Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2012-2013 Florida Panthers/NHL Thread

Featured Replies

Got my tickets for Saturday night. Anyone else going?

I want to go--- all this panthers talk is getting me hungry for hockey.

Looks like Ed Jovanovski is the new captain of the #FlaPanthers ... Appears Dineen just told them on the ice

 

-@GeorgeRichards

There goes Weiss.

Looks like Ed Jovanovski is the new captain of the #FlaPanthers ... Appears Dineen just told them on the ice

 

-@GeorgeRichards

You know, after I thought about this for a minute, it makes perfect sense. Jovo has been leading the team from behind the scenes and that's a good choice for the time being. But Dineen also knows that Jovo probably won't be playing for more than another 3 years or so (or at least the Panthers won't keep him for longer than that), and that opens up that captaincy position just about the time Gudbranson is ready for it.

They were so sucessful they didn't get to the playoffs for 10+ years with all of those goalies?

 

What I'm getting at is a platoon has an effect on a goalie by ruining routine. Once that routine is ruined, it's difficult to get it back. When coaches like Torterella routinely play the hot hand until the magic is gone, the back up in that instance or 1B is usually rusty, overprepared and playing like he wants to keep his job- rather than playing because he's capable.

 

Rolo/Fernandez/Harding was a great platoon, but they did nothing together.

 

Beezer/Ricther was considered one of the best tandems in the game in the early 90's. Richter was the hot shot prospect, Beezer was the Vet who won a Vezina. With expansion they could only keep one, so Beezer went off to Vancouver (so VAN wouldn't have to give up one of their goalies).

 

The point is platooning hasn't worked for this team, and it needs to come to an end. My hope is Luongo is bought out at the end of the year but I don't believe he will be a Canuck then. You find stability in net, and you can focus on offense and defense. We have a defense. We'll have a goalie for 3+ years. For the next 3 years we can focus on Forwards and Centers, which has proven to be our achilles heel with low scoring outputs.

 

Tim Thomas is old (not retired yet though, Kiprusoff is old and capable, Brodeur the same. It is possible to be a strong goaltender in your late 30's.

 

My opinion is get a long term answer at goalie, find some stability between the pipes- and continued success will follow.

 

Markstrom should be in Florida playing to see what they have. This offseason its possible Luongo, Bryzgalov, Dipietro (I know, I know), and certain Thomas, Backstom, and Tomas Griess (I'd like to see him find a chance) will all be free agents.

 

With a shortened season, and one I believe that has been compacted- you can have two goalies playing every other game with the same rest between a number 1 will get in a normal year.

 

I like Markstrom, I hope he develops into a top 10 goalie in the least- but if he isn't the answer where do you go from there.

 

 

There lack of success had nothing to do with what was in net, though. That was always the only one good thing the Panthers had. They usually had zero offense, or in the cases where they were really really bad, zero offense and zero defense.

 

Tortorella? What does he have to do with this? As in, TB/NYR coach? In his time with TB he never had good goalies. Khabibulin/Graham were good goalies that ditched early. Ramo, Smith, Denis, etc. all suck. They were never good, never have been good, and never will be good. He was never playing a hot hand so much as he was desperately trying to find a goalie who didn't suck. I don't need lessons in expansion history :p

 

If you're talking about John Torchetti, the Florida Panthers interim head coach in 2004, he didn't have a platoon. He had Roberto Luongo and a bad backup in Steve Shields.

 

I have no idea what you mean by Roloson/Fernandez/Harding did nothing together.

 

Beezer won the Vezina during a season that he by no means deserved the Vezina. Beezer was nothing more than an average goalie in the 80s. He only played two seasons with Richter, the first of which he hardly put up his mediocre career numbers.

 

The point is not that platooning hasn't worked for this team. This team has been highly successful at platooning. I don't know what you're talking about. The evidence is there. We've yet to have a failure of a season in net while platooning in the entire history of this franchise.

 

I don't think anyone's serious concern is Luongo's age. It's his cap hit, and it's the fact that we have Jacob Markstrom. We don't need Luongo to stopgap, and if/when all turns out nicely, we definitely don't need his cap hit to sit on the bench.

 

We've got plenty of depth in goal, too. If Markstrom doesn't pan out, we have options to explore from within. There's also options to explore externally. Little known secret though... if Markstrom doesn't pan out, we will know that sometime a year or two before Luongo's contract expires.

 

I would LOVE to sign a free agent Roberto Luongo. That's a completely different story and it requires Roberto Luongo is bought out. We can talk about that if the opportunity comes along. Until then, we should not be wasting money (5x) paying what would be our backup/1B goalie to play less games than the player who is hopefully starting.

 

 

Most of what I meant, and I realized I didn't say it exactly---

 

We've been trading assets to acquire goaltending for over a decade, and it's cost us in not having any offense / not being able to trade for offense since our assets are routinely tied into our pipes.

 

Most of the goalies that played here we traded for I believe: Vernon (with SJ for Radek Dvorak), Mclean (Carolina for Ray Sheppard) ,Kidd (With ATL), Anderson (Blackhawks), Auld (Canucks/Luongo Deal to get offense with Bertuzzi), Vokoun (1st and 2nd Round Picks)

 

We gave up alot of good offensive players for these guys, and good picks. Those two picks could have helped us gain offensive players, but we had a hole at goaltending we needed addressing.

 

Like I meant before- stop the revolving door at Goalie, and we'll be able to focus on the offense.

 

 

This isn't true either.

  • Author

Well the one time we did it, it paid off and we had one of the best runs in Panther history in net with Tomas Vokoun. Clearly got our value's worth.

  • Author

Looks like Ed Jovanovski is the new captain of the #FlaPanthers ... Appears Dineen just told them on the ice

 

-@GeorgeRichards

There goes Weiss.If anything it's a clear indication that Stephen Weiss never wanted to be captain.

Well the one time we did it, it paid off and we had one of the best runs in Panther history in net with Tomas Vokoun. Clearly got our value's worth.

 

Right and I'm assuming he had no problem with that trade considering he wants to do the same thing for Luongo now.

  • Author

And if we were not already in a fine position I would approve.

 

But we've got a nice tandem to pull through with until we can get Markstrom up.

 

Well, Clemmensen is a system goalie who sucks when you suck in front of him but that's another story...

Well the one time we did it, it paid off and we had one of the best runs in Panther history in net with Tomas Vokoun. Clearly got our value's worth.

 

 

Right and I'm assuming he had no problem with that trade considering he wants to do the same thing for Luongo now. At the time I actually did because I didn't believe we were a goaltender away from competing. I also viewed Vokoun as a good goalie with bad lapses in judgement on save selection based on his time with Nashville. He did make strides in Florida and he was fun to watch, but he wasn't going to make the difference.

 

I don't see Luongo demanding more than a goalie, a first and third and a defenseman. His trade value isn't as high as it should be and everyone knows if Vancouver keeps him he's going to be amnestied on July.

 

Knowing that he wants to play in Florida, and he is available one way or the other should help him get here.

 

What ever happened to our first round pick that year anyway?

  • Author

I would never give up a 1st, 3rd, and a defenseman for Luongo.

 

In light of the recent captainship given to Jovo, the ONLY trade I would consider for Luongo is:

 

Upshall, 2nd, mid tier prospect

 

for

 

Luongo

Well the one time we did it, it paid off and we had one of the best runs in Panther history in net with Tomas Vokoun. Clearly got our value's worth.

 

 

Right and I'm assuming he had no problem with that trade considering he wants to do the same thing for Luongo now.At the time I actually did because I didn't believe we were a goaltender away from competing. I also viewed Vokoun as a good goalie with bad lapses in judgement on save selection based on his time with Nashville. He did make strides in Florida and he was fun to watch, but he wasn't going to make the difference.

 

I don't see Luongo demanding more than a goalie, a first and third and a defenseman. His trade value isn't as high as it should be and everyone knows if Vancouver keeps him he's going to be amnestied on July.

 

Knowing that he wants to play in Florida, and he is available one way or the other should help him get here.

 

What ever happened to our first round pick that year anyway?

 

-Vokoun's always been consistent.

-That's a lot for Luongo.

-This current team isn't a better goaltender away from competing for a Stanley Cup either.

 

Goaltending was the strength of the team last year. Goaltending has been the strength of the team for awhile now. They need to score more.

Which, considering I don't know what luongos value is- might get it done.

 

He has a full no trade clause, and he can grab the Canucks by the balls and force a trade to Florida.

 

I just looked it up- we traded a 9th overall first round pick for vokoun and the 40th that year, and thd 2007 58th overall.

 

Was Vokoun worth that?

Well the one time we did it, it paid off and we had one of the best runs in Panther history in net with Tomas Vokoun. Clearly got our value's worth.

 

Right and I'm assuming he had no problem with that trade considering he wants to do the same thing for Luongo now.At the time I actually did because I didn't believe we were a goaltender away from competing. I also viewed Vokoun as a good goalie with bad lapses in judgement on save selection based on his time with Nashville. He did make strides in Florida and he was fun to watch, but he wasn't going to make the difference.

 

I don't see Luongo demanding more than a goalie, a first and third and a defenseman. His trade value isn't as high as it should be and everyone knows if Vancouver keeps him he's going to be amnestied on July.

 

Knowing that he wants to play in Florida, and he is available one way or the other should help him get here.

 

What ever happened to our first round pick that year anyway?

 

-Vokoun's always been consistent.

-That's a lot for Luongo.

-This current team isn't a better goaltender away from competing for a Stanley Cup either.

 

Goaltending was the strength of the team last year. Goaltending has been the strength of the team for awhile now. They need to score more.

 

Vokoun a stats have always been consistent- he's always had mental lapses with bad passes and very very poor goals allowed.

I'd have liked to see Campbell get the C but Jovo has done a lot for the team behind the scenes and is a great locker room leader. Don't mind him having it. The Soupy One should definitely be an A, though. Weiss too.

Which, considering I don't know what luongos value is- might get it done.

 

He has a full no trade clause, and he can grab the Canucks by the balls and force a trade to Florida.

 

I just looked it up- we traded a 9th overall first round pick for vokoun and the 40th that year, and thd 2007 58th overall.

 

Was Vokoun worth that?

You've made an argument on here for Luongo saying we should trade assets because a revolving door at goalie does not work so I'm assuming you think he's worth that.

 

Vokoun is a #1 and we did not have a revolving door when he was here.

 

Would you be okay trading the same value for Luongo right now? What would you like to trade for Luongo?

Well the one time we did it, it paid off and we had one of the best runs in Panther history in net with Tomas Vokoun. Clearly got our value's worth.

 

Right and I'm assuming he had no problem with that trade considering he wants to do the same thing for Luongo now.At the time I actually did because I didn't believe we were a goaltender away from competing. I also viewed Vokoun as a good goalie with bad lapses in judgement on save selection based on his time with Nashville. He did make strides in Florida and he was fun to watch, but he wasn't going to make the difference.

 

I don't see Luongo demanding more than a goalie, a first and third and a defenseman. His trade value isn't as high as it should be and everyone knows if Vancouver keeps him he's going to be amnestied on July.

 

Knowing that he wants to play in Florida, and he is available one way or the other should help him get here.

 

What ever happened to our first round pick that year anyway?

 

-Vokoun's always been consistent.

-That's a lot for Luongo.

-This current team isn't a better goaltender away from competing for a Stanley Cup either.

 

Goaltending was the strength of the team last year. Goaltending has been the strength of the team for awhile now. They need to score more.

 

Vokoun a stats have always been consistent- he's always had mental lapses with bad passes and very very poor goals allowed.

 

Vokoun was consistently good.

He might've had bad stretches at times, but that's the case for every goalie, Luongo included.

Well the one time we did it, it paid off and we had one of the best runs in Panther history in net with Tomas Vokoun. Clearly got our value's worth.

Right and I'm assuming he had no problem with that trade considering he wants to do the same thing for Luongo now.At the time I actually did because I didn't believe we were a goaltender away from competing. I also viewed Vokoun as a good goalie with bad lapses in judgement on save selection based on his time with Nashville. He did make strides in Florida and he was fun to watch, but he wasn't going to make the difference.

 

I don't see Luongo demanding more than a goalie, a first and third and a defenseman. His trade value isn't as high as it should be and everyone knows if Vancouver keeps him he's going to be amnestied on July.

 

Knowing that he wants to play in Florida, and he is available one way or the other should help him get here.

 

What ever happened to our first round pick that year anyway?-Vokoun's always been consistent.

-That's a lot for Luongo.

-This current team isn't a better goaltender away from competing for a Stanley Cup either.

 

Goaltending was the strength of the team last year. Goaltending has been the strength of the team for awhile now. They need to score more.Vokoun a stats have always been consistent- he's always had mental lapses with bad passes and very very poor goals allowed.

Vokoun was consistently good.

He might've had bad stretches at times, but that's the case for every goalie, Luongo included. Dropping into a butterfly at the top of the crease when the puck is off to the right boards is a pretty big mental lapse.

 

It's an even bigger mental lapse trying to catch the puck across your body when your blocker is there to direct it into the boards.

 

Or even to take penalties for playing the puck in your restricted zone- or tripping over the net when you pass the puck poorly along the boards.

 

Luongo may butterfly too much and not rely enough on his trapper, but he's never looked aloof out there.

 

Well- except that playoff game he was yelling at the refs.

The point is that every goalie allows bad goals.

As of right now, you can group Luongo and Vokoun into the same class/tier of goalies.

I really don't get why people think we need a goalie. Without injuries, this is a playoff team with Markstrom/Theodore. Clemmensen is a fine fill in until Markstrom gets here.

 

Yeah, it's a shortened season and you want to win all you can both early and late but there's no reason to trade assets for a goalie right now.

I really don't get why people think we need a goalie. Without injuries, this is a playoff team with Markstrom/Theodore. Clemmensen is a fine fill in until Markstrom gets here.

 

Yeah, it's a shortened season and you want to win all you can both early and late but there's no reason to trade assets for a goalie right now.

I'm the only one on this board who has openly said he wants @strombone1 . My preference is when he's cut but you get him when you can.

 

I heard a interesting rumor of the flyers trading bryz to NYI for Dipietro, only to amnesty Dipietro and start Bob in net.

 

Islanders would keep Bryz but get rid of Ricks contract. Flyers get whatever they get for taking Rick- be it picks or players.

Which, considering I don't know what luongos value is- might get it done.

 

He has a full no trade clause, and he can grab the Canucks by the balls and force a trade to Florida.

 

I just looked it up- we traded a 9th overall first round pick for vokoun and the 40th that year, and thd 2007 58th overall.

 

Was Vokoun worth that?

 

You've made an argument on here for Luongo saying we should trade assets because a revolving door at goalie does not work so I'm assuming you think he's worth that.

 

Vokoun is a #1 and we did not have a revolving door when he was here.

 

Would you be okay trading the same value for Luongo right now? What would you like to trade for Luongo? I would be okay with the same rounds and a player from depth. If we can get a Canucks offensive player I'd add more obviously.

 

Right now we wouldn't be trading the 9th overall pick, or the 40th, I'd see it as the 20th or so and the 50th.

 

Outside of the top 10 it's hard to judge talent, although its there. Top 10 picks should be coveted.

I really don't get why people think we need a goalie. Without injuries, this is a playoff team with Markstrom/Theodore. Clemmensen is a fine fill in until Markstrom gets here.

 

Yeah, it's a shortened season and you want to win all you can both early and late but there's no reason to trade assets for a goalie right now.

I'm the only one on this board who has openly said he wants @strombone1 . My preference is when he's cut but you get him when you can.

 

I heard a interesting rumor of the flyers trading bryz to NYI for Dipietro, only to amnesty Dipietro and start Bob in net.

 

Islanders would keep Bryz but get rid of Ricks contract. Flyers get whatever they get for taking Rick- be it picks or players.Why on earth would the Flyers a) trade Bryzgalov who won them 33 games last year and who they have under a steal of a contract and b) even consider taking on the contract of DiPietro, who cannot stay healthy to save his life and even when he is healthy is a bottom tier goalie? To make that even somewhat attractive for the Flyers they'd need to be getting Taveres. Where did you hear that because that source is on some good drugs.

I really don't get why people think we need a goalie. Without injuries, this is a playoff team with Markstrom/Theodore. Clemmensen is a fine fill in until Markstrom gets here.

 

Yeah, it's a shortened season and you want to win all you can both early and late but there's no reason to trade assets for a goalie right now.

 

I'm the only one on this board who has openly said he wants @strombone1 . My preference is when he's cut but you get him when you can.

 

I heard a interesting rumor of the flyers trading bryz to NYI for Dipietro, only to amnesty Dipietro and start Bob in net.

 

Islanders would keep Bryz but get rid of Ricks contract. Flyers get whatever they get for taking Rick- be it picks or players.Why on earth would the Flyers a) trade Bryzgalov who won them 33 games last year and who they have under a steal of a contract and b) even consider taking on the contract of DiPietro, who cannot stay healthy to save his life and even when he is healthy is a bottom tier goalie? To make that even somewhat attractive for the Flyers they'd need to be getting Taveres. Where did you hear that because that source is on some good drugs.

The idea is Bryz for players, and cut Dipietro.

 

Bryz was considered aloof last year and didn't fit in. Ask any flyers fan snd some anonymous sources and they regret Bryz signing / trade and not giving bobosky a chance.

 

I like Bryz, but he didn't seem to work out.

 

Oh- and YouTube his name for interviews leading up to the winter classic. Priceless

I really don't get why people think we need a goalie. Without injuries, this is a playoff team with Markstrom/Theodore. Clemmensen is a fine fill in until Markstrom gets here.

 

Yeah, it's a shortened season and you want to win all you can both early and late but there's no reason to trade assets for a goalie right now.

I'm the only one on this board who has openly said he wants @strombone1 . My preference is when he's cut but you get him when you can.

 

I heard a interesting rumor of the flyers trading bryz to NYI for Dipietro, only to amnesty Dipietro and start Bob in net.

 

Islanders would keep Bryz but get rid of Ricks contract. Flyers get whatever they get for taking Rick- be it picks or players.Why on earth would the Flyers a) trade Bryzgalov who won them 33 games last year and who they have under a steal of a contract and b) even consider taking on the contract of DiPietro, who cannot stay healthy to save his life and even when he is healthy is a bottom tier goalie? To make that even somewhat attractive for the Flyers they'd need to be getting Taveres. Where did you hear that because that source is on some good drugs.

 

 

I think you mean Bryzgalov is stealing money from the Flyers, right?

Rinne: 7 years/$49 million ($7 million per year)/23 wins per year

Backstrom: 10 years/$67 million ($6.7 million per year)/27 wins per year

Lundqvist: 6 years/~$39 million (~$6.5 million per year)/36 wins per year

Price: 6 years/$39 million ($6.5 million per year)/25 wins per year

Ward: 6 years/$37.8 million ($6.3 million per year)/29 wins per year

Lehtonen: 5 years/$29.5 million ($5.9 million per year)/21 wins per year

Quick: 10 years/$58 million ($5.8 million per year)/26 wins per year

Bryzgalov: 9 years/$51 million ($5.6 mil per year)/20 wins per year

Fleury: 7 years/$35 million ($5 million per year)/28 wins per year

Brodeur: 2 years/$9 million ($4.5 million per year)/35 wins per year

Hiller: 4 years/$18 million ($4.5 million per year)/24 wins per year

DiPietro: 15 years/$67.5 million (4.5 million per year)/13 wins per year

Schneider: 3 years/$12 million ($4 million per year)/10 wins per year

Pavelec: 5 years/$19.5 million ($3.9 million per year)/14 wins per year

Halak: 4 years/$15 million ($3.75 million per year)/18 wins per year

Rask: 1 year/$3.5 million ($3.5 million per year)/9 wins per year

Anderson: 4 years/$12.75 mil ($3.18 million per year)/13 wins per year

Varlamov: 3 years/$8.5 million ($2.83 million per year)/14 wins per year

Nabokov: 1 year/$2.75 million ($2.75 million per year)/28 wins per year

Crawford: 3 years/$8 million ($2.6 million per year)13 wins per year

Howard: 2 years/$4.5 million ($2.25 million per year)/18 wins per year

Smith: 2 years/$4 million ($2 million per year)/15 wins per year

Lindback: 2 years/$3.9 million ($1.95 million per year)/8 wins per year

Reimer: 3 years/$5.4 million ($1.8 million per year)/17 wins per year

Theodore: 2 years/$3 million ($1.5 million per year)18 wins per year

Bobrovsky: 3 years/$2.70 million ($0.9 million per year)/21 wins per year

Holtby: 3 years/$1.86 million ($0.62 million per year)/7 wins per year

 

That's this year's starting goalies' (with DiPietro thrown in for laughs) salaries with their season average win total.

 

If not for a season ending injury in 2007, that wins/year number would be a lot higher. Probably somewhere around 25-30 as the Ducks were second in their division that year with a 47-27 record. Taking that into account, he deserves the money he gets paid and probably should get a little more.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.