Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Post Game 8/8/11

Featured Replies

  • Author

Aww come on you can't say that Dobbs hasn't been a big influence positively to the team.. You might not agree best marlin but you cannot say that he has been a hindrance to this team. It's nice having someone off the bench that can actually get you some runs and definitely some hits and platoon at 3rd. I would try to look up his defensive numbers in comparison to our everyday starters, those that have around the same number of innings, but I'm on my phone and can't really look it up without taking forever.

Aww come on you can't say that Dobbs hasn't been a big influence positively to the team.. You might not agree best marlin but you cannot say that he has been a hindrance to this team. It's nice having someone off the bench that can actually get you some runs and definitely some hits and platoon at 3rd. I would try to look up his defensive numbers in comparison to our everyday starters, those that have around the same number of innings, but I'm on my phone and can't really look it up without taking forever.

 

Of course Dobbs has been a pleasant surprise, at least with the bat. He has been a below-average fielder, though. But the bottom line is that he's nowhere in the realm of Mike Stanton, this year or otherwise.

 

By the way, Dobbs is a negative WAR player for his career on BR, and net 1.9 WAR of fangraphs.

The Marlin of the year is Mike Stanton. He's the best player on the team. It's obvious.

 

 

 

 

 

Marlin of the year is Dobbs or Bonifacio, there hasn't really been a best player this year though when all is said and done Dobbs has been most consistent as well as the most clutch I think thats a no-brainer.

 

Stanton has been good but he's not the Marlin of the year a .261 average isn't Marlin of the year, I don't care what kind of power he has.

 

Marlins of the year don't strike out with the bases loaded in the 9th either. (Yes I was there)

Re: Clutch:

 

Runners in scoring position:

Greg Dobbs - .748 OPS, 27 RBI/85 PA ~ .32 RBI/PA with RISP.

Mike Stanton - .789 OPS, 42 RBI/127 PA ~ .33 RBI/PA with RISP.

 

Late and Close:

Greg Dobbs - .734 OPS, 12 RBI/64 PA ~ .19 RBI/PA Late and Close.

Mike Stanton - .885 OPS, 18 RBI/76 PA ~ .24 RBI/PA Late and Close.

 

In the two most "clutch" situations, Stanton has a higher OPS and is getting RBI at a higher rate than Dobbs. And he's a much better fielder. Heck, he's faster, too,

 

I love how you only use "some" stats to back up your claims, I don't only use stats I use my eyes.

 

If baseball was played on paper (which I know you wish it was, it would be boring as hell.)

 

Concerning Close and Late:

 

Dobbs is batting .322

Stanton is batting .224

 

Not even close, I'll take batting average AND OBP over SLG any day of the week.

 

Yea Stanton is going to have more RBI's but that's probably due to the fact that he starts everyday and has more power.

 

Besides that it doesn't change the fact that Dobbs has been more "consistent" and has stepped up more in clutch situations this year.

 

Not saying Stanton hasn't had clutch moments just not as many as Dobbs, not this year at least.

Even though taking batting average over OBP and SLG is more than questionable, especially when there is such a big gap, you are still wrong.

 

Stanton doesn't have more RBI just because he starts everyday. I already laid this out for you above - in close and late situations, as well as with runners in scoring position, Stanton has more RBI PER AT BAT. As in, when he comes to the plate in those situations, he is more likely to end up with an RBI than Dobbs. Not sure what is so complicated or arguable here. Even if Dobbs has a higher batting average in those spots, Stanton still somehow ends up with RBIs more frequently (as a rate) in "clutch" situations.

  • Author

Aww come on you can't say that Dobbs hasn't been a big influence positively to the team.. You might not agree best marlin but you cannot say that he has been a hindrance to this team. It's nice having someone off the bench that can actually get you some runs and definitely some hits and platoon at 3rd. I would try to look up his defensive numbers in comparison to our everyday starters, those that have around the same number of innings, but I'm on my phone and can't really look it up without taking forever.

 

Of course Dobbs has been a pleasant surprise, at least with the bat. He has been a below-average fielder, though. But the bottom line is that he's nowhere in the realm of Mike Stanton, this year or otherwise.

 

By the way, Dobbs is a negative WAR player for his career on BR, and net 1.9 WAR of fangraphs.

 

Just out of curiosity, how does Dobbs compare to Hanley this year defensively? I would guess they have around the same amount of innings.

Not for debate but just curious.

 

I would be lying to say I'm familiar enough to argue WAR, but Dobbs last few years in philly were pretty bad, is there a calculated WAR for just this year?

Geez, I can't imagine our record without Dobby!

 

 

/end sarcasm

 

 

Dude, he got killed in the Deathly Hallows Part 1.....

Dude, he got killed in the Deathly Hallows Part 1.....

Aww come on you can't say that Dobbs hasn't been a big influence positively to the team.. You might not agree best marlin but you cannot say that he has been a hindrance to this team. It's nice having someone off the bench that can actually get you some runs and definitely some hits and platoon at 3rd. I would try to look up his defensive numbers in comparison to our everyday starters, those that have around the same number of innings, but I'm on my phone and can't really look it up without taking forever.

 

Of course Dobbs has been a pleasant surprise, at least with the bat. He has been a below-average fielder, though. But the bottom line is that he's nowhere in the realm of Mike Stanton, this year or otherwise.

 

By the way, Dobbs is a negative WAR player for his career on BR, and net 1.9 WAR of fangraphs.

 

Just out of curiosity, how does Dobbs compare to Hanley this year defensively? I would guess they have around the same amount of innings.

Not for debate but just curious.

 

I would be lying to say I'm familiar enough to argue WAR, but Dobbs last few years in philly were pretty bad, is there a calculated WAR for just this year?

 

Fangraphs and Baseball Reference have fielding stats, and they scale them to +/- defensive runs, i.e. +7 means you have been worth 7 runs above average with your defense. WAR is an overall calculation, and it's not really an argument per se, but just a number which is the sum total of other stats - always hitting and fielding, and now often including baserunning.

The Marlin of the year is Mike Stanton. He's the best player on the team. It's obvious.

 

No he's not, see when you make ignorant statements like this, I question if you sometimes just go off of emotion when you make statements.

 

I don't need mystikol's input to know Dobbs has been more "consistent" this year at the plate.

 

I know Stanton is a blooming superstar, with a .261 average but I don't show bias to my favorite players because I'm frustrated I just call it like it is.

 

I like Stanton I just don't agree with you.

 

BTW, the "real" best player on this team is still on the DL.

 

But I mean, were all allowed to have opinions, you can keep yours, I'll keep mine.

How can a guy who started 6 games during the month of July be our "most consistent" player?\

 

He only appeared in 18 of our 27 games that month.

 

Sorry, a guy who has roughly 60% playing time does not get to be your best player. That's stupid. You don't get to be in the conversation for best player if you're not playing every day. You also don't get to be considered consistent when you hit .228 with a .548 OPS for the entire month of June.

In terms of most valuable, you could probably name a dozen guys on the team before mentioning Dobbs. There's a reason why players like Greg Dobbs change teams just about every year.

The Marlin of the year is Mike Stanton. He's the best player on the team. It's obvious.

 

No he's not, see when you make ignorant statements like this, I question if you sometimes just go off of emotion when you make statements.

 

I don't need mystikol's input to know Dobbs has been more "consistent" this year at the plate.

 

I know Stanton is a blooming superstar, with a .261 average but I don't show bias to my favorite players because I'm frustrated I just call it like it is.

 

I like Stanton I just don't agree with you.

 

BTW, the "real" best player on this team is still on the DL.

 

But I mean, were all allowed to have opinions, you can keep yours, I'll keep mine.

 

If it's so ignorant, you could come up with something better than "he's hitting .261!"

 

If batting average is so important, you can have your team with nine Greg Dobbs; I'll take my team with nine Mike Stanton's, and we'll see who wins.

 

Dobbs could hit .330, for all I care; Stanton's power and differential in defense, alone, make him a more valuable player. Always.

And power is more important than anything else for a hitter, anyway.

 

This is the only thing I'll disagree with, you had good points with everything else.

If a hitter has just power and nothing else, you get Mark Reynolds or Adam Dunn. Stanton isn't exactly in that grouping with them, since I believe he's capable of hitting .300 at some point with a ton less strikeouts, but you get what I'm saying.

 

If Mike Stanton's career offensively = Adam Dunn, he'll be in the hall of fame. I don't see anything wrong with Adam Dunn. A big reason he sucks so much this year is because his power numbers aren't the same, not necessarily because he strikes out a lot. He's had a productive career, however.

In terms of most valuable, you could probably name a dozen guys on the team before mentioning Dobbs. There's a reason why players like Greg Dobbs change teams just about every year.

 

 

I can understand the argument for Dobbs, because he's been a pretty decent stop gap at a position where we really needed him. But you have to really overrate him to say he's THE MOST valuable. There's value in being a roughly average player who shores up a hole on the team.

 

But MVP is between Stanton and Gaby.

 

 

 

It's also funny that a roughly one month cold streak has turned Gaby into a guy that EVERYONE was calling our most consistent hitter into a guy that everyone hates now.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.