July 23, 200620 yr They are both inconsistent but I'd rather have Beckett in the future. Inconsistent relative to Nolan Ryan and Roger Clemens? You do realize that by your standard there probably are 2 or 3 consistent pitchers in the big leagues? And by your standard, any pitcher who finds a way to win 10 games is "GREAT!"
July 23, 200620 yr Author They are both inconsistent but I'd rather have Beckett in the future. Inconsistent relative to Nolan Ryan and Roger Clemens? You do realize that by your standard there probably are 2 or 3 consistent pitchers in the big leagues? Ask Red Sox fans if Beckett is consistent....then go look at his game logs..... They are both inconsistent but I'd rather have Beckett in the future. Inconsistent relative to Nolan Ryan and Roger Clemens? You do realize that by your standard there probably are 2 or 3 consistent pitchers in the big leagues? Beckett has allowed.............. 0 ERs in 2 starts 1 ER in 4 starts 2 ERs in 3 starts 3 ERs in 4 starts 4 ERs in 1 start 5 ERs in 2 starts 6 ERs in 0 starts 7 ERs in 3 starts 8 ERs in 1 start I don't find that consistent especially when in 7 starts he allowed 0 homers. But in 5 starts he's allowed 3 or MORE homers!
July 23, 200620 yr I'd rather send out a package of young pitching to get a CF'er than trade Willis. These kids may turn out to be as good as Willis but not a single one of them has the heart, emotion and love of the game like Dontrelle. His attitude is always a positive influence to the club. He's loyal and wants to be here. He's only 24, he has allot of years left. It would be crazy to let go of a player like that.
July 23, 200620 yr Author I'd rather send out a package of young pitching to get a CF'er than trade Willis. These kids may turn out to be as good as Willis but not a single one of them has the heart, emotion and love of the game like Dontrelle. His attitude is always a positive influence to the club. He's loyal and wants to be here. He's only 24, he has allot of years left. It would be crazy to let go of a player like that. Well if you believe the Marlins are going to keep him then thats crazy! They are already talking trade...whether its now, the offseason, or a couple years from now......I think he's as good as gone. I'd rather sell high....
July 23, 200620 yr A lot of you guys are nuts. It is so much easier to get a solid CF than it is to get a stud like Dontrelle. Dontrelle is so underappreciated here, it's ridiculous. This is like Derrek Lee all over again. None of you have any idea how these guys in our rotation right now are going to pan out long term. Vargas had a pretty good season last year--his ERA was the same as Olsen's, and better than Nolasco's. He's crap right now. He might have a good career, he might not. Same goes for all these guys, Johnson included. And even if they all pan out, which is unlikely at the very least, the chances that even one of them will match Willis is pretty slim. How many guys are going to challenge for a Cy Young at 23? Dontrelle has put up pretty good numbers every year in the majors. He's a proven commodity. Why is he going to get worse? Why is he going to get injured? Where are you guys getting this stuff from? He's missed like 2 starts in his entire career.
July 23, 200620 yr You're clearly biased and most likely trying to make an argument to ruffle feathers. Look at the numbers again. One pitcher has improved every year while making more starts than he has in his previous season. Oh I see, so Beckett actually gets credit under this scenario for being injury prone.....nice work. Dontrelle is a workhorse, but because he has been from day one it appears he has topped out without much room for improvement. Very nice analysis....... Another pitcher hovers around the same number of starts yet fluctuates greatly on his win totals, ERA and WHIP. Again penalizing Willis for not being fragile, and the "fluctuates greatly" bit seems to penalize him for winning 22 games. Put him side by side from '03 to '05 and you'll see that pitching on the same team, Willis had more wins than Beckett each year. How exactly is that a bad thing? Willis cannot hold a candle to Beckett in terms of stuff, ability or pitching ability. Now here's your only valid point, but again you can't help but overstate it. Yes Beckett has better stuff and ability, but not "pitching ability." There are a lot of guys with great stuff that never amount to much, so at some point (I would think 6 years is a pretty good sample size) you have to recognize that Beckett may not be capable of taking that "stuff" and ability and using it to make himself a great pitcher. Dontrelle, on the other hand, has less talent, but he has proven every year save for '04 that he is a star. Unlike Beckett he knows how to pitch, he energizes his team, and he is out there every 5th day. Beckett's made 30 starts twice and in both cases he will win more games than he loses. Willis has made 30 starts 3 times, and in 2 of those three cases, he will lose more games than he wins. Why totally disregard the other 4 years in which Beckett is merely hovering around .500? Because he was injury prone? And nice job pencilling Willis in for a losing season this year. Very studious of you. Clearly, the extreme winning season of 2005 is an aberration as Scott Olsen, Josh Johnson, Ricky Nolasco and Anibal Sanchez have proven that it's possible to have a winning record as a starter for the 2006 Florida Marlins, yet Dontrelle is late to the party. Because if Beckett was on this team, he would show these guys how to pitch.........with his close to 5 ERA. I'd say nice try on your part, but that would convey an understanding that your position made a reasonable degree of sense. Very elementary of you. Sorry I had to point out that your arguments are illogical..... They are both inconsistent but I'd rather have Beckett in the future. Inconsistent relative to Nolan Ryan and Roger Clemens? You do realize that by your standard there probably are 2 or 3 consistent pitchers in the big leagues? And by your standard, any pitcher who finds a way to win 10 games is "GREAT!" Thanks for putting words in my mouth.....again sorry for showing how illogical your stance is.
July 23, 200620 yr I'd trade Cabrera before trading Willis. I'd love to see him on the team for another 5 years. :lol
July 23, 200620 yr Last time I'm going to say this, so clean your eyes and read along, in your case, I'd recommend reading as slowly as possible so perhaps you can comprehend some of the intracacies of this. Beckett, for all the talk of his AWFUL season HAS A LOWER WHIP THAN DONTRELLE WILLIS IN 2006! According to any stat head you listen to, or any person with a goddamn brain in their head, the most important area in evaluating a pitcher is how many baserunners he allows. Thus, WHIP is ARGUABLY THE SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT STAT WHEN EVALUATING PITCHERS. Beckett is not only beating Willis silly this season, but also for their career totals. Beckett has improved his number of starts each season, Willis has always made his starts. When Beckett makes more starts, he wins more games. When Willis makes his season's worth of starts, Willis is more likely to lose 10 or more games than win more than 10 games. Hence, my statement of: The problem with Beckett was never inconsistency, it was health. The problem with Willis is inconsistency. There's a big difference and why I felt one was emminently more untouchable than the other (and, in case you're wondering, I think we picked the wrong pony). :thumbup Now, maybe, just maybe you'll get it, probably not, but if pitcher A will win around 18 games with a WHIP of 1.20 whenever he makes 30 starts and pitcher B is a guarantee for 10 losses in any season in which he makes 30 starts, you're going to take pitcher A 10 times out of 10. Or, monosyllobically for you. A will lose 10 in any full year. B will win 15 in any full year.
July 23, 200620 yr Author A lot of you guys are nuts. It is so much easier to get a solid CF than it is to get a stud like Dontrelle. Dontrelle is so underappreciated here, it's ridiculous. This is like Derrek Lee all over again. None of you have any idea how these guys in our rotation right now are going to pan out long term. Vargas had a pretty good season last year--his ERA was the same as Olsen's, and better than Nolasco's. He's crap right now. He might have a good career, he might not. Same goes for all these guys, Johnson included. And even if they all pan out, which is unlikely at the very least, the chances that even one of them will match Willis is pretty slim. How many guys are going to challenge for a Cy Young at 23? Dontrelle has put up pretty good numbers every year in the majors. He's a proven commodity. Why is he going to get worse? Why is he going to get injured? Where are you guys getting this stuff from? He's missed like 2 starts in his entire career. It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe?
July 23, 200620 yr They are both inconsistent but I'd rather have Beckett in the future. Inconsistent relative to Nolan Ryan and Roger Clemens? You do realize that by your standard there probably are 2 or 3 consistent pitchers in the big leagues? And by your standard, any pitcher who finds a way to win 10 games is "GREAT!" Thanks for putting words in my mouth.....again sorry for showing how illogical your stance is. Dontrelle has been consistently good, if not great. Yup, put words in your mouth. :whistle
July 23, 200620 yr Author Last time I'm going to say this, so clean your eyes and read along, in your case, I'd recommend reading as slowly as possible so perhaps you can comprehend some of the intracacies of this. Beckett, for all the talk of his AWFUL season HAS A LOWER WHIP THAN DONTRELLE WILLIS IN 2006! According to any stat head you listen to, or any person with a goddamn brain in their head, the most important area in evaluating a pitcher is how many baserunners he allows. Thus, WHIP is ARGUABLY THE SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT STAT WHEN EVALUATING PITCHERS. Beckett is not only beating Willis silly this season, but also for their career totals. Beckett has improved his number of starts each season, Willis has always made his starts. When Beckett makes more starts, he wins more games. When Willis makes his season's worth of starts, Willis is more likely to lose 10 or more games than win more than 10 games. Hence, my statement of: The problem with Beckett was never inconsistency, it was health. The problem with Willis is inconsistency. There's a big difference and why I felt one was emminently more untouchable than the other (and, in case you're wondering, I think we picked the wrong pony). :thumbup Now, maybe, just maybe you'll get it, probably not, but if pitcher A will win around 18 games with a WHIP of 1.20 whenever he makes 30 starts and pitcher B is a guarantee for 10 losses in any season in which he makes 30 starts, you're going to take pitcher A 10 times out of 10. Or, monosyllobically for you. A will lose 10 in any full year. B will win 15 in any full year. I agree.... :thumbup
July 23, 200620 yr It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Getting a little crazy there man.
July 23, 200620 yr Author It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Getting a little crazy there man. Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team. Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter). What can these guys do on a good team? Some of you don't understand how good these guys are.....
July 23, 200620 yr It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Getting a little crazy there man. Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team. Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter). What can these guys do on a good team? Some of you don't understand how good these guys are..... Concept of a small sample size escapes you, eh? They're all good, very good in fact, but basing future Cy Young awards based on less than a full season of work (and in the case of Anibal, about a month's worth) is the apex of foolishness.
July 23, 200620 yr It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Would you trade Verlander or Liriano for one of those CFs you listed?
July 23, 200620 yr While recognizing that I am still relatively new to this board, I have yet to get this incensed by any discussions on this site. Why on earth should we be LOOKING to trade Dontrelle. I agree that no player should ever be untradeable. Theoretically, there is a good enough package to trade anybody. Does everyone even realize what we have in Dontrelle? A pitcher who has proven that on any given night he has complete game,shutout potential. A pitcher who has shown he is good for 200+ innings every year. A pitcher who has not had one hint of an injury as a major leaguer. A pitcher who is nothing but positive and a great teamate (hooray intangibles!). He came on as a rookie and was absolutely instrumental in helping this team win the World Series. His "horrible" 2nd year was in reality perfectly acceptable for a young pitcher. His 3d year he put together as fine a season as any non-surfire Hall of Famer has put up in the last 20 years-sub 3 era, 22 wins, countless complete games, 220+ innings etc. How many cities and fans have been dying to produce a young pitcher with these kinds of credentials? Franchises literally wait 20+ years to develop a player like this. And he happens to be a great guy- doesn't mean that much but it sure beats a prick like Randy Johnson or Roger Clemens. Why wouldn't we possibly be looking to trade 1, 2, or 3 or our youngsters if it gave us the superstar CF,C, and/or LF this team needs to make us complete top to bottom? I would rather eventually see Dontrelle leave and get compensation draft picks then see us actively look to trade him (i think i believe that). Dontrelle is a proven commodity. There is no logical reason to think he is about to "fall off" or somehow is more susceptible to injury then young pitchers who have never thrown 200+ innings. Short of something like Stephen Drew, Chris Young, and Carlos Quentin I have no interest. We have more than enough ammunition to acquire the 1 or 2 offensive players we need without trading Dontrelle. This guy is a franchise icon who can and should be a top of the line starter for the next 10+ years. And players like that are extremely rare. Let's not f' up a good thing. I'm so pissed i can barely muster up a decent "Whammy!"
July 23, 200620 yr Author It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Getting a little crazy there man. Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team. Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter). What can these guys do on a good team? Some of you don't understand how good these guys are..... Concept of a small sample size escapes you, eh? They're all good, very good in fact, but basing future Cy Young awards based on less than a full season of work (and in the case of Anibal, about a month's worth) is the apex of foolishness. obviously....but this whole thread is about TALENT and these guys have just as much if not more talent and potential than Dontrelle. It's as simple as economics supply and demand....we have a surplus of young arms and we demand some more hitting.....so lets go get it! While recognizing that I am still relatively new to this board, I have yet to get this incensed by any discussions on this site. Why on earth should we be LOOKING to trade Dontrelle. I agree that no player should ever be untradeable. Theoretically, there is a good enough package to trade anybody. Does everyone even realize what we have in Dontrelle? A pitcher who has proven that on any given night he has complete game,shutout potential. A pitcher who has shown he is good for 200+ innings every year. A pitcher who has not had one hint of an injury as a major leaguer. A pitcher who is nothing but positive and a great teamate (hooray intangibles!). He came on as a rookie and was absolutely instrumental in helping this team win the World Series. His "horrible" 2nd year was in reality perfectly acceptable for a young pitcher. His 3d year he put together as fine a season as any non-surfire Hall of Famer has put up in the last 20 years-sub 3 era, 22 wins, countless complete games, 220+ innings etc. How many cities and fans have been dying to produce a young pitcher with these kinds of credentials? Franchises literally wait 20+ years to develop a player like this. And he happens to be a great guy- doesn't mean that much but it sure beats a prick like Randy Johnson or Roger Clemens. Why wouldn't we possibly be looking to trade 1, 2, or 3 or our youngsters if it gave us the superstar CF,C, and/or LF this team needs to make us complete top to bottom? I would rather eventually see Dontrelle leave and get compensation draft picks then see us actively look to trade him (i think i believe that). Dontrelle is a proven commodity. There is no logical reason to think he is about to "fall off" or somehow is more susceptible to injury then young pitchers who have never thrown 200+ innings. Short of something like Stephen Drew, Chris Young, and Carlos Quentin I have no interest. We have more than enough ammunition to acquire the 1 or 2 offensive players we need without trading Dontrelle. This guy is a franchise icon who can and should be a top of the line starter for the next 10+ years. And players like that are extremely rare. Let's not f' up a good thing. I'm so pissed i can barely muster up a decent "Whammy!" good post BUT if you'd would rather Dontrelle leave and get comp. picks instead of looking to trade him then I can't help you.... Drew, Young, and Quentin? I'd take 2 of them. I love Dontrelle man. I only have 2 jerseys from this years team (D-Train and Cabs) but baseball is a business and I think we can be a better team by trading him for "A+" prospects who are ready now!
July 23, 200620 yr While recognizing that I am still relatively new to this board, I have yet to get this incensed by any discussions on this site. Why on earth should we be LOOKING to trade Dontrelle. I agree that no player should ever be untradeable. Theoretically, there is a good enough package to trade anybody. Does everyone even realize what we have in Dontrelle? A pitcher who has proven that on any given night he has complete game,shutout potential. A pitcher who has shown he is good for 200+ innings every year. A pitcher who has not had one hint of an injury as a major leaguer. A pitcher who is nothing but positive and a great teamate (hooray intangibles!). He came on as a rookie and was absolutely instrumental in helping this team win the World Series. His "horrible" 2nd year was in reality perfectly acceptable for a young pitcher. His 3d year he put together as fine a season as any non-surfire Hall of Famer has put up in the last 20 years-sub 3 era, 22 wins, countless complete games, 220+ innings etc. How many cities and fans have been dying to produce a young pitcher with these kinds of credentials? Franchises literally wait 20+ years to develop a player like this. And he happens to be a great guy- doesn't mean that much but it sure beats a prick like Randy Johnson or Roger Clemens. Why wouldn't we possibly be looking to trade 1, 2, or 3 or our youngsters if it gave us the superstar CF,C, and/or LF this team needs to make us complete top to bottom? I would rather eventually see Dontrelle leave and get compensation draft picks then see us actively look to trade him (i think i believe that). Dontrelle is a proven commodity. There is no logical reason to think he is about to "fall off" or somehow is more susceptible to injury then young pitchers who have never thrown 200+ innings. Short of something like Stephen Drew, Chris Young, and Carlos Quentin I have no interest. We have more than enough ammunition to acquire the 1 or 2 offensive players we need without trading Dontrelle. This guy is a franchise icon who can and should be a top of the line starter for the next 10+ years. And players like that are extremely rare. Let's not f' up a good thing. I'm so pissed i can barely muster up a decent "Whammy!" In no way am I advocating trading him. I'd let teams have their pick of the farm to fill centerfield, but at some point, Dontrelle will be making more than he's worth. It'd be irresponsible of the Marlins to not inquire. My stance was more aimed at the actions of the last offseason, and if we were to have neither Beckett nor Willis going forward, we misplayed the trades terribly as Willis tied to Lowell would have gotten us more in return than we already received.
July 23, 200620 yr Last time I'm going to say this, so clean your eyes and read along, in your case, I'd recommend reading as slowly as possible so perhaps you can comprehend some of the intracacies of this. Beckett, for all the talk of his AWFUL season HAS A LOWER WHIP THAN DONTRELLE WILLIS IN 2006! According to any stat head you listen to, or any person with a goddamn brain in their head, the most important area in evaluating a pitcher is how many baserunners he allows. Thus, WHIP is ARGUABLY THE SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT STAT WHEN EVALUATING PITCHERS. Beckett is not only beating Willis silly this season, but also for their career totals. Beckett has improved his number of starts each season, Willis has always made his starts. When Beckett makes more starts, he wins more games. When Willis makes his season's worth of starts, Willis is more likely to lose 10 or more games than win more than 10 games. Again, very intimidating of you to talk down to me. You are doing wonders for your side by acting like a child. Chew on this.... WHIP is a statitiscal measure used for predicting the future NOT for evaluating the past. It matters not how many baserunners you allowed, but how many runners you allowed to cross home plate. Saying that Beckett is a superior pitcher because his whip is (marginally) lower throughout his career ignores the "clutch" aspect of pitching. The goal, again, is to keep runners from crossing home - not to keep them off base. If Willis allows more baserunners but allows less of them to score, then you can make the case that he is either more clutch or that he has been lucky and the numbers will eventually even out. After 4 years sample size, it's safe to assume that Willis is more clutch than Beckett and can achieve lower ERA's while allowing more baserunners. You can't really believe that, by using whip, you are making a case that Beckett is having a better season than Willis this year or in the past? You, like many, are taking a relevant statistic and trying to use it for something it was never meant for. If you wanna make the case that his lower WHIP shows that he will be the better pitcher in the long run, that's a valid argument. I woul counter that the sample sizes are large enough to assume Willis is simply better at escaping jams, but it's still a fair argument. What's not fair is to say that because pitcher A had a lower whip, he had the better season. If first base were home plate then that would be true, but obviously it's not so it's a fallacious argument. The problem with Beckett was never inconsistency, it was health. Now, maybe, just maybe you'll get it, probably not, but if pitcher A will win around 18 games with a WHIP of 1.20 whenever he makes 30 starts and pitcher B is a guarantee for 10 losses in any season in which he makes 30 starts, you're going to take pitcher A 10 times out of 10. Or, monosyllobically for you. A will lose 10 in any full year. B will win 15 in any full year. Again, you break your back to give Beckett every benefit of the doubt. 1) B has shown he can't stay healthy for a full year, so it's dishonest to evaluate A and B on a full season when one has consistently shown he can last a year, and the other has shown he can't. It's an attempt by you to skew the statistics and overlook a strength of Willis and a weakness of Beckett. 2) Willis has pitched almost 3 full seasons, only one of which he lost 10 games. Very fallacious to say he is "gauranteed" to lose 10 games every year, or for that matter, that Beckett is gauranteed to win 15 when, in fact, he has never won 15.
July 23, 200620 yr Author While recognizing that I am still relatively new to this board, I have yet to get this incensed by any discussions on this site. Why on earth should we be LOOKING to trade Dontrelle. I agree that no player should ever be untradeable. Theoretically, there is a good enough package to trade anybody. Does everyone even realize what we have in Dontrelle? A pitcher who has proven that on any given night he has complete game,shutout potential. A pitcher who has shown he is good for 200+ innings every year. A pitcher who has not had one hint of an injury as a major leaguer. A pitcher who is nothing but positive and a great teamate (hooray intangibles!). He came on as a rookie and was absolutely instrumental in helping this team win the World Series. His "horrible" 2nd year was in reality perfectly acceptable for a young pitcher. His 3d year he put together as fine a season as any non-surfire Hall of Famer has put up in the last 20 years-sub 3 era, 22 wins, countless complete games, 220+ innings etc. How many cities and fans have been dying to produce a young pitcher with these kinds of credentials? Franchises literally wait 20+ years to develop a player like this. And he happens to be a great guy- doesn't mean that much but it sure beats a prick like Randy Johnson or Roger Clemens. Why wouldn't we possibly be looking to trade 1, 2, or 3 or our youngsters if it gave us the superstar CF,C, and/or LF this team needs to make us complete top to bottom? I would rather eventually see Dontrelle leave and get compensation draft picks then see us actively look to trade him (i think i believe that). Dontrelle is a proven commodity. There is no logical reason to think he is about to "fall off" or somehow is more susceptible to injury then young pitchers who have never thrown 200+ innings. Short of something like Stephen Drew, Chris Young, and Carlos Quentin I have no interest. We have more than enough ammunition to acquire the 1 or 2 offensive players we need without trading Dontrelle. This guy is a franchise icon who can and should be a top of the line starter for the next 10+ years. And players like that are extremely rare. Let's not f' up a good thing. I'm so pissed i can barely muster up a decent "Whammy!" In no way am I advocating trading him. I'd let teams have their pick of the farm to fill centerfield, but at some point, Dontrelle will be making more than he's worth. It'd be irresponsible of the Marlins to not inquire. My stance was more aimed at the actions of the last offseason, and if we were to have neither Beckett nor Willis going forward, we misplayed the trades terribly as Willis tied to Lowell would have gotten us more in return than we already received. We didn't misplay anything....Hanley and Sanchez are future all stars for years to come.
July 23, 200620 yr 2) Willis has pitched almost 3 full seasons, only one of which he lost 10 games. Very fallacious to say he is "gauranteed" to lose 10 games every year, or for that matter, that Beckett is gauranteed to win 15 when, in fact, he has never won 15. You sure? Dontrelle: 2004: 10-11 2005: 22-10 Beckett: 2005: 15-8 :lol :lol :lol :lol :whistle :thumbup Seriously, you're retarded.
July 23, 200620 yr Yup, put words in your mouth. :whistle Yeah because Dontrelle = "any pitcher who manages to win 10 games" Nice work again.
July 23, 200620 yr It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Getting a little crazy there man. Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team. Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter). What can these guys do on a good team? Some of you don't understand how good these guys are..... Is UCF such a meh school that you have nothing better to do than sit in front of a computer spouting your nonsense? Seriously, I'd like to know, as my son got accepted into UCF and UF and he's undecided. . . Anibel Sanchez has looked good, but he's pitched a handful of games. You have him as a possible Cy Young candidate in the future. I guess by those sandards Vargas would have been considered a possible Cy Young winner after his first few starts in the bigs last year. Maybe they'll both win it one day, but it's nuts to talk about such things based on less than 100 innings pitching in MLB. . . Anyone who proposes trading Willis is just too young and/or has no prespective of MLB history. A player with the talent, heart, charisma, hustle, fun to watch, personality, humbleness, etc., like Willis.....these kind of players come around once every 50 years. You just do not trade them. Consider yourself lucky that he's on your team. Period.
July 23, 200620 yr A lot of you guys are nuts. It is so much easier to get a solid CF than it is to get a stud like Dontrelle. Dontrelle is so underappreciated here, it's ridiculous. This is like Derrek Lee all over again. None of you have any idea how these guys in our rotation right now are going to pan out long term. Vargas had a pretty good season last year--his ERA was the same as Olsen's, and better than Nolasco's. He's crap right now. He might have a good career, he might not. Same goes for all these guys, Johnson included. And even if they all pan out, which is unlikely at the very least, the chances that even one of them will match Willis is pretty slim. How many guys are going to challenge for a Cy Young at 23? Dontrelle has put up pretty good numbers every year in the majors. He's a proven commodity. Why is he going to get worse? Why is he going to get injured? Where are you guys getting this stuff from? He's missed like 2 starts in his entire career. I agree the thread is pretty crazy, but I don't agree with not moving Dontrelle. Yes, he is extremely valuable, but I personally have a lot of confidence in our rotation rookies to keep this up, and the Fab 5 (West, Thompson, Volstad, Gaby, J. Garcia) down in the minors to make a tremendous impact around 08/09 (when we'll be a serious contender). I can understand your hesitancy in moving our only 'proven commodity" but I think you'd be singing a very different tune if the Diamondbacks go crazy and offer a Chris Young/Carlos Gonzalez/Miguel Montero package, or the Dodgers do something like Guzman/Kemp/Billingsly. Our lineup would be flat out ridiculous in a season or two. I'm talking 200+ HR as a team, every regular over .350+ OBP crazy, and we'd still have an absolutely explosive pitching staff. We won't be able to get those high ceiling type players with moving Sean West and Gaby Hernandez. Believe in the farm system. All these pitchers are for real. Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team. Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter). What can these guys do on a good team? Some of you don't understand how good these guys are..... Are you really kidding comparing those two to Liriano and Verlander? WHIP Johnson 1.28 Anibal 1.24 Liriano .95 Verlander 1.15 I think that says it all. JJ and Anibal are great looking young pitchers, but let's not get crazy here. We also have a better pitching park then those clubs (or very comparable) and play in the NL versus the AL. It's not even close despite how good JJ and Anibal have looked this season. Let's not go overboard.
July 23, 200620 yr Author It is not easier to get a solid CF than D-Train. I'm talking all star calibar....then we could have all stars in Uggla, Cabrera, CF, Hanley,and maybe Hermida for the future! How many will challenge for the Cy Young at 23? Let's see....Verlander, Liriano, Josh Johnson, A.Sanchez maybe? Getting a little crazy there man. Johnson has a 2.49 at age 22 on a bad team. Sanchez has a 3.41 ERA at age 22 on a bad team (his era is only 1.41 as a starter). What can these guys do on a good team? Some of you don't understand how good these guys are..... Is UCF such a meh school that you have nothing better to do than sit in front of a computer spouting your nonsense? Seriously, I'd like to know, as my son got accepted into UCF and UF and he's undecided. . . Anibel Sanchez has looked good, but he's pitched a handful of games. You have him as a possible Cy Young candidate in the future. I guess by those sandards Vargas would have been considered a possible Cy Young winner after his first few starts in the bigs last year. Maybe they'll both win it one day, but it's nuts to talk about such things based on less than 100 innings pitching in MLB. . . Anyone who proposes trading Willis is just too young and/or has no prespective of MLB history. A player with the talent, heart, charisma, hustle, fun to watch, personality, humbleness, etc., like Willis.....these kind of players come around once every 50 years. You just do not trade them. Consider yourself lucky that he's on your team. Period. Now you're making fun of UCF because you don't agree with someone....hey whatever makes you feel better. When we do trade Willis for players who will make our team even better....then I'll come talk to you.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.