at the plate has had a negative effect on Hermida. You know that Pressley has a very aggressive approach for the hitters on the team. Hermida is often trying to hit too many home runs or doubles and its showing with his dramatic increase in strike outs. This is not the kind of player he is, or should try to be. He can hit the long ball, yes, but he's a guy who should have a high average, high on base, good at bats, makes contact, is patient at the plate, etc. We don't NEED him to be a home run hitter, we have plenty of those. He's built as more of a line drive guy.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.