I would say Yes sign him but not for more then $6mill a year.

It all depends on how Castro/Redmond are doing. Plus, it doesn't seem that Pudge left the team on good terms, so I would be surprised to see him back.

no way he is a free agent on May 1st

no way he is a free agent on May 1st

Umm why? I been saying it since he started talk with the Fish, only an idiot will give him $10+mill a year.

Umm why? I been saying it since he started talk with the Fish, only an idiot will give him $10+mill a year.

He'll lower his demands.

no way he is a free agent on May 1st

Umm why? I been saying it since he started talk with the Fish, only an idiot will give him $10+mill a year. he will lower his demands..... dont be foolish

if by some miracle he's still a FA by may 1st there is no way in hell he would get $6 mill in my opinion. i wouldnt mind bringing him back, but like someone said it depends on Castro/Redmond. but for $6 mill? hell no, he'll have to swallow up his pride and inflatable ego and take a huge paycut to come here or anywhere if he's still a FA come May 1st

if mr. rodriguez is still a free agent come may 1, i would offer him a contract.

 

 

for 2 million dollars.

i might even go half a mill to a million lower

pudge is an idiot, he should of taking our 2 year offer

i will never welcome that idiot back after how he left our organization

Give him 5 bucks and a candy bar. Maybe a croqueta or two and thats it.

I would want to see how Castro develops first. If we are struggling, then yeah for $3-4 million.

What's the point? The Marlins FO already said he's not coming back in 2004.

If he is still available I say go for it.

i would hire pudge for 3 mill to be the janitor so that everbodyy has a chance to feed him crow

 

noing pudge, he probly accept it to

Give him 5 bucks and a candy bar. Maybe a croqueta or two and thats it.

 

Lmao. That's funny.

 

I wouldn't mind seeing him come back, but I mean if he doesn't wanna be there because supposedly they're not paying him "enough" then what's the point? He's obviously not playing for the game, he's playing for the money, and why would the Marlin players want him back after he betrayed them??? I'm sure i would be pretty pissed if I saw his face again. All for the money. You don't see Juan Pierre complaining, probably our most valuable player, he didn't even make close to a 4th of what Pudge made... but he dooesn'tt care. He plays the game with heart! I mean why would Pudge even want to eb with a nother team? With a team liek the Marlins they could win soooo many more World Series! I just don't get it. PLus, what could Pudge possibly do with all that money, why would he wnat even more? Not liek he's even gonna spend half of it in his whole lifetime!

Yes.

right now, i really don't care much for him...that's just me.

i dont know if its just me, but now when i watch the DVD and see him and hear him say all that stuff about being happy playing down here, it looks so fake.

you aren't the only one...

i dont know if its just me, but now when i watch the DVD and see him and hear him say all that stuff about being happy playing down here, it looks so fake.

Ugh, I saw that today and thought the same thing. Really sucks.

when he put on the jersey for the 1st time at Sring traning and some one asked "how does it feel?" and he just looks at something, i forget if it was his glove or bat or maybe the jersey and then says like he's trying to think: "its different". it just looked and sounded so fake

No i wont mind.

 

But he was being a LITTLE greedy asking for more money.

 

We need him back, he was a big key last season. He started bad in the first half but after he was heating up. The Pitchers were getting very comfortable with Pudge behind the plate.

 

Who wouldnt like him behind the plate anyways.

But he was being a LITTLE greedy asking for more money.

 

We need him back

:lol