Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. I never saw a ball leave PPS faster or harder hit (talking about to right field), including Delgado, than a half dozen hit by Hee Seop Choi. It's a shame he wasn't able to elevate his total game to the MLB level.
  2. The new system really seems to work to the advantage of both parties, at when it comes to players past their prime but still of interest to their exisiting team. The new rules make it possible (Note: I didn't say likely) for the Marlins and Borowski to find a common ground they were precluded from in years past. Giving up a possible draft pick (an extra not one you already are entitled to) for this kind of contractural flexibility was one of the best things to come out of the new agreement. BTW, there's alot of talent floating around there this morning, especially for the Florida's, the Kansas City's, the Tampa's, other rebuilding teams to look at. And the good news is that talent is without compensation and without obligation to long term contracts. I'm starting to think this might be an interesting Winter Meeting after all.
  3. :banghead (Don't tell anyone but I was "ranting" about something only barely related to Ramp's remark, rather the general state of the board. We're like animals in the wild eating their young because there's no other food for thought)
  4. Ramp, let me rant for a second. I think the virtual media blackout/ignoring the Marlins has left all of us kind of sitting on pins and needles and we all are sort of suffering from cabin fever (Jonesing for baseball), we're all (including me) just a little too sensitive for our own goods. Every day I read the Kansas City Star or this e-paper or that and guess what there's coverage of the hometown team but here we're left to fight over NYC rumprs about Dontrelle and who should be packaged for Baldelli because there is almost nothing else to discuss. Now we are discussing what Admin Beinfest's motives are in a one line comment about Jacobs. Now granted you're closer to things than most but it has come down to that, we analyze and reanalyze even the smallest comment as if world peace was at stake. It sucks. Rants over. lololol
  5. Call me naive but I keep reading Beinfest saying good things about Jacobs and talking about 2007 Well would you expect something else out of a GM's mouth? First of all it's just my opinion, but my feeling is until Beinfest says something contrary to what he did as recently as (I think) this week, I'm taking the guy at his word. Things change everyday, I know that but as much as I'm open to anything that makes the team better, I value the cummulative value of both players more than I do their loss to simply get back Rocco. The operative word above is "I". That's how "I" see it. If someone else sees it differently, be my guest (and that was not pointed at you Ramp, but generally).
  6. Call me naive but I keep reading Beinfest saying good things about Jacobs and talking about 2007, and I admit to be someone who thinks Nolasco has the chance to be a very successful pitcher at the ML level, so as much as I'd like to have Baldelli, and have for a long time, I don't think a 3-1 or a trade somwhere around this cast of players works to the Marlins advantage unless a legitimate corner outfielder or a first base capable player comes back as well, and even then I'm not so hot on it. Admin pulls the string on the deal and I'm in, but I'm not going to rally around this trade as a must-do for 2007. Right now, with the team we have, warts and all, even with Amezaga in centerfield and huge question mark for a bullpen, we are much more competitive vis a vis our divisional/wildcard chances than Tampa Bay is in the AL East. In fact, with the Yankees and Red Sox (and let's not forget the Jays) doing their things, the addition of Nolasco and Jacobs will do nothing to improve the D'Rays chances in 2007 and beyond. They're screwed. Cy Young could come down and throw 300 perfect innings and still wouldn't get the Rays any closer to third place than they are now. Frankly I think it's an awful situation, speaks volumes about the need for a real, hard, spending cap (yeah, yeah and a floor too) because let's face it's hopeless being in the AL East if you're anybody but Boston, New York and on a good day, Toronto. That's what I think gets in the way of intelligent trading with TB.
  7. Just noodling around I realized that some of us may have already seen Owens pitch. July 7th and 8th (in NYC so it was probably on tv) he pitched a total of three scoreless innings against the Fish - 2BB, 1 SO. I was looking for video (couldn't find any) as I've heard he pitches like he was a catcher throwing to second, short armed. I'm thinking Miguel Olivo throwing a bullet to 2B.
  8. By the way, those of you wondering....he was protected on their 40 man roster on Nov. 20th. Gee, there's a surprise :whistle :thumbup Maybe you can get a view of Owens if he's still with the team. Be great to get a first hand report. Have a good trip.
  9. On the Licey team there is only one guy with better numbers than Owens, his name is Oneli Perez, who it turns out is in the White Sox organization. His MiLB stats so far in his short career (went through three levels in 2006) are mind-blowing, .960 ERA over 77+ innings with 91 strikeouts and 19 BB. http://thebaseballcube.com/players/P/Oneli-Perez.shtml
  10. Does anyone know if the Marlins asked Henry to leave the Licey team of the Dominican Winter League? He was dominating and I have been checking his stats regularly since the trade and they remain the same. I was wondering if anyone had an official press release stating the Marlins FO did not want him participating in the DWL. I noticed this as well. The same is true of Jason Vargas and Shane Costa (a KC outfielder I've been following) on another team (Escogido) in the league. I don't speak spanish so I haven't been able to determine why but it does seem like a significant number of MLB/MiLB players are not playing any longer. None of the three have seen their stats change in at least a week and maybe two. Owens numbers can be found here Licey. BTW, thanks for posting originally the link to this league. :thumbup
  11. he'saverage because he projects as a backend rotation guy, but more likely a bullpen arm with his build...and there are a ton more relief prospects than legit SP prospects. His build is a big knock. Already read the full article so I know where they are coming from and I understand there's a popular myth that ballplayers have to be X size and why, because in many cases it fits. And the perception that taller pitchers have the physical tools to throw certain pitches more deceptively and again all that makes sense, until you realize Pedro Martinez and Jose Garcia are the same height and the fifteen pound differential in weight I bet is gone already if not by spring training. In no way am I equating the two or drawing any comparisons other than to say stature is only a problem if you need it and don't have it. If you have "it", in life and in baseball, your stature is measured by your accomplishments not with a ruler. It's not a myth if more ballplayers succeed with a certain body type. I don't even know what you're arguing here. I said more "likely," which means there's a greater chance that his body type holds him back than helps him. sometimes I wonder... I wasn't arguing Shamster. It was merely an observation. Not to say conventional wisdom by definition is wrong but one of the reasons more players of X size and shape succeed is because more players of X size and weight are programmed (as in college program, as in professional program) to succeed. Imagine if you will a minor league manager sending his first report of spring training back to the home office, "Tony Gwynn, 5'11', 200 lbs, got this funny voice and won't shut up...might be able to hit a little. Where'd you find this guy? I thought you were sending me that new stud Orestes Destrade. What gives?" But in the end, if you read what I wrote I said all these generalities made sense. I'm just willing to be open-minded about the exceptions.
  12. he'saverage because he projects as a backend rotation guy, but more likely a bullpen arm with his build...and there are a ton more relief prospects than legit SP prospects. His build is a big knock. Already read the full article so I know where they are coming from and I understand there's a popular myth that ballplayers have to be X size and why, because in many cases it fits. And the perception that taller pitchers have the physical tools to throw certain pitches more deceptively and again all that makes sense, until you realize Pedro Martinez and Jose Garcia are the same height and the fifteen pound differential in weight I bet is gone already if not by spring training. In no way am I equating the two or drawing any comparisons other than to say stature is only a problem if you need it and don't have it. If you have "it", in life and in baseball, your stature is measured by your accomplishments not with a ruler.
  13. The changes in the MLB-MLBPA CBA that increased the professional service requirements for Rule V eligibility may have some beneficial value atleast this year. Players who have the talent to contribute in the majors but have fallen out of favor with their current teams had another year of seasoning. Of course that extra year may have had their current teams reconsider their role in the organization and remove them from the draft board. What the lord giveth, the lord taketh away. Next year there will be a bumper crop of Rule 5 guys as there will no longer be room for them on the 40 man roster as a new crop of guys have to be protected. While the rule change thinned out the herd of eligible players in 2006, by 2007 we'll be right back where we were before the change in terms of quasi-quality players available, albeit a year older.
  14. I would agree on Garcia with CM. As September rolled along, the two players who I thought really stood out were Pinto and Garcia, who, while his stats may not show it, seemed to just get more and more comfortable, and more capable with every appearance. Whereas Petit always looked like he was waiting for the roof to cave in and it did all too often, Garcia (and anyone who wants to accuse me of mind-reading be my guest) it seemed to me went to the mound each time with "the right stuff", that attitude that says "I'm here to get you out...and I can". Unlike a Randy Messenger who tries to be an intimidating presence until he throws the first pitch and the real player behind the personna is exposed, Garcia really seemed to love the combat and thrived on it, even through what was a rough initiation. I think he has the potential to be around a long time. And BTW I wasn't being negative about Petit. I think he just needs more time.
  15. This article is a year old and is often the case with Baseball Prospectus, they do a great job even if their conclusions end up being wrong. That said, I found this piece really informative about the mechanics of the draft. Hopefully you'll find value as well. ------------- If the Winter Meetings are like a turkey dinner, then the Rule 5 draft is the dessert, the hot apple pie. Held on the last day of the Winter Meetings, the Rule 5 draft is very different from June?s Rule 4 draft in terms of both format and strategy. Though not many people attend, the draft is open to the public. Before you enter you can grab a Selection Meeting sheet, which details the draft order and a handy scorecard with which to keep track of the action. Held in a large auditorium, the setup will look familiar to those who have watched their share of NFL and NBA drafts. Thirty tables are lined up, one for each team. Executives not sitting at the team tables watch from the audience along with the media and other interested parties, creating an interesting dynamic of interested observer and very interested observer. This is very different from the Rule 4 draft, which is conducted via a conference call that everyone within earshot can hear and can contribute to. Another thing to keep in mind is that the Rule 5 is not limited to the few players who get selected to appear on Major League clubs. There is also a Triple-A and Double-A phase to the draft as well. This is not to say, however, that everything is different. While the Rule 4 draft does take two days simply because of the quantity of players selected, the draft moves very swiftly, one pick fired right after the other. The pace of the Rule 5 draft is similar, if not faster. In fact, 2004's draft didn't take much more than an hour to finish. Though the flurry of activity just before the Draft may lead some to believe that this is all a very last minute thing, teams actually start planning for the Rule 5 Draft months in advance. Much like they do with potential free agents, Major League Baseball distributes a list of players that will qualify to be selected in the Rule 5 draft early in each season. By doing so early, scouts and executives will have the opportunity to spend a little extra time observing the Rule 5 eligible players, regardless of their eventual status on a 40-man roster. When MLB freezes rosters and distributes the Reserve List, a front office will come together with all of its information--scouting reports, recommendations, statistics, etcetera--and decide what the best course of action will be. There are generally three courses of action a club can take with respect to its Rule 5 pick during the Major League phase, but all of them stem from how a team defines its 40-man roster. A 40-man roster consists of your 25 Major League players, and the remaining 15 will be a mixture of replacement level players who can contribute as injuries and other situations arise, and a number of projectable, future Major Leaguers. How clubs define that secondary mix will ultimately determine how a club looks at the Rule 5 draft. One way to go is to do nothing. Some teams do this frequently. For instance, under Brian Cashman, who has been at his current post since 1998, the Yankees have made six Rule 5 selections, but have never made one during the Major League phase. Some teams simply do not work under a model that allows them to carry a player who may not contribute for an entire season. Another strategy a team can take is to select a player for another club. In order for this to happen, a Club has to have first decided that they will not be selecting anyone with their pick. ?Teams generally try to network with one another and feel each other out,? explains Tripp Norton, the Orioles Assistant Director of Minor League Operations. The Orioles made such a transaction in 2004 when they selected Luke Hagerty from the Cubs on behalf of the Florida Marlins. The receiving club agrees to compensate the selecting club for the $50,000 cost of the selection, in addition to a future consideration. Norton further explained that this player will not be a real prospect, and is generally selected from a list provided by the receiving club. The third strategy, of course, is to actually make a selection. In speaking with industry insiders, there are two distinct ways that clubs strategize for their selections. One is to select a guy in the hopes of stashing him on the roster for the season and returning him to the minors the next year in order to build depth any way possible. This is generally employed by teams that don?t expect to compete in the coming season, as they want to get better any way possible and can afford to gamble with the roster spot. The other main strategy is to see who will be a good fit for the upcoming roster. This type of player is generally one with a more limited skill set, but who could be a contributor for that season. The Red Sox employed this strategy in the ?02 draft, trying to fill left-handed reliever and backup outfielder/pinch runner roles, by selecting Javier Lopez, Matthew White, and Adrian Brown in the Major League phase. While Lopez and White did not ultimately stay with the Sox, Brown did remain, filling what is today known better in Boston as "the Dave Roberts role." Brown appeared in 4 ALDS games vs. Oakland in a pinch-hitting and pinch-running capacity. Such players are desirable choices as they will almost always be earning the Major League minimum and allow teams to avoid overpaying for an infrequently used player. Overall, the Rule 5 draft has increased in prominence the past few years. From 1995-2001, an average of 60 players were chosen, but in the three most recent drafts, that average has increased 25%, to just over 79 players. While those inside the game do not attribute this increase to any single reason, it is apparent that teams are at the very least considering it as a legitimate way to build depth in their organization in an efficient and inexpensive fashion. Another interesting byproduct of the Rule 5 draft are the trades that are made in the days leading up to the draft--a recent example would be the Jon Leicester trade--where a player can be traded from one 40-man roster to another for a Player To Be Named Later, simply because rosters are frozen. In essence, a team executing this type of trade is conducting a Rule 5 type transaction, but with more certainty for both clubs--one does not have to worry about other teams picking their player before they get the opportunity, and the other club is not faced with a situation where they will lose a player of value for nothing more than a $50,000 transaction fee. Nevertheless, at least one industry insider believes that the 2005 Draft will be a bit uneventful. One thing that lends credence to that theory is that with the Meetings earlier this year there are other issues on which to focus, such as who was offered salary arbitration. The second reason for this is because, as David Regan points out, there really aren't many attractive choices, as this year's Andy Sisco seems nowhere to be found. Paul Swydan http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=4645
  16. The following *RED SOX* players will be eligible for the 2006 Rule 5 Draft unless they are added to the 40-Man Roster: Chris Smith, Barry Hertzler, Jose Vaquedano, Justin Sturge, Bryan Corey, Mike Burns Catchers Dusty Brown Infielders Chad Spann, Jeremy West, Ian Bladergroen, Zach Borowiak, Iggy Suarez, Tony Granadillo Outfilders Chris Durbin, Claudio Arias, Chris Turner Note: Rule 5 Eligibility Rules have been edited in the new Collective Bargaining Agreement effective for the 2006 Rule 5 Draft. This list was edited to reflect the new eligibility rules. http://soxprospects.wikispaces.com/2006+Ru...ligible+Players
  17. Since I've failed to find a unified list of eligible players (although I expect one to show up somewhere before the draft) I'm just going to dump stuff in here I find regarding other teams' players left unprotected. The first one is from a Cubs fansite: http://www.all-baseball.com/cubreporter/archives/024633.html I'll have a Rapada with Cheese, and a Cherry Coke by Arizona Phil With today being the deadline for moving players from the minor leagues to the 40-man roster, the Cubs announced today that they have added LHP Clay Rapada and RHP Rocky Cherry to their 40-man reserve list. All players still remaining on a Cubs minor league roster will remain "frozen" (cannot be added to the 40-man roster and cannot be traded) until after the conclusion of the Rule 5 Draft, which will be held on December 7th at the MLB Winter Meetings. If any player currently on a Cub minor league roster is to be part of a trade consummated sometime in the next couple of weeks, that player will have to be identified as a"Player to be Named Later" (PTBNL), and cannot be named until the Rule 5 Draft concludes. Although players on minor league rosters are now "frozen," players on major league 40-man rosters are not. Players on MLB 40-man rosters can be traded, and players on MLB 40-man rosters can even be assigned outright to the minors during the "frozen" period. Also, free-agents can be signed to minor league contracts and can be assigned to a minor league club during this period. By adding Rapada and Cherry, the Cubs would seem to now have 42 players on their 40-man roster, which (of course) is not allowed. So the only obvious explanation is that apparently Mark DeRosa and Alfonso Soriano have yet to be officially added to the Cubs roster, because no other roster moves were made today. Some of you may remember the same thing happened last year when Bob Howry was signed as a free-agent, but wasn't officially added to the Cubs 40-man roster for several days. But at least two more roster moves will need to be made in the near future, possibly by means of a a two-fer-one or three-fer-one trade for a starting pitcher. A lanky side-armin' slinger who is death on left-handed hitters, the 25-year old Rapada was THE best reliever I saw in the Arizona Fall League this year. I believe he can pitch in the big leagues right now. Signed out of Virginia State University by Cubs "bird dog" scout Billy Swoope in 2002, Rapada is notable for being a one-time "Non-drafted Free-Agent" (NDFA) who made good. Cherry, 27, was drafted by the Cubs out of the University of Oklahoma in the 14th round of the 2002 Rule 4 Draft (June Draft), but didn't sign until January 2003. He made his pro debut at Boise that season. The Rock underwent Tommy John transplannt surgery in 2005, after suffering a torn elbow ligament. A starter earlier in his career, Cherry returned to action this season, working out of the bullpen at AA West Tenn (Cherry and Rapada were an extremely effective 1-2 punch out of the DiamondJaxx pen). Like Rapada, Cherry pitched well-enough to earn a mid-season promotion to AAA Iowa. Showing a mid-90's heater and a devastating breaking ball, Rocky was supposedly about to be called up to the Cubs when he suffered a season-ending finger injury that required surgery. Among the notables not added to the Cub 40 at this time include pitchers Carmen Pignatiello, Lincoln Holdzkom, Randy Wells, and Federico Baez, catcher Jake Fox, and third-baseman Casey McGehee. Each will be eligible for selection by the other 29 MLB clubs at the upcoming Rule 5 Draft Jake Fox was Rich Hill's battery-mate at the University of Michigan, and has spent several years in the Cubs farm system. A slugging catcher who has strugggled with his catching mechanics, Fox split the 2006 season between Daytona and West Tenn. Besides his receiving problems, Fox has had difficulty making consistent contact, and has a tendency to chase pitches out of the strike zone. Still, he is the only catcher in the Cubs system with any power. It is unlikely that he will be ready for the big leagues any time soon. LHP Carmen Pignatiello has been pitching in the Cubs organizatioin since 2000, and was eligible to be a six-year minor league free-agent on October 15th. But he opted to re-up and signed a 2007 minor league contract with the Cub instead, probably after getting a "Cubs slot" in the AFL and a likely NRI to Spring Training. However, Piggy was very impressive pitching out of the bullpen for the Mesa Solar Sox this past month, and will be a very good candidate to get selected in the Rule 5 Draft. RHP Lincoln Holdzkom was one of two pitchers acquired from the Marlins at the end of Spring Training in a deal where Todd Wellemeyer was sent to Florida. Rob Dibble Redux, Holdzkom was one of the Marlins top relief prospects a few years ago (he was on the Marlins 40-man roster for about a year), before suffering a torn elbow ligament in 2004 that required Tommy John ligament transplant surgery. Like Pignatiello, Holdzkom pitched for the Mesa Solar Sox in the AFL, and armed with a mid-90's fastball, showed flashes of brilliance offset by spurts of extreme wildness. After getting an NRI to Spring Training with the big club, Casey McGehee spent the 2006 season as the starting 3rd baseman at AAA Iowa. He is one of the most fundamentally sound players in the Cubs organization, and is capable of playing either corner infield position, McGehee has a solid line-drive stroke, and has had an outstanding last few weeks (including a 16-game hitting streak) while playing for Culiacan in the Mexican Pacific League. McGehee could be a useful (and cheap) option for a small-market and/or low revenue club looking for a platoon third-baseman, or a right-handed bat off the bench. Like Carlos Marmol, RHP Randy Wells was a one-time catcher in the Cubs organization who was converted into a pitcher. Wells started the 2006 season at AA West Tenn and pitched very well, earning himself a mid-season promotion to AAA Iowa. Wells seems to fit the profile of a MLB middle-reliever, and might be another pretty good candidate to be selected in next month's Rule 5 Draft. RHP Federico Baez is still another converted position player. A former third-baseman in the Orioles organization, the rubber-armed Baez pitched for Team Puerto Rico in the World Baseball Classic last March, and has the ability to either start or relieve. As such, Baez might be attractive to a club looking to acquire a versatile (and cheap) pitcher in the Rule 5 Draft. Here are the 50 Cubs players eligible for selection in the Rule 5 Draft on December 7th: Jason Anderson, RHP (MLFA after 2007) Thomas Atlee, RHP Federico Baez, RHP (MLFA after 2007) Oscar Bernard, RHP (6Y MLFA after 2007) Ryan Bicondoa, RHP (MLFA after 2007) Nate Bland, LHP (MLFA after 2007) Chadd Blasko, RHP Bobby Brownlie, RHP Edward Campusano, LHP Jose Caridad RHP Gary Cates, Jr, IF-OF (MLFA after 2007) Robinson Chirinos, 2B (6Y MLFA after 2007) Matt Craig, 1B-3B Mike Fontenot, 2B Jake Fox, C Alfredo Francisco, RHP Alberto Garcia, 1B-OF Cristian Gonzalez, RHP (MLFA after 2007) Luke Hagerty, LHP Koyie Hill, C (MLFA after 2007) Lincoln Holdzkom, RHP (6Y MLFA after 2007) Micah Hoffpauir, 1B Jesse Hoorelbeke, 1B (MLFA after 2007) Ben Howard, RHP (MLFA after 2007) Fabian Jimenez-Angulo, LHP Geoff Jones, LHP (MLFA after 2007) Richard Lewis, 2B (6Y MLFA after 2007) Albenis Machado, INF (MLFA after 2007) Casey McGehee, 3B Adalberto Mendez, RHP Isaac Pavlik, LHP (MLFA after 2007) Leonel Perez, RHP Billy Petrick, RHP Carmen Pignatiello, LHP (MLFA after 2007) Jose Pina, RHP Robert Ransom, RHP Tony Richie, C Alan Rick, C Carlos Rojas, SS (6Y MLFA after 2007) Issmael Salas, INF (6Y MLFA after 2007) Joel Santo, RHP Andy Shipman, RHP Jason Smith, INF (MLFA after 2007) Jemel Spearman, INF Jesus Valdez, OF Chris Walker, OF Les Walrond, LHP (MLFA after 2007) John Webb, RHP (MLFA after 2007) Randy Wells, RHP Jesus Yepez, LHP
  18. From today's flamarlins.com website: Lineup comes of age: When the Winter Meetings begin next week in Orlando, the Marlins will be hoping to upgrade in center field. While the team is weighing trade and modest free-agency options, general manager Admin Beinfest said recently that the lineup should remain pretty much the same as 2006. "We're always looking to improve and we won't shy away from anything," Beinfest said. "But [the lineup in general] is not an area that we're concentrating on. "We have to evaluate what we have, what our options are and our allocation to our payroll, and spend in the right areas. We were happy with our lineup." Beinfest points out that first baseman Mike Jacobs, who hit 20 home runs as a rookie, should show improvement next season, especially now that his right ankle has healed. "Jacobs hit 20 home runs and played on one leg half the season," Beinfest said. "A lot of good things happened there. It's not an area we are [looking to improve]." The entire piece includes comments on Hermida, Gonzalez and miscellaneous stuff http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/...sp&c_id=fla
  19. we have absolutely no hitting prospects of note :lol On one hand it kind of makes you want to have a swap meet with a Kansas City, Tampa or LAA, especially the former, which is overflowing with offense and little in the way of pitching prospects and equally as cost conscious as the Fish but I suspect the thinking is that pitching prospects increase in value faster than position players and as long as you have pitchers in the pipeline you can trade for position players as the need warrants. Lol, and why won't I be surprised if and when Admin Beinfest drafts more pitching in the next draft.
  20. Thanks, I'll take a look. I keep thinking a Sickels or Mayo will publish a list or some enterprising blogger or minor league messageboard poster will, but so far to no avail. I'm sure before the draft one will apear, they always do, although we all understand this year and going forward, the quality of player being left exposed is diminished by the new rules.
  21. Moronic? Well certainly your expetise in that area is something I'll have to defer to. No one takes a backseat to you in that department. I love it. When you've been backed into a corner you just result to mudslinging. Sad, really, but oh so predictable.. Your paranoia is showing again Swifty. tsk tsk
  22. I've driven around this site the last three times I'm been to the county and for the life of me, unless they're planning using at least one more of the adjacent lots and close off another north/south street, I don;t see how they could fit the footprint for a stadium in there, with or without a roof. I'm not saying it's not possible, but very hard to visualize.
  23. Moronic? Well certainly your expetise in that area is something I'll have to defer to. No one takes a backseat to you in that department.
  24. What I didn't say Lou was that Jacobs would eventually be as good as Lee. I think I was very clear on that. My point was that, and it seems to be lost here, is that rookie seasons are not in and of themselves a universal barometer for future success or failure. If they were Hermida would be riding a bench in the Mexican League. Considering Jacobs was injured the entire season there is no logical conclusions that can be drawn either offensively or defensively about his future. I don't see why Jacobs and Willingham can't be on the same team. Willingham improved incrementally as an outfielder as the season went on and may turn into the next incarnation of Jeff Conine before it's over. If Jacobs comes back healthy and without any lingering effects from running around on a broken ankle for six months he may contribute the way he was expected to. Outside of some rumor mongering there is no indication that the FO intends to move Willingham to first. Some there may want to, some may have discussed it, but until it happens or Beinfest says something even remotely indicating it, it's nothing more than supposition. You could always ask him at the season ticketholder Christmas party in a few weeks. I'd ask him but I have another question.
  25. 3 additional years of professional baseball, at any level, is a tremendous difference. A 25 year old Derrek Lee posted an OPS above .800, that's a far more relevant number if you wish to compare the players, which is foolish to begin with. Just as I said, a straw man argument. BTW, what three years are you referring to? Jacobs went back to A and into AA to learn a new position after missing virtually all of the 2004 season with his shoulder injury. Am I wrong to assume you know that? According to TBC they both are listed as having the same number of minor league service years. The fact is Lee was a total flop his rookie season and yet turned his career around and became the great player he is today. While I'm not suggesting Jacobs will do as well, comparatively speaking, Jacobs outplayed Lee in their rookie years. Just like you'd hope a 25 year old would be able to out perform a 22 year old. If you have a player thought highly enough of to be thrust into the majors at 22, odds are, good things are expected in the future even if there are immediate struggles. Lastly, why continue this inane comparison of Lee and Jacobs? It's a laughable juxtaposition, if anything, it should be Lee and Hermida. You mean it's inane because it proves you wrong We're comparing first basemen in their rookie years who played for the Florida Marlins, each in rebuilding years after a major talent sell-off. I guess there's not enough there in common for you. I can understand why from your point of view you need to compare a first baseman to the a rightfielder. Because that's the only one that's works for you.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.