December 1, 200421 yr Hey guys, someone from one of my white sox message boards posted a rumor that I guess was heard from a Florida Radio Station. The deal would have been: Sox get: Luis Castillo, 2B Scott Posednik, CF Milwaukee gets Brian Anderson Florida Prospect Marlins get: Carlos Lee Now this might be complete bs and I'm interested to see if any of you guys heard about this. Sorry if this is just something that was made up, I'm just curious. Thanks a lot. P.S. Sorry to hear about Armando but SF overpaid anyways.
December 1, 200421 yr damn another oeo magglio? sounds good depending on who the prospect would be. i love castillo but we need a power bat.
December 1, 200421 yr Author Hey guys, someone from one of my white sox message boards posted a rumor that I guess was heard from a Florida Radio Station. The deal would have been: Sox get: Luis Castillo, 2B Scott Posednik, CF Milwaukee gets Brian Anderson Florida Prospect Marlins get: Carlos Lee Now this might be complete bs and I'm interested to see if any of you guys heard about this. Sorry if this is just something that was made up, I'm just curious. Thanks a lot. P.S. Sorry to hear about Armando but SF overpaid anyways. 624147[/snapback] Ha....ya we both post on WSI also.
December 1, 200421 yr I don't see it happening, and this is the first I hear of it. I'm curious to know which "radio station" it is.
December 1, 200421 yr the sox already have a really good young CF.. im guessing if this were to happen, theyd move him to LF.. but again, this won't happen.
December 1, 200421 yr mmmm lets see... we lose our best defensive player,potential leadoff hitter,300 hitter and a prospect. we get a mediocre carlos lee who wont put those numbers in pps...mmm im thinking no.
December 1, 200421 yr Author mmmm lets see... we lose our best defensive player,potential leadoff hitter,300 hitter and a prospect. we get a mediocre carlos lee who wont put those numbers in pps...mmm im thinking no. 624203[/snapback] Hey.....I wasn't the one who came up with this, I was just acting if you guys heard anything about it. Also Carlos Lee is anything but mediocre, he is one hell of a player.
December 1, 200421 yr mmmm lets see... we lose our best defensive player,potential leadoff hitter,300 hitter and a prospect. we get a mediocre carlos lee who wont put those numbers in pps...mmm im thinking no. 624203[/snapback] Hey.....I wasn't the one who came up with this, I was just acting if you guys heard anything about it. Also Carlos Lee is anything but mediocre, he is one hell of a player. 624207[/snapback] vlad= one hell of a player carlos lee=mediocre
December 1, 200421 yr mmmm lets see... we lose our best defensive player,potential leadoff hitter,300 hitter and a prospect. we get a mediocre carlos lee who wont put those numbers in pps...mmm im thinking no. 624203[/snapback] I concur. We lose to much and the Sox gain too much.
December 1, 200421 yr Author May I ask what a good player is?? Carlos batted .305 with 31 homers and 99 rbi's last year. If you're going to use the park for an argument you should check out his splits, he batted .307 with 14 homers and 54 rbi's on the road.
December 1, 200421 yr May I ask what a good player is?? Carlos batted .305 with 31 homers and 99 rbi's last year. If you're going to use the park for an argument you should check out his splits, he batted .307 with 14 homers and 54 rbi's on the road. 624214[/snapback] those are mediocre numbers.
December 1, 200421 yr May I ask what a good player is?? Carlos batted .305 with 31 homers and 99 rbi's last year. If you're going to use the park for an argument you should check out his splits, he batted .307 with 14 homers and 54 rbi's on the road. 624214[/snapback] those are mediocre numbers. 624216[/snapback] You're right... trade cabs too.. he's mediocre.
December 1, 200421 yr May I ask what a good player is??? Carlos batted .305 with 31 homers and 99 rbi's last year.? If you're going to use the park for an argument you should check out his splits, he batted .307 with 14 homers and 54 rbi's on the road. 624214[/snapback] those are mediocre numbers. 624216[/snapback] You're right... trade cabs too.. he's mediocre. 624218[/snapback] cabrera- 33 HR, 112 RBI, 21 years old Lee-31 HR,99 RBI,28 Years old dont be a smart ass.
December 1, 200421 yr also lee has only had 2 years over 30 hr and 1 year over 100 rbi. as well as 1 year over .300
December 1, 200421 yr May I ask what a good player is??? Carlos batted .305 with 31 homers and 99 rbi's last year.? If you're going to use the park for an argument you should check out his splits, he batted .307 with 14 homers and 54 rbi's on the road. 624214[/snapback] those are mediocre numbers. 624216[/snapback] Not really. His career OPS isnt anything great. Though he is headed in the right direction.
December 1, 200421 yr May I ask what a good player is?? Carlos batted .305 with 31 homers and 99 rbi's last year. If you're going to use the park for an argument you should check out his splits, he batted .307 with 14 homers and 54 rbi's on the road. 624214[/snapback] those are mediocre numbers. 624216[/snapback] You're right... trade cabs too.. he's mediocre. 624218[/snapback] He's a decent player, Career .280 hitter and right handed and an average fielder. If he were left handed maybe this trade would be somewhat fair. Plus where the hell do we put him. We can't have Encarnacion sitting on the bench making 5 million. This deal makes no sense what so ever for the Marlins. I can see us trading Luis, but not for Carlos Lee.
December 1, 200421 yr If anyone can convince me how this trade helps the Marlins, I'll mail that person a buck. I'd be pissed if we traded Castillo for any player. The guy took a discount to stay a Marlin. Out of loyalty, I wouldn't even trade him for Pujols.
December 1, 200421 yr This trade sucks. Beckett for Dunn, now your talking. :thumbup If Adam Dunn is not on the Marlins roster to start next year I am going to be...... mad. The rumblings of Beckett for Dunn have been kicked around so long, since last year, that I think there is some life to it somewhere along the line. I want the trigger pulled. Make a move, lay yourself on the line. You don't win by being passive.
December 1, 200421 yr All I can say is - PLEASE let this happen. Then we can finally put Miguel back in the IF (at 2B), and we'll have a powerhouse attack. To those hating on Carlos Lee - you people are out of your damn minds if you wouldn't trade Luis Castillo + a prospect for Lee.
December 1, 200421 yr If anyone can convince me how this trade helps the Marlins, I'll mail that person a buck. It allows the Marlins to significantly upgrade the offense. Looking at their last 3 years, Castillo has averaged a .741 OPS and Lee has averaged an .855 OPS. 'Nuff said. Where's my buck?
December 1, 200421 yr All I can say is - PLEASE let this happen. Then we can finally put Miguel back in the IF (at 2B) 624333[/snapback] are you kidding me?
December 1, 200421 yr This trade sucks. Beckett for Dunn, now your talking. :thumbup If Adam Dunn is not on the Marlins roster to start next year I am going to be...... mad. The rumblings of Beckett for Dunn have been kicked around so long, since last year, that I think there is some life to it somewhere along the line. I want the trigger pulled. Make a move, lay yourself on the line. You don't win by being passive. I'm glad that that's been nothing but a rumor. Beckett for Dunn is a zero-sum move, and I'd rather keep Beckett.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.