Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Trade Willis!?

Featured Replies

I understand that I will be blasted for this.....

 

Anyway, we already have a good young pitching staff and something tells me Dontrelle will not ever have another season like he did last year. Don't get me wrong, I think he's a great young pitcher but I think he's already topped out. I know he is the face of the franchise but what happens if he gets worse every year or worst case he gets injured with that funky delivery?

 

I believe his trade value is at an all time high and we should move him now. Again, I will be blasted for this but I want a STUD CF and some other pitching prospects. The only way to get a young All-star level CF would be to trade Willis.

 

I would make D-Train available to the highest bidder....but maybe thats just me.

 

Beckett, AJ, Sheffield, Etc.....the list goes on and on....we will survive without him and I believe we COULD be a better team if we deal him for the right trade.

 

Would Milledge and Pelfrey make us a better team? I think it just might over the long haul.......

 

whats your take?

I wouldnt send him to the mets

 

but arizona or LAD or Tampa Bay could give us an offer we might have to consider.

 

If we could get something like a Crawford or baldelli, or get something like a upton or young +quentin. It would be hard to say no

There's no reason to trade him just for the sake of trading him or even for financial reasons, but if you can get equal value and fill some organizational holes at the same time I'd say yes. His value was probably at its peak after last season, though, because he was coming off a Cy Young-caliber season and was cheaper heading into last offseason than he will be this offseason or any time in the future.

 

It is funny how these threads pop up whenever Willis doesn't have his best outings.

There isn't any indication that he is going to get worse as his career progresses, to trade him (or anyone) based on a hunch would be a horribe move. There isn't any evidence whatsoever that he has topped out.

I could understand trading him, but you can't trade him to the Mets.

 

For the next 2 years, the Mets are likely the top team in the division, but they're old and/or vulnerable at a lot of key positions, rotation, bullpen, first-base, catcher, and they have no answers immediately from within.

 

Do you really want to give the Mets the one thing they need more than anything else going forward? What good would that do us? Do you really want to help a team get better and younger when we'd both be targeting the same timetable for "winning."

 

This is totally different than the Delgado/LoDuca firesales.

 

And, honestly, I'd be so goddamn angry if we trade Willis now instead of tying him to Lowell this past offseason and keeping Beckett or shopping Beckett on his own. We would have been a much stronger team going forward if we were both willing to shop Willis and do those moves.

  • Author

There isn't any indication that he is going to get worse as his career progresses, to trade him (or anyone) based on a hunch would be a horribe move. There isn't any evidence whatsoever that he has topped out.

 

 

Well I trust whatever Beinfest does....I'm just saying that I truly believe we could be a better team by dealing him in we get the right players back.

 

Quentin, Chris Young, Milledge, Pelfrey, Rasmus, a lot of Dodger prospects...........

 

Honestly I would trade him to LA (because he's from Cali). No way would I trade him to a bad franchise like TB.

 

The Dodgers or Angels could give us some great guys.....

 

This isn't just a trade for the sake of trading....it is to improve our club. We are stacked at pitching and our lineup needs help....so lets go out and improve our lineup!

 

I could understand trading him, but you can't trade him to the Mets.

 

For the next 2 years, the Mets are likely the top team in the division, but they're old and/or vulnerable at a lot of key positions, rotation, bullpen, first-base, catcher, and they have no answers immediately from within.

 

Do you really want to give the Mets the one thing they need more than anything else going forward? What good would that do us? Do you really want to help a team get better and younger when we'd both be targeting the same timetable for "winning."

 

This is totally different than the Delgado/LoDuca firesales.

 

And, honestly, I'd be so goddamn angry if we trade Willis now instead of tying him to Lowell this past offseason and keeping Beckett or shopping Beckett on his own. We would have been a much stronger team going forward if we were both willing to shop Willis and do those moves.

 

 

 

I agree...I wouldn't want to face Willis for the next 10 years....I'd trade him to the Dodgers or Angels.

now one trade I would do is

 

willis + borowski + pitching spec for arod + cash

 

but that would never happen

now one trade I would do is

 

willis + borowski + pitching spec for arod + cash

 

but that would never happen

 

and move Hanley to CF?

 

anyway Im not against trading Willis if its for one of them real pretty packages

We're the luckiest team in MLB to have Willis. He's not the #1 best pitcher in MLB, but he exemplifies everything great about the game. His love of the game and his style of play(things that are great to see but also help the team) are things that come around once every 50 years. I'd trade Cabrera before trading Willis. I'd love to see him on the team for another 5 years.

now one trade I would do is

 

willis + borowski + pitching spec for arod + cash

 

but that would never happen

 

 

I'm not so sure the Yankees wouldn't do it since even the YES network analysts are ragging on ARod, so it's doubtful that's ever going to be a beneficial relationship for player and team, but I just can't see ARod (or Boras) approving a trade to Miami.

 

I'd trade Cabrera before trading Willis. I'd love to see him on the team for another 5 years.

 

 

:lol

 

On so many levels, one of the dumbest exchanges I've ever heard here.

 

5 whopping years?????

  • Author

We're the luckiest team in MLB to have Willis. He's not the #1 best pitcher in MLB, but he exemplifies everything great about the game. His love of the game and his style of play(things that are great to see but also help the team) are things that come around once every 50 years. I'd trade Cabrera before trading Willis. I'd love to see him on the team for another 5 years.

 

 

 

Moving Cabrera before Willis is a little crazy. I know he's great for sports but we are LOADED at pitcher. We have to do what's best to improve us for the future.

 

Everyone just automatically assumes that Willis will pitch for the next 15 years. I have news for you...there are no more Maddux's, Nolan Ryan's, or Clemen's around. Today's pitchers are much more injury prone (Prior, Wood, Burnett, Sheets). All of those guys get hurt and who knows about their future.

 

I say deal him for a great package while we still can!

Nolasco, Johnson, Olsen and Sanchez are not No.1 pitchers now and maybe not even in the near future. Dontrelle won 22 games last year because he had an experienced team behind him that could not only score runs (ironic considering how difficult it was for them at times last year :lol ) and a bullpen that shut down the opposing team almost every time he pitched. I think given the growth of this team in another year or two, we can see Dontrelle get back to winning 15-20 games in the very near future and they will have an anchor at the No. 1 rotation for years to come.

 

 

IMO, there is no reason to trade D-Train right now and vote to keep him on just to see how far he can carry this team on his own.

now one trade I would do is

 

willis + borowski + pitching spec for arod + cash

 

but that would never happen

 

and move Hanley to CF?

 

anyway Im not against trading Willis if its for one of them real pretty packages

 

yep, it would be pretty sweet to have and solves our CF problem too. He has the speed, arm and did some time in the minors at it.

 

It would give us that big bat. But shall see. I doubt the yanks would do it.

Nolasco, Johnson, Olsen and Sanchez are not No.1 pitchers now and maybe not even in the near future. Dontrelle won 22 games last year because he had an experienced team behind him that could not only score runs (ironic considering how difficult it was for them at times last year :lol ) and a bullpen that shut down the opposing team almost every time he pitched. I think given the growth of this team in another year or two, we can see Dontrelle get back to winning 15-20 games in the very near future and they will have an anchor at the No. 1 rotation for years to come.

 

 

IMO, there is no reason to trade D-Train right now and vote to keep him on just to see how far he can carry this team on his own.

 

 

A true ace does not need a good team behind him to win ballgames.

 

Johnson, Nolasco and Olsen all have more wins than Dontrelle in far fewer starts, and Sanchez is rapidly approaching Willis' win total in 1/5 of the starts Dontrelle has.

 

In no way am I saying wins is the definitive measuring stick for a starting pitcher, but you claimed that being a 15-20 game winner anchors the "ace" role. Anyone who believes that should look up Russ Ortiz and see how that's worked out for Arizona.

  • Author

Nolasco, Johnson, Olsen and Sanchez are not No.1 pitchers now and maybe not even in the near future. Dontrelle won 22 games last year because he had an experienced team behind him that could not only score runs (ironic considering how difficult it was for them at times last year :lol ) and a bullpen that shut down the opposing team almost every time he pitched. I think given the growth of this team in another year or two, we can see Dontrelle get back to winning 15-20 games in the very near future and they will have an anchor at the No. 1 rotation for years to come.

 

 

IMO, there is no reason to trade D-Train right now and vote to keep him on just to see how far he can carry this team on his own.

 

 

 

I believe Johnson, Olsen, Nolasco, and Sanchez have as much or even more talent than Dontrelle- I think you will see that in the future.

Nolasco, Johnson, Olsen and Sanchez are not No.1 pitchers now and maybe not even in the near future. Dontrelle won 22 games last year because he had an experienced team behind him that could not only score runs (ironic considering how difficult it was for them at times last year :lol ) and a bullpen that shut down the opposing team almost every time he pitched. I think given the growth of this team in another year or two, we can see Dontrelle get back to winning 15-20 games in the very near future and they will have an anchor at the No. 1 rotation for years to come.

 

 

IMO, there is no reason to trade D-Train right now and vote to keep him on just to see how far he can carry this team on his own.

 

Johnson, Olsen and Sanchez are No.1 pitchers

 

fixed

Nolasco, Johnson, Olsen and Sanchez are not No.1 pitchers now and maybe not even in the near future. Dontrelle won 22 games last year because he had an experienced team behind him that could not only score runs (ironic considering how difficult it was for them at times last year :lol ) and a bullpen that shut down the opposing team almost every time he pitched. I think given the growth of this team in another year or two, we can see Dontrelle get back to winning 15-20 games in the very near future and they will have an anchor at the No. 1 rotation for years to come.

 

 

IMO, there is no reason to trade D-Train right now and vote to keep him on just to see how far he can carry this team on his own.

 

 

 

I'm sure they do, we are just a few years away from seeing it. I think given another year or two under their belts, Nolasco and especially Johnson are going to be very dominant. Just got to give them the few years to get there.

 

 

I believe Johnson, Olsen, Nolasco, and Sanchez have as much or even more talent than Dontrelle- I think you will see that in the future.

I usually am not a fan of creating trade ideas.. but ill throw one out there for fun

 

Willis and Borowksi to the Dodgers for Kemp, Billingsly and Broxton.. maybe inquire about Martin as well.

 

Trade Willingham, Broxton and Petit (or whatever SP prospect combo) to the DRays for Crawford.

 

SS Ramirez

LF Crawford

3B Cabrera

1B Jacobs

2B Uggla

RF Hermida

CF Kemp

C Olivo

 

1. Olsen

2. Johnson

3. Billingsly

4. Nolasco

5. Sanchez

 

Thoughts?

 

 

And let me not forget, I don't want DTrain going anywhere.

I never get some of you on this board.....

 

For 5 years Beckett was untouchable. Nobody would consider trading him even for the best of packages, despite the fact he was injury prone and never touched greatness save for the '03 postseason.

 

Willis has been a true superstar ever since he got here. He's pitched great and stayed healthy, yet everyone wants to unload him before he implodes. I don't get it. We have a 24 year old ace that is one of the faces of MLB, much less the Marlins......why do we continually feel the need to hope we can get a great package for him?

  • Author

I never get some of you on this board.....

 

For 5 years Beckett was untouchable. Nobody would consider trading him even for the best of packages, despite the fact he was injury prone and never touched greatness save for the '03 postseason.

 

Willis has been a true superstar ever since he got here. He's pitched great and stayed healthy, yet everyone wants to unload him before he implodes. I don't get it. We have a 24 year old ace that is one of the faces of MLB, much less the Marlins......why do we continually feel the need to hope we can get a great package for him?

 

 

 

Sinple...it will make the team better.

I never get some of you on this board.....

 

For 5 years Beckett was untouchable. Nobody would consider trading him even for the best of packages, despite the fact he was injury prone and never touched greatness save for the '03 postseason.

 

Willis has been a true superstar ever since he got here. He's pitched great and stayed healthy, yet everyone wants to unload him before he implodes. I don't get it. We have a 24 year old ace that is one of the faces of MLB, much less the Marlins......why do we continually feel the need to hope we can get a great package for him?

 

 

The problem with Beckett was never inconsistency, it was health.

 

The problem with Willis is inconsistency.

 

There's a big difference and why I felt one was emminently more untouchable than the other (and, in case you're wondering, I think we picked the wrong pony).

I never get some of you on this board.....

 

For 5 years Beckett was untouchable. Nobody would consider trading him even for the best of packages, despite the fact he was injury prone and never touched greatness save for the '03 postseason.

 

Willis has been a true superstar ever since he got here. He's pitched great and stayed healthy, yet everyone wants to unload him before he implodes. I don't get it. We have a 24 year old ace that is one of the faces of MLB, much less the Marlins......why do we continually feel the need to hope we can get a great package for him?

 

 

The problem with Beckett was never inconsistency, it was health.

 

The problem with Willis is inconsistency.

 

There's a big difference and why I felt one was emminently more untouchable than the other (and, in case you're wondering, I think we picked the wrong pony).

Please explain to me how Beckett is more consistent than Willis....

 

Sinple...it will make the team better.

 

Because we are naive enough to think that our bottom 4 pitchers have at least as much or more talent than our ace? Sorry, but you're living in a dream world. Here's a news flash, we don't have 5 aces on our team right now. For every Dontrelle Willis, a pitcher who starts his career on fire and is able to maintain it, there are 10 guys who fall flat. I'm not saying that our young staff has no talent, I think it's just ridiculous to assume that all 5 will sustain success like Willis has.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.