Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

The "Other" Outfield Prospects

Featured Replies

Now, we all know about (and i assume are pretty high on, rightfully so) Mike Stanton and Cameron Maybin. But even after that, the Marlins have outfield talent in their farm that most major league teams would envy. The question is, where do you see these guys ending up?

 

John Raynor

Pro: He's fast. REALLY fast (102 steals in 07 and 08 combined). He draws his share of walks (128 in 07 and 08 combined). He'll hit the occasional home run, and does have gap power (97 extra base hits in 07 and 08 combined. roughly 30% of his hits). Hits pretty well for contact (averages over .310 in both 07 AND 08). Tore up A and AA ball. Incredible range.

 

Con: He strikes out ALOT (~1/4th of his at-bats). Not old, but not exactly young either (25). He has probably topped out already, talent wise. Has struggled heavily in AAA this year.

 

Scott Cousins

Pro: Very balanced guy. Solid contact hitter, solid defender, solid pop. Has all the tools to be a solid player.

 

Con: And that's that. He's just tools. He hasn't excelled in any level of professional baseball, except maybe high A ball. He's quite the impatient hitter. He's been average everywhere he's gone, and will most likely continue that trend his entire career. He's also probably reached his summit.

 

Bryan Petersen

Pro: Great contact hitter. Will put the ball in play almost always. Very few walks, but very few strikeouts. Some pop. Some speed.

 

Con: Actually not many cons. Not many pros either though. He's similar to Scott cousins, except that Petersen actually gets the bat on the ball more. Hasn't topped out, but outside of learning patience, there isn't much more to this guy.

 

Isaac Galloway

Pro: Great tools. Definitely has potential to be an above average outfielder in the majors one day. He's very young (19).

 

Con: As is, he's a carbon copy of Jose Guillen. This dude had 4 (not, that's not a typo) walks in 211 PAs in rookie ball in 08. In his pro career, he's had 520 plate appearances, and he's gotten to first on account of balls only 16 times. To worsen that, it's not exactly as if he's not walking because he gets the bat on the ball every time (ala petersen). He's struck out 100 times in those 520 plate appearances. This guy just simply has very, VERY poor pitch selection skills.

peterson is someone im extremely high on. great in the field and pretty good with the bat. i could see a major league line of .280-300, 10-15 hr's, 15-20 sb's, 0 errors. that would be great.

  • Author

i voted for John Raynor, btw.

 

i think he has a bit more going for him than cousins and petersen, and galloway is to big a gamble for me to pick him.

Petersen is going to be a good one. His game closely resembles that of Chris Coghlan's.

 

 

 

same, i found myself thinking of chris coghlan when i was typing what i thought his future line could be. i could definitely see this lineup in the future.

 

c- baker/ paulino (hopefully eventually skipworth)

1b-morrison

2b- coghlan

ss-hanley

3b- matty d

lf- peterson

cf- maybin

rf- stanton

 

with many opther options like cousins, de aza, carroll, and that is just what is homegrown right now.

  • Author

For those who voted/considering voting for Galloway, check my sig for a quick look at his stats.

 

 

yeah, they're terrible.

 

galloway has potential, but he's way too raw for me to consider voting for him. he wasn't particularly in the running for me. in fact, i wasn't going to include him when i originally wrote up the post.

It's gotta be Peterson. Galloway probably has the most upside out of the group though, and in our rookie league team I love the way Marquis Cooper looks physically in stature (SPEED!). Peterson is also the only one out of those outfielders who had somewhat of a good season this year. At the age of 23, he should probably be in the majors soon, most likely as a 4th outfielder long term rather than a permanent fix. The outfield of the future more likely looks like LF-Morrison CF-Maybin RF-Stanton. Sure Morrison is a more natural 1st baseman, but the fact that a good 1st baseman is a lot easier to find for cheap in free agency will probably effect that decision.

 

I'm not sold on the Coghlan/Peterson comparison. Two pretty different players in their own right. Ya'll probably made that comparison simply because they both are currently playing LF and Peterson is having a year in AA similar to that of Coghlan in the majors.

 

So basically, I'll take Marquis Cooper in a few years over that core now.

I don't know how anyone could vote for Raynor after the season he's having. JMO, though.

  • Author

I don't know how anyone could vote for Raynor after the season he's having. JMO, though.

 

 

he absolutely destroyed A and AA ball in 07 and 08. that's why.

I don't know how anyone could vote for Raynor after the season he's having. JMO, though.

 

 

he absolutely destroyed A and AA ball in 07 and 08. that's why.

 

 

 

no he didnt. he k'd a lot and didnt hit for much power and is stinking it up in a hitters league at the age of 25, not really a prospect anymore.

I don't know how anyone could vote for Raynor after the season he's having. JMO, though.

 

 

he absolutely destroyed A and AA ball in 07 and 08. that's why.

 

 

 

no he didnt. he k'd a lot and didnt hit for much power and is stinking it up in a hitters league at the age of 25, not really a prospect anymore.

 

X2, although he's still a prospect, just not one that projects to much at the ML-level. Petersen is the easy answer IMO, with Galloway having a shot to be better if he develops.

I don't know how anyone could vote for Raynor after the season he's having. JMO, though.

 

 

he absolutely destroyed A and AA ball in 07 and 08. that's why.

 

 

 

no he didnt. he k'd a lot and didnt hit for much power and is stinking it up in a hitters league at the age of 25, not really a prospect anymore.

 

X2, although he's still a prospect, just not one that projects to much at the ML-level. Petersen is the easy answer IMO, with Galloway having a shot to be better if he develops.

 

 

i really just dont think very highly of galloway. i think that a guy like him should not be having this many k's at this level.

I don't know how anyone could vote for Raynor after the season he's having. JMO, though.

 

 

he absolutely destroyed A and AA ball in 07 and 08. that's why.

 

 

 

no he didnt. he k'd a lot and didnt hit for much power and is stinking it up in a hitters league at the age of 25, not really a prospect anymore.

 

X2, although he's still a prospect, just not one that projects to much at the ML-level. Petersen is the easy answer IMO, with Galloway having a shot to be better if he develops.

 

 

i really just dont think very highly of galloway. i think that a guy like him should not be having this many k's at this level.

 

He has 80 K's in 303 PAs. Sure it's a high number. Last year Mike Stanton had 153 K's in 598 PAs. I'm not comparing the two as players, but those are very similar rates (Galloway K's about 1% more often). So don't write him off just yet.

i also considered including jai miller.

 

 

 

Jai Miller strikes out FAR too much to be of any use outside of maybe being a back up OFer. Ontop of which he's basically +0 defensively and +0 on the base paths, so he doesn't add in other parts of the game.

 

Raynor doesn't have too much going for him: his OPS in his previous years were BABIP-induced. He is stuck in LF and he doesn't play LF well. It's hard to take his old SLG/ISOs seriously because he was always old for his level, and that showed in NOLA this season. He strikes out way too much to actually hit for average. And with his bad contact skills and lack of power pitchers will just pound the zone and there goes his walks. I think his season line in NOLA this year is more or less what to expect. Adding 10+ runs on the base paths is certainly tits, but then looking at an upper 600-lower 700 OPS from a not good fielding LFer is :| If he was 10+ run defensively, with his runs on the base paths, you could live with that OPS. Still has use as a 4th ofer though.

 

Petersen's success has a lot to do with his drop in K's, which is a good thing. But his lack of power is not. He's been acting like a slap hitter this season. If this lack of power is serious then, like Raynor, pitchers will just pound the zone at this level, which will drop his BB (but will also drop his K's since, unlike Raynor, he makes contact), essentially making him an empty hitter. His old power needs to come back. He has been hitting for power lately which is a positive sign. Actually just saw he's up to a .121 ISO so that's good to see. He really needs to be pushing 150 though. Coghlan comparison isn't exactly apt but it's not horrible. Coghlan at the same level at the same age had a BB/K that was 28 points better and finished with more walks then strike outs. Another disappointing thing though is his lack of steals, and more so his inability to steal them well. He's 12 for 24 this season. 50% CS is horrible. He was suppose to be a 20/20 guy and this season kinda killed that with his lack of power and lack of stealing ability. Hopefully he can show both of those again next year with the same contact rates. Expectation out of him is probably a middish 700 OPS, and with the fact he can play average defense at 3 spots that's rather decent.

 

Cousins though is my pick. It hasn't been a great season for him offensively, but he's still shown his plus power (.186 ISO). Would like to see more walks and a better BB/K, didn't really improve either this season. His biggest problem his season his been BABIP but then that brings up the question of was he unlucky or has his BABIP skillset declined? Considering the fact he still posted a 20% LD rate, same basic career BB/K, same basic career ISO, I'm gonna say he was unlucky. I'd say his season line is more or less what to expect in the majors aswell, a mid 700ish OPS. The main thing with cousins is what he does elsewhere. He is our second best defensive OFer besides Brett Carroll. He's definitely not at BC's level but we're still talking +10-15 runs on defense. He's also a good base runner, 25 SB on the year at a 78% rate. The fact that he'll add ~20+ runs in those two fields is what puts Cousins ahead of the other two. The biggest problem for him though is that he'd need a platoon. Seems he does not see the ball well out of LHP hands, strikes out a ton against them. But with Bry Pete being a RHB, viola, good platoon.

 

It'd be Cousins > Petersen > (big gap) > Raynor > (gap) > Miller to me.

no he didnt. he k'd a lot and didnt hit for much power and is stinking it up in a hitters league at the age of 25, not really a prospect anymore.

 

 

X2, although he's still a prospect, just not one that projects to much at the ML-level. Petersen is the easy answer IMO, with Galloway having a shot to be better if he develops.

 

 

i really just dont think very highly of galloway. i think that a guy like him should not be having this many k's at this level.

 

He has 80 K's in 303 PAs. Sure it's a high number. Last year Mike Stanton had 153 K's in 598 PAs. I'm not comparing the two as players, but those are very similar rates (Galloway K's about 1% more often). So don't write him off just yet.

 

 

im not writing him off. just when you project to be a leadoff hitter, these k problems are a much bigger problem then if you are gonna be a power hitter like stanton

He has 80 K's in 303 PAs. Sure it's a high number. Last year Mike Stanton had 153 K's in 598 PAs. I'm not comparing the two as players, but those are very similar rates (Galloway K's about 1% more often). So don't write him off just yet.

 

 

There's a basic rule of thumb: if you strike out more than 25% of the time in A ball, you won't succeed in the majors. Even big K guys in the majors don't normally strike out that much (Dunn stuck out 22.5%, Mike Cameron stuck out 24.5%, so on). There's exceptions to the rules, and with Stanton's power he should be an exception to th erule. But for Galloway, the K's aren't good. He's at 26.8% on the year now. He needs to get into the sub-20% range if he wants to be a good prospect, but he needs to cut the k's sub-25 if he wants to still be any kind of prospect.

I'm not sold on the Coghlan/Peterson comparison. Two pretty different players in their own right. Ya'll probably made that comparison simply because they both are currently playing LF and Peterson is having a year in AA similar to that of Coghlan in the majors.

 

 

 

Dim, hear me out...don't let my post count speak for how closely I follow the Marlins minor leaguers...but I understand that to expect anyone to come up and do what Cogs has done at the MLB level is assinine.

 

Obviously the left field comparison and the fact that they both bat lefty, they both bat leadoff makes them comparable, but their stat progression is EERILY similar. In A ball, and so far in AA.

 

In a full year at AA, age 23, Coghlan hit .298, 7HR's, had an OPS of .825, and struck out 65 times.

 

Now get this...

 

In a full year at AA (there is only a week left), Petersen, age 23, has hit .303, 7HR's, has an OPS of .801, and has struck out..you guessed it...65 times.

 

Granted, Petersen has done this in fewer AB's. You could argue he has more power than Cogs, and will strike out a few more times, but I think it's a valid comparison. I don't think you could find many players on the other 29 teams in baseball that are as similar to Bryan Petersen than is Chris Coghlan. They were also both drafted out of college programs and are the same size.

 

This is why I'm buying the Coghlan/Petersen comparison. Not based on similar seasons this year.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.