Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Arizona immigration law

Featured Replies

The major economic drawback of loose immigration policy is the potential for the new immigrants to exploit the welfare state and consume public goods and services without first paying a sufficient amount first through taxation. The solution to this would be to reform the welfare model so it could not be abused. The government needs to make it clear that immigrants will be given an opportunity to earn a living but will be exluded from welfare (and I mean this term loosely) benefits. It simply isn't sustainable for taxpayers to be subsidizing benefits of immigrants.

 

I don't see something like that ever getting passed. Is it even constitutional? I doubt it.

 

Not exactly the same but when California residents passed an amendment to deny illegal immigrants various government services such as education, health care, etc. it was found to be unconstitutional in the courts.

 

As Penguino mentioned, this has already been done.

 

As far as your other point, yes, it's not the same. Education is available to everyone. Emergency health care is available to everyone. Illegal immigrants, whether you like it or not, do pay taxes. They consume things here (they buy stuff), and that gets taxed. They rent property, and property gets taxed. They work with fake SSN's and pay the taxes that everyone else pays (SS taxes, federal income taxes, etc.). Obviously, most of them do not file income tax returns, so they never see a refund. If they get paid under the table, that allows people to buy things cheaper (whether it be property or food or whatever).

 

Just for the record, just because someone is here undocumented doesn't mean they don't pay taxes. Everyone has a right to their opinion, but that opinion should be based on actual facts.

So whats the basis for all of this illegal immigration tension?

 

1. They have the opportunity to abuse the welfare state. AKA leeching (Get rid of excessive handouts)

2. Marijuana. AKA Cheech and Chong AKA Weed(Legalize and tax marijuana. Make marijuana laws similar to alcohol laws)

3. Hard drugs AKA Everything else with high traffic that isn't weed (No idea)

4. They took our jobs. AKA dey took our jobs AKA dey turk ur jerbs (Make becoming legal simple and an advantage over being illegal. Being a citizen should mean having major benefits over undocumented status.)

5. Higher crime rates AKA como chingas! (I think a lot of it stems from drug trafficking. Legalizing marijuana would put a big dent in it.)

 

 

1. Illegal immigrants can't get welfare. This is an often-repeated misconception. I am not sure where this comes from.

2. Agreed.

3. Agreed.

4. Agreed - this happens because of the free market. Employers need help, they can't get enough Americans to do it, and so they hire illegal immigrants. It's basically as simple as you say.

5. This could be true in some places (most notably Texas), but the data shows that crime in Arizona is lower now than it was twenty years ago. There really hasn't been any increase in violence in the last few decades. This is also something that is repeated often, but it has no basis in fact.

I really love the image of this giant wall on our border with sensors and cameras and death rays and a giant moat next to it filled with boiling oil. I gotta get my homeowners association to take up this plan too.

 

"Complete the dang fence!"

I agree that we badly need to increase the quotas on legal immigration. My understanding is that they are far, far behind what real rates should be. I don't know why this is exactly, but it might be due in part to political pressure.

 

I also tend to agree that one major thing which would badly hurt the drug cartels would be regulating and taxing marijuana use in the US. Just recently the Mexican government approved individuals within that country to possess certain amounts of basically every kind of illegal drug (we're talking anything from pot to coke to meth), because they frankly don't have the resources to worry about arresting individuals over a few joints. This is where the US need to head eventually. It's clear that the 'War on Drugs' has failed miserably, and only continues to make the problem worse. People are going to use drugs no matter what we try to do about it. I've heard people from Holland talk about the fact that very few people in their country even smoke pot anymore now that it's legal, because making it legal took away the 'danger' or whatever that interested people who wanted to use. If we legalized pot, over time the same thing would probably happen here.

 

When looking at legalizing pot, you can draw a direct parallel to Prohibition. Under prohibition, scores of people died because they consumed alcohol made with dangerous ingredients, because that's all they could get their hands on. A similar thing has been occurring with pot, where dealers have been lacing it with things like meth, which have resulted in crimes and sometimes deaths. The thing that bothers me most is people having the book thrown at them by the court system because they had some pot, of all things. Of course this tends to lead into a debate about our prison system as a whole, but it's a legitimate one. We should focus more on dealing with violent offenders than ones who sold some drugs (I guess the exception would be for meth, which is an awful drug that destroys brain cells and permanently rewires the brain after even a small amount of usage).

  • 2 months later...

I hope the GOP keeps trying this, because it's going to continue to piss off the fastest growing demographic in the country more and more. I was just reading in the Herald today about how even conservative hispanics are backing away from supporting McCollum now because of this new proposal.

 

But honestly, what is the benefit to this legislation? It's pointless and based on bigoted and racist views of immigrants.

Polls I've seen indicate something like 50/50 public support in Florida for the AZ law. That isn't exactly unanimous support, but nevertheless a much healthier showing than one would expect due to the bitter criticisms made by the bill's opponents.

 

 

 

The latest poll says 61% support it while only 35% oppose it:

 

http://www.baynews9.com/article/news/2010/august/136876/Exclusive-poll:-Floridians-favor-Arizona-type-immigration-law

I hope the GOP keeps trying this, because it's going to continue to piss off the fastest growing demographic in the country more and more. I was just reading in the Herald today about how even conservative hispanics are backing away from supporting McCollum now because of this new proposal.

 

But honestly, what is the benefit to this legislation? It's pointless and based on bigoted and racist views of immigrants.

 

 

 

The GOP has always pissed off the fastest growing demographic, although historically it has been with European immigrants. In the end, the numbers always seem to balance out. In fact, this poll says that Hispanic's opinions towards the Republican Party haven't shifted one bit: http://www.gallup.com/poll/139751/Hispanic-Voters-Preferences-Unchanged-Post-Arizona-Law.aspx

 

The only reason why people think this will actually hurt the GOP is because the media keeps on displaying all of the Hispanic protesters at every event in Arizona. They try to portray the situation as if hispanics can't think individually and instead have to think as a group (similar to what Democrats are doing with African-Americans.)

 

The benefit of the legislation is that a large majority of citizens in Arizona favor the law, a solid majority of Americans as a whole support the law, and from all of the polls I have seen, I haven't seen one state (even the most liberal ones) in which the majority of residents oppose the law rather than support it.

 

According to your logic, I would also assume that the 21% of hispanics (using the latest poll) that support the bill are also self-haters and bigots against themselves, right?

Polls I've seen indicate something like 50/50 public support in Florida for the AZ law. That isn't exactly unanimous support, but nevertheless a much healthier showing than one would expect due to the bitter criticisms made by the bill's opponents.

 

 

 

The latest poll says 61% support it while only 35% oppose it:

 

http://www.baynews9....immigration-law

Not saying it's wrong because I expect public sentiment to move toward being more favorable to the law in this economy, but that doesn't sound like the most reputable polling source.

 

 

Knowing you, I always need a backup poll.

 

Rasmussen says that 62% of Floridians favor an Arizona-like law in the state, while only 24% oppose it:

 

http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/general_state_surveys/florida/60_in_florida_oppose_justice_department_challenge_of_arizona_immigration_law

You are missing the point.

 

It doesn't matter if the opinions of Hispanics toward the GOP don't decline percent-wise. It matters that the percentage remains constant while the number of potential Hispanic voters is increasing rapidly. The GOP needs to be pushing policy that attracts minority voters (all minorities) and not simply be satisfied with not pissing them off anymore.

 

10 years ago the minority percentage in this country was something like 20%. Now it's somewhere like 30-40%.

 

Will it hurt them in 2010 and 2012? Probably not substantially, but it will have a negative effect over the long term.

 

 

 

Knowing history, it isn't a big deal for the GOP. In the 1960's, this country was about 85% white (non-hispanic.) Today, that number has decreased to about 65%, yet the GOP hasn't lost any popularity. As long as a higher percentage of non-hispanics keep on voting for the GOP, they don't need an increase in support from hispanics.

 

People said the same thing when conservatives tried to stop the Irish from immigrating in the mid-19th century, and again when the Italians started immigrating at a rapid rate in the late 19th century, and once again when Jews and other Catholics immigrated in the early 20th century.

That's because there have been a ton of various other political, social, ethnic, and economic factors that have shifted party identification since the 1960s.

 

Pew Research has a great graph here:

http://people-press....fication-trend/

 

Notice the huge revival during the Reagan years that has completed evaporated over the last eight or nine years. Obviously this is not entirely due to minority voters, but it's still significant. The party won't be able to survive on white votes alone. McCain beat Obama by seven points (I've seen some numbers indicate the margin was even wider) in the white vote and still lost the election.

 

The GOP can try to get back some of the white voters they lost in the Bush years (and try to win over the new voters), but they will need to face the ever growing minority demographic in this country.

 

 

 

I never said that the GOP would be able to survive solely on the white vote. I simply provided examples on how many times what you are saying now has been said in the past.

 

Whites will still make up a majority of voters for the next several decades, and assuming the GOP can attract at least 60% of whites, they wouldn't need to get that high of a percentage of minority votes (I would guess around 30% of minority voters at most.)

 

Also, if I'm not mistaken, Bush got around 40% of the hispanic vote, so it is definitely doable.

I'm confused. Are you guys that oppose this bill saying you would rather have illegal immigrants and more voters rather than legal immigrants?

 

Just a warning though, I am card-carrying republican.Though I tend to lean more towards the center than the right. and I'm more interested in stopping illegal immigration than winning an election. And what part of "We stressed as hard as we could in the bill that racial profiling will NOT be tolerated" don't you get? (yes I'm paraphrasing)

According to your logic, I would also assume that the 21% of hispanics (using the latest poll) that support the bill are also self-haters and bigots against themselves, right?

 

 

 

I don't know who the person you're referring to is, so I'm not directing this at them... but it's so common these days for people to have that kind of logic. If you're hispanic and support something that other hispanics are against, you either hate yourself, your people, or are a hypocrit. Regardless if you have a logical reason for your views, you're going to run into a lot of angry people - many who have no idea what they're talking about. I see it as this collective victim mentality that people exhibit when they believe they are underrepresented or being oppressed. Of course, a few will see this and say I'm being racist towards minorities but I really don't care, I would think the same way if this was a predominantly hispanic/black/asian country and whites would protest everything with racism as a reason. This doesn't neccessarily pertain to the law you're discussing on here, but there's so much bickering in this country due to people believing they're entitled to more simply because they believe they're being mistreated by the majority. The ironic part is that it leads to more racism and intolerance and the moment that people realize that they aren't the victims they believe they are is the moment this country will move forward in race relation issues.

Well, you did say this:

 

“Knowing history, it isn't a big deal for the GOP. In the 1960's, this country was about 85% white (non-hispanic.) Today, that number has decreased to about 65%, yet the GOP hasn't lost any popularity. As long as a higher percentage of non-hispanics keep on voting for the GOP, they don't need an increase in support from hispanics.�

 

Saying that they don’t need increasing support from Hispanics explicitly means that the party can remain viable through the support of white voters. Perhaps you should clarify.

 

Secondly, your examples aren’t valid because as I stated above, party politics have shifted dramatically since the 1960s. During the Civil Rights era, it was many prominent Democrats lobbying for Southern segregation against the Kennedy wing. Most importantly, the Republicans didn’t start heavily polarizing minorities until much later (perhaps peaking around the 1990s with regard to Hispanics). And of course, GOP support has been extremely volatile since the 1960s, despite what you said earlier.

 

Simply put, the arising situation with the minority voter demographic is rather unprecedented for the GOP.

 

A 2008 Census Bureau estimate indicates that by 2042, minorities will be the majority and by 2050 they will reach 54%.

 

http://www.cnn.com/2...ties/index.html

 

Your math just doesn’t really add up. Over those coming decades, getting 60% of the white vote isn’t going to cut it for the GOP. As I said already, McCain got the white vote by a 7-12 point margin. According to Gallup, McCain got 56% to Obama’s 44%. That resulted in a 7% total popular vote victory for Obama.

 

http://www.gallup.co...roups-2008.aspx

 

You keep saying that as long as white non-Hispanics keep voting for GOP, the party will be fine. In 2008, they got the white majority handily and still lost. You can try to pass this off on high black turnout, but if the GOP starts establishing a record of anti-Hispanic policies, the Hispanics will be incentivized to come out and vote.

 

 

 

My historic examples actually fit perfectly, as during those time periods the Irish/Italians/Jews/other Catholics all were an increasing demographic that tended to vote for the Democratic Party, yet the GOP always found a way to survive. But if you really are going to just deny history, I'll move on.

 

If you would have taken what I said literally, you would have understood my argument. Here is my quote from my earlier post:

 

"As long as a higher percentage of non-hispanics keep on voting for the GOP, they don't need an increase in support from hispanics."

 

The point I made was that it doesn't matter if the GOP only receives roughly 1/3 of the hispanic vote in the future, because they will remain in good shape if the amount of non-hispanics voting for them continues to rise.

 

You're also confusing the percentage of minorities as a whole in the United States with the percentage of voters that are actually minorities. In 2008, the demographics of the U.S. looked like this: 66% white, 15% hispanic, 14% black, 5% asian. However, the voting demographics looked like this: 74% white, 13% black, 9% hispanic, 2% asian, and 2% other according to this- http://www.projectvote.org/images/publications/Reports%20on%20the%20Electorate/Demographics_of_Voters_in_the_2008_Election.pdf

 

So let's use this similar voting trend for the year 2050, when whites will make up 46%, hispanics 30%, blacks 15%, and asians 9%. Comparing this to the 2008 voter demographics, in 2050 whites will make up (roughly, trying to include the 2% "other" in the previous poll) 62% of voters, hispanics 20%, blacks 14%, and asians 4%.

 

Now, let's say that between 2010 and 2050 the percentage of whites voting for the GOP keeps on increasing, so the GOP in 2050 receive 65% of the white vote. That would give them 40% of all voters already. Let's also say that they take 1/3 of the hispanic vote which is 7% of all voters, increasing their total to 47%.

 

We'll assume the GOP takes around 10-15% of the black vote, and about 1/4 of the asian vote. 10-15% of the black vote equals 2% of all voters, and 1/4 of the asian vote is 1% of all voters. 47% + 2% + 1% = 50% popularity among all voters.

 

And there you have it, a perfectly logical scenario where the GOP would still have a thriving party.

According to your logic, I would also assume that the 21% of hispanics (using the latest poll) that support the bill are also self-haters and bigots against themselves, right?

 

 

 

I don't know who the person you're referring to is, so I'm not directing this at them... but it's so common these days for people to have that kind of logic. If you're hispanic and support something that other hispanics are against, you either hate yourself, your people, or are a hypocrit. Regardless if you have a logical reason for your views, you're going to run into a lot of angry people - many who have no idea what they're talking about. I see it as this collective victim mentality that people exhibit when they believe they are underrepresented or being oppressed. Of course, a few will see this and say I'm being racist towards minorities but I really don't care, I would think the same way if this was a predominantly hispanic/black/asian country and whites would protest everything with racism as a reason. This doesn't neccessarily pertain to the law you're discussing on here, but there's so much bickering in this country due to people believing they're entitled to more simply because they believe they're being mistreated by the majority. The ironic part is that it leads to more racism and intolerance and the moment that people realize that they aren't the victims they believe they are is the moment this country will move forward in race relation issues.

 

 

It was directed towards FutureGM (the person I quoted.)

 

The point you made is absolutely correct though. I didn't find it surprising at all that the only station that frequently reported on Harry Reid saying that he couldn't believe how any hispanic could possibly be a Republican was Fox News.

 

Imagine if Mitch McConnell came out and said that he couldn't believe how any white person could possibly be a Democrat. Most would have probably called for his called for his resignation in seconds.

 

Going back to your point though, racism in this country will never end as long as people are classified as a group. Every election you hear news reports on how a certain politician will be able to win the "hispanic vote" or the "black vote". Rarely do you simply see a discussion about campaigning strategy where race/ethnicity isn't involved.

 

I also look at how much hate someone like Clarence Thomas receives for not "backing his people" by supporting affirmative action. It's really disgusting to be honest, because it's as if minorities in this country aren't allowed to think for themselves.

Don't forget that slowly those 2nd or third generation Hispanics (especially those who have a white parent) will lose much of that Hispanic identity and for voting purposes will probably cease to be Hispanics altogether. I know you're only looking 40 years ahead but you probably can't go further than that without being entirely off

 

As time passes the minority will integrate into the majority. Hell, we see it in second generation Hispanics. It seems like half of the people interviewed in Arizona on the bill are of Hispanic descent yet can't express themselves fully in Spanish (I watch univision or telemundo or something when eating dinner)

It's pure fallacy to say that the GOP will "always find a way to survive" under that historical context and ignore the present circumstances. It's an illogical generalization. In history, there have been other circumstances that have caused shifts in party identification. We must assume that there will be no immediate shifts in party allegience among minority voters, since the GOP is not pursuing policy to attract them while the Democrats are doing little to expel them.

 

On what planet can you assume that the GOP is going to be getting 65% of the white vote by 2050? This alone makes your numbers preposterous. What will the GOP percentage be in 2050 if you use a number closer to earth (say 55%)? I also question your extrapolation for the Hispanic voter turnout by 2050. By that time, the Hispanic population will have increased dramtically from the domestic birth rate (these are citizens who will be able to vote), and not necessarily due to a proportion of illegals living in the US equal to 2010.

 

 

 

Well, all I have to do in order to argue my theory is twist your statement around. The Democrats are not pursuing a policy to attract white voters at all, while the Republicans are doing everything they can to get more of them.

 

Attracting 65% of the white vote is definitely not out of the question for the GOP. According to this- http://www.dailykos.com/story/2010/8/13/892857/-Comparing-the-White-Vote-and-the-General-Vote, Reagan won over 65% of the white vote in 1984. Also, Bush won 58% of the white vote in 2004, so it is far from a stretch to say that the GOP can manage to increase their popularity with white voters by just a few points in the next four decades.

 

The U.S. Census Bureau has had very little success in counting illegal immigrants, so my numbers from the census (the fact that hispanics currently make up 15% of the U.S. population) doesn't even include illegals (or barely any.) Plus, predictions of future demographics also do not take into consideration certain actions that could stop the flow of hispanics coming into America. For example, if the border is completely secure within the nexy few years and the U.S. decides to hand out less Visas due to overpopulation (both of which are at least somewhat likely to occur), the projection that in 2050 30% of America's population will be hispanic could obviously be misconstrued.

How are the Republicans specifically targeting white voters? What policies are they implementing or proposing that explicitly address the needs of whites? There really isn’t a common ground between the two scenarios whatsoever.

 

Isolated cases of Republican candidates in the past (Regan in 1984) does not substantiate whatsoever that the GOP will take 65% of the white vote for most of the years between 2012 and 2050. Reagan faced a weak candidate and faced an unprecedented political climate where conservative ideology increased in popularity and liberalism declined. You are making the same logical mistake you made earlier in claiming that radically different events will set precedents for the future will ignoring the present and forthcoming circumstances. What is your rationale for the GOP taking 65% of the white vote consistently for 40 years other than simply saying “well, Reagan did it in 1984…?�

 

You yourself say it’s “not out of the question� to get 65% of the white vote. Well, that could simply be blind optimism. Nothing is out of the question, so we must consider what is realistic. In reality, based on recent white voting trends, a number closer to 55% is much more realistic. What is the expected GOP vote total under that scenario?

 

The Census Bureau does at least attempt to record the illegal population, while this does in fact prove to be difficult. The point I was making earlier is that while there might be a lot of non-citizens off of the books, their citizen children will be on them. This is probably why the Census Bureau retracted 2050 as the year that minorities overtake whites and replaced it with 2042; their projections are far more likely to underestimate the Hispanic population than overestimate it.

 

Obviously any changes in policy in the future could drastically alter the Hispanic population in either direction. That isn’t important when we are discussing how the current policy decisions could unfold in the future under the current circumstances.

 

 

 

You and I both know that it's not politically correct in the modern era to say that the GOP is going after the "white vote." For example though, just as opposition to the Arizona law and support for Obamacare will help attract hispanics and blacks to the Democratic Party, support for the Arizona law and opposition to Obamacare will help the GOP with the white vote.

 

Also, I said that by the year 2050, the GOP will probably be able to capture 65% of the white vote. My examples were provided simply to portray that the situation is far from impossible, as you tried to describe it earlier. Just to satisfy you though, the GOP would have the support of 44% of Americans if they only received 55% of the white vote.

 

You accuse me of making blind assumption while you are doing the exact same thing. Do you even know the age demographics of hispanics? And even if you do, I would guarantee you that the Census Bureau already took that into account.

I'm confused. Are you guys that oppose this bill saying you would rather have illegal immigrants and more voters rather than legal immigrants?

 

Just a warning though, I am card-carrying republican.Though I tend to lean more towards the center than the right. and I'm more interested in stopping illegal immigration than winning an election. And what part of "We stressed as hard as we could in the bill that racial profiling will NOT be tolerated" don't you get? (yes I'm paraphrasing)

 

 

Hmm...

 

In the other thread, you listed three things an officer could use to have reasonable suspicion that someone is an illegal, and you listed this as your first:

 

Accent

 

 

I don't see any way in which judging someone's status by accent isn't racial profiling.

 

So my question to you, then, is what part of that don't you get?

I vote for everybody having to show citizenship papers at the request of authority. Regardless of heritage, race, whatever. If you're legal, this shouldn't hurt your feelings that bad. I know that strips us of a certain freedom as Americans, but that is a freedom I'm willing to give up if it means it will help this country in countless ways, and benefit citizens that work and pay taxes.

I'm confused. Are you guys that oppose this bill saying you would rather have illegal immigrants and more voters rather than legal immigrants?

 

Just a warning though, I am card-carrying republican.Though I tend to lean more towards the center than the right. and I'm more interested in stopping illegal immigration than winning an election. And what part of "We stressed as hard as we could in the bill that racial profiling will NOT be tolerated" don't you get? (yes I'm paraphrasing)

 

 

Hmm...

 

In the other thread, you listed three things an officer could use to have reasonable suspicion that someone is an illegal, and you listed this as your first:

 

Accent

 

 

I don't see any way in which judging someone's status by accent isn't racial profiling.

 

So my question to you, then, is what part of that don't you get?

I am a white male, with dark brown eyes, and dark brown hair, and a darker complexion that gets even darker during the summer. In Ga., where I live, I am assumed white. If I go to the city next to mine, Gainesville, Ga., a heavily mexican city, I could be confused. If I go to south Florida, where I'm from, I could and have been assumed to be Cuban. If I go to Chicago, I could very easily be assumed to be Italian. Nevada - Native American, etc.... The dividing factor.....I speak perfect english.

How are the Republicans specifically targeting white voters? What policies are they implementing or proposing that explicitly address the needs of whites? There really isn’t a common ground between the two scenarios whatsoever.

 

Isolated cases of Republican candidates in the past (Regan in 1984) does not substantiate whatsoever that the GOP will take 65% of the white vote for most of the years between 2012 and 2050. Reagan faced a weak candidate and faced an unprecedented political climate where conservative ideology increased in popularity and liberalism declined. You are making the same logical mistake you made earlier in claiming that radically different events will set precedents for the future will ignoring the present and forthcoming circumstances. What is your rationale for the GOP taking 65% of the white vote consistently for 40 years other than simply saying “well, Reagan did it in 1984…?�

 

You yourself say it’s “not out of the question� to get 65% of the white vote. Well, that could simply be blind optimism. Nothing is out of the question, so we must consider what is realistic. In reality, based on recent white voting trends, a number closer to 55% is much more realistic. What is the expected GOP vote total under that scenario?

 

The Census Bureau does at least attempt to record the illegal population, while this does in fact prove to be difficult. The point I was making earlier is that while there might be a lot of non-citizens off of the books, their citizen children will be on them. This is probably why the Census Bureau retracted 2050 as the year that minorities overtake whites and replaced it with 2042; their projections are far more likely to underestimate the Hispanic population than overestimate it.

 

Obviously any changes in policy in the future could drastically alter the Hispanic population in either direction. That isn’t important when we are discussing how the current policy decisions could unfold in the future under the current circumstances.

 

 

 

You and I both know that it's not politically correct in the modern era to say that the GOP is going after the "white vote." For example though, just as opposition to the Arizona law and support for Obamacare will help attract hispanics and blacks to the Democratic Party, support for the Arizona law and opposition to Obamacare will help the GOP with the white vote.

 

Also, I said that by the year 2050, the GOP will probably be able to capture 65% of the white vote. My examples were provided simply to portray that the situation is far from impossible, as you tried to describe it earlier. Just to satisfy you though, the GOP would have the support of 44% of Americans if they only received 55% of the white vote.

 

You accuse me of making blind assumption while you are doing the exact same thing. Do you even know the age demographics of hispanics? And even if you do, I would guarantee you that the Census Bureau already took that into account.

What you are saying isn’t logically consistent.

 

The Democrats receive the minority vote (support of minorities) because they have specific initiatives that appeal to this demographic. This is facilitated by the GOP opposing most of those initiatives.

 

However, the GOP is not targeting the white vote either explicitly or implicitly. It has nothing to do with political correctness. They are merely adhering to a platform that does not appeal to minority voters, but they aren’t attempting to reel in white voters specifically. It sounds like to me that you are insinuating that the GOP does what it can to get specifically white support, although it doesn’t openly admit it. I find this to be questionable logic.

 

The AZ law attracts Hispanics to the Democrats because many of them might potentially feel oppressed like second class people. The law does not directly pertain to whites, so you can’t openly say it has an equal effect in attracting whites. Ultimately for the white vote, the AZ law is just like every other issue.

 

And again, saying that something is “far from impossible� doesn’t mean that it is intellectually honest to use that figure as a hard number in projecting the white vote consistently over the next four decades. Yes, 65% was a one-time occurrence under different circumstances (detached from the present time). It’s absurd to use that as the estimate of white vote breakdown over the forthcoming years.

 

I’m not making blind assumptions on anything. It’s always necessary to take into account certain possibilities with census studies. I’m merely saying that it’s something to be aware of down the road since they’ve already adjusted the figure once already. It should be outright frightening to Republicans when they consider how many illegals off of the books are in this country having children. If the GOP is only projected to be getting 44% of the vote they are already in trouble, but this variable could potentially make things much worse.

 

 

The GOP is definitely targeting the white vote. The only reason that most (like you) do not think so is because they can't come out and directly say they are doing so.

 

You aren't using the cause-and-effect method at all here. For example, the fact that the GOP doesn't go out of its way just to cater to minorities by supporting policies such as affirmative action is a method in which the Republican Party can attract more white supporters.

 

A policy doesn't have to directly target a specific group in order for it to have that purpose. Obamacare doesn't specifically target black voters, but the Democrats know that they received a major boost in support from the black community by passing it. The same thing can be said for the Arizona law. Most Republicans knew that a strong majority of whites wanted a halt on illegal immigration, which prompted the creation of the Arizona law.

 

For the second time, I never said that the GOP will receive approximately 65% of the white vote "over the next four decades." If you would look back to my post, you would see that I said that by the year 2050 the GOP has a very good chance at receiving 65% of the white vote.

 

I don't even recall when it was originally projected that whites would be a minority in 2050, but I guess I'll have to take your word for it. I highly doubt though, that the Census Bureau didn't think of something that you easily could have thought of.

I vote for everybody having to show citizenship papers at the request of authority. Regardless of heritage, race, whatever. If you're legal, this shouldn't hurt your feelings that bad. I know that strips us of a certain freedom as Americans, but that is a freedom I'm willing to give up if it means it will help this country in countless ways, and benefit citizens that work and pay taxes.

 

 

I think if we explore ways to make a drivers license a more official form of identification it could do the trick. What's the minimum amount of information necessary for a government official to deem someone a U.S. Citizen, anyhow?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.