April 24, 200620 yr Author Joey Gathright has a .368 OBP I am not getting into is Gathright worth Olsen argument either. He is exactly what we need however. Just wait till he starts hitting .280+ and those BB stay consistent. For which one of our SPs would you value him at now? The Rays have got to be getting desperate to trade him. He's not playing everyday, they need SPs, and not exactly racking up value with his BA. I'd still like to get him as well despite reggie's recent tease.
April 24, 200620 yr I'm stalking you because I keep posting in ONE of your threads that's on the forum I visit the most on this messageboard? By the way, Mike Maroth is leading the majors with a 0.49 ERA in 18.1 IP. Sustainable??? awww, at least you're honest. I'm straight though bro, sorry. Not only are you now stalking me, but also twisting my words, and purposefully ignoring the post directly above. Here, I'll copy paste it for you... You didn't post an opinion you f***ing moron. You basically claimed that I said the small sample sizes I included (ALONG WITH THEIR CAREER STATISTICS) were "really meaningful," which I didn't. It's basically moot anyway, since Ross was traded and Borchard is crap. Now will you please get off my sac? I suggest a name change to "Stalker Sid," maybe? So, in other words (the above was in plain English, but I'll try again) I recognize that the numbers I posted represented small sample sizes, that they weren't even close to sustainable, but that they were pieces of information that might be asked for later in the thread...so I included them. I know you're thick, but does this compute? Can a mod please close this now that I got the last word in. Fixed that for you. My point which I've reiterated already is that posting those stats was useless. But that's really caring of you to post numbers that someone as intelligent as yourself is certain are irrelevant just because someone was going to ask for them. Smart, clairvoyant and able to keep his cool in internet arguments. Shamrock is one of life's winners.
April 24, 200620 yr Author ok, take the last word, since apparently you need it. anyway, I'd still not trade any of our top tier for Gathright...which to me includes Olsen, Sanchez, Vargas, Johnson, Petit...might be missing someone here.
April 24, 200620 yr Gathright defense and arm are subpar... He has his average up to .220...only 2 sb. Gathright give you a lot of speed and does walk quite a bit but you give up a lot with the glove in the field and he isn't that great of a hitter...Tampa bats him 9th...I know they have Crawford but still..
April 24, 200620 yr Author Gathright defense and arm are subpar... He has his average up to .220...only 2 sb. Gathright give you a lot of speed and does walk quite a bit but you give up a lot with the glove in the field and he isn't that great of a hitter...Tampa bats him 9th...I know they have Crawford but still.. perfect time to nab him for one of our surplus arms not in our top tier SPs. :hat I'd be very surprised if he didn't bring that average up around the 280s w/ a 350+ OBP. As for the defense, I havn't watched but one D-Rays game this year, so I couldn't comment on his defense.
April 24, 200620 yr Gathright defense and arm are subpar... He has his average up to .220...only 2 sb. Gathright give you a lot of speed and does walk quite a bit but you give up a lot with the glove in the field and he isn't that great of a hitter...Tampa bats him 9th...I know they have Crawford but still.. Noodle Arm has 2 outfield assists, is currently first in baseball in CF range factor, and has the seventh best zone rating. These stats parallel the Fielding Bible, which is something you need to read. Gathright is not going to hurt you on defense. For which one of our SPs would you value him at now? The Rays have got to be getting desperate to trade him. He's not playing everyday, they need SPs, and not exactly racking up value with his BA. I'd still like to get him as well despite reggie's recent tease. Yea, the avg is a concern, but I think it will settle .270-.290, he can be a solid .340-.360 OBP guy. Which is probably about 120-150 points higher then what any CF in the Marlins organization would do. I'd still move Johnson 1-1 for him, or Nolasco, or Gaby. I agree with you to hold onto the top tier - Vargas, Olsen, Anibal, and Petit, unless Tampa wants to float Elijiah.
April 24, 200620 yr I'd be very surprised if he didn't bring that average up around the 280s w/ a 350+ OBP. Negated by a bat that's unlikely to slug much of anything over the .400 mark
April 24, 200620 yr I'd be very surprised if he didn't bring that average up around the 280s w/ a 350+ OBP. Negated by a bat that's unlikely to slug much of anything over the .400 mark To bad he is going to create 50+ TB with steals, and only give up a marginal amount of outs to do it with. He will steal over 70% in huge quantities.
April 24, 200620 yr Reds designated infielder Tony Womack for assignment. A complete waste of $1.1 million, money that could have been used to try for a reliever better than Rick White or Chris Hammond. The Reds will attempt to trade Womack, but it's likely that he'll just become a free agent. Maybe the Cardinals will want him back. Womack's departure leaves the Reds with one less player to challenge Brandon Phillips for at-bats at second base. Apr. 24 - 3:59 pm et Tony Womack for our team may be a solid pickup. He can play 2B and OF, has speed, makes contact and is a veteran. Girardi was with Womack on the Yanks so I am sure he has thoughts one way or the other. Assuming the Reds picked up his salary (most of it) I think the Marlins should look in to this.
April 24, 200620 yr I'd be very surprised if he didn't bring that average up around the 280s w/ a 350+ OBP. Negated by a bat that's unlikely to slug much of anything over the .400 mark To bad he is going to create 50+ TB with steals, and only give up a marginal amount of outs to do it with. He will steal over 70% in huge quantities. It's wrong to suggest stolen bases have the same value of other types of attained bases. A hit is valuable as it is because it is in effect not an out and advances existing baserunners. Extra base hits advance existing baserunners even further. That extra base from the stolen base often is irrevelant to the result of the runner scoring. This is why according to the run expectancy metrics (which factor in the intangibles of a distracting baserunner) 50 stolen bases at a 80% success rate adds 4 runs over the course of the year. About the same as 6 solo homeruns.
April 24, 200620 yr If the Marlins were able to acquire Womack for the major league minimum and he took Reed's roster spot and not Amezega's, I would have to say I'm all for it, if for no other reason than in his career (which obviously is nearly over) he's played 2B, SS and all three outfield positions. I'm normally NOT in favor of these kinds of pickups but this one could help out.
April 24, 200620 yr Gathright defense and arm are subpar... He has his average up to .220...only 2 sb. Gathright give you a lot of speed and does walk quite a bit but you give up a lot with the glove in the field and he isn't that great of a hitter...Tampa bats him 9th...I know they have Crawford but still.. perfect time to nab him for one of our surplus arms not in our top tier SPs. :hat I'd be very surprised if he didn't bring that average up around the 280s w/ a 350+ OBP. As for the defense, I havn't watched but one D-Rays game this year, so I couldn't comment on his defense. Living in the Orlando Area The D-Rays is the only Baseball we get...Believe me if you had gripes about JP as an outfielder it wouldn't be too long before Gathright would make you wanna hurl with his Outfield play...he does have the speed to correct mistakes, which is good because he makes a lot of them...He made the highlights the other day because he tried to get a runner out in 3rd base and he threw it about 20ft above the 3rd baseman's head...Im use to seeing that...in my son's little league game!
April 24, 200620 yr I'd be very surprised if he didn't bring that average up around the 280s w/ a 350+ OBP. ]Negated by a bat that's unlikely to slug much of anything over the .400 mark To bad he is going to create 50+ TB with steals, and only give up a marginal amount of outs to do it with. He will steal over 70% in huge quantities. It's wrong to suggest stolen bases have the same value of other types of attained bases. A hit is valuable as it is because it is in effect not an out and advances existing baserunners. Extra base hits advance existing baserunners even further. That extra base from the stolen base often is irrevelant to the result of the runner scoring. This is why according to the run expectancy metrics (which factor in the intangibles of a distracting baserunner) 50 stolen bases at a 80% success rate adds 4 runs over the course of the year. About the same as 6 solo homeruns. No they don't have the same value as OBP, but it's also brutally silly to suggest running wild contributes so little to run production. And regardless, if Gathright is not creating outs 34-35% of the time and does not have a defensive liability as shown by the RF and ZR rankings which I know you like, what does it matter where on base he is with slugging? OBP >Slug. It's not ideal he won't hit much more then 40 extra base hits a year, but he's contributing to the gap by creating TB at the expense of a small amount of outs. Gathright creates runs. With his 2006 rate, which is a small sample size, he is creating over 115+ runs in 650 plate apperances. This is with leadoff hitters behind him. Also, how does 4 runs = 6 solo home runs? Typo?
April 24, 200620 yr Gathright defense and arm are subpar... He has his average up to .220...only 2 sb. Gathright give you a lot of speed and does walk quite a bit but you give up a lot with the glove in the field and he isn't that great of a hitter...Tampa bats him 9th...I know they have Crawford but still.. Noodle Arm has 2 outfield assists, is currently first in baseball in CF range factor, and has the seventh best zone rating. These stats parallel the Fielding Bible, which is something you need to read. Gathright is not going to hurt you on defense. For which one of our SPs would you value him at now? The Rays have got to be getting desperate to trade him. He's not playing everyday, they need SPs, and not exactly racking up value with his BA. I'd still like to get him as well despite reggie's recent tease. Yea, the avg is a concern, but I think it will settle .270-.290, he can be a solid .340-.360 OBP guy. Which is probably about 120-150 points higher then what any CF in the Marlins organization would do. I'd still move Johnson 1-1 for him, or Nolasco, or Gaby. I agree with you to hold onto the top tier - Vargas, Olsen, Anibal, and Petit, unless Tampa wants to float Elijiah. I would have traded Vargas quickly for Gathwright. I'm much higher on Olsen because I think he can be a front-line starter. Not Vargas. Gathwright is the only guy mentioned is this thread as a trade option that I would take. I think that with Ty Wigginton hitting so well, maybe Tampa would be more willing to part with their 5th outfielder in an OF prospect rich-system for pitching.
April 24, 200620 yr Lou, as I've asked you before, what evidence do you have to suggest that stolen bases have the value you say and how do you reconcile that with the many articles I know that both you and I are familiar with through our readings of Baseball Prospectus and other studies? Not a typo. A mistake. The proper measurement of a baseball play in run expectancy is its beginning situation plus any runs scored minus its resulting situation. The result is 1, not .677. 4 solo homers equal 4 runs. (BTW, I used the average of each out situation. This depresses the expected run value a bit, as a true average would include slightly more 0 out opportunities than with 1 out and then more than with 2 out. Thus slightly overstating the impact of positive events and understating the negative.)
April 24, 200620 yr Don't get me wrong guys...Gathright could play CF for us...I am just really turned-off with the original Scott Olsen trade talk which clearly was aan overestimation of value on the D-Rays behalf. I still believe We are better off waiting on Campusano to be ready meanwhile Koolaid can man the job. Koolaid is a better defensive player who has pop in the bat (493 ft of pop) We also should be getting a pretty snazzy CF prospect in this upcoming June Draft...If a good trade does comeup I am sure Beinfest will take advantage of it...lets just not force anything right now
April 25, 200620 yr I'm stalking you because I keep posting in ONE of your threads that's on the forum I visit the most on this messageboard? By the way, Mike Maroth is leading the majors with a 0.49 ERA in 18.1 IP. Sustainable??? awww, at least you're honest. I'm straight though bro, sorry. Not only are you now stalking me, but also twisting my words, and purposefully ignoring the post directly above. Here, I'll copy paste it for you... You didn't post an opinion you f***ing moron. You basically claimed that I said the small sample sizes I included (ALONG WITH THEIR CAREER STATISTICS) were "really meaningful," which I didn't. It's basically moot anyway, since Ross was traded and Borchard is crap. Now will you please get off my sac? I suggest a name change to "Stalker Sid," maybe? So, in other words (the above was in plain English, but I'll try again) I recognize that the numbers I posted represented small sample sizes, that they weren't even close to sustainable, but that they were pieces of information that might be asked for later in the thread...so I included them. I know you're thick, but does this compute? Can a mod please close this now that the thread is irrelevant (ross traded). This is gettin good
April 25, 200620 yr Lou, as I've asked you before, what evidence do you have to suggest that stolen bases have the value you say and how do you reconcile that with the many articles I know that both you and I are familiar with through our readings of Baseball Prospectus and other studies? Not a typo. A mistake. The proper measurement of a baseball play in run expectancy is its beginning situation plus any runs scored minus its resulting situation. The result is 1, not .677. 4 solo homers equal 4 runs. (BTW, I used the average of each out situation. This depresses the expected run value a bit, as a true average would include slightly more 0 out opportunities than with 1 out and then more than with 2 out. Thus slightly overstating the impact of positive events and understating the negative.) I'm not saying he magically transforms into Ricky Henderson because of the steals, but 55/20 SB are going to create more then 4 runs above normal. I'm sure you can bust out a run expectancy analysis, and I know I can find one on BP that completely contradicts my interest for 50+ SB at a 70%+ clip, but that still doesn't mean they are correct at a game that is completely random as baseball. BP will be the first to admit that sabermetrics is an imperfect analysis and it's sheer chaos on a situational level. You can do a pretty good job of figuring out base levels of production, but there are still a lot of unquantifiable aspects to the game, and speed is certainly one of them. You know I can go rambling into situations so I'll stop, but I cannot fathom moving into scoring position 50+ times, at the expense of creating 20 outs, while just being fast as holy hell on the base paths while disrupting the pitcher only produces a net gain of 4 runs. If this is a cop out, sorry. I just can't see it. I do agree with you for the most part that SB are over valued on the market, i.e. Moneyball, but when a guy is stealing a huge quantity at a fantastic clip, it's worthy of note versus someone like uggla or jacobs who will do a 15/6 SB this year or whatever. The percentage might be similar, but the quantity is a distinct advantage. If Gathright had a .310 OBP with the steals, I wouldn't like him (Reyes). If he was a .350 OBP, with 40/20 SB, I wouldn't want him stealing at all and I'd just take the OBP. But if he's going to be a .350 guy, the SB production is going to help out his slugging (TB) a lot, while giving up an acceptable amount of outs. Plus, the Marlins are in the national league where run production is more then station to station. I think it's really hard to statistically argue speed, as in going 1st to 3rd, scoring from 1st on a double, situationally creating runs from stealing 2nd-moving to 3rd on a grounder to the right side, etc. I'm guessing you aren't a huge fan of Pierre (03/04) or Posednik (05). The real question is, whose going to produce more runs. Let's assume defense is league average for both, dude B does not steal, and Gathright negates all doubles and triples from a normal hitter on a TB scale (which is pretty fair), so they only differance in overall offense, is HR production. Dude A - .340 OBP, 55/20 SB Dude B - .340 OBP, 5 HR or 10 HR or 15 HR or 20 HR I'm guessing you're under the belief that all things equal, 10 HR are worth more then all the SB. Maybe even 5. I think it's going to take a good 15+ bombs to flat out outproduce that SB/speed. I think that's a pretty fair level of offensive production needed to start outproducing the Pierre/Posedniks of the world. I have no problems with the Marlins actively pursuing a Ryan Church, or a future Granderson (Elijiah Dukes), or better (Chris Young, BJ Upton), but I'm pretty sure you agree Gathright is a tremendous upgrade for the Marlins with or without the SB, because none of the dudes we have are going to break .300 OBP, and that's really my overall interest with Gathright. He is an avaliable longterm option that could help us tremendously, even if he is not going to be an allstar level player. I've said Olsen is to much unless Gathright is going to really be a OBP whore (.375+) or Tampa throws in another player, but in a rational world, I can't see them not taking Johnson, and he is totally expendable from our organization. We have 0 hope in the minors for a future starting calibre CF, it's silly to think we can just magically draft one that will pan out and be ready to start come 2008. If we want to go nuts and grab one of the guys in the parenthesis above, it's going to cost one of the tier one starters versus one of the 2nd tier guys, and I want to keep the Willis/Olsen/Vargas/Anibal/Petit together. That's really Gathright in a nutshell to me.
April 25, 200620 yr I've said Olsen is to much unless Gathright is going to really be a OBP whore (.375+) or Tampa throws in another player Curious but what other player would Tampa Bay have to add for you to be okay with trading Olsen? We have 0 hope in the minors for a future starting calibre CF Not that I am a big believer but I have some hope Jose Campusano can be our future CF. Campusano currently has 11 SB(caught twice) and is hitting .390 (through 59 at-bats)
April 25, 200620 yr Hmmmm, anything to address the bullpen would be applauded by me. Especially after tonight's meltdown, but it's prolly never gonna happen -- at least this year.
April 25, 200620 yr I've said Olsen is to much unless Gathright is going to really be a OBP whore (.375+) or Tampa throws in another player Curious but what other player would Tampa Bay have to add for you to be okay with trading Olsen? Not that I am a big believer but I have some hope Jose Campusano can be our future CF. Campusano currently has 11 SB(caught twice) and is hitting .390 (through 59 at-bats) I have no idea because I hate wild speculation despite the fact I always post about it (ha), but if they want to throw a Gathright/Tiffany or W. Davis for Olsen, don't you have to take that offer very seriously? Hammel, Edwin, Niemann, etc are probably all off limits, but maybe they can pick off one of the single A guys with potential. I'm not familiar with the DRays low level bats, but I can't imagine them trading us any sort of infield prospect or catcher because they are going to need those guys to fill holes in a year or two when they realize BJ Upton is as much of a shortstop as Gary Sheffield. I still don't know why Dukes has never really been floated by baseball sources. And more importantly now, Dontrelle gets the Marlins whatever they want. If they are really going to be crazy and trade him, needless trade speculation for Gathright and Church types need not occur because I'm 100% confident if they go down that road, we will get a young stud CF back. I'm guessing the Rays would listen for Upton and Arizona for one of their guys. And that dramatically fixes our CF situation, even if we lose the ace. So much for not mentioning wild trade speculation, let's say they did actually grab David Wright, then immediatly flipped him to the Drays for a package around Upton and young arms. That makes a lot of sense for the DRays, because it makes their offense basically invincible with Huff, Lugo, and probably another OF to still trade for pitching. Anyways, maybe this is what the organization is thinking, as in trading Dontrelle, getting the motherload back, and just praying all the young starters pan out. It would be pretty ballsy, but if it worked, it would payout huge. I'm not to excited on Campusano. I like De Aza best of all the CF guys, but he's struggling out of the gate right now. Hopefully it's just a level adjustment and he performs like 2005 again. He's my # 1 offensive sleeper among all the 'not highly regarded' Marlins hitting prospects.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.