Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2025/26 Off-season

Featured Replies

3 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

So Avisail Garcia finally retired….

Disaster of a contract before the ink even dried....

2 hours ago, rmc523 said:

Disaster of a contract before the ink even dried....

Not even close to the disaster that was the purchase contract from Loria to Sherman

29 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

Not even close to the disaster that was the purchase contract from Loria to Sherman

They aren't mutually exclusive disasters lol.

The Mesa brother signings might be the strangest story in MLB history. Scouts get things wrong, it happens a lot. I don't know that they have ever been as wrong about a player as they were Victor Victor.

Just now, Spike said:

The Mesa brother signings might be the strangest story in MLB history. Scouts get things wrong, it happens a lot. I don't know that they have ever been as wrong about a player as they were Victor Victor.

I get them confused - which was the older, was it Victor Victor Mesa, or was it Victor Mesa, Jr.?

Victor Victor was older and had a lot of hype. Got I think around $5 million bonus and rocketed up top prospects lists. It was realized almost immediately after he actually got to the team that something was way off with his scouting evaluation and he couldn't hit at all. He eventually went missing in the sense he stopped showing up. He was beyond awful.

Victor Mesa Jr, who was just DFA, was the lesser thought of brother and was signed for around $1 million and largely to help get his brother to sign. He pretty quickly leapfrogged his brother.

I really would like a deep dive someday of how they got it so wrong. And this isnt really a condemnation of the Marlins either, the Orioles(IIRC) were willing to give them that much money too.

55 minutes ago, Spike said:

Victor Victor was older and had a lot of hype. Got I think around $5 million bonus and rocketed up top prospects lists. It was realized almost immediately after he actually got to the team that something was way off with his scouting evaluation and he couldn't hit at all. He eventually went missing in the sense he stopped showing up. He was beyond awful.

Victor Mesa Jr, who was just DFA, was the lesser thought of brother and was signed for around $1 million and largely to help get his brother to sign. He pretty quickly leapfrogged his brother.

I really would like a deep dive someday of how they got it so wrong. And this isnt really a condemnation of the Marlins either, the Orioles(IIRC) were willing to give them that much money too.

The hype around the Cuban prospects was still riding a high back then.

2 hours ago, Spike said:

Victor Victor was older and had a lot of hype. Got I think around $5 million bonus and rocketed up top prospects lists. It was realized almost immediately after he actually got to the team that something was way off with his scouting evaluation and he couldn't hit at all. He eventually went missing in the sense he stopped showing up. He was beyond awful.

Victor Mesa Jr, who was just DFA, was the lesser thought of brother and was signed for around $1 million and largely to help get his brother to sign. He pretty quickly leapfrogged his brother.

I really would like a deep dive someday of how they got it so wrong. And this isnt really a condemnation of the Marlins either, the Orioles(IIRC) were willing to give them that much money too.

Jeter and co were just god-awful talent evaluators.

I'll be looking for Acton Saturday for his autograph before he goes all Osvaldo Bido on us

On 1/30/2026 at 10:53 PM, TheMarlinsProject said:

My least favorite Marlin of all time retired today. F U David Robertson. Here's to hoping he trips on a baseball in his living room on the way to the recliner.

Excuse me, you have a group call from Jorge Julio, Andrew Cashner, Matt Herges, and Renyel Pinto on line 1.

8 hours ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

Marlins, thank you for not fooling us.

Huh? 3 days ago you were harping on them for lying about wanting to spend.......

image.png

  • Author
4 hours ago, rmc523 said:

Huh? 3 days ago you were harping on them for lying about wanting to spend.......

image.png

Marlins and Pirates both said want to spend in the beginning of the off-season but Marlins didn't fooling fans with numerous rumors of big name FAs like the Pirates did to their fans.

1 hour ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

Marlins and Pirates both said want to spend in the beginning of the off-season but Marlins didn't fooling fans with numerous rumors of big name FAs like the Pirates did to their fans.

1) I think on at least several of the FAs, it was confirmed the Pirates did actually present offers

2) The team can't control rumors

3) At least they tried, the Marlins don't bother.

23 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

Rays To Acquire Victor Mesa Jr. - MLB Trade Rumors

Mesa was actually not claimed by the Rays but rather traded to them, reports Kevin Barral of Fish On First. It doesn’t materially change the outcome for Tampa Bay, but Miami will be receiving a minor leaguer in return for Mesa rather than losing him for nothing.

Turned a lottery ticket who failed into another lottery ticket. I'm cool with it.

Super Bowl is done. Unofficial start of baseball season. Go Marlins!

Edited by FishFan95

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.