January 31Jan 31 Author 6 hours ago, Spike said:Edwards isnt anyone you have to worry about going year to year with.He is a good defender at 2B but he is a poor hitter.X is a good hitter.
January 31Jan 31 3 hours ago, TaiwanMarlins said:X is a good hitter.Spike has guys that he just decides suck and won't get off that train until they win a Cy Young. (and then he'll just be desperate to trade that guy) Edited January 31Jan 31 by farmer_fran
January 31Jan 31 Edwards is not a good hitter. He is exactly replacement level and that is with a .330 BABIP. He is 15th out of 22 qualified 2B in WRC+. He has no power and doesn't draw BBs. In a perfect world with a normal operating franchise, with his weak bat and positional versatility, he would be a utility guy.Spike has guys that he just decides suck and won't get off that train until they win a Cy Young. (and then he'll just be desperate to trade that guy)I never said Alcantra sucked. Just that he wasnt and ace. And he objectively never has been, as even in that kind of flukey Cy Young year his peripheral stats weren't particularly good. Edited January 31Jan 31 by Spike
January 31Jan 31 6 hours ago, Spike said:Edwards is not a good hitter. He is exactly replacement level and that is with a .330 BABIP. He is 15th out of 22 qualified 2B in WRC+. He has no power and doesn't draw BBs. In a perfect world with a normal operating franchise, with his weak bat and positional versatility, he would be a utility guy.I never said Alcantra sucked. Just that he wasnt and ace. And he objectively never has been, as even in that kind of flukey Cy Young year his peripheral stats weren't particularly good.X is a 2.5 to 3.5 WAR player spike lol. He has elite speed so his babip can sustain that high. .340+ OBP with his speed is valuable. He walks at exactly the league average. He also plays elite 2b.Sandy’s cy young year was flukey? The peripherals are excellent and he had an elite GB rate. He also put up 4 WAR the season before. You’re out to lunch m8 Edited January 31Jan 31 by pollythewog
February 1Feb 1 6 hours ago, pollythewog said:X is a 2.5 to 3.5 WAR player spike lol. He has elite speed so his babip can sustain that high. .340+ OBP with his speed is valuable. He walks at exactly the league average. He also plays elite 2b.Sandy’s cy young year was flukey? The peripherals are excellent and he had an elite GB rate. He also put up 4 WAR the season before. You’re out to lunch m8I may be sensing a particular pattern here in players he criticizes ...... but I may also just be trippin'.
February 1Feb 1 1 hour ago, pollythewog said:X is a 2.5 to 3.5 WAR player spike lol. He has elite speed so his babip can sustain that high. .340+ OBP with his speed is valuable. He walks at exactly the league average. He also plays elite 2b.Sandy’s cy young year was flukey? The peripherals are excellent and he had an elite GB rate. He also put up 4 WAR the season before. You’re out to lunch m8Edwards WAR is basically all defense. Whether his BABIP is sustainable is irrelevant, as his bat is below average even considering that.I dont hate Edwards. But he isnt some irreplaceable player that you should worry about extending.
February 1Feb 1 Author 11 hours ago, Spike said:Edwards WAR is basically all defense. Whether his BABIP is sustainable is irrelevant, as his bat is below average even considering that.I dont hate Edwards. But he isnt some irreplaceable player that you should worry about extending.What a coincidence that MLB think X is among the most underrated players now.
February 1Feb 1 11 hours ago, Spike said:Edwards WAR is basically all defense. Whether his BABIP is sustainable is irrelevant, as his bat is below average even considering that.I dont hate Edwards. But he isnt some irreplaceable player that you should worry about extending.I agree he shouldn’t be extended at this juncture (he’s just 26) but he’s an above average player not a utility IF (that’s Starlyn Caba ceiling). I guarantee X is a top 12 2b this year WAR-wise if healthy. .345 OBP with elite speed does not grow on trees amigo. Edited February 1Feb 1 by pollythewog
February 1Feb 1 I think it is just a different valuation of players. I dont really think guys that are mediocre at BB and depend on putting the ball in play to get on base are that valuable. And that bores out as Edwards basically has zero offensive value from advanced metrics. He might be a high WAR player this season, but it will again be entirely from his defense which is hard to quantify.
February 1Feb 1 45 minutes ago, Spike said:I think it is just a different valuation of players. I dont really think guys that are mediocre at BB and depend on putting the ball in play to get on base are that valuable. And that bores out as Edwards basically has zero offensive value from advanced metrics. He might be a high WAR player this season, but it will again be entirely from his defense which is hard to quantify.Your narrative isn’t even correct though. Mediocre means “below average” yet X career walk rate is literally at the league average 8.4%.
February 1Feb 1 He was slightly above average in 2024 and slightly below average in 2025. The rest of his offensive game isnt anything to write home about either. Again, he is bottom of the league for 2B for OPS+ and WRC+ and his offensive contribution to his WAR is at replacement level.
February 1Feb 1 Suarez only $15M To reds. Not saying he would come here, but sure could have used him
February 1Feb 1 6 minutes ago, pollythewog said:Suarez only $15M To reds. Not saying he would come here, but sure could have used himWe have enough DHs already.
February 1Feb 1 5 minutes ago, Michael said:We have enough DHs already.Pal he’s an average to above average 3b still what are you even saying - he’s a better defender than Norby that’s for sure. Also, none of our DH Will come close to his offensive output anyway. It looks like he wanted to go back Cinci anyway but still
February 2Feb 2 3 hours ago, pollythewog said:Pal he’s an average to above average 3b still what are you even saying - he’s a better defender than Norby that’s for sure. Also, none of our DH Will come close to his offensive output anyway. It looks like he wanted to go back Cinci anyway but stillGeno:Fielding Run Value: -3 (26th percentile)Range (OAA): -6 (9th percentile)Arm Strength: 82.9 (39th)Norby:Fielding Run Value: -3 (26th)Range: -4 (15th)Arm Strength: 84.7 (53rd)What are you talking about?
February 2Feb 2 1 hour ago, Michael said:Geno:Fielding Run Value: -3 (26th percentile)Range (OAA): -6 (9th percentile)Arm Strength: 82.9 (39th)Norby:Fielding Run Value: -3 (26th)Range: -4 (15th)Arm Strength: 84.7 (53rd)What are you talking about?How about 2024?
February 2Feb 2 Just now, pollythewog said:How about 2024?Why do we care about 2024? This is the players they are most recently.
February 2Feb 2 10 hours ago, Michael said:Why do we care about 2024? This is the players they are most recently.Pal Eugenio is a known solid to above solid defender with a long track record. He won’t be DHing anytime soon m8.
February 2Feb 2 26 minutes ago, pollythewog said:Pal Eugenio is a known solid to above solid defender with a long track record. He won’t be DHing anytime soon m8.And Arenado was a perennial gold glover until he wasn't. They're the same age. Suarez may not be that anymore, considering how drastic a dip he just had.He can play the spot, but he's likely DH material now, or first base. Won't or shouldn't be playing third anymore.
February 2Feb 2 23 minutes ago, Michael said:And Arenado was a perennial gold glover until he wasn't. They're the same age. Suarez may not be that anymore, considering how drastic a dip he just had.He can play the spot, but he's likely DH material now, or first base. Won't or shouldn't be playing third anymore.Graham Pauley better than either so
February 2Feb 2 Author Marlins and Pirates, two of the most stingy franchises in MLB, all said want to spend big in the beginning of this off-season, so who's the bigger liar now ? Edited February 2Feb 2 by TaiwanMarlins
February 2Feb 2 1 hour ago, TaiwanMarlins said:Marlins and Pirates, two of the most stingy franchises in MLB, all said want to spend big in the beginning of this off-season, so who's the bigger liar now ?That's on you for believing them...
February 3Feb 3 Author Bendix waited for bargains at the SP market now. Edited February 3Feb 3 by TaiwanMarlins
February 3Feb 3 Author 13 hours ago, rmc523 said:That's on you for believing them...I won't believe in them if they said it every year but it seems it's the first time they said it since this regime take over.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.