September 13, 200422 yr I'm strongly against the "save your closer until the 9th inning when you have the lead philosophy."? It just doesnt make any sense...especially in late innings.? Dont think in terms of closers.? Think in terms of this is my best pitcher and he will pitch in the most critical situation (i.e. lead in danger in the 8th, people on base, others struggling) otherwise why even have him? 554299[/snapback] Agreed I was telling my brother in the game why the f*** didnt Jack put Benetiz in. I mean one-third of an inning isnt going to kill his arm. These are must game wins and we cant be fooling around. 554303[/snapback] Agree is much harder to get out of a tough situation then to pitch the last inning scoreless
September 13, 200422 yr i dont like that pitch that seanez uses, that it goes up and then goes right back down really quick. sometimes loduca cant handle it and it becomes a ball. but overall, he seems to be helpful. but id rather see benitez up there.
September 13, 200422 yr i dont like that pitch that seanez uses, that it goes up and then goes right back down really quick. sometimes loduca cant handle it and it becomes a ball. but overall, he seems to be helpful. but id rather see benitez up there. 555813[/snapback] shows alot about what youk know...thats a slider,it fools the batter and they swing alof of the time for a strike.
September 13, 200422 yr i dont like that pitch that seanez uses, that it goes up and then goes right back down really quick. sometimes loduca cant handle it and it becomes a ball. but overall, he seems to be helpful. but id rather see benitez up there. 555813[/snapback] :lol
September 13, 200422 yr It's easy for all of you to sit there and criticize McKeon for his moves. Anytime one of his moves does not work out everyone acts like they should be managing baseball in the Major Leagues. Unfortunately managers do not have the benefit of hindsight when they are making their decisions. Second guessing is easy when you don't like an outcome. The fact is McKeon played this game the same way he has played every game since we got Mota and Seanez. They have always been relied upon to do their jobs and have always performed. The one day they fail you are all jumping on Seanez and McKeon about it. I remember earlier in the year when McKeon brought in Benitez with the bases loaded in the 8th to get us out of a jam. That was the right move because there was 1 out left in the 8th and Benitez was coming in the 9th anyhow. The problem with the situation against the Cubs was that it was only the 7th inning. You need to have Benitez there to assure that we do not blow a lead in the 9th because in the 9th there is no more chances for us to score runs and win. If Benitez comes in and saves us from giving up a lead in the 7th and then we have no one to close the game out then what? At least is we surrender a run in the 7th then we have 6 out's left to score runs. He did not know that the bullpen was going to give up 3 runs, but then again he doesn't have the benefit of hindsight. Whatever, one can argue this till they are blue in the face and everyone is entitled to their opinions. But McKeon did it right and it didn't workout, his players did not perform, I do not think McKeon should be blamed for that.
September 13, 200422 yr It's easy for all of you to sit there and criticize McKeon for his moves. Anytime one of his moves does not work out everyone acts like they should be managing baseball in the Major Leagues. Unfortunately managers do not have the benefit of hindsight when they are making their decisions. Second guessing is easy when you don't like an outcome. The fact is McKeon played this game the same way he has played every game since we got Mota and Seanez. They have always been relied upon to do their jobs and have always performed. The one day they fail you are all jumping on Seanez and McKeon about it. I remember earlier in the year when McKeon brought in Benitez with the bases loaded in the 8th to get us out of a jam. That was the right move because there was 1 out left in the 8th and Benitez was coming in the 9th anyhow. The problem with the situation against the Cubs was that it was only the 7th inning. You need to have Benitez there to assure that we do not blow a lead in the 9th because in the 9th there is no more chances for us to score runs and win. If Benitez comes in and saves us from giving up a lead in the 7th and then we have no one to close the game out then what? At least is we surrender a run in the 7th then we have 6 out's left to score runs. He did not know that the bullpen was going to give up 3 runs, but then again he doesn't have the benefit of hindsight. Whatever, one can argue this till they are blue in the face and everyone is entitled to their opinions. But McKeon did it right and it didn't workout, his players did not perform, I do not think McKeon should be blamed for that. 555924[/snapback] Exactly. If benitez were to have come in, lets say they dont score, and he pitches a scoreless ninth as well. Who comes in next or if we get a lead? Koch, manzanillo, bump? I rather save benitez and unfortuneately MOTA was the one that got in the jam in the first place, so he blew the save. Then seanez gave up a bases loaded hit, which for a pitcher just coming out of the pen is a tough spot to be in
September 13, 200422 yr send in Seanez if it goes into extras. Mando could've very easily pitched the 9th plus that one batter in the 8th. And it was not the 7th inning we're talking about djm, it's the 8th. If it were the 7th I might agree with you. another reason I would've wanted Benitez in there against DLee was the Cubs had the bases loaded. You know Mando's going in there throwing strikes, & thus don't have to worry about him walking in the leading run.
September 13, 200422 yr i dont like that pitch that seanez uses, that it goes up and then goes right back down really quick. sometimes loduca cant handle it and it becomes a ball. but overall, he seems to be helpful. but id rather see benitez up there. 555813[/snapback] seriously! i hate the way loduca makes pitches become balls! why does he do that? gosh!!one!!shiftone!!! [/sarcasm]
September 13, 200422 yr It's easy for all of you to sit there and criticize McKeon for his moves. Anytime one of his moves does not work out everyone acts like they should be managing baseball in the Major Leagues. Unfortunately managers do not have the benefit of hindsight when they are making their decisions. Second guessing is easy when you don't like an outcome. The fact is McKeon played this game the same way he has played every game since we got Mota and Seanez. They have always been relied upon to do their jobs and have always performed. The one day they fail you are all jumping on Seanez and McKeon about it. I remember earlier in the year when McKeon brought in Benitez with the bases loaded in the 8th to get us out of a jam. That was the right move because there was 1 out left in the 8th and Benitez was coming in the 9th anyhow. The problem with the situation against the Cubs was that it was only the 7th inning. You need to have Benitez there to assure that we do not blow a lead in the 9th because in the 9th there is no more chances for us to score runs and win. If Benitez comes in and saves us from giving up a lead in the 7th and then we have no one to close the game out then what? At least is we surrender a run in the 7th then we have 6 out's left to score runs. He did not know that the bullpen was going to give up 3 runs, but then again he doesn't have the benefit of hindsight. Whatever, one can argue this till they are blue in the face and everyone is entitled to their opinions. But McKeon did it right and it didn't workout, his players did not perform, I do not think McKeon should be blamed for that. 555924[/snapback] I think the time to use your best reliever is when you really need outs, not just when it's the 9th inning, you have the lead and the bases empty. It's far easier to lose a tie game with middle relievers than it is to lose a lead with middle relievers. But that's what managers do and I won't blame McKeon or any manager for failing to try the unorthodox. What I did find very odd was not having someone else available when Mota got into trouble. Mota had no control and loaded the bases in the 7th before recording the third and final out of the inning. Normally you wouldn't be too concerned if the best setup man in baseball is a little off after a few days of rest, but normally you don't have the luxry of a 11-man bullpen. Jack should have had someone else warming up. He waited until Mota gave up the lead to get Perisho and Seanez up in the bullpen, then had to wait for Mota to get in further trouble before Perisho had a few seconds to warm up. Seanez never got into a rhythm and couldn't spot his fastball. It was inexcusable to have no one up and ready to come in.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.