August 2, 200818 yr seriously, hendricson pitches bad even when he doesnt give up runs. he s jusat tortue to watch. we need to give some sort of waiver trade for jacobs for a catcher and i dont know how much more gaby sanchez and logan morrison get promoted to the majors and aa respectively. so mcpherson to mlb for hendrickson. jacobs traded and sanchez called up. what more do they have to do? Hendrickson gave up 3 hits in 3 innings and no runs. WHAT A SH*TFACE!
August 2, 200818 yr how can you not hate on a guy who has no eye and decides before the pitch if hes going to swing on every pitch
August 2, 200818 yr seriously, hendricson pitches bad even when he doesnt give up runs. he s jusat tortue to watch. we need to give some sort of waiver trade for jacobs for a catcher and i dont know how much more gaby sanchez and logan morrison get promoted to the majors and aa respectively. so mcpherson to mlb for hendrickson. jacobs traded and sanchez called up. what more do they have to do? Hendrickson gave up 3 hits in 3 innings and no runs. WHAT A SH*TFACE! ya he is. he is just a torture to watch and the only reason he is on the team is because he is getting paid to much. he cant be reliable out of the pen if he throws so many pitches and he cant control a pitch count
August 2, 200818 yr It literally pisses me off every time I watch one of his at-bats. His swings are so atrocious and he just flat out refuses to do anything but swing for the fences. 5 run game with nobody on? Swing for the fences. Runners on second and third with one out in a close game? Close your eyes and swing your back out. It's painful to watch him just keep taking those huge off-mark cuts no matter what the situation is. He is total trash, IMO. When you factor in his worse than horrible defense, it just makes our FO look that much dumber for keeping him on the field. I honestly think we're better off with Alfredo on first if we have to...Jacobs is just a terrible player all the way around.
August 2, 200818 yr seriously, hendricson pitches bad even when he doesnt give up runs. he s jusat tortue to watch. we need to give some sort of waiver trade for jacobs for a catcher and i dont know how much more gaby sanchez and logan morrison get promoted to the majors and aa respectively. so mcpherson to mlb for hendrickson. jacobs traded and sanchez called up. what more do they have to do? Hendrickson gave up 3 hits in 3 innings and no runs. WHAT A SH*TFACE! ya he is. he is just a torture to watch and the only reason he is on the team is because he is getting paid to much. he cant be reliable out of the pen if he throws so many pitches and he cant control a pitch count He's perfect out of the pen, exactly what we need. A guy who can pitch when we just need to save the pen. Also, a guy with a 3.77 ERA 1.116 WHIP this year out of the pen and 3.71 ERA with a 1.148 WHIP out of the pen lifetime is kinda useful.
August 2, 200818 yr Helms at 3rd, Cantu at 1st has always been the best way to go, but nope Fredi seems to think differently. Helms can't produce what Jake can. Helms was fine yesterday. He actually...*gasp*....got on base. You know, its hard to rally without base runners, sometimes. His OPS is only like .020 more than Jake's, and not nearly enough to offset the Slugging. That said, I was the first person to want Jake off this team before the season even started, and I want him even less now. I was the second then haha.
August 2, 200818 yr No one wants to perform more than Jake who understands this is his make or break year with the organization. For him the pressure to produce must be getting worse by the day as he runs out of opportunities to generate the production anticipated from him. Plus he's on a contending team which only adds more pressure to perform. Frankly, at least outwardly (as we see him through the eyes of the media), I think he's handled his situation very well. A lesser person might be throwing tantrums or blaming everyone around him instead of himself but we've seen none of that from Jake. It may be that in years to come (assuming it's pretty much assured he won't be a Marlins in 2009 unless his fortunes improve dramatically in the next eight weeks) he may be more comfortable and more productive on a Seattle or other non-contending team, (or even in Japan although that would mean uprooting his family and raising his two infant children in a foreign country) where he doesn't have a gun to his head to produce or perish. Or in the AL at least some of the time as a DH. After all, it's hard to conceive of a 30 home run season (which is probably more or less where he'll wind up) as a failure but that may be how Jacobs' season will be perceived by any number of MLB decision-makers. My quess is there will be a few teams willing to give him at least one more chance to put things together in hopes of him finally being the player many thought he'd be just a couple of years ago, not unlike Jorge Cantu's situation this spring. A new team, a new hitting coach, another year of maturity may do for him what the humbling experience Cantu went through did for him.
August 2, 200818 yr Or Jake can be used in the 5 hole sandwiched between a pair of good hitters and thrive like he was in April and May when he was running a .600 SLG. My problem with Jake is that he can't pick any throws.
August 2, 200818 yr Or Jake can be used in the 5 hole sandwiched between a pair of good hitters and thrive like he was in April and May when he was running a .600 SLG Or we can put a guy like Cody Ross, who's come up with some of the biggest hits this year (along with Cantu) ahead of Jake in the lineup.
August 2, 200818 yr Or Jake can be used in the 5 hole sandwiched between a pair of good hitters and thrive like he was in April and May when he was running a .600 SLG Or we can put a guy like Cody Ross, who's come up with some of the biggest hits this year (along with Cantu) ahead of Jake in the lineup. [sarcasm] Cody's .300 OBP right-handed is certainly a much better thing than Jacobs' .300 OBP left-handed [/sarcasm] People don't seem to recall some of the biggest hits this year from Jacobs because they were back when the team was way out in first place.
August 2, 200818 yr Or Jake can be used in the 5 hole sandwiched between a pair of good hitters and thrive like he was in April and May when he was running a .600 SLG Or we can put a guy like Cody Ross, who's come up with some of the biggest hits this year (along with Cantu) ahead of Jake in the lineup. [sarcasm] Cody's .300 OBP right-handed is certainly a much better thing than Jacobs' .300 OBP left-handed [/sarcasm] People don't seem to recall some of the biggest hits this year from Jacobs because they were back when the team was way out in first place. Cody's .OBP is .309; Jacobs .OBP is .287. If we're throwing out stats, might as well, not sugarcoat it. Also, if you're going to excuse Jacobs b/c he had a horrid June...well, you know what, Cody Ross' stats are deceiving, as well. He went .159/.188/.227 in April. And when exactly was Jake being soooo clutch? I recall one walkoff hit. What are his #'s when he's really needed? Late & close? Why are Jake's #'s at their best when the team is down by more than four? Why are Cody's #'s at their worst when the team is down by more than four? Are you really comparing the two in terms of BIG hits?
August 2, 200818 yr Or Jake can be used in the 5 hole sandwiched between a pair of good hitters and thrive like he was in April and May when he was running a .600 SLG Or we can put a guy like Cody Ross, who's come up with some of the biggest hits this year (along with Cantu) ahead of Jake in the lineup. [sarcasm] Cody's .300 OBP right-handed is certainly a much better thing than Jacobs' .300 OBP left-handed [/sarcasm] People don't seem to recall some of the biggest hits this year from Jacobs because they were back when the team was way out in first place. Cody's .OBP is .309; Jacobs .OBP is .287. If we're throwing out stats, might as well, not sugarcoat it. Also, if you're going to excuse Jacobs b/c he had a horrid June...well, you know what, Cody Ross' stats are deceiving, as well. He went .159/.188/.227 in April. And when exactly was Jake being soooo clutch? I recall one walkoff hit. What are his #'s when he's really needed? Late & close? Why are Jake's #'s at their best when the team is down by more than four? Why are Cody's #'s at their worst when the team is down by more than four? Are you really comparing the two in terms of BIG hits? People piss and moan about RISP on this team all the time. Jake rakes with runners on and with RISP. The man knocks in people. Why do you think that late & close is somehow more needed than earlier in a game when the team as a chance to avoid being late & close? I hardly consider Jake to be a long-term solution, but there is a place to have him in the lineup where we will be dangerous and, I'll slow down for those that can't seem to get it: HE IS THE BEST HITTING OPTION AVAILABLE ON THE CURRENT ROSTER Dream about McPherson all you want, maybe he will be the greatest thing since canned beer, but 28 year old AAA stats are useless as a measure of anything useful.
August 2, 200818 yr Or Jake can be used in the 5 hole sandwiched between a pair of good hitters and thrive like he was in April and May when he was running a .600 SLG Or we can put a guy like Cody Ross, who's come up with some of the biggest hits this year (along with Cantu) ahead of Jake in the lineup. [sarcasm] Cody's .300 OBP right-handed is certainly a much better thing than Jacobs' .300 OBP left-handed [/sarcasm] People don't seem to recall some of the biggest hits this year from Jacobs because they were back when the team was way out in first place. Cody's .OBP is .309; Jacobs .OBP is .287. If we're throwing out stats, might as well, not sugarcoat it. Also, if you're going to excuse Jacobs b/c he had a horrid June...well, you know what, Cody Ross' stats are deceiving, as well. He went .159/.188/.227 in April. And when exactly was Jake being soooo clutch? I recall one walkoff hit. What are his #'s when he's really needed? Late & close? Why are Jake's #'s at their best when the team is down by more than four? Why are Cody's #'s at their worst when the team is down by more than four? Are you really comparing the two in terms of BIG hits? People piss and moan about RISP on this team all the time. Jake rakes with runners on and with RISP. The man knocks in people. Why do you think that late & close is somehow more needed than earlier in a game when the team as a chance to avoid being late & close? I hardly consider Jake to be a long-term solution, but there is a place to have him in the lineup where we will be dangerous and, I'll slow down for those that can't seem to get it: HE IS THE BEST HITTING OPTION AVAILABLE ON THE CURRENT ROSTER Dream about McPherson all you want, maybe he will be the greatest thing since canned beer, but 28 year old AAA stats are useless as a measure of anything useful. And that's where you are wrong. Scouting reports have always indicated that McPherson has ALWAYS had great power. I'm not saying he's the "greatest thing since canned beer..." however, I don't see why a guy with 39 HR's and an .OBP over .400 IS NOT WORTHY of a callup. Especially when your 1B refuses to get on base at a good pace, doesn't exactly win games with the bat (haven't seen him do it in awhile), and is, BY FAR, the WORST defensive 1B in baseball. And hitting with .RISP is important...however, situations in a game are also important. Some situations are more important than others.
August 2, 200818 yr Dream about McPherson all you want, maybe he will be the greatest thing since canned beer, but 28 year old AAA stats are useless as a measure of anything useful. And that's where you are wrong. Scouting reports have always indicated that McPherson has ALWAYS had great power. I'm not saying he's the "greatest thing since canned beer..." however, I don't see why a guy with 39 HR's and an .OBP over .400 IS NOT WORTHY of a callup. Especially when your 1B refuses to get on base at a good pace, doesn't exactly win games with the bat (haven't seen him do it in awhile), and is, BY FAR, the WORST defensive 1B in baseball. And hitting with .RISP is important...however, situations in a game are also important. Some situations are more important than others. Jacobs has great power, frankly Jacobs has amazing power, freakishly amazing power. There is no earthly reason that a man with his crappy contact rate crushes so many pitches. If he is left alone to hit in his style in the 5 hole, he'll up his average a bit, and thus his OBP and slug. We've seen it already. McPherson's walks are clearly inflated this season, it is somthing akin to 30% of his career walks. He will walk at maybe half the AAA rate, and probably would lose half those HRs as flyball outs.... and if you run those numbers I expect that would be around a .290 OBP also. It would be different if he were working 30+ doubles, because that shows some line drive Panache, but that just isn't the case.
August 2, 200818 yr Jakes offense really isn't what worries me about him.. ... its defense... Which is why he will not be with us next season. He is going to be traded. Hopefully one of our infielders will come around next year.
August 2, 200818 yr Jakes offense really isn't what worries me about him.. ... its defense... I think its both...
August 2, 200818 yr McPherson's injury-marred ML stats: G --- AB R- H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO AVG OBP SLG 117 360 50 89 19 2 -18 -- 45 - 5 - 3 -- 23 121 .247 .294 .461 Please stop thinking he'll be 10x better than Jake offensively OR defensively... he's a 28 yr old (considering many on this board think Uggla is old and peaking at 28), DL-prone, K machine (note the god-awful BB/K ratio that is still present in his PCL #'s), who will bring nothing to the table that this team actually needs right now - i.e. defense, or patience at the plate. So I say again, please stop drooling over the stats this guy is putting up in a league that made brett carroll look like a monster at the plate as well. With that being said, I'd like to see him get called up in Sept. to see how he does at the ML level, and based on his performance, either keep him for next yr at first or trade him.
August 2, 200818 yr 39 HR's (PCL or not...why hasn't anyone reached that # in that league?) and a .400 .OBP (the really intriguing part). You're right...NO REASON to give McPherson any consideration of a callup. Lets just be ignorant and not give it a chance...a chance he deserves. BTW, do you really think our defense will get worse without Grandma Jake at 1B, for those complaining about McPhersons' defense? I'm not saying McPherson's GREAT...but it doesn't take much to upgrade over the replaceable Mike Jacobs.
August 2, 200818 yr McPherson's injury-marred ML stats: G --- AB R- H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO AVG OBP SLG 117 360 50 89 19 2 -18 -- 45 - 5 - 3 -- 23 121 .247 .294 .461 Please stop thinking he'll be 10x better than Jake offensively OR defensively... he's a 28 yr old (considering many on this board think Uggla is old and peaking at 28), DL-prone, K machine (note the god-awful BB/K ratio that is still present in his PCL #'s), who will bring nothing to the table that this team actually needs right now - i.e. defense, or patience at the plate. So I say again, please stop drooling over the stats this guy is putting up in a league that made brett carroll look like a monster at the plate as well. With that being said, I'd like to see him get called up in Sept. to see how he does at the ML level, and based on his performance, either keep him for next yr at first or trade him. I'd love to know where someone has posted he would be 10X better than Jake, and to bring up his pre-surgery major league stats (although I give you credit for at least acknowledging he was injured much of the time) has no real value when considering a "healthy" Dallas McPherson today. I'm a big believer in the belief players don't all mature at the same rate. Dallas McPherson today has much more respect for where he is and how he got there than the kid branded with the "can't miss" prospect sticker and rushed to the bigs after one hyper minor league season. I've heard two interviews with him, one on 790 another on MLBTV and he remarkably humble and grateful for a second chance. You might want to take a look at his BB/K month by month as he gets better at recognizing the strikezone and walks go up and strikeouts down. The same for a number of his stats (although I don't mean this to be a hunting expedition to find his weaknesses). The first part of his Isotopes season was really his spring training and his numbers show as much, he was way behind everyone else having been hurt and missing most of spring training with the Marlins. As for the PCL, you might want to take a look at the makeup of the league, it is no longer a cluster of teams near or along the western United States but more than half the teams are either in the eastern half of the country (Memphis, Nashville, New Orleans, etc.) or in low-lying parts of the west coast like Fresno and Sacremento. It's a mistake to see the PCL as every team being akin to the Colorado SkySox but I understand the perception exists and probably won't begin to change until the League changes its name to something that better conveys the message that they have franchises from one coast to the other. As for his age, in some ways like Lindstrom, his age doesn't equate to his number of years playing ball at the major or minor league level. Certainly the circumstances of why they missed time are different but McPherson says this is the first time in five years he's played without pain and with complete mobility. I have no reason to disbelieve him. Some people admittedly may be too far off the charts in what their expectations are, but I would argue there's just as many who haven't followed his progress (both on the field and his improving health) closely enough to understand what he's accomplished so far this season is an extraordinary achievement. That said, if he does come up in August or Sept without a doubt there will be a period of adjustment but as long as he gets a chance to play everyday and isn't measured by eight late innings pinch-hits a week, I think he'll do fine. Does that mean he'll do fine and hit .320 and ten homers in his first month? I have no idea. I want to see what he can do. Beyond that it's in his hands. But I'm comfortable saying he's capable of playing successfully at the major league level.
August 2, 200818 yr McPherson's injury-marred ML stats: G --- AB R- H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO AVG OBP SLG 117 360 50 89 19 2 -18 -- 45 - 5 - 3 -- 23 121 .247 .294 .461 Please stop thinking he'll be 10x better than Jake offensively OR defensively... he's a 28 yr old (considering many on this board think Uggla is old and peaking at 28), DL-prone, K machine (note the god-awful BB/K ratio that is still present in his PCL #'s), who will bring nothing to the table that this team actually needs right now - i.e. defense, or patience at the plate. So I say again, please stop drooling over the stats this guy is putting up in a league that made brett carroll look like a monster at the plate as well. With that being said, I'd like to see him get called up in Sept. to see how he does at the ML level, and based on his performance, either keep him for next yr at first or trade him. I'd love to know where someone has posted he would be 10X better than Jake, and to bring up his pre-surgery major league stats (although I give you credit for at least acknowledging he was injured much of the time) has no real value when considering a "healthy" Dallas McPherson today. I'm a big believer in the belief players don't all mature at the same rate. Dallas McPherson today has much more respect for where he is and how he got there than the kid branded with the "can't miss" prospect sticker and rushed to the bigs after one hyper minor league season. I've heard two interviews with him, one on 790 another on MLBTV and he remarkably humble and grateful for a second chance. You might want to take a look at his BB/K month by month as he gets better at recognizing the strikezone and walks go up and strikeouts down. The same for a number of his stats (although I don't mean this to be a hunting expedition to find his weaknesses). The first part of his Isotopes season was really his spring training and his numbers show as much, he was way behind everyone else having been hurt and missing most of spring training with the Marlins. As for the PCL, you might want to take a look at the makeup of the league, it is no longer a cluster of teams near or along the western United States but more than half the teams are either in the eastern half of the country (Memphis, Nashville, New Orleans, etc.) or in low-lying parts of the west coast like Fresno and Sacremento. It's a mistake to see the PCL as every team being akin to the Colorado SkySox but I understand the perception exists and probably won't begin to change until the League changes its name to something that better conveys the message that they have franchises from one coast to the other. As for his age, in some ways like Lindstrom, his age doesn't equate to his number of years playing ball at the major or minor league level. Certainly the circumstances of why they missed time are different but McPherson says this is the first time in five years he's played without pain and with complete mobility. I have no reason to disbelieve him. Some people admittedly may be too far off the charts in what their expectations are, but I would argue there's just as many who haven't followed his progress (both on the field and his improving health) closely enough to understand what he's accomplished so far this season is an extraordinary achievement. That said, if he does come up in August or Sept without a doubt there will be a period of adjustment but as long as he gets a chance to play everyday and isn't measured by eight late innings pinch-hits a week, I think he'll do fine. Does that mean he'll do fine and hit .320 and ten homers in his first month? I have no idea. I want to see what he can do. Beyond that it's in his hands. But I'm comfortable saying he's capable of playing successfully at the major league level. The bolded statement is exactly why I made my post to begin with. Let's not be hasty in trading Jake just so we can "get a look" at McPherson and hope his PCL numbers translate to the bigs. Call him up in September, give him some starting opportunities at 3rd and see how he does. Make subsequent moves from there.
August 2, 200818 yr As for the PCL, you might want to take a look at the makeup of the league, it is no longer a cluster of teams near or along the western United States but more than half the teams are either in the eastern half of the country (Memphis, Nashville, New Orleans, etc.) or in low-lying parts of the west coast like Fresno and Sacremento. It's a mistake to see the PCL as every team being akin to the Colorado SkySox but I understand the perception exists and probably won't begin to change until the League changes its name to something that better conveys the message that they have franchises from one coast to the other. Beyond that it's in his hands. But I'm comfortable saying he's capable of playing successfully at the major league level. Except of his 39 HRs, 26 have been in his home park, the best park for LH flyball hitters in professional baseball. His away OPS is 100 points lower, his batting average drops to .256 away from the paradise that is Isotopes Park.
August 2, 200818 yr Tim Kurkijan said at the beginnig of the year (when Jacobs started off with a huge AVG and leading the league in HRs) that he was this year's Chris Shelton. I remember being pissed when I heard that, and now looking back he was exactlly right. :banghead
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.