Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Dr Beinfest

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Dr Beinfest

  1. More like the difference between $100,000 salary and $102,000. Small percentage, but all of us would love an extra $2000.
  2. I don't see a point in attempting to trade Stanton while retaining salary - they still won't get a lot. I think that scenario, unless a total steal, falls behind retaining Stanton. Find someone who can eat his whole contract happily. Take the mid level prospects. Call it a day. We all knew this was the point where Stanton would be traded (before his opt out). That's the way the contract was designed. The only way retaining Stanton money makes sense is if they're confident they have ways to get rid of guys like Chen without eating salary. Otherwise, just keep Stanton for the year and let him walk... don't let his contract haunt this team if he's not playing for it.
  3. In other words, they're willing to sacrifice future pieces for "now" pieces. At least I think that's what he's saying.
  4. Every single team refusing to take on a contract that would otherwise get signed in free agency? His contract is a liability, true. To assume he simply would come free and zero teams would take him? Yeah not buying that.
  5. It was revokable waivers, and teams do this all the time. If Stanton was claimed, the Marlins would've pulled him off waivers. Other managers just know and respect the process. That's how he can be traded. He's going to fetch a return. No would've gotten Stanton for free. His return is jusg going to be like, prospects #3/4/5 with the Marlins eating salary.
  6. Two things: 1. Stanton isn't going to fetch what you think he will. MVP or not, he's a salary dump and a flight risk at the same time. We are going to be hearbroken when we get relative peanuts for him, I guarantee you that. 2. The statement I quoted is silly. You haven't even seen the return and you're forecasting that we are going to be good. Any team at any point can make the argument that if they slash and burn, in five years they will be good. If you didn't notice, this current really good Marlins offense is... really good. Some poor management and ownership shit the bed along the way. The pitching is god awful, as we all know. Awful is an understatement, actually. It doesn't exist. Anything can happen from a rebuild. We have been particularly bad at producing pitching. Let's hope, however this rebuild goes (or if it does at all), that this trend doesn't continue under new ownership.
  7. Play a season and arguably play it like a contract year. Walk, and get paid more money to go where he wants. even if he has a meh season, he will likely still get similar money to what he has now.
  8. I hope he finds himself and we keep him so that when we are ready for the real firesale next year, we can trade him without offering up collateral.
  9. Stanton's September will be why he doesn't win, IMO.
  10. Hold on. Bleed some. Get Stanton to opt in. Then trade everyone. Done.
  11. I'd argue it's fairly obvious they wish to keep "something" but wish it to be Ozuna. Formally they might not say so, and they'll probably listen to all offers, but they are probably genuine at their word of trying to piece together a competitive team next year. Tbh it's not the worst idea in the world - if Stanton etc is worth solid starting pitching. But, the farm is so dry that it would be a major disaster if the attempt failed.
  12. The idea that Stanton is a big draw is overrated, sure. The idea that trading Stanton won't be a hugely destructive move towards an already nonexistent following is false. Stanton is keeping things in place. Trading him absolutely absolutely absolutely is going to take a huge hit at this fanbase. It has nothing to do with what he is as a draw. It has to do with what he is as a trade.
  13. Lmao it's a sad reality when you have to even say "I like Stanton, but..." There is no need to clarify. He is one of the most dominant players in baseball.
  14. I'm not saying don't trade him. Im saying expect a garbage return.
  15. A player who, if successful, could walk on his player-option to sign an even bigger contract. Couple that with the fact that people know Miami is shedding salary. Fire sale = devaluation. Couple that with the fact that Miami is trying to get rid of other unwanted contracts. Whatever Stanton trade we see might be awfully disappointing.
  16. Stanton's trade value isn't even that high right now (assuming he carries a player option with a trade). Theres no point in not stripping it down. Keep Smellich, keep Realmuto, trade everyone else.
  17. Lol criticizing the metric system.
  18. I mean, there's nothing wrong with retaining one guy. My fear is that we end up going another decade in search of a catcher that isn't a total piece of trash.
  19. I see no reason why Realmuto can't survive the rebuild. He's a vital position this franchise has failed to tackle for years. I'd hold onto him, if possible.
  20. I'm more in line with a variant of what penguin was theorizing. Expensive contracts are sunk costs. It'll cost you assets to dump some of those players. Might as well ride them out and sell by parts. The fire sale is a two season thing. From the fan's perspective it's quite literally the ugliest thing, as unless a miracle happens next season, it's going to be a very long and very slow rebuild.
  21. Or it could be a slow rebuild. Firesales can definitely devalue players. Could try and sell in two parts? I imagined this was the path, with Stanton going first.
  22. Not picking sides here, but it's not "mental gymnastics." It's zero index versus 1 index. It's quite simple.
  23. Depends on what the language "in the year" means, and when their years start from. This sale seems to have gone through at a questionable time. It's either the beginning of the sixth year or the end of the fifth year. Or neither, and just the fifth year of its calendar or from the date of signing. Well, then the actual date of agreement would matter. Dunno.
  24. It was without having to owe him a lot more money per year. Actually money, not average money.
  25. What makes you think that? If Stanton has a successful season next year, he could try and get an even bigger contract, could he no than? I don't think Stanton can't draw a massive return. I just don't think he will, because no GM will respect the Marlins if they know just how much of a shithole they're in. And I'm sure nobody respects any of the Loria backloaded contracts either.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.