Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Valid

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Valid

  1. Waiting to see who we actually gave up before reacting.
  2. Right, but he's three years younger. That matters. I also think he's probably better.
  3. That's fine, but would the Marlins have signed Garcia if Duvall were still on the roster? Just so I myself am not accused of being a "homer," I specifically said that I was not a huge fan of giving Garcia four years and would have been much more comfortable with something like 3/45. But I would rather have a 30-year-old Garcia locked in for the next four years than have one more year of a 33-year-old Duvall who almost surely would have been traded during the 2022 season or walked next offseason anyway.
  4. I could be misreading you here, but are you seriously comparing Christian Yelich to Adam freaking Duvall? If so, then I don't know what to tell you.
  5. Adam Duvall is 33 years old and isn't very good. Yes, I would take a 30-year-old Garcia over him. The Marte thing is obviously a legitimate gripe (even though I said right from the beginning that I really didn't want to give him four years), but harping on Adam freaking Duvall is overkill.
  6. Lmao. So no other front offices in baseball make mistakes? Got it. Guess that's why the Mariners haven't made the playoffs since 2001. I also find it hilarious how now having Garcia over Adam freaking Duvall is considered a "f**k up." Didn't realize Duvall suddenly became a perennial HOFer.
  7. Joel Sherman is also the same idiot who said the Yankees should bench Giancarlo Stanton in favor of Tyler Wade in the 2020 playoffs and Stanton went on to hit six home runs. Duvall is also three years older than Garcia and is arguably not even as good. I'm not a fan of giving Garcia four years, but let's relax with Adam Duvall.
  8. There is no way Marte would have signed for 4/53 even back in July.
  9. Not to mention the fact that marquee franchises like the Yankees, Red Sox and Dodgers haven't done anything yet. Still really early in the offseason. Chances are, this will drag out quite a bit.
  10. Meh. Really good outfielder, but up-and-down offensively. Also seems to be an every other year kind of guy at the plate. 2017: .885 OPS 2018: .719 OPS 2019: .796 OPS 2020: .659 OPS (albeit, it was a shortened season) 2021: .820 OPS Sooo hopefully that trend stops in 2022 and he picks up where he left off. Not really crazy about giving Garcia four years just like I didn't want to give Marte four years (particularly at $20 million annually like NY gave him). Would have been much more comfortable at something like 3/39 or even 3/45 rather than 4/53. Whatever. Hopefully more to come.
  11. Buxton owns a lifetime slash line of .248/.299/.461 and has played 100 games once in his career. Yes, I know he's great defensively, but we need offense. No way in hell am I moving Sanchez for him. I also find it pretty funny how so many people are getting all upset over the Marlins "low-balling" Marte when we don't even know what his price tag is. If it's around $100 million like some have guessed, then I don't blame the FO for not wanting to give that type of money to a 33-year-old with a lifetime .797 OPS.
  12. Well, of course you would. You're a fan of the team, aren't you? Lol.
  13. I mean, they have also given you zero reasons to doubt because they haven't had the opportunity to sign any big-name FAs yet. I'm in "believe it when I see it mode" too, but I am not immediately writing them off in saying "yeah this won't happen." We'll see.
  14. How do you know that? When have they had the chance to sign a big-name free agent up until this point under this current regime? This is really the first time they've had the opportunity to do so. I agree that there are reasons to be skeptical, but let's give them a chance before we immediately say "we know they won't."
  15. I would assume most of you already saw this, but: Hopefully "active" means offering legitimate deals to legitimate free agents rather than just making a few phone calls and offering "we tried" types of contracts. EDIT: I see this was already posted in another thread. But oh well. Point still stands.
  16. I could be wrong here, but isn't it very unorthodox to open the season with a four-game series?
  17. I stand by my assertion that the Marlins are actually better than the Mets when healthy. Not that that's exactly saying much.
  18. The Mets aren't even much better than the Marlins. To be perfectly honest, I'm not sure they're better at all if both teams are at full strength. The only reason why they are even in the playoff hunt is because they are in the NL East.
  19. I don't hate the Mets nearly as much as I used to, but man; beating them late in the season never gets old.
  20. Sandy, Rogers and Pablo have the top three spots locked down. After that, it's anybody's guess. My prediction is Sixto and Luzardo getting the fourth and fifth spots.
  21. Where did I say anything about other teams' stars? All I said is that Sixto has ace potential. I never said I wouldn't be open to moving him for the right return. I have seen several posts saying things like he has been a non-factor and hasn't been on the field, and all I was saying was that those claims were exaggerated and that it's too early to essentially write him off.
  22. See but here's the thing: the contract didn't look THAT bad at that time. He was coming off of one of the best seasons in recent history, if not ever. He was a dominant hitter and a Gold Glove-caliber outfielder. It only looks bad now because of the injuries. Hindsight is 20/20. I could be wrong, but I don't seem to remember anyone complaining about Stanton's contract in 2017. It's only been the last couple of years with him missing extensive time that it has become such an issue. Do you think the Yanks would want to reverse the trade if Stanton were healthy and smashing 40-50 homers a year? The fact of the matter is that we literally got nothing of consequence in terms of players in return for a guy who was, at the time, the best player in baseball. That trade was a bad one no matter how you spin it.
  23. That's fair, but I don't think it needs as much of a major overhaul as people are letting on. Adding a couple of cheap pieces could make all the difference. Again, bullpens are typically a crapshoot. What's great one year may suck the next and vice versa.
  24. The problem is that we got absolutely nothing of consequence for a guy who was probably the best player on the planet at the time (or at the very least top 3-5). I understand Jeter wanted to get out from under the contract, but for a guy who just hit 59 home runs and won an MVP, you need to get something other than financial relief. His contract also did not look bad at the time given the monster season he had just had. Keep in mind that I'm one of the more positive posters here when it comes to the FO, but the Stanton trade was bad.
  25. I mean it's been one season. It's not like he has been on and off the IL for three years straight. The kid is 23 and entered 2021 ranked as the No. 6 prospect in all of baseball. He also showed significant promise last year. Way, wayyyy too soon to throw in the towel on him.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.