Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

A trade has gone down.....

Featured Replies

I saw on espn.com that one of the proposals for the three team deal was said to involve Penny and Choi for For Guillermo Mota, Paul Lo Duca and Juan Encarnacion from L.A.

 

I like this trade, wasn't really big on giving away Juan anyways.

 

If we do trade Penny we should try to pickup lowe if we can.

482587[/snapback]

 

 

this would be awesome....cabs can go back to left... 432 Juan can go back to RF....and i guess the FO has faith in conine now to be our everyday 1st baseman....then we get loduca AND MOTA!!! are you kidding me!!! this would be AWESOME. i believe we would hold the rights to mota for a couple more years....

 

i would just hope that stokes is not one of the prospects that we send...since choi is gone

 

man, i will wet myself if this goes down

So we're going to give up Choi too? So that we can get Juan Encarncion and his 235BA back? This is getting ridiculous... The DBacks would make out like bandits.

what do we have that the Red Sox want after Penny is moved other than Pavano which would just create another hole?

482590[/snapback]

 

absolutley nothing......unless the fish plan on turning around and trading mota and a prospect for lowe...the sox want bullpen....and maybe an upgrade at RF...but i dont see us sending conine or enc (if we get him) since that would leave a hole in our lineup.

you guys must have missed the part where Encarnacion's hitting .235 this season & basically blows.

 

Choi to Enc is a downgrade.

 

The rest would be Penny for Lo Duca & Mota, which is fine but then we're on the hook for another starter. & Derek Lowe's fine but having a below average season & his contract is up after this season too.

you guys must have missed the part where Encarnacion's hitting .235 this season & basically blows.

 

Choi to Enc is a downgrade.

482597[/snapback]

thank you.

 

i wouldnt give up choi for that filth.

So we're going to give up Choi too? So that we can get Juan Encarncion and his 235BA back? This is getting ridiculous...

482594[/snapback]

 

 

Ok here is how I look at it..

 

Lo duca>redmond

and I would much rather have encarnacion roaming right then cabrera, and cabrera roaming left than conine. And getting Mota would help the bolster the bullpen a bit. And if we can possibly trade for a SP like lowe without giving up any SP in return we should be alright. And yes I do prefer Lo duca over redmond. I hate redmond

482587[/snapback][/right]

 

 

this would be awesome....cabs can go back to left... 432 Juan can go back to RF....and i guess the FO has faith in conine now to be our everyday 1st baseman....then we get loduca AND MOTA!!! are you kidding me!!! this would be AWESOME. i believe we would hold the rights to mota for a couple more years....

 

i would just hope that stokes is not one of the prospects that we send...since choi is gone

 

man, i will wet myself if this goes down

482593[/snapback]

 

I'm not as excited about this deal. Why give up Choi? He is affordable and is the only left-handed bat in the lineup. We would fill a holes in the bullpen and behind the plate but create a huge hole in the starting rotation. We would also lack any sort of left-handed presence in the lineup. I hope there is more to this than meets the eye.

 

I guess we'll just have to wait and see what transpires.

what do we have that the Red Sox want after Penny is moved other than Pavano which would just create another hole?

482590[/snapback]

 

enc was recently injured...before the injury he was doing pretty well

 

his swing is good for the Pro also

 

you are right, it is a bit of a gamble....but teams gotta roll the dice...penny wasn't gonna be here next year anyway, we're prob gonna give the hampton money to pavz..... sure choi has contributed, but is he an absolute staple?? i have never been convinced....if this goes down...it can work out great...or, you're right, and we just lost on a gamble

you guys must have missed the part where Encarnacion's hitting .235 this season & basically blows.

 

Choi to Enc is a downgrade.

 

The rest would be Penny for Lo Duca & Mota, which is fine but then we're on the hook for another starter.

482597[/snapback]

 

This trade looks bad to me. Especially when you consider that its doubtful we can afford LoDuca at $8mil next year. Including Choi is a horrible, horrible idea.

enc was recently injured...before the injury he was doing pretty well

482601[/snapback]

before his injury, enc was hitting .240 with a .292 OBP and a .431 SLG.

 

that's HORRENDOUS for an outfielder.

 

i wouldnt even call this deal a "gamble"... its a horrible deal.

482587[/snapback][/right]

 

 

this would be awesome....cabs can go back to left... 432 Juan can go back to RF....and i guess the FO has faith in conine now to be our everyday 1st baseman....then we get loduca AND MOTA!!! are you kidding me!!! this would be AWESOME. i believe we would hold the rights to mota for a couple more years....

 

i would just hope that stokes is not one of the prospects that we send...since choi is gone

 

man, i will wet myself if this goes down

482593[/snapback]

 

I'm not as excited about this deal. Why give up Choi? He is affordable and is the only left-handed bat in the lineup. We would fill a holes in the bullpen and behind the plate but create a huge hole in the starting rotation. We would also lack any sort of left-handed presence in the lineup. I hope there is more to this than meets the eye.

 

I guess we'll just have to wait and see what transpires.

482600[/snapback]

 

 

last years championship team had 0 left handed pop...unless you wanna count hollandsworthitnowbutnotsomuchbefore

 

and, yup, i know giving up choi is a gamble : young, affordable....but so is mota, who would be more valuable to this team.....remember, stokes is waiting, and conine can play 1st next year (if he can still swing)....there are definite questions to be answered with this deal, but its a great chance to take......if the deal goes down, we're one starter away from LOOKING like a playoff team

 

pierre

castillo

Cabs

lowell

loduca

niner

agon

enc

 

you could really tinker with that line up....and all of a sudden you have mota and benitez for the 8th and 9th...along with koch and manzy. that is a bullpen my friend

So we're going to give up Choi too? So that we can get Juan Encarncion and his 235BA back? This is getting ridiculous...

482594[/snapback]

 

 

Ok here is how I look at it..

 

Lo duca>redmond

and I would much rather have encarnacion roaming right then cabrera, and cabrera roaming left than conine. And getting Mota would help the bolster the bullpen a bit. And if we can possibly trade for a SP like lowe without giving up any SP in return we should be alright. And yes I do prefer Lo duca over redmond. I hate redmond

482599[/snapback]

 

What are we going to trade for a starter? Don't forget that in addition to giving up Penny and Choi we also have to part with prospects. We don't have more than a handful that are attractive options at this point.

 

Knee jerk reaction, if this goes down its fiasco. We give up a potential #1 starter for an aging powerless catcher (not to mention the fact that there projected arbitration salaries wash) and then we give up a young, improving/good, affordable 1B for an engima like Enc. Plus we get a good setup man in Mota for two prospects. Not to mention that we're missing a 5th starter with precious little left to deal to get one. I don't get it.

Not sure if posted somewhere else but I was just on sportsline.com that doesn't even involve choi

 

The Sun-Sentinel reported the Marlins were closing in on a three-way deal with the Diamondbacks and Dodgers that would net them catcher Paul Lo Duca and left-hander Kaz Ishii, according to West Coast baseball sources. The deal would cost the Marlins righty Brad Penny and another hitter off their major league roster. Sources said that player wouldn't be a regular.

482606[/snapback][/right]

 

think of it this way.

 

you're giving up choi (a guy who will cost us peas for several years) to get an overpaid enc (a humongous downgrade) and and overpaid lo duca (a marginal upgrade).

 

even if you could call that part of the trade even, look at the rest:

 

you're giving up a dominant starting pitcher in penny (while basically throwing the 5th starter spot to the dogs) for a reliever in mota.

 

that's not even close to even. there's no way that trade makes this team better.

If this is all about salary, can't Penny just take a pay cut? He doesn't seem so much about the money, but more about the game...

482578[/snapback]

 

 

lolololol

Here's the trade:

 

 

L.A. gets Finley from Arizona, and Brad Penny and Hee Seop Choi from Florida.

 

 

 

Florida gets Guillermo Mota, Paul Lo Duca and Juan Encarnacion from L.A.

 

 

 

Arizona gets Jayson Werth from the Dodgers, and prospects from the Marlins.

Here's the trade:

 

 

L.A. gets Finley from Arizona, and Brad Penny and Hee Seop Choi from Florida.

 

 

 

Florida gets Guillermo Mota, Paul Lo Duca and Juan Encarnacion from L.A.

 

 

 

Arizona gets Jayson Werth from the Dodgers, and prospects from the Marlins.

482615[/snapback]

 

I hope not...

Here's the trade:

 

 

L.A. gets Finley from Arizona, and Brad Penny and Hee Seop Choi from Florida.

 

 

 

Florida gets Guillermo Mota, Paul Lo Duca and Juan Encarnacion from L.A.

 

 

 

Arizona gets Jayson Werth from the Dodgers, and prospects from the Marlins.

482615[/snapback]

 

 

What's this, the trade in your opinion?

I mean Penny is probably better than Ishii, but you also have to look at the future. Next year we would still have Ishii, we wont be able to have Penny and Pavano. The rotation we would essentially have would be here for a few years probably. I am going to check Lo Duca and Ishii's numbers right now.

Here's the trade:

 

 

L.A. gets Finley from Arizona, and Brad Penny and Hee Seop Choi from Florida.

 

 

 

Florida gets Guillermo Mota, Paul Lo Duca and Juan Encarnacion from L.A.

 

 

 

Arizona gets Jayson Werth from the Dodgers, and prospects from the Marlins.

482615[/snapback]

 

 

What's this, the trade in your opinion?

482619[/snapback]

 

Better be... :thumbdown

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.