Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

A trade has gone down.....

Featured Replies

i know all the talk has been with dodgers but wat happend to our number one priority being walker

d trizzle has a great point it makes no sense to trade one our starting 5 of possibly the best staff in baseball.

 

also weve been waiting all year to get the big healthy and starting 5 in a row and break it up the day beckett returns

482654[/snapback]

i agree with that

 

but it DOES make sense

 

i would have rather kept our rotation though and give the prospects up

 

this type of rotation is the one that takes you deep into the playoffs

 

 

penny is a tough loss

482658[/snapback]

 

I like Penny, but he is a "stocky" individual who will break down as he ages... He WILL become a project once his weight becomes completely out of control. It does hurt to see him go, though.

OPS Redmond to Lo Duca:

.646 up to .795 - increase of .150

 

OPS Choi to Encarnacion:

.882 down to .705 - decrease of .180

 

even if you take Enc's career OPS average (.753) it's still a big drop from Choi.

 

After that, its Penny for Mota, then we?re still stuck looking for a starter who will certainly be a downgrade from Penny?

 

 

NO DEAL! :thumbdown

We all know Juan is better than .235 hitter and he could catch on fire back in S.Florida.He loves S.Florida and good friends with Castillo.

in the Sun Sent. its says our fall back deeal on the dodgers would be peavy. I would much rather that hes a stud let me find his stats

You guys dont have this deal understood. We are not giving up Penny and Choi for Enc, Lo Duca and Mota. Payroll doesnt make sense. I fail to see how this makes us better - I love Mota, but he is going to be in our pen (and would be a candidate for a closer next year). Our starters take a big hit unless we get Lowe for cheap (it is possible - and I think he could turn it around). Lo Duca makes a lot of money and Enc is, well, have you all forgotten how little he contributed last year in the playoffs? I like the guy, but I am not crazy about this deal.

if we did get lowe which lowe are we getting the one that threw the no hitter or the one this year

If this is all about salary, can't Penny just take a pay cut? He doesn't seem so much about the money, but more about the game...

482578[/snapback]

 

 

lolololol

482613[/snapback]

 

Why not? I mean thats just my opinion, I of course don't know him personally. How ever thats how he comes across to me. I've seen him around various places and he isn't as showy as some of the other players. More down to earth. I don't know, just my opinion.

482641[/snapback]

 

So you are saying that Penny doesn't seem like a guy that has a little bit of pride or a guy that would like to take care of his family unequivocally for the rest of his life? Please... I know you mean well, but this is supposed to be a serious trade thread *cough cough*...

482651[/snapback]

 

I'm sorry to mess up your "serious trade thread," I do mean well... As, I'm sure you do. But, how did you get that I don't think Penny would want to take care of his family out of my post though? I was just trying to look at a different point of view. With his salary now, he isn't exactly living in the slums. :)

482668[/snapback]

 

Let's just agree to disagree... Penny WILL NOT take a paycut to stay here...

Here's the trade:

 

 

L.A. gets Finley from Arizona, and Brad Penny and Hee Seop Choi from Florida.

 

 

 

Florida gets Guillermo Mota, Paul Lo Duca and Juan Encarnacion from L.A.

 

 

 

Arizona gets Jayson Werth from the Dodgers, and prospects from the Marlins.

482615[/snapback]

 

 

I think I'm going to need a vomit bag :thumbdown

482633[/snapback]

 

You serious? Mota is better than anyone in our bullpen right now not named Benitez, Lo Duca instantly becomes the best catcher and say what you want, but Choi and Enc are pretty much washes with Enc having more RBI, but a lower BA.

 

I love this trade. Every single weakness gets upgraded: stronger bullpen, a legit everyday catcher, great right field defense, but our rotation does take a hit. If we get Lowe, now we really may be on to something...

482653[/snapback]

 

Choi and Enc are anything but a wash. What do you proposes we get Lowe with? Don't forget we'll also be giving up good prospects and its not like we have a bunch of those lying around. Not to mention why the Red Sox would create a whole for themselves by moving Lowe without getting a starter back.

 

This trade is garbage.

I love the deal Penny for Ishii and Lo Duca. Ishii is a more than capable 5th starter. While Lo Duca would complete this line up. I hate the Choi deal. That would be the stupidest deal of all time. Choi is going to be a great player in this league and is way better than Enc right now.

i think all of us are badly mistaken

 

this trade should not and will not include choi

 

and beinfest is not stupid enough to give away penny without getting another starter MLB ready

 

we will not get ENC...he is worthless to us now, conine is a keeper in the OF

 

and now it has been concluded that our hole is at C

 

Prospects and Penny for Duca and Mota? i dont think so...doesnt make sense...where is our starter?

I love the deal Penny for Ishii and Lo Duca. Ishii is a more than capable 5th starter. While Lo Duca would complete this line up. I hate the Choi deal. That would be the stupidest deal of all time. Choi is going to be a great player in this league and is way better than Enc right now.

482680[/snapback]

i think that might be the deal

 

penny for ishii and lo duca

 

because i think it has been concluded by the FO that Conine is not the problem, and that our hole is at catcher

ya, I highly doubt we trade Choi, he is very cheap and young. Why would you mess with that? We'll see what happens if in fact something does happen

wait a second.......

 

with arizona involved, yankees could be involved

 

randy johnson is supposed to be on the move possibly

 

randy to yankees? contreras to florida? finley to LA? penny to LA? Arizona gets prospects? We get lo duca also?

 

:shifty :shifty :shifty

ya, I highly doubt we trade Choi, he is very cheap and young. Why would you mess with that? We'll see what happens if in fact something does happen

482684[/snapback]

:thumbup

anybody know a good Dodgers message board?

482690[/snapback]

 

www.rapethemarlins.com ? :confused

:lol :plain :anon :banghead :chair :boxed :censored :crying :tv_horror :stare :pullhair :rofl

 

 

that's all i have to say about this trade.

anybody know a good Dodgers message board?

482690[/snapback]

 

www.rapethemarlins.com ? :confused

482692[/snapback]

If choi's involved somebody should make that site.

anybody know a good Dodgers message board?

482690[/snapback]

 

 

Try - www.dodgerblues.com

 

Sounds like they are vehemently opposed to trading Jason Werth.

 

:hat

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.