August 30, 200917 yr Finding better comparisons on other teams wouldn't be hard at all. You're just cherry picking things like the same amount of HRs and K's, and things that don't really matter like being drafted out of college and height, but as you say yourself it's not close to the same amount of ABs. It's rate that really matters. BB%: season, career Petersen: 10.6%, 9.9% Coghlan: 11.9%, 11.8% K% Petersen: 16.3%, 20.1% Coghlan: 13.5%, 13.2% As you can see, Coghlan has vastly supperior contact rates. Petersen also has superior power potential, blasting 23 HRs last year whereas Coghlan's career high was 12. Again it's not a horrible comp, but there are a lot better ones out there.
August 30, 200917 yr I'll give into that M O T. I'll reserve that comparison however until I see Peterson in AAA. If Peterson next season could have a breakout season the way Coghlan broke out with his monster season this year in 25 games before getting called up (yes small sample size, but he was raking). If Peterson can have around a high .800 OPS while keeping his BA around .300 while doing what he has done this year in AAA to begin next year, then yeah I'd say it's fair to make that comparison. And we have seen a few sides of Peterson. Last year in Single A, we saw very good power from him while maintaining a very nice average, but a big issue was his high number of K's. We really haven't seen that kind of power from him this year, but very nice to see his average up. One thing that is a tiny bit alarming is he has gotten caught stealing this year as much as he stole. Basically, I'm not totally shutting down the comparison, I'm just saying that we should probably send Peterson to AAA next season, and if he can have a Chris Coghlan type of beginning to the season, I wouldn't be the least bit surprised to see him as a Marlin in late May/early July. But we have seen bits of inconsistancy from Peterson at different levels in the minors, I'd like to see some consistancy before comparing him to a possible rookie of the year this year. Damn it Nny, I wrote out this entire rant and the simple thing you wrote makes 10X more sense than w/e I rambled about
August 30, 200917 yr And we have seen a few sides of Peterson. Last year in Single A, we saw very good power from him while maintaining a very nice average, but a big issue was his high number of K's. We really haven't seen that kind of power from him this year, but very nice to see his average up. One thing that is a tiny bit alarming is he has gotten caught stealing this year as much as he stole. I think this is one of the main things to remember. It's not just Petersen this season, it's Petersen's career we need to look at. Yeah, this season gets weighted more, but you cannot simply ignore what happened last season. Something to remember is that a season full of ABs is the greatest of sample sizes. He's most likely is somewhere in between both his power last year and this year and his contact rates between last year and this year. I'd say his career line is more along the lines of what to look at. I would say Gary Matthews JR's career line is about what to expect, except hopefully with a better BABIP (Petersen's expected BABIP for this year would be .310, Sarge JR's being .301). Increasing BABIP to .310 would give us a line around .265/.340/.420/.760.
August 30, 200917 yr Galloway's pretty disappointing right now. In terms of potential, he's supposed to be the best of the bunch. He's got all the "tools," supposedly. I remember being excited when we drafted him in the 8th round b/c some people were saying he had 1st round talent, and the only reason he wasn't taken sooner was b/c he had a strong commitment to SD State. So I'm hoping he starts producing more b/c I expect more. He's only 19 in A ball...maybe he develops?
August 30, 200917 yr I completely forgot that Peterson hit 23 homers last year. Nineteen of them were in Greensboro. Four of them were in 200 PA in Jupiter/Carolina. I'd say this year's power output is more realistic. Greensboro doesn't really count unless you're 18 or 19. I like what NNY has said. This lack of power is going to cause people to pound the zone, and that's going to hurt him. A mid .700 OPS is reasonable because of his contact rate, but this is probably not a longterm starter. If he can splits a little higher versus LHP, he'll be a very useful bench player. Especially if Cousins works out. To rank them, it's easily Cousins who has the best power potential and defensive ability, then Petersen, then Raynor, and then Galloway because of his youth and uncertainty.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.