February 26, 20215 yr 3 hours ago, SonOfJack said: Every team operates that way. I've said it before, but everyone expected Brinson to start 2018 in the minors in order to secure an additional year of team control. It shows the Marlins absolutely will thumb their nose at service time issues, but I imagine, especially after Brinson, they want to be 100% sure this guy will succeed at MLB. For Belday, he won't make the MLB roster because of a matter of time -- the lack of it. There's simply no way he can prove he's 100% ready with just a good Spring Training (hasn't even faced AA yet). But if he looks good in ST and breaks AA pitching for a month... I think it gets very tempting to call him up.
February 26, 20215 yr 2 hours ago, Photo-Realistic Billy said: I've said it before, but everyone expected Brinson to start 2018 in the minors in order to secure an additional year of team control. It shows the Marlins absolutely will thumb their nose at service time issues, but I imagine, especially after Brinson, they want to be 100% sure this guy will succeed at MLB. For Belday, he won't make the MLB roster because of a matter of time -- the lack of it. There's simply no way he can prove he's 100% ready with just a good Spring Training (hasn't even faced AA yet). But if he looks good in ST and breaks AA pitching for a month... I think it gets very tempting to call him up. Do you think this extra conditioning in 2018 will help his 2021 season? I'm so sick of these mediocre players. I want to see Harold have a better year than Brinson... Sorry. His dumb face made me cranky and it is Friday...so I am reverting to a 10 year old. Edited February 26, 20215 yr by Major-Minor
February 26, 20215 yr 3 hours ago, rmc523 said: Like I said, regardless teams will work around the rules to their benefit. I guess to be fair, if they're not put on the 40 man, they're subject to getting Rule 5'd. And if you get a top prospect who's going to either go on the Rule 5 draft or starting service time a little earlier ... teams might be more willing to bring em up.
February 27, 20215 yr 5 hours ago, Michael said: It forces the team to not hold their top prospects down though. But, they'd just keep em off the 40 then ... so eh. But they already have the rule 5 draft to protect against this problem.
February 27, 20215 yr What about an arbitration style way of determining the details of service time? This way teams can manipulate the roster however they want but an independent third party determines the actual service time so that players who have been dicked around get their service time but teams who had valid reasons to make moves are still able to do so. Because 100% of the power can't just go to the players in this... there are actually times when teams have legitimate reasons to keep a player down. Having human judgment finalize service time instead of doing it mathematically would be the key here.
February 27, 20215 yr 17 minutes ago, SilverBullet said: But they already have the rule 5 draft to protect against this problem. Protect from keeping them off the 40, yes. But if service time is tied to the 40 ...
February 27, 20215 yr 15 hours ago, SilverBullet said: What about an arbitration style way of determining the details of service time? This way teams can manipulate the roster however they want but an independent third party determines the actual service time so that players who have been dicked around get their service time but teams who had valid reasons to make moves are still able to do so. Because 100% of the power can't just go to the players in this... there are actually times when teams have legitimate reasons to keep a player down. Having human judgment finalize service time instead of doing it mathematically would be the key here. Interesting idea. But then you're rolling the dice with every (top) player? Would that still cause teams to just keep guys down longer to be safe? Like if the guy played 10 games and this arbitration panel awards him 20 games of time because they "feel" he should get that? Just thinking out loud.
March 1, 20215 yr On 2/27/2021 at 11:18 AM, rmc523 said: Interesting idea. But then you're rolling the dice with every (top) player? Would that still cause teams to just keep guys down longer to be safe? Like if the guy played 10 games and this arbitration panel awards him 20 games of time because they "feel" he should get that? Just thinking out loud. On 2/27/2021 at 11:18 AM, rmc523 said: Interesting idea. But then you're rolling the dice with every (top) player? Would that still cause teams to just keep guys down longer to be safe? Like if the guy played 10 games and this arbitration panel awards him 20 games of time because they "feel" he should get that? Just thinking out loud. Obviously I don't have the kinks worked out but if they kept a guy down longer and his stats showed he should be up and the roster dictated he should be up then the hearing would side with the player. Or something like that lol.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.