Everything posted by EricWiener
-
CBSSportsline Notes
i guess that .310 MLB OBP must be just me misreading things. It is. He has 1700 or so Pro plate appearances and you are focusing on the last 270 or so.
-
CBSSportsline Notes
he is? Yes since when? Since he's been playing pro ball.
-
CBSSportsline Notes
We should acquire Gathright. why? because he has proven how marvelous he is at the major league level? No, because he is a .380+ OBP contact hitter that steals bases at a rate greater than 75%. Also because we have a giant ass-ton of pitchers and the Devil Rays don't.
-
Uggla getting defensive
There are plenty of things to recommend Juan Pierre under SABRmetrics. His last season was not the greatest, sure. But as a rule he has a better than average OBP (usually 20+ points higher), steals at greater than a 70% rate (the run-neutral level is 66%), and doesn't strike out. Would I rather have Brian Giles or Jason Bay? Yes, but while I'm wishing I also want a pony. Oh, I like Juanpy. But I'm not a SABR guy. Just saying I've heard many a stat guru look down on him because of his steal percentage (while the mean might be 66%, the general rule I've always read is that a runner must steal at or better than 75% of the time to be worth it), his noodle arm (well everyone does), and "empty" batting average as you'd see from rferry in the MLB thread about him. He isn't as good a hitter as his reputation would indicate and he has a noodle arm for sure. 66% is not the mean (actually better than the average), 66% is where your SBs neither help nor harm your offense, since he is in excess of 70% his speed is a net gain. You do have to get to 75% success for that to be a reason to spend more money for you. I liked Juan, I also liked Chuckie Carr (not that JP isn't far better than CC). I don't think either should be a leadoff man. I always thought JP should have batted 2nd. Left handed (exploit 1B hole), good contact (no strike `em out + throw `em out), good speed (hard to double up), good bunter (bunt for basehits or show it to bring in the corners to increase your OBP chances) and we have Luis Castillo, one of the top 20 or so OBP players in the game with which to lead off. Of course at this point we are way off of the subject of Dan Uggla. :hat
-
Uggla getting defensive
There are plenty of things to recommend Juan Pierre under SABRmetrics. His last season was not the greatest, sure. But as a rule he has a better than average OBP (usually 20+ points higher), steals at greater than a 70% rate (the run-neutral level is 66%), and doesn't strike out. Would I rather have Brian Giles or Jason Bay? Yes, but while I'm wishing I also want a pony.
-
Box Score v. UM
[ I also hope that certain individuals will happily enjoy some crow if the player they predicted to falter ends up being an all-star. I mean in the end, we all love the Fish - right? hehehehe :mischief I will be thrilled to death if Uggla can hang in the bigs.
-
Which Spring Training Games Will You be At?
Roger Dean Stadium on the 26th vs. the Cards.
-
CBSSportsline Notes
We should acquire Gathright.
-
Uggla getting defensive
I would love for Dan Uggla to be a productive player. I would love Hanley Ramierez to be ready for the show. I would be thrilled if Josh Willingham could catch and for Eric Reed to be the next Juan Pierre. Realistically, Josh will be a solid LF (and we should be happy about it), CF will be a hole where run production goes to die and our middle infield will be not ready for prime time. Our rotation will not suck and we have some real gems that are new to the lineup (Hermedia, Jacobs, Willingham) so we should be able to escape worst-team ever and we have so many arms that we will be able to have a world-class team in a few seasons.
-
Uggla getting defensive
So Lou, am I to assume that you too feel that Hanley Ramirez is a "doomed to fail" prospect as well given his career .793 OPS (never at a level higher than AA) and routinely 2-1 K/BB ratio? So many weak arguments in favor of a guy that is only getting a shot because he is basically free. The Ramierez thing is not even comparable. Hanley is significantly younger than Uggla. I may be willing to agree that Hanely is ready for the bigs. Uggla has some encouraging minor league trends. He hits lots of 2B, which tend to develop into HRs later, but he is 25 years old and has only JUST had success at AA. The age thing doesn't compare to Willingham as Josh has enjoyed success for years now, and had that success as high as AAA. No comparason to Cabs can be made, as Cabs is an elite MLB player at several years younger.
-
Uggla getting defensive
I'm not betting crap over OPS, it's a garbage stat that should only be used as a measuring stick amongst 3-5 hole hitters...Uggla doesn't fit that profile this year or in his immediate future. OPS isn't a garbage stat, it is an easy stat to look at that gives an idea of a player's offensive performance. RC/27 or Offensive Winning % or even Total Average are likely "superior" stats, but here's the kicker: OPS accurately relates to runs scored. So any advantages held by any other stats are so marginal as to not be worth calculating the stat. Looking at last year's NL results, the Cubs have the largest disparity between runs and OPS (4th in OPS, 9th in Runs) but they were also adept at running themselves into outs (another "moneyball" no-no). The 2002 draft is still an open question, but to judge the results without comparing the results of the other teams is pointless. If 7 of the "Moneyball top 20" pan out, that may represent double or even triple the success rate of a normal draft. The RedSox are a stathead team, they won the title. Yes, they spent a lot of money, but so did many a non-championship team. Hell, so did many a bad team. There are only 3 SABRmetric-based teams, if all 3 were to make the playoffs in a given year, the odds would still not favor a SABRmetric team winning it all. The only thing one can do to give themselves a short-series advantage would be to have the 4 best starting pitchers possible. I will agree though, that OPS is not the most important stat in judging Uggla. I think is SO/BB ratio is far more important. The man has no concept of the strikezone and he is going to be brutally punished for that failing. If a player knows the strikezone at 20, he's only going to get better as he ages, if he doesn't he may never have a chance to get better.
-
Uggla getting defensive
He's a 25 year-old AA prospect who strikes out at a frightening pace. 2B is going to be as big of an offensive concern for the Fish as CF. Frightening is Preston Wilson. Now there's a strike-out machine. Carlos Delgado struck out 121 last season, Miguel Cabrera 125. Uggla struck out 103 times in 500 ABs and still managed a .378 OBP. While you may have no hope, I'll reserve judgement. Miguel never struck out 100 times in AA, or any minor league level for that matter. Neither did Delgado. Fact is, these guys have a sense of the strike zone and the get struck out working for balls they can crush. They also walk from time to time. With Uggla, we could be looking at a .700 OPS hitter that sets a SO record. As for Preston, I wasn't sad to see him go and don't want him back.
-
Marlins Team Defense 2005
Lowell does have bad range to his left, and A-Gon does make his share of errors... but no one can convince me that there is a better defensive shortstop or second baseman than Gonzalez and Castillo. Show me the tape. Encarnacion has tracked down some balls in that deep right center field gap and has never hurt the team on his defense. Derrek Lee not being in the top 3 automatically makes this analysis b.s. Gonzo and Castillo are top notch, and the measurement of Lee's defense reffered to is of the actual ability to get to balls, not his surehandedness and ability to stretch for throws. If anything, this rating is less applicable to 1B than the other positions since there needs to be a rating for picks and stretches, basically how many errors are prevented. I doubt that stat heads have any issue with Gonzo's D, instead it is his poor plate discipline. All that said, Lowell is exceedingly average at 3B, bottom half even. Though his arm is good and his hands are sure, his range is poor. On the other hand, he was very good at 2B when he was in there, though the sample size is small.
-
Mora to skip WBC over third-base snub
What is there all this press questioning Cabs at 3B? He is better than Lowell at the position.
-
Marlins Team Defense 2005
Nothing in this suprises me. BTW, we need to move on Gathright, and there is no shortage of arms that I'd be willing to part with to get him. The MLEs on our CF options are appalling.
-
Uggla getting defensive
He's a 25 year-old AA prospect who strikes out at a frightening pace. 2B is going to be as big of an offensive concern for the Fish as CF.
-
Starting Rotation
Willis Vargas Sanchez Olson Moehler
-
Girardi sets clean-shave policy
The clean-shaved rule is a good one. It make the team look clean-cut and will improve the image. The Reds had that rule for a long time also, and even when they were struggling in the standings, the team was well supported.
-
Hialeah: Agua, Fango y los Marlins?
Doesn't anyone think that perhaps Hialeah isn't fiscally viable enough to actually build a state of the art stadium?
-
Cabrera worse in '06?
If we get a good option for CF, we will have a pretty solid hitting team. I don't think Miggy will suffer too much as he performed in every lineup position.
-
In 1994 the US wanted to eliminate the use of landmines
The US stopped participating in the treaty process. Until an exception for Korea is put in, the US will not return to the talks. This is a non-partisan issues. The demand for the excaption as a matter for Congress began under Clinton and is continued by Bush.
-
Alex a Hall of Famer?
Andre Dawson Gary Sheffield Kevin Brown Ivan Rodriguez Jim Leyland
-
Marlins to profit bigtime in 2006
Yummy. Still believe the team lost 8 figures last year? I don't have enough information either way, but a decrease of tens of millions of dollars in payroll combined with an increase of 8 figures due to the Expos could easily turn a loss of 10m+ into a profit. Which IS NOT A BAD THING, unless you feel that profit belongs to you in a good product or cheaper prices or better service, not the owners who very well might use it to secure a stadium in South Florida. Not claiming it is a bad thing, only that the fact that the team stands to profit next year does not mean that previous claims of losses are untrue.
-
Marlins to profit bigtime in 2006
Yummy. Still believe the team lost 8 figures last year? I don't have enough information either way, but a decrease of tens of millions of dollars in payroll combined with an increase of 8 figures due to the Expos could easily turn a loss of 10m+ into a profit.
-
Contenders in 2006!?
Even if the rotation performs like it could, and the young hitters develop immediately, the bullpen will still be apalling.