June 23, 200323 yr Author that mostly young bullpen, alot of them have more then 3 years under there belt Wow! A whole 3 years! Break out the canes and get Raffy over here to pitch some Viagra! I totally forgot about Spooney heh. Mando having elbow pain? Where did you read this? Also forgot about Borland...where would I be without you odom! Well at least we have some options with the bullpen once we set it. We all know what Neal can do once he gets his head under control...
June 23, 200323 yr basically....one can say his idea works. But it isnt heaven-sent. It kind of works, but is nothing special. It does not disprove the use of scouts who actually know baseball to use instinct and gut reactions along with the use of looking at "tools" etc like so many Beane-followers want to make it out to be. In fact, Beane has gotten lucky on a few, and fell into the rest of his A's team. I mean, Mulder was the #2 pick in the draft that year. Ooohhh, such a bold move! Such a diamond in the rough! I'd take good old-fashioned scouting over this egg-head calculator-toting mathematical baseball crap.
June 23, 200323 yr ya almanza cryin ova some elbow pain blaming his high a** ERA on it..... maybe its an Xcuse could be true... here Armando Almanza is bothered by a little elbow pain, but he'll continue to pitch through it. ''We're taking it slow,'' said Almanza, who has had arthroscopic surgery on his elbow in 1994 and 2001. ''The same stuff happens every year. I begin the season with tightness in the arm. They tell me I'll have to deal with it for the rest of my career, but I'm getting used to that and learning how to deal with it. The most important thing is being ready for the season
June 23, 200323 yr you cant really go against what scheurhloz says.... i also like opponents average against for pitchers. for routine hitters i like OPS. for run producers i like SLG. but the categories given are hard to quibble about.
June 23, 200323 yr Author Just because he was taken as the #2 pick doesn't mean he was projected as the #2 pick. Find that fact out and then you can make an informed decision. Where is that article from and what date?
June 23, 200323 yr he was projected top 10 at least. He wasnt some great steal. If the A's didnt pick him up, he would have been picked up real soon. Once again...Ariel Prieto?
June 23, 200323 yr Author das, if you respect avg against as a telling stat read this essay... http://www.baseballprospectus.com/news/200...3mccracken.html a little heavy, but a good read.
June 23, 200323 yr Author Its a little confusing..I had to read it through 3 times. He is simply trying to state with many examples and stats is that major-league pitchers do not have the ability to prevent hits on balls in play. Bu he also can'y explain why this is...so...
June 23, 200323 yr yah, and I agree with what he says especially with the lob-league analogy. Yah pitchers are good, great, bad, terrible, alright, etc. But, a lot does depend on the hitter. But, back to Beane....I really hate the fact that people put too much emphasis on stats...and not enough on talent, and gameplaying ability. It sickens me to see such a pure sport like baseball get turned into a mathematical, stat-reading, bookworm, egghead, nerdy sport (sorry to all the nerds). I'm not saying that it needs to be a dumb sport, but more needs to be emphasized like the 5 tools, athletic ability. I mean...stats dont always reflect the player perfectly...OPS or whatever may have said that Ariel Prieto was a better player than Todd Helton and look what happens. There are a lot of GMs in baseball now that do not like at all what Beane is trying to do to baseball.
June 23, 200323 yr Author I say the game itself can still be pure while with the power to choose who is drafted don't have to follow the 5-tool approach.
June 23, 200323 yr But, back to Beane....I really hate the fact that people put too much emphasis on stats...and not enough on talent, and gameplaying ability. It sickens me to see such a pure sport like baseball get turned into a mathematical, stat-reading, bookworm, egghead, nerdy sport (sorry to all the nerds). I'm not saying that it needs to be a dumb sport, but more needs to be emphasized like the 5 tools, athletic ability. I mean...stats dont always reflect the player perfectly...OPS or whatever may have said that Ariel Prieto was a better player than Todd Helton and look what happens. There are a lot of GMs in baseball now that do not like at all what Beane is trying to do to baseball. Statistics are just a numerical representation of what happens on the field. They're derived from how a player performs in a game. So it seems kind of silly (to me anyway) to criticize statistics when they're directly derived from the real-life performance of the player. It's not that statheads like Billy Beane are completely ignoring talent and athleticism in favor of stats. They just want to see if that talent and athleticism translates into on-the-field production. If a player is truly talented, then it will show in that player's statistics. Also, giving the example of Ariel Prieto I think misses the point. Billy Beane knows that his methods aren't perfect and that once in a while he'll draft a disappointment like Prieto. The idea is to make the success rate as high as possible. If 70% of Oakland's first round draft picks turn out to be solid major leaguers, then Beane's methods were successful. Sure it may result in the drafting of a guy like Ariel Prieto. But for every Ariel Prieto, you could point out "5-tool players" like Travis Lee and Brian Anderson that have also been disappointments. The goal is to have more hits than misses. Besides, if "5-tool-players" and "athletic ability" were the only things emphasized, then players like Kevin Millar and Mike Sweeney wouldn't even be in the majors.
June 23, 200323 yr i think Billy Beane is full of it. He's doing something right. I especially liked the chapters on Scott Hatteberg & Chad Bradford. The chapter on the 2002 Draft strongly suggests Beane was laughing his a** off when the Marlins selected Hermidia with Nick Swisher still available. Beane had Swisher as his #1 prospect. Beane was ecstatic when the Mets passed on Swisher and selected Edcanes favortie...Scott Kazmir. Beane is vehemently against the drafting of high school pitchers. I strongly recommend Moneyball to any true baseball fan. Also, it would behoove the many dolts who post on this board to pick up a copy and learn something for a change. It's a must read for Das Texan, Fish Fillet and the other Marlin "realists." :thumbup
June 23, 200323 yr nice to see someone else has read it........Im not up to the chapter on Hatteberg yet..... the chapter on the draft was awesome....Jeremy Brown eh?
June 23, 200323 yr The Jeremy Brown story was amazing. I was checking his stats at AA and he is doing well. I loved the whole Swisher story as well. You know he was mocking the Marlins for drafting Hermidia with Swisher staring them right in the face.
June 23, 200323 yr of course he was...... he must have been going crazy when Swisher fell.... i would hve liked to see Jeremy Brown's face when they told him he was a 20th round, check that 10th round, check that 1st round pick
June 23, 200323 yr I'm not suprised we have the best IF in baseball... But I'm also not suprised we have the 28th OF... And I agree with where the rotation is... 7th in baseball, but they might have given us a little favor in the bullpen... None the less, some people may look at this and be very, very suprised to see us up there...
June 23, 200323 yr But what has he really done? The 2 best players on the team are Chavez and Tejada. I think both were there before he got there, but even if they werent, they still break his "plan for success." Also, Zito was taken because they couldn't get Sheets! He dumb lucked himself into that one! Mulder was a no-brainer from everyone's opinion...nothing special about that pick. The fact remains, that the A's do well because of late season trades. I'll look for the quote in Sports Illustrated on this buffoon.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.