Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. 3 additional years of professional baseball, at any level, is a tremendous difference. A 25 year old Derrek Lee posted an OPS above .800, that's a far more relevant number if you wish to compare the players, which is foolish to begin with. Just as I said, a straw man argument. BTW, what three years are you referring to? Jacobs went back to A and into AA to learn a new position after missing virtually all of the 2004 season with his shoulder injury. Am I wrong to assume you know that? According to TBC they both are listed as having the same number of minor league service years. The fact is Lee was a total flop his rookie season and yet turned his career around and became the great player he is today. While I'm not suggesting Jacobs will do as well, comparatively speaking, Jacobs outplayed Lee in their rookie years. BTW NOTE : I stand corrected, while their at bats etc were very close in minor league play, one year counted against Lee is actually rehab time from the cubs but it was only one game/four at bats. So Lee had six years in the minors, Jacobs seven. One of Jacobs though was on the DL.
  2. I don't get it...you're not equating their rookie season, but then you are? Which is it. It's a terrible comparison seeing as how DLee was a full 3yrs younger than Jacobs. Beyond the silly DLee comparison (where did that come from?), I agree that he shouldn't be dumped for someone like Chris Duffy. Gee Sham, unless I confused some numbers and inwhich case mea culpa, I was comparing rookie season to rookie season. My contention is that the age differential was irrelevant ( it's nothing more than a straw man argument) when considered in the light of both having seven years minor league experience, both having about the same minor league at bats, etc. It isn't like DLee was some kid fresh off the farm and was thrust on the major league stage. He had plenty of years of professional experience before he got his shot. To call my post and the comparison to DLee, which is all over this thread, silly, is plain insulting. But like I said most people remember the 2003 DLee and the 2005 Mike Jacobs and somehow compare the two when comparing their rookie years is the right analysis in every category from at bats to OPS. They had almost identical chances to succeed. You may not like the results, but they are what they are.
  3. In a recent Marlins Mailbag Joe wrote in response to this question: Could the Marlins look at the Rule 5 Draft again next year for a center fielder, hopefully they can get a surprise pick like they did with Dan Uggla. -- Jimi F., Miami The Marlins certainly captured lightning in a bottle a year ago by plucking Uggla out of the Rule 5 Draft. While the scouting department is combing through potential Rule 5 candidates, to expect them to once again use the Rule 5 Draft to land a starting center fielder may be wishful thinking. Keep in mind, Rule 5 picks have to make the active roster on Opening Day and remain there throughout the entire season. It's just so rare to find available position players capable of doing that. Still, the front office spent a great deal of time in the Arizona Fall League searching for those diamonds in the rough. If last year taught us anything, it's that the Rule 5 Draft shouldn't be taken lightly. It's not surprising the Fish had scouts and talent evaluators in Arizona looking at players. We all know the Rule 5 rules have changed this season with an additional year added to ineligibility so there is a lesser chance of finding a quality player and an even lesser chance than that of finding a Rule 5 candidate (someone who did not wind up on their parent club's 40 man roster) at the AFL. If you're good enough to be picked by your team to participate in the AFL one would assume you are destined tobe paced on their 40 man roster. So my question is...were there any? Short of going through rosters of all the players in the AFL and checking player vs 40 man rosters which is an impossible task, has anyone seen a story on this or a list or anything? Just curious.
  4. It seems to be a popular sport these days to find reason to demean and villify Mike Jacobs as if he is what ails the Florida Marlins or is single-handedly keeping us from winning it all next year. Some here call his play terrible. Some revel in his .798 OPS as an indicator of his future performance. Well, if you're one of them you are about to be in for a rude awakening. There seem to be few among us who remember how many years Derrek Lee toiled in the minors before making it to the big leagues, only to fall flat on his face and not only lose his starting job after his first full season in the majors but be banished back to the minors. If he isn't the poster child for the belief that not all players mature at the same rate or that a player's first season in the majors is not always indicative of how their career will play out, I don't know who is. In fact, in researching this post, the number of "experts" back in the day wrote off Lee is almost funny, over and over suggesting he'd never amount to anything and was destined to be a bust. Sound familiar? While a healthy Lee was younger than Jacobs when he made it in 1998 than Jacobs was in 2005, what's lost here is that Lee started playing professional ball at age seventeen (1993) and it took him until 1998 (after a taste in *'97* ala Jacobs in '05) to make it onto a MLB roster, where he stunk up the joint batting .234 with a .318 OBP, .414 SLG and .732 OPS with 17 homeruns and 120 strikeouts in 454 at bats. So bad was his play as I alluded to above, the next season he lost his first base job and in 1999 spent more than half the season in Calgary, the Marlins AAA franchise at the time. Jacobs on the otherhand started his professional career in 1999 and made it to the bigs (as a taste in 2005) as a starter in 2006. He started in the minors as a catcher, but after losing almost an entire season after a shoulder injury, he was moved to first base where he played for one season. Nonetheless, in his first MLB year, hobbled by a stress fracture to his right ankle for the entire season, his rookie line was an improvement on Lee's in every single category. In 469 at bats, Jacobs hit 20 homeruns, batted .262 with an OBP of .325 and .473 SLG and .798 OPS. Not only that but Jacobs struckout less (105 times) as well. Am I equating the two? No. Is Mike Jacobs ever going to be the defensive star Derrek Lee has matured into? I doubt it very much and if I was a betting man I'd say no there as well. Will he ever become the hitter Derrek Lee has become? I'd probably say no but schools out on that one. Comparing rookie season to rookie season, with virtually the same number of years and at bats in the minors for each player entering their rookie MLB season, Mike Jacobs outperformed Derrek Lee in every offensive category including doubles (37 vs 29 for Lee). Not bad for a guy who could barely run the bases and who so many here are ready to throw under the bus. Only time will tell. The mind plays tricks with all of us. We remember Derrek Lee at his best and we're remembering an injured Mike Jacobs at what may turn out to be his worst. Even if he turns into a baby Carlos Delgado defensively and starts hitting 30+ homeruns year in and year out, that's not a guy I would be so quick to trade away for some spare part. All the numbers I've quoted are available at thebaseballcube.com. Here are the links: http://thebaseballcube.com/players/L/Derrek-Lee.shtml http://thebaseballcube.com/players/J/Mike-Jacobs-1.shtml
  5. It really comes down to where they wind with Clemens and Pettitte and at what price. If one or both don't come back, what good was Lee and the rest of the signings if they can't find a quality starter or starters to replace him/them? If they both want to come back, especially Roger, it may break the bank. The scenarios are endless. I think I read somewhere that the 'Stros payroll was supposed to be around $90 million, has already grown to over $100,000,000 and could go above $110 million before all is said and done with the gold dust twins. If you're the Astros trying to balance the books and the Marlins can provide a $350,000 starting pitcher who can give them 12-14 wins vs having to pay Clemens $12 million for half that number, in this white hot market, the Fish can have whatever they want, even without reason. If the Astros either lose their guys to free agency, retirement or are forced to pick between the two, any of the Marlins starting pitchers are worth a king's ransom. For the Marlins the question is do they wait another year or not? Do they enable the Astros to become perpetual contenders? Are the Fish better off waiting until the time is right based on what's right for them? Any way you cut it, the Marlins are in the driver's seat (if they want to be) in any trade involving starting pitching with the Astros.
  6. Wait, you mean they don't realize he did it all on a bad ankle, which clearly impared everything Mike Jacobs did last season, including derailing his attempts to cure cancer! He didn't have a "bad" ankle, he had a broken ankle, a stress fracture of his right ankle to be precise. It's laughable and yet sad at the same time how immature some people can be to continue feigning ignorance of the impact it had on his play, or the impact it would have on any player's play. And it's sad that some can be so ignorant that they ignore he had THE WORST OPS by any full time NL first-baseman. There's almost no response to this kind of ugliness except perhaps pity. Because you can't say ANYTHING to reconcile that he is, statistically speaking, THE WORST 1st baseman in the National League, ankle or no ankle. He's going to have to change so drastically to even be league average that it's foolish to blame his ankle for all his short comings. No, because watching you spew your hate with the moral superiority you so often try to display just makes me pity your parents for having spawned such an unhappy child. You seem to revel in being hurtful. Ignoring the guy toughed it out and played on a broken ankle all season only weakens your argument and betrays your understanding of the game, you're like one of those kids who enjoys pulling the wings off butterflies. Thanks Dr. Freud. You're incessant need to coddle players as if opinions are hurtful or that suggesting that they, as professionals, are not making the cut is blasphemous suggests to me that you are a deeply insecure person. After all, the degradation you love heaping on other people certainly screams that you need to build up your own weakened ego. Does looking in a mirror bring that much pain to you that you need to anonymously pick on others to feel better. My sad sad person, you epitomize paltriness. If you're going to try big words (those more than one syllable) you might want to invest in a dictionary. Works wonders.
  7. Wait, you mean they don't realize he did it all on a bad ankle, which clearly impared everything Mike Jacobs did last season, including derailing his attempts to cure cancer! He didn't have a "bad" ankle, he had a broken ankle, a stress fracture of his right ankle to be precise. It's laughable and yet sad at the same time how immature some people can be to continue feigning ignorance of the impact it had on his play, or the impact it would have on any player's play. And it's sad that some can be so ignorant that they ignore he had THE WORST OPS by any full time NL first-baseman. There's almost no response to this kind of ugliness except perhaps pity. Because you can't say ANYTHING to reconcile that he is, statistically speaking, THE WORST 1st baseman in the National League, ankle or no ankle. He's going to have to change so drastically to even be league average that it's foolish to blame his ankle for all his short comings. No, because watching you spew your hate with the moral superiority you so often try to display just makes me pity your parents for having spawned such an unhappy child. You seem to revel in being hurtful. Ignoring the guy toughed it out and played on a broken ankle all season only weakens your argument and betrays your understanding of the game, you're like one of those kids who enjoys pulling the wings off butterflies.
  8. I believe $200 million was the number quoted a year or so ago. But keep in mind there is a difference between liquidity and asset value. The way the art market has gone the last eighteen months he could be worth significantly more.
  9. Wait, you mean they don't realize he did it all on a bad ankle, which clearly impared everything Mike Jacobs did last season, including derailing his attempts to cure cancer! He didn't have a "bad" ankle, he had a broken ankle, a stress fracture of his right ankle to be precise. It's laughable and yet sad at the same time how immature some people can be to continue feigning ignorance of the impact it had on his play, or the impact it would have on any player's play. And it's sad that some can be so ignorant that they ignore he had THE WORST OPS by any full time NL first-baseman. There's almost no response to this kind of ugliness except perhaps pity.
  10. Wait, you mean they don't realize he did it all on a bad ankle, which clearly impared everything Mike Jacobs did last season, including derailing his attempts to cure cancer! He didn't have a "bad" ankle, he had a broken ankle, a stress fracture of his right ankle to be precise. It's laughable and yet sad at the same time how unknowledgable some people can be to continue feigning ignorance of the impact it had on his play, or the impact it would have on any player's play.
  11. At least for me this gets curiouser and curiouser. If the Marlins as an organization thinks Josh Willingham is a better "overall" first baseman I don't know what they could have possibly based that on since over the last three years and 170+/- games and 1,150+/- innings, Josh Willingham has played a total of three (3) innings at first base, less than Jason Wood, less than Miguel Olivo, lessthan Jeff Conine, less than Wes Helms. And according to flamarlins.com, Willingham did not play so much as a single inning at first base during spring training. One would think with an injured Mike Jacobs and Cody Ross or Joe Borchard or Alfredo Almezaga or Wes Helms available to play left field in place of Willingham so he could move over to first, if the Marlins were really interested in seeing how well Willingham played the position, somehow they would have found him some playing time there. Color me highly skeptical. :mischief2 Why would they move Helms to LF and put Willingham at 1b? That doesnt make much sense. And they are basing it on pure athleticism and the fact that Josh has been able to play SS, and 3b in the past. Mike Jacobs can barely move at 1b, you would have a better zone rating and defensive efficiency score. Don't be ridiculous Ramp. If they wanted to see the guy play there he would started a half dozen games in September, plattoned there instead of Wood or Amezaga or Miguel Olivo for chrissakes. They would have found time to evaluate him on the field, god knows with Jacobs injured they had every opportunity. Who exactly are these people anyways? If you're just blowing smoke up everyone's ass because you've had a hard*n for Willingham for a year and half that's okay, but to say Jacobs can barely move at first when you know he's playing with a stress fractured ankle is so disingenuous it's laughable. You should know better. Now what's the real story? BTW, I'm not adverse to Willingham platooning with Jacobs at first this season or taking over completely if Jacobs can't make the grade when he's healthy but the FO would be fools to give 25 homeruns that easily. Or are we back to Barry Bonds gimping around left field again? Is that what this is all about?
  12. At least for me this gets curiouser and curiouser. If the Marlins as an organization thinks Josh Willingham is a better "overall" first baseman I don't know what they could have possibly based that on since over the last three years and 170+/- games and 1,150+/- innings, Josh Willingham has played a total of three (3) innings at first base, less than Jason Wood, less than Miguel Olivo, less than Jeff Conine, less than Wes Helms. And according to flamarlins.com, Willingham did not play so much as a single inning at first base during spring training. One would think with an injured Mike Jacobs and Cody Ross or Joe Borchard or Alfredo Almezaga or Wes Helms available to play left field in place of Willingham so he could move over to first, if the Marlins were really interested in seeing how well Willingham played the position, somehow they would have found him some playing time there. Color me highly skeptical. :mischief2
  13. Gee, I'm enjoying not being in the middle of this argument, there's almost no words to describe how liberating it feels. I think you're both knit-picking. Baldelli had a couple of back to back serious injuries that almost ended his career. He fought his way back and you'd have to think if weren't playing on turf next season he'd have an even better chance of staying healthy. To suggest he's in decline and will only play 40 games next season is just plain silly. On the other side, it is fair to point out Jacobs played the entire season hurt. It was painful as a fan just watching him try to just run down the first base line, limping all the way, and to ignore that impacted his play undermines ones case. No one knows what kind of numbers he could have put up last season if he was healthy. I do remember he was the Mets' consensus (fans and media types) pick as their 2006 Rookie of the Year candidate after his performance last fall.
  14. The problem with this argument is people on either side continue to compare apples to oranges as if they're the same. My assumption is Ramp's continued hints that Jacobs will be traded in the near future have little to do with something onfield related. I find it impossible to believe some team covets him so much after seeing him play injured for an entire season that they're banging down the doots chanting "We want Jacobs! We want Jacobs!" Is he on someone's sh*t list? Did Girardi cause irreparable harm to him by playing him with a stress fracture to his ankle? You don't give upon a rookie who hits 20 homeruns on one foot without a reason. There has to be a back story here.
  15. Trade no one, at least until you know what a healthy Jeremy Hermida and Mike Jacobs are capable of contributing. Trade no starting pitcher until you know everyone is healthy and you have a sixth guy forcing the issue. Fixing one problem by creating two more gets you nowhere.
  16. One name I haven't seen in this thread is Chris Duffy, a player mentioned frequently in articles on centerfielders the Marlins are interested in. I would be disappointed if we gave up anything substantial for Duffy and would rather see the Marlins go out in the FA market and sign a one or two year rental before getting shafted in a trade for a CF with a questionable future. Here is the latest Duffy rumor: The Pirates reportedly could make a deal for Florida first baseman Mike Jacobs if they are willing to give up center fielder Chris Duffy. While Jacobs hit .262 with 20 homers and 77 RBIs in 136 games as a rookie last season, the Pirates are scared off by the fact he batted just .203 with six homers in the final two months. http://www.timesonline.com/site/news.cfm?n...78568&rfi=6 News travels slow to Beaver County. I believe Duffy's name has been mentioned on and off since the on-set of this discussion topic, if not in this thread other times. And it shouldn't come as any surprise that if he were acquired I wouldn't be unhappy, so long as we didn't part with starting pitching or a position player. Duffy is worth a prospect or prospects, depending who would be involved. If you look at his minor league splits and believe he can add twenty points to his average and thirty to his OBP, he wouldn't be the worst pickup for the team. It's all a matter of how much you give up to get him or anyone else.
  17. lofton is going to get 6+ million a year next year too much for our budget If Lofton gets $6 a year I will absolutely be shocked. I bet if we laid him $3 and said, you will start 100% of the time vs RHP in CF and sit 25+ games vs LHP (awful RHP/LHP splits), he'd sign a 1 year. If Juan Pierre gets 9 million a year I'd be shocked. Shocking is the best way to describe this FA market right now. And what does it say about Matt Kemp and several of the other Dodgers' over-hyped outfield prospects that they had to make the Pierre deal (for five years no less) in the first place? *edit*
  18. I've come to the conclusion, the real trade was Vargas for Owens and the other guys were added to even things out. I think we're all just going to have to wait until spring training to figure out what these guys have.
  19. I've tried writing a response three four times now and I give up. You win.
  20. Matt Kemp, Ryan Langerhans I've excluded Matt Kemp from my thinking because I can't imagine getting him for a reasonable price (a prospect not named Chris Volstad or a starter like Nolasco) but don't misunderstand, he works for me. Does strikeout alot though. As for Langerhans, can he even play CF? Wanna find a way to get RL as a corner outfielder, I'm game but he does strike out a ton, but CF? I don't know.
  21. Maier put up great numbers at AA Wichita (.306/.357) before heading off to the Arizona Fall league and batting .350/.371. He returned to Wichita and put up solid numbers, finishing the year with a line of .306/.357/.473 For the love of god man. If you're going to do a .350/.450 type line, you ignore the AVERAGE, not the SLUGGING percentage. I almost had a heart attack that you're recommending someone with a .663 OPS in AA. Lou, first of all happy Thanksgiving. What I'm trying to do is look for guys who get on base with enough frequency to equate with Hanley Ramirez' (.353 OBP) rookie season, so that Fredi Gonzalez is then in a position to move Hanley down in the lineup as he's suggested. *I hope you understand that.* And I'm trying to find entry level players who have yet to competely mature as ballplayers but emotionally and tools-wise are ready to play at the major league level. I'm looking for guys who are works in progress, the Dan Ugglas (generically), the Josh Willinghams. Guys who might take a season to really blossom but in the interim will be an asset to the team. Why? Because I think the likihood is he'll be an entry level player working for the league minimum and cheap for a number of years and equally as important will not cost us a starting rotation guy, rather an equivalent prospect or a second tier guy like a Mitre. So yes, I'm limiting my searches according to my own criteria. I've said before, I don't want to trade even Ricky Nolasco. He gets another decent year under his belt and his value *literally* doubles. I thought by now that was a given. I'm looking for a Jeff Conine, not a Miguel Cabrera. A David Eckstein, not a Derek Jeter. A complement to the team, not a new superstar. If you want to accuse me setting my sights too low as is your right, go ahead, but as I said above, my contention is if we found a new centerfielder who could play everyday and put up Hanley-like BA and OBP (not looking at Hrs, rbis etc.) in his rookie year, for $350k, I'd say job well done. uh, I don't know why my comment got this response. I understand completely what you want to do and I actually agree with you. But for a bench OF to maybe grow into a future starter, not for our starting CF. I want a Endy Chavez bench OF more then anything. The comment was about incorrectly citing statistics. A lot of guys ignore the average and go OBP/SLUG as the base OPS stats when discussing performance. Absolutely nobody goes AVG/OBP and that will lead to a lot of confusion. Just pointing it out. No problemo...I was explaining my thinking, not criticizing your post. And the numbers I'm looking at say an OPS of .830 at Wichita in '06, so someone is wrong but again maybe I'm missing you're point. Is it that you want me to ignore BA and post stats the way you want them posted? ( http://thebaseballcube.com/players/M/Mitch-Maier.shtml ) But then again I don't get the "bench OF" comment, it must be me because I didn't get Sham's "4th OF" or Spud's "second tier" either. The kid has so far been exclusively a minor leaguer climbing through an organization after graduating college (taste in Sept), this isn't Joe Borchard. He was just drafted in '03. What's that thing you get from eating too much turkey, tryptophanic shock? I fall on the mercy of the court, the turkey made me do it.
  22. I don't mind looking for second tier guys, and that's probably what we're likely to get if any. My only thing is, I'm not sure how many of these second tier guys are really capable of playing much better than Cody Ross could. Can he handle center regularly? Centerfield IS his position. Here's what the report posted above said about his defense: "...he's now widely regarded as the Royals' best defensive outfielder in the system. His arm is good enough to play at either corner, and it's even better in center." He's listed as anywhere from the number five to eight prospect in the entire orgainzation, not among position players, all players. By "second tier" do you mean he's not an established major league player?
  23. maybe. there's a much, much larger chance he fails to even carve out 4th OFer career if you look at the history of such players. I'm trying to figure out what you keep referring to when you things like "such players". And I'm not trying to be disagreeable but the kid is a first round draft pick (2003), by every account this has been a breakout year for him, he's coming off a successful AFL experience and he's actually considered a higher valued prospect now than at the beginning of the season. Again, not saying you're wrong and I'm right or that the kid is can't miss, but I am truly confused what you mean?
  24. I'm sure there's several candidates we haven't discussed yet in fact I can think of several, but what it comes *down to which road you think the front office will travel*. Do you think the Marlins *are willing* to commit millions over the next three years to a Baldelli or Taveras or someone else who is either under contract or about to enter their arbitration years *at the same time they try and hold onto Willis and Cabrera*, or do you think the Marlins will continue to try and find developable talent that fits with what they started last season? Obviously, I believe the latter. That's why you've read me bringing up Willits, Costa, Gathright and now Maier. BTW, thanks for the comment on Willits et al but truth be told I didn't "find" Willits, a freelance writer put him together with the Marlins as a good get for the team. What I did was research the heck out of the guy. *edit*
  25. Maier put up great numbers at AA Wichita (.306/.357) before heading off to the Arizona Fall league and batting .350/.371. He returned to Wichita and put up solid numbers, finishing the year with a line of .306/.357/.473 For the love of god man. If you're going to do a .350/.450 type line, you ignore the AVERAGE, not the SLUGGING percentage. I almost had a heart attack that you're recommending someone with a .663 OPS in AA. Lou, first of all happy Thanksgiving. What I'm trying to do is look for guys who get on base with enough frequency to equate with Hanley Ramirez' (.353 OBP) rookie season, so that Fredi Gonzalez is then in a position to move Hanley down in the lineup as he's suggested. *I hope you understand that.* And I'm trying to find entry level players who have yet to competely mature as ballplayers but emotionally and tools-wise are ready to play at the major league level. I'm looking for guys who are works in progress, the Dan Ugglas (generically), the Josh Willinghams. Guys who might take a season to really blossom but in the interim will be an asset to the team. Why? Because I think the likihood is he'll be an entry level player working for the league minimum and cheap for a number of years and equally as important will not cost us a starting rotation guy, rather an equivalent prospect or a second tier guy like a Mitre. So yes, I'm limiting my searches according to my own criteria. I've said before, I don't want to trade even Ricky Nolasco. He gets another decent year under his belt and his value *literally* doubles. I thought by now that was a given. I'm looking for a Jeff Conine, not a Miguel Cabrera. A David Eckstein, not a Derek Jeter. A complement to the team, not a new superstar. If you want to accuse me setting my sights too low as is your right, go ahead, but as I said above, my contention is if we found a new centerfielder who could play everyday and put up Hanley-like BA and OBP (not looking at Hrs, rbis etc.) in his rookie year, for $350k, I'd say job well done. Maier has some work to do just to make it as a 4th OFer in this league. Absolutely. The question is, does he have the tools and desire to make it in the big leagues over time? By August 2007 can he be your everyday centerfielder for the next five years? I think so. Your opinion is as valid as mine. But his performance this season indicates (at least to me) that he has the tools, tools that need polishing to be sure, and the favorable reports coming out of the Arizona Fall League say he wants it. I'm trying to point out guys who should be considered. I can't tell the future, but looking at our in-house options right now and my desire to not trade any of the young arms, he works for me. http://kansascity.royals.mlb.com/NASApp/ml...jsp&c_id=kc *edit*

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.